Message Boards

Topic : 12/26 "I Am Right!"

Number of Replies: 376
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:44:44 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Airdate: 10/18/05) Would you rather be right or would you rather be happy? Stacey says she and her husband, Eddie, made a plan when they got married -- and it didn't have anything to do with Eddie's current goal of becoming an ultimate fighting champion.  Now she's giving him an ultimatum: "Give up the dream or give up me!“ Then, an entire family faces off against a mother in a debate about the weight of her 8-year-old daughter. Plus, a 30-year-old virgin saving himself for his soul mate wonders if he made the right decision. And, Jylana is determined to home school her son, but her husband, Mike, says he'll miss opportunities and become socially stunted. What does Dr. Phil think? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More December 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 1:41 pm PDT

To the 30 year old virgin

I am a blonde haired girl named Erin, and when I heard a virgin was going to be on the Dr. Phil show publicly discussing the topic, I wanted to call Dr. Phil and ask for your phone number.  I'm a virgin as well, and am "patiently" awaiting my soul mate.  I don't have a specific idea of who this soul mate will be, and I guess I don't entirely agree with the concept of a soul mate, but it's possible that God does have a specific person in mind for me.  I don't believe it really matters if i know it or not.  I believe that as long as I am in God's will, and am seeking the things that he wishes for me to find, he will show me who he wants me to marry.  He definatly has shown me who he doesn't want me to marry, as evidenced by the past array of guys I have dated.  Just seek Gods will.  Go on dates, and enjoy them, but don't make a split second judgement.  Spend some earnest time in prayer over each one of those girls, and ask God to tell you.  I believe he will!  and if you're open to blonde haired girls named Erin, I know where you could find one! 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 1:47 pm PDT

Back Off Grandma!

I was thin as a child ,but my sister was 10-12 lbs 'overweight'.  We never ate junk food and soda 

pop was forbidden. So,it just "was".   My family was incredibly critical and she has food issues 

to this day. FORTY YEARS LATER.    

  

Cut it out Joyce!  Your daughter is a smart woman. She has the information, she can act or not. 

It's HER child to raise. I know you love your granddaughter,but this is SO none of your business 

after a certain point.   

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
hopeful
October 18, 2005, 1:47 pm PDT

I am right

I think that the man who has the dream to become a ultimate fighting champion, should go for it! If you don't reach for your dreams you will never be able to experience them. I understand his wife's concerns. Everything in life has potential danger. If this man does not go for his dream, he will end up resenting his wife. He will also wonder "what if."  

  

I think that the 30 year old virgin has made a decision that everyone has to make for themselves. I think that it is important to have absolute morals and values. I honestly wish that I could have waited myself. My plan was to wait, but things didn't necessarily go the way I planned.  

  

Annabelle 's grandmother is a quack. This young girl of 8 years old is fine! She is going to have major problems in the future if her grandmother and aunts do not stop this non-sense. I feel like this is a form of abuse for Jodi and Annabelle. This grandmother is pushing her daughter to do something she does not want to do. It is putting stress on their relationships, and will eventually throw Annabelle into the mix where her relationship with them will be affected 

  

I have an aunt who was not fat at all as a child (in my opinion.) My grandmother, her mother, was constantly telling her she was a "cow", "fat", "beached whale" and so on. This all started when she was 5 years old.  Now my aunt is in her early thirties and she is very over weight. She tries every kind of diet and exercise programs, and she still can't lose the weight. It stresses her out. She now has panic attacks, she has had two nervous breakdowns, and she has a very low self-esteem. Her self-concept is almost non-existent. She is obsessed with her appearance.  

  

This grandmother is hurting her grandchild, not helping. She is hurting her daughter as well. In my opinion if Jodi feels that her daughter does need to lose some weight she should set an example herself!  Jodi looks like she could use some toning up, so maybe she could take her daughter out on a regular basis that they could get some exercise outside TOGETHER (playing sports or something.) This would start a healthy routine, some needed exercises, and would bring the two of them together. Maybe the grandmother could join in as well.  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 1:48 pm PDT

overweight children

 I definitely agree with Dr. Phil about the 8 yr. old, who's grandmother thinks she's overweight. If you 

emphasize dieting and weight, they will most assuredly develop low self esteem issues, and maybe even eating disorders. Teaching by example is one of the best ways, and looking at food from the perspective of nutrition and health, will allow them to develop self esteem and to be a healthy adult. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
October 18, 2005, 1:49 pm PDT

Mark - you will be greatly rewarded.....

Quote From: kimmikak23

MARK, 

  

I URGE YOU TO STAND YOUR GROUND.  THERE ARE MORE PEOPLE OUT THERE THAN YOU COULD IMAGINE THAT BELIEVE THE WAY YOU DO, AND THEY  THINK THAT THINK THEY ARE THE ONLY ONES WITH THIS MIND SET.  YOUR COMING FORWARD WITH THIS WILL NOT ONLY HELP YOU STAND TO YOUR CONVICTIONS, BUT ALSO HELP THOSE THAT ARE WAITING FOR THE RIGHT ONE TO ALSO HOLD FIRM TO THEIR BELIEFS.  

  

I HAVE TOLD MY CHILDREN THAT I HAVE BEEN PRAYING FOR THEIR MATES BEFORE I EVER EVEN THOUGHT OF HAVING CHILDREN AND KNOW THAT GOD HAS THAT SPECIAL ONE THAT HE CREATED JUST FOR THEM.  I REMIND THEM OF THIS OFTEN, AND EACH ONE CHOSE TO SIGN A COVENANT OF AGREEMENT TO GOD, THEMSELVES, US (PARENTS) AND THEIR FUTURE SPOUSES, TO REMAIN PURE UNTIL MARRIAGE.  

  

THE DESIRES OF YOUR HEART, ARE PUT THERE BY GOD, ESPECIALLY IF YOU HAVE A RELATIONSHIP WITH THE LORD, THEN THOSE DREAMS AND DESIRES OF HIS GIFT TO YOU SO THAT YOU WILL KNOW HIS PLAN FOR YOUR LIFE.  HIS DESIRE FOR YOU IS TO HAVE THE VERY BEST HE HAS TO GIVE, AND HE HAS GIVEN YOU THOSE DREAMS FOR A SPECIAL PURPOSE. 

  

IT IS VERY HONORABLE, ADMIRABLE, AND HIGHLY FAVORED OF GOD, FOR YOU TO NOT DEFILE THE MARRIAGE BED, AND FOR YOU TO BE PATIENT AND WAIT FOR THE ONE THAT HE HAS FOR YOU. 

  

I DO AGREE WITH DOCTOR  PHIL ABOUT YOUR SPECIFICS COULD  BE OFF, BUT I WILL NOT SAY THIS IS THE CASE IF YOU DO INDEED HAVE A PERSONAL RELATIONSHIP WITH THE LORD...BECAUSE IF YOU DO STUDY THE WORD OF GOD, HE SPECIFICALLY SAYS WE ARE HIS SHEEP AND KNOW HIS VOICE AND WILL FOLLOW NO OTHER.  THIS IS WHERE YOU AND YOU ALONE HAVE TO DECIDE IF THIS "SARA" IS OF GOD, OR IS JUST ONE YOU DESIRE BECAUSE OF HAVING MADE HER UP.  BUT KNOW THIS, YOUR MATE IS OUT THERE, AND WAS CREATED JUST FOR YOU AND YOU ALONE.  DON'T GIVE UP ON THAT AND STAND FIRM.  

  

I WANT TO SUGGEST THAT YOU READ ANOTHER LOVE STORY WHICH IS TRUE AND ALONG THESE LINES, AND BELIEVE THAT IT WILL HELP YOU TO STAY THE COURSE.  THERE ARE 2 BOOKS SPECIFICALLY, AND THEY ARE  WRITTEN BY ERIC AND LESLIE LUDY.  

 THE TITLES ARE, "WHEN GOD WRITES YOUR LOVE STORY", AND "WHEN DREAMS COME TRUE."   

I WOULD VENTURE TO SAY THAT HE IS AROUND YOUR AGE, AND SHE IS A BIT YOUNGER, BUT THERE STORY IS INSPIRING AND WILL HELP YOU TO SEE THAT YOU ARE ON THE RIGHT PATH.   

  

I ALSO WANT TO COMMENT ON YOUR LOVE LETTER TO YOUR FUTURE WIFE.  CONTINUE TO DO THIS, BECAUSE WHEN GOD DOES BRING HER INTO YOUR LIFE, THESE LETTERS WILL BE CHERISHED BY HER FOR ALL ETERNITY.  (OF COURSE, DON'T PUT THE NAME AND DESCRIPTION UNLESS  YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY POSITIVE THAT GOD HAS GIVEN YOU THESE SPECIFICS.) 

  

SO MARK, HANG ON TO THE DREAM YOU HAVE OF YOUR WIFE.  SHE IS OUT THERE!  GOD BLESS YOU AND I WILL BE PRAYING FOR YOU AND YOUR MATE TO BE. 

  

Mark - I truly believe that you will be greatly rewarded some day for your strength of character and your self control.  Hats off to you.  I am going to tell you the same thing I told my 24 yr old daughter in 2001.  She was sure there were no Christian young men around.  Then she was sure it was because we were living in Colorado, and if she just could get back to Texas and find a good southern boy, life would be grand.  She had down pat what her 'type' was.  Dark hair, olive skin....brown eyes, (she'd settle for blue), and tall...since she is almost 5'10".  I finally told her that she was totally disregarding a huge segment of the population.  I told her that she had to get to know the person, and get to know their heart.  Well, lo and behold, almost a year later she started dating a boy, one of the first boys she'd met at our new church in CO.  A blonde hair, green eyed boy, that is every bit of an inch taller than she is.  He isn't a southern boy, but from a small  town in Nebraska.  He felt that the Lord had ledhim to attend school in Colorado, and I think he is right.  They got married this past May, and they were both virgins, by choice.  Anyway, my point is this, don't rule out someone because they don't fit the 'Sarah' profile; blonde hair and blue eyes.  Ms. Right may pass right by you and you won't recognize her.  Good luck and God bless.....some girl is going to hit the jack pot with you. 

Stacy 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 1:49 pm PDT

STAND STRONG

Quote From: casey4

Would you rather be right or be happy?… This is a powerful question, which on occasions I have trouble with. 

If you have an insight as to something being wrong (not personal, but more with the world), do you try to do something about it (be right) or do you accept it as the way it is (be happy)? 

  

I frequently pray: 

Lord give me the courage to change things I can, 

the humility to accept the things I can not, 

and the wisdom to know the difference. 

  

Unfortunately this prayer does not help me a whole lot, and I find what is wrong with the world frequently flows over to my personal life…..:-( 

  

Does anyone have insights as to what one can do? 

Best Regards, 

 

  

FIRST I WANT TO SAY THAT YOU ARE NOT THE MINORITY IN THIS .I DON'T KNOW IF YOU HAVE AN INTIMATE RELATIONSHIP WITH THE LORD, BUT I DO KNOW FROM YOUR MESSAGE THAT YOU DO PRAY AND BELIEVE IN HIM.  SO, GOING FROM THERE I WOULD JUST LIKE TO ENCOURAGE YOU. 

THE KNOWING THINGS ARE NOT RIGHT IS A KNOWING FROM GOD.  I URGE YOU TO SEEK HIM IN ALL THE SITUATIONS THAT YOUR REFERRING TO AS TO IF YOU ARE TO JUST PRAY ABOUT THEM, OR IF YOU ARE TO TAKE ACTUAL ACTION IN THE SITUATION.   

ANOTHER THING IS TO JUST STAND ON THE PROMISES THAT HE HAS MADE US IN HIS WORD, AND TO KNOW THAT THOSE ARE JUST THAT---PROMISES.  HE IS THE ONE THAT IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE FULFILLMENT OF THOSE PROMISES, AND WE HAVE TO STAND ON THOSE WHICH HE MADE.  I ALSO GO TO THE WORDS OF JESUS TO HELP ME GET THROUGH WHEN IT SEEMS LIKE THE WORLD IS CAVING IN AROUND ME.  IT TAKES, TO MY UNDERSTANDING AT LEAST 20 DAYS TO BREAK A BAD HABIT, SO IT STANDS TO REASON THAT IT WOULD TAKE AT LEAST THAT LONG TO FORM A NEW HABIT IN IT'S PLACE.  I PRACTICE SPEAKING THE WORD OVER SITUATIONS, VERSES FALLING INTO THE DOOM AND GLOOM WE HEAR SO MUCH IN OUR EVERY DAY LIVES.  JESUS SAID TO PREACH THE GOOD NEWS OF THE GOSPEL, AND STANDING ON THIS IS WHAT GIVES ME STRENGTH.  MY ENCOURAGEMENT COMES FROM THIS FAITH, AND HAVING  PEOPLE TO HELP ME HOLD MY ARMS UP AS MOSES DID WHEN HE BECAME WEAK.  I WILL BE PRAYING THAT YOU WILL HAVE PEACE, AND THAT GOD WILL GIVE YOU CLEAR DIRECTION IN YOUR DAY TO DAY WALK.  GOD BLESS, AND KEEP YOUR MIND ON HIM AND HE WILL GIVE YOU THAT PERFECT PEACE. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 1:55 pm PDT

Homeschooling

I do not believe that homeschooling is for everyone, but it has worked well for us.  Most homeschoolers are loving parents who want to give their children an excellent education. I disagree with Dr. Phil's comment that homeschooling is not a wise choice for high school. We currently homeschool our 16 year old son, a senior; 15 year old son, a junior; and 10 year old daughter, a sixth grader.  Yes, all children are one year beyond others their age. All children are well adjusted socially and emotionally.  Homeschooling for high school has enabled the boys to develop their strengths. They started a neighborhood yard/handyman business a few years ago.  Their reputation is one of being kind, polite, trustworthy, reliable, hardworking, and dependable. These are not my words, but their customers who call to schedule a time with the boys and then tell me these thing if I answer the phone. One customer is a public school teacher who called and said she was never in favor of homeschooling, but our boys have chnged her opinion. Homeschooling has enabled the boy to learn skills such as roofing, putting up dry wall, etc. The 16 year old is a sax player at a college band, something he would not have time for if he were in school. The 15 year old has been in a few local plays and writes and acts in skits to encourage other teens at church to get involved at the soup kitchen in Trenton. Trust me, he is not shy or socially inept!  Both boys are Junior Rangers in a Stockade group (a type of church based boyscout).  We have always allowed our boys to be involved in sports such as Little League, soccer, tennis, etc. if they wanted. The 15 year old has taken art lessons and the 16 year old music lessons. Most homeschoolers do not want to isolate their children and most children enjoy being homeschooled so they can pursue their strengths. My children do not want to go to school because they can get ahead in studies, run their business, and graduate early--all the while being socially well adjusted! 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 1:55 pm PDT

Response to guy waiting for his soul mate

Dear Dr. Phil, 

This is not something that I would normally do, but here it goes. I would like to respond to the gentleman you had on your show today who is 30 years old and waiting for his soul mate. You made a comment when he contained  the words "soul mate" in his sentence. You sounded to me like you did not believe finding your soul mate was possible. Settle for 80% of what you are looking for and the other 20% can be worked out down the road. WRONG! WRONG! WRONG! Man, your soul mate is out there waiting for you to look her in the eyes so she can see her soul mate looking back at her. I know this is possible because it happened to me some 20 years ago and this wonderful thing has just happened to my 37 year old cousin. She has not believed what I have been telling her for the past 20 years about how my husband and I feel we are soul mates until she experienced it for herself. SHE IS A BELIEVER NOW!!!!! The feelings are so hard to describe. The best advise to give him is that he will know her when they find each other. No questions. No doubts. No looking back. All you want is to spend every moment possible with this person because this is the time you are happiest and most content. The safety you feel with this person is beyond measure. I did not have to settle for 80% because my husband is 100% for me. P.S. I love your show. 

 

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:03 pm PDT

NOT the way it's

Quote From: blueangel777

How sad it is that society doesn't view virginity as sacred!!!!!!!!  I am older then 30 and am.  I believe in marriage before having sex.  I was made fun of for many years.  A very special person told me, "That's the way it is suppose to be!"  He was the first person to validate my choice.  A mental health professional said to me, "That is really odd at your age." and quickly changed the subject.  I am very glad I am and if I die a virgin, SO BE IT!!!  That is the way to suppose to be!!!

While attempting to avoid a huge and detailed discussion, I have to say that if you view our history as biological beings, saving your virginity for your "soulmate" is NOT the way it's "supposed" to be. 

  

Evolutionarily speaking, we have sex to procreate.  Evolutionarily speaking, love has nothing to do with sex. 

  

This is NOT to say I believe love & sex are unrelated.  It's quite wonderful to love the person with whom you are intimate. 

  

However, it is only your personal view that sex before marriage is wrong.  Yes, it is a view that is held by many - but it IS a moral OPINION and nothing more.   

  

To keep the post on topic and refer back to the show, I feel that if the 20-year-old guest is happy with his choice to remain celibate until he meets the woman he marries, the choice should be his.  I have no problem with this.  I only take issue with the statement that this is "the way it's SUPPOSED to be." 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:09 pm PDT

I totally agree

Quote From: maegan23

Speaking as one of the "religious folk" I have to say that I am not offended by your comment. If that was your intention I hate to disappoint you.  I am a Christian, who succombed to temptation as a teenager. My only regret is that even though I am older now, I feel that there is baggage between my husband and I. It, personally, makes me uncomfortable that I didn't have that to give my husband when we got married.  God intended it to be a gift that you are to give to your spouse, not just any man or woman that you meet at a bar. However, you seem to be getting Sex and Love confused...No one ever said that the 30 year old virgin ahd never "loved" anyone. Just that he hadn't had sex with anyone. You can certainly have a feeling of openness and mutual acceptance with someone whom you haven't had sex with...in fact I'm sure that you can, as you say, "fart" around someone you love and respect without actually having had sex with them. I am proud that he has been able to maintain his virginity...and I hope he is too.
You couldn't have said it better. I also am one of the "religious folk" but when I was a teen I went through a wild stage. I was rebelling from my parents. I have to say now that I wish so badly that I had saved myself for my husband. It would feel me with so much pride to say that I had saved myself for my husband and not just for religious reason but because I love my husband so much and I see how special being with him is. No sex in the world could ever compare to the bond I share with my husband. God doesn't give you a time line for finding your soul mate but he does bring that person around at just the right time. And I can promise you, 9 times out of 10 is will be when you least expect it. I met my husband on a girls only weekend and well, so much for that because there he was, my prince charming. I told everyone that weekend that I would marry him and I did and we are still happily married with a beautiful baby boy. I couldn't be happier. So for all of you out there, your time will come, when the time is right!
 
First | Prev | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | Next | Last