Topic : 03/14 Overprotective Moms

Number of Replies: 313
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 07, 2005, 03:41:17 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/12/05) They won’t let you walk down the street alone.  They call your house five times a day, screen your calls, and monitor your every move. It’s not the FBI; it’s mothers! When 14-year-old Ashlee was on the show nearly two years ago, she said her mother, Teresa, was embarrassing and strict, and she wanted it to stop. Now she’s back and says her mom still won’t allow her to have any freedom. See the assignment Dr. Phil gave them that brought Teresa to tears. Plus, meet a 43-year old woman who says her mother is so overprotective, she calls the police if she comes home late. Can her mom learn how to let go? Share your thoughts.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More March 2006 Show Boards.



User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
chillin'
October 12, 2005, 2:18 pm PDT

being overprotective

I'm all for parents protecting their kids & caring about what they're doing BUT, the 2 mothers on todays show were absolutely too overprotective!!! I mean Teresa literally CRIED when Dr. Phil allowed Ashley to ride the bus and she wouldnt even allow Ashley to participate in any after school activities!!! That is way too extreme! I mean, in a way I can understand about the whole bus thing because Its a safety issue with me also..... I'm 19 years old and I will not take public transportation(city bus, cab, plane, train) alone, I never have & most likely never will unless someone is with me (but thats just me)!And one day when/if I have kids, thats something that we'll have to discuss but I'm not going to forbid them from taking it and I certainly would not CRY when they stept foot into whatever their taking!  Then there's Diane and her daughter Dana, I mean dana is a grown, 43 year old woman.... her mother doesnt need to (and shouldnt) be controlling every aspect of her life!!! She can make her own decisions and live her life the way she wants to! Both mothers had very unfortunate events happen in their lives & I totally get that but they need to deal with their pain & fear without inflicting it on their kids cause they're hurting their daughters and destroying the relationship between them! Theresa needs to let Ashley be a young girl before she becomes really rebellious & resents her and Diane needs to just mind her own business. There is a way to teach your children how to be responsible and protect them without going way overboard and parents just need to find that balance!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 2:24 pm PDT

10/12 Overprotective Moms

MY DAUGHTER IS ONLY 18 MONTHS OLD, BUT I ALREADY WORRY ABOUT WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN TO HER WHEN SHE GETS OLDER!!  I AM ONLY 22 YEARS OLD, BUT EVEN WHEN I WAS GROWING UP MY PARENTS WOULD LET US GO TO THE PARK OF TO FRIENDS HOUSES AT LIKE 5 YEARS OLD AND GRANTED WE DID LIVE IN A SMALL TOWN SO IT WAS LESS LIKELY THAT SOMETHING WOULD PROBABLY HAPPEN, BUT IT STILL COULD HAVE!!  I WATCHED TODAY'S SHOW ABOUT OVERPROTECTIVE MOTHERS AND I FEEL THAT WHEN MY DAUGHTER GETS OLDER I WILL BE LIKE THE MOTHER'S ON TODAYS SHOW!  HOW CAN I STOP WHAT I THINK WILL BE ENEVITABLE BEFORE IT EVEN BEGINS???  WHEN WE GO TO THE STORE I AM ALWAYS SO WORRIED THAT IF I TURN MY BACK TO THE STROLLER OR THE CART THAT SOMEONE WILL JUST COME AND GRAB HER AND RUN AWAY WITH HER.  SHE SLEEPS IN THE OTHER ROOM AND I ALWAYS GET UP AND CHECK UP ON HER TO MAKE SURE THAT SOMEONE DIDN'T BREAK IN THRU THE WINDOW AND KIDNAP HER TO SELL HER ON THE BALCK MARKET!!  I DREAM ABOUT THINGS HAPPING TO MY HUSBAND AND MY DAUGHTER AND THEN IN MY DREAM IT IS ALL UP TO ME TO SAVE THEM.   I AM WORRIED ABOUT GERMS AND MY DAUGHTER GETTING SICK.  I GET UP SOME MORNINGS AND DON'T EVEN WANT TO GO OUTSIDE FOR THE FEAR OF THE UNKNOWN.  I DON'T WANT MY DAUGHTER TO GROW UP THINKING THAT HER MOM NEEDS PSYCIATRIC HELP!!!  I JUST WANT TOT KNOW IF THERE IS OTHER PEOPLE OUT THERE THAT GO THRU THE SAME THINGS I DO!!  I AM WORRIED ABOUT MY DAUGHTER CATCHING AN STD AND HER GETTING PREGNANT AT 15, HER BEING RAPED AND KILLED.  OR EVEN JUST GOING ON A VACATION AND BEING STOLEN!! 

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
angry
October 12, 2005, 2:29 pm PDT

10/12 Overprotective Moms

Quote From: chicyuna

 Just my two cents here. I think the thing that parents need to understand and remember is that children are not a peice of possession that you own.They are thinking, loving, caring INDIVIDUALS, just like you are from your parents. Yes, I know the world is a dangerous place for people, especially children. But I think it's really important to understand that as children get older, they develope a mind of their own. And the job of  parents is to help their kids develope their mind and thoughts. Parents are here to raise children into individuals that make positive contributions to society. How can kids become those individuals if their parents don't let them see society, or make choices about it? My mom always let me do what I wanted, simply because she trusted me (as an individual person, not necessarily as her daughter) to make the right choices. Yeah, I screwed up a couple of times, but you know what? I LEARNED FROM MY MISTAKES! The number one excuse I hear from overprotected parents is that they protect their children simply because they do not want them making the same mistakes that the parents made when they were younger. How is a child to learn from their mistakes and life if they're not given a chance to experience it? Now, granted, setting boundaries is fine. There's nothing wrong with that. It's a great way for kids to show parents that they can be trusted to make the right choices. The reason why my mom let my do what I wanted (other than the fact that she trusted me), is that when she set boundaries, I followed them. She never gave me a curfew when I was a teenager, but she would always tell me "Amber, give me a call if you're going to be late." I loved and respected my mom enough to do just that. I would call her at around 10:30ish and tell her where I was, who I was with, and about what time I would be home. She was fine with that. She trusted me enough to not go anywhere with strangers, or do anything "stupid". She met all of my friends (so I could show her who they were and who I was hanging out with), and it was through all of this that I gained her trust. Yes, I'll admit, I still live at home at the age of 22 (I'm going to school, that's why :)), and not only do I see my mom as my mom, but I see her as my best friend, sometimes even as a roommate. I can come and go as I please without her worrying about where I am. I can talk to her about anything (believe it or not, even *gasp* SEX). I really do believe it's because she trusted me enough with my choices that I'm the person I am today. I have very strong opinions about things (not necessarily the same as hers), and that's what makes me ME. I have an awesome relationship with her, and I wouldn't change that for the world.Now, I understand that parents want to protect their children from "preditors". After all, even though I'm not a mother, I'd want the same for my children. However, I also want my future children to become their own individual, with their own thoughts and feelings about certain things. I want them to experience life to the fullest. I even want them to make mistakes so they can learn from them! I want them to become productive individuals in society, who can make positive contributions. Good and bad experiences is what makes people grow into who they are today, and I think that's what kids need.
It is easy for people that do not have children to give advise.  I am trying the best that I can do with Ashlee.  She is allowed to do some things, but not things that I know could possibly put her in harms way.  We have 2 child molesters in  our neighborhoods.  I do not think of my kids as possessions, but as gifts from God and I am going to make sure that my children are not going to be just another child that ends up hurt or worse murdered by some strange pervert.  So until you have become a parent, then please don't try and give advise.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
October 12, 2005, 2:30 pm PDT

Gangs and rapes in my cereal bowl

The reason for my message title is a bit funny and a bit sad...My mom is EXACTLY like the Moms on this show. To sum up my childhood, I tell people that I had the morning's blotter (section of the paper that reports crimes in the area) cut out and put in my cereal bowl as a child...and that was just the start of the day! If you could call your own mother a stalker, I would have. My mom's tactics included fear and guilt. I was raised to be terrified of strangers because "at least one of them would end up stealing me" and my mom "would end up dying of sadness." To this day (at 27 years old) I am requested to tell her where I'm going, call her when I arrive, call when I leave and when I get home, along with listening to all the reasons why I shouldn't even bother going, what with all the risks and all. Fortunately, I live a couple of hours away (my own doing) and I just don't tell her every time I go somewhere...although I am still feeling the guilt like "if I die or get kidnapped, I'll feel terrible that she didn't know that I was even going to be gone." I try to be well-adjusted and very concious of where my fear comes from when I feel it over-whelming me, but the constant reminder from her that "I will be kidnapped someday" is always on my mind in some way. Because of our struggle with this, we have much less contact than I wish we had. It is the only way that I can live my life and she can be at peace just thinking I'm sitting at home... 

Real healthy, right? 

About two years ago, we were in the upper peninsula of Michigan visiting my Grandama (town population of 150 people) and when my mom laid down to take a nap, i drove about 20 miles away just looking at the landscape. In the 35 minutes that I was gone, my Mom had woke to find me gone, notified everyone in the motel and insisted (hysterically) that they call the police because LUMBERJACKS had kidnapped me! I came back to find mass hysteria, and yet another humiliating ordeal. All because I wanted to look at some trees!!! 

I am writing to appeal to all the Moms out there headed down this path. I want to thank you for loving us enough to do anything to protect us. I also want to remind you that a child's outlook on life is based on what he or she is taught as a child. Please do not subject your children to public embarassment, social anxiety and a life so sheltered that they might as well be chained in someone's basement. Believe me, it sets them up for a life of working at over-coming a fear that is so real and so "validated" by your own Mom that you have to remind yourself that it hasn't actually happened.  

And to all the children in this situation, be patient. They love you. But, do something now so it can start to change as early as possible.  

I am very well-adjusted despite all of this, but not without work. I want all Moms to see that if you do this, your child has a HUGE chance of being harmed emotionally and socially. So, how can you do that to them based on a fear that something "might" happen if you don't. 

Hope this all makes sense! I'm off to the mailbox...don't tell my Mom! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 2:31 pm PDT

overprotective mothers beware

Your child at some point is going to turn 18. When they do if you havent already let them go you kid is going to move out and not want to come back or even keep in contact. My mother has a friend who was extremely over protective and when she said she didnt want to go to the college her parents picked out for her she wasnt heard. The daughter in question realized she was eighteen, pacted up her stuff and moved in with friends over and hour away from parents house. They grow up weither you like it or not.
 
User Mood
Bored

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 2:34 pm PDT

children will find a way

I am now 23 years old with a 3 year old son. Growing up i had a wonderful mother and yes she was extremely over protective. My sister who is a year younger than myself caused many problems. She skipped school, had sex, fell into drugs and alcohol , was expelled from school , admitted into a psychiatric ward, and became pregnant all before she reached the age of 16. I was never like my sister, i was a b average student , good attendance and all in all a pretty good kid.But do to my sisters mistakes my mother tried to shield me from everything convinced that if she let me out of her sight for one brief second i would become my little sister. As i got older i started to become resentful, here i was 17 and i was not allowed to have a boyfriend, go to the movies, attend school functions such as homecoming or prom. Needless to say i began to sneak around behind my parents backs. I would make up excuses like i was going to the library to study or that i had to stay after school to catch up on work. When in reality i was seeing my boyfriend at the time. This went on for 2 years until i was 19 and suddenly pregnant. My parents were shocked that i was able to go under there radar i mean after all they thought that they were shielding me from such things when thee Truth of the matter is they shield me from so much i didn't know what to do or how to protect myself form the jerks or the deadbeats that are out there. They were so busy trying to protect me they didn't take the time to fill me in on what they were protecting me from. So you can sit there and think not my child i have all the bases covered my kid would not sneak or lie to me but if you do not give them little taste of freedom every now and then they will become tired of living vicariously through there friends and find ways to do things themselves with or without your permission.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 2:34 pm PDT

10/12 Overprotective Moms

Quote From: mommyblues

I have a 9 year old and i live 2 blocks from the school and i will NOT let her walk. She has freinds who do. and that is fine for them. But i have seen and heard of  kids missing on there way to school. I have worked my job around them to be here with them. I love them to much to let  them get hurt .  

  

I have a 9 year old and live 1 1/2 blocks from school. I walk with her partly because she'd be an easy target for someone bigger than her who is determined, and partly because there's a bad corner where three roads and a driveway to a parking lot meet which is right in the middle of the daily SUV parade. It's just not worth the risk to me. I know others who let their kids walk, but I just tell them I'm not ready yet. I trust my daughter, I just don't trust everyone else. It only takes once! But that, said, I understand the statiscal probablilty of something happening is pretty low. I just trust I'll know when it's time.
 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
angry
October 12, 2005, 2:35 pm PDT

What ????

Quote From: aekonzen

I had to stop watching, but I hope, after all the jocularity, that we are getting this woman some help for her panic disorder!  That kid is going to start sneaking out.   
For one thing my child is a very good child.  If you cared to watch the rest of the show, he said that I had not ruined her.  My question to you are you a parent?  If not then don't try and say I need medication and therapy.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
anxious
October 12, 2005, 2:39 pm PDT

Try not to raise them on fear

My mother is the most wonderful person and I can't imagine life without her. However, I am 99% decided that without couseling, I cannot have children, as I will be just like she was-paranoid and over protective. (I'm not exaggerating-the last thing she said to me before I went camping when I was 17 was "Don't pitch your tent under a tree that looks like it's going to fall down!" And she was dead serious) It's a vicious cycle-she meant the best and she had her reasons, but she has instilled this fear in me that I just can't get rid of sometimes. It's not a good way to live. I know that the possibility is always there that the child will turn the other way and be totally rebellious and make dangerous choices, and that is a bad way to live, too.  

  

Find a happy medium with your kids, make them aware of the dangers of the real world-but don't make them terrified to figure things out on their own. Be there for them, make the environment comfortable enough for them to come to you with anything, and try to trust them. They will remain naieve forever if you never give them the chance to learn about life.  

  

All my respect and admiration for ALL mothers just looking to protect their babies.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 12, 2005, 2:39 pm PDT

fearful I'm the same way

My son is two years old and I'm afraid I'm the beginning of an overprotective mother. I think of the worst thing that could happen when he's not with me. I am very conscious of my outrageous feelings, but nevertheless, they are still there. I just can't get past all the crazy incidents that happen in our country EVERYDAY and I always wonder "what if that were my son?"  I can already sense that I will be "one of those moms" and I don't know how to change it.
 

First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | Next | Last