Message Boards

Topic : 12/26 "I Am Right!"

Number of Replies: 376
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:44:44 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Airdate: 10/18/05) Would you rather be right or would you rather be happy? Stacey says she and her husband, Eddie, made a plan when they got married -- and it didn't have anything to do with Eddie's current goal of becoming an ultimate fighting champion.  Now she's giving him an ultimatum: "Give up the dream or give up me!“ Then, an entire family faces off against a mother in a debate about the weight of her 8-year-old daughter. Plus, a 30-year-old virgin saving himself for his soul mate wonders if he made the right decision. And, Jylana is determined to home school her son, but her husband, Mike, says he'll miss opportunities and become socially stunted. What does Dr. Phil think? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More December 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:21 pm PDT

10/18 "I Am Right!"

Quote From: amy1918

I was thin as a child ,but my sister was 10-12 lbs 'overweight'.  We never ate junk food and soda 

pop was forbidden. So,it just "was".   My family was incredibly critical and she has food issues 

to this day. FORTY YEARS LATER.    

  

Cut it out Joyce!  Your daughter is a smart woman. She has the information, she can act or not. 

It's HER child to raise. I know you love your granddaughter,but this is SO none of your business 

after a certain point.   

I am extrememly active and I watch what I eat. I wouldn't consider myself overweight but I am. I wish that somebody would have told me that I wasn't eating right and would have helped me form healthy eating habits when I was younger so that I wouldn't be here now trying to break these habits that I have developed over the years. As long as truth is presented in a positive and loving way, there isn't any harm and may in fact be helpful.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:22 pm PDT

Home school

I home school 3 of my 4 children.  My oldest (daughter, now 13) and I had gotten to a point where something different had to happen.  I found a University Model School in my area and enrolled her this year.  Her social skills are wonderful, always have been.  She and I had gotten to a point where we were accomplishing nothing and the other children's school was suffering because of my pride.  She now goes to school three times a week and home schools the other two days.  She enrolls in her classes just like a college with a fall semester and spring semester and purchases her books for the classes in which she is enrolled.  My relationship with her is much better.  We are back on track, thank goodness!  I am in close contact with her teachers and we work together for her to achieve the retention of knowledge of the material rather than just testing, testing and more testing that the public school systems seem to always be doing.  Her classes have about 5-12 students in each class.  The teachers are wonderful and love the parent support.  Her grades are great and she is cheer leading and participating in school politics.  I could not be more proud.  Because of this change in our home school, my other three children have the opportunity to blossom!   

  

I do have to say that I never intended to home school through high-school.  I am not and was not ever trying to isolate my children in anyway.  My only desire is for them to be insulated long enough to know who they are and what they believe before they are put out in the world on their own for eight to ten hours at a time. 

  

My daughter's new school is an answer to prayer!!! 

  

As far as right and wrong, if you do not have the desire, drive and calling to homeschool....don't. 

It is not for every child or parent.   

But, home school or public school...know your children!  I have an intimacy that most parents do not have with their children. 

  

Brenda 

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
happy
October 18, 2005, 2:22 pm PDT

Princessal "Don't Worry"

Quote From: princessal

I agree with Dr. Phil that he is totally right, and although I am younger I am in a similar situation.  I do find it odd that he would have a name in his mind.  I'm only 23 but people around me are always getting married and wondering why I'm not. And I've never had a serious boy friend.  I have gone on some dates, but seriously I could write a book on the losers I've dated. I know that I have time, but it does get discouraging.  I do feel that God is in control of the situation.  Of mine and his.   

  

Hey BTW I have dark blond hair and blue eyes, but my name is not Sarah.  Sorry, guess I don't fit the bill. 

      I read your message and thought, "you don't need to worry." Things are in His control. I have a true story for you.  

     Growing up my best friend (Anna) and I did everything together.  I got Anna and her mother (Lisa) going to my church. They absolutely loved it and went every service after the day I brought them. About a year later Lisa's husband died in a horrible accident, when Anna was 9 years old. Everyone was devastated. He had never accepted Jesus, he thought that he didn't even exist. Lisa prayed every moment of everyday that God would help her and her family and bless them. A couple years later she prayed that God would send her someone, if that was his plan for her. She stayed faithful. She did go on some dates but nothing serious. When she would get discouraged she would pray that God would help her to be strong. To make a long story short. Lisa went on about her life. Anna started college and got married. Lisa did meet the man of her dreams ( who is very active in the church, he is a family man, he makes great money, and he loves is wife and step-daughter (Anna) with all of his heart. He does everything for them, they do everything together. I have never seen such a happy family. What is wild is that Lisa was told after she had Anna that she would not be able to have children again. Anna grew up as an only child, I think that is why we were so close. We were like sisters. The man that she married had a medical problem were he could not have kids either. They discussed adopting because they wanted a child together so badly. Lisa prayed that God help her to know what to do. A few weeks later Lisa found out that she was pregnant with a little boy. It was a miracle!  

  

God will send you "Mr. Right" Just be patient. You will be blessed tremendously. 

      

 

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:22 pm PDT

10/18 "I Am Right!"

 I thought it was awfully arrogant of the home-schooling mother to say she didn't think the public schools could deal with how advanced her child is.  Oh, please.  Does she have a degree in education?  I get frustrated when I see children being taught by parents who don't know much about the subject matter themselves.  Does this woman plan on home-schooling her advanced child until he goes to college?  Is she ready to instruct him in Physics and higher-level mathematics?  Is she an expert in Literature or the History of Western Civilization?

I understand wanting to protect your child.  I have three kids, myself.  I was one of those kids who scored in the 99%ile all my life in standardized tests... plus I have a Master's degree in Education.   However, I would not deny my children the opportunity to be instructed by people who have more expertise than I do in certain subjects.   I've always believed anyone can achieve great success in whatever schooling environment they choose... whether it's public, private or home-schooled as long as the instructors are competent and the parents are involved.

As long  as her local public school is a safe environment, I would say, give it a chance.  Your son just might flourish there.  You could volunteer at the school.  You might even discover you enjoy helping other children succeed.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:23 pm PDT

The D word

Quote From: hannwett

I do not agree with Dr. Phil's answer in response to the little gir.  Dieting doesn't mean put her on Jennie Craig. It can mean to throw out the cookies, ice cream, cheetoes, etc., and replace it with fruit and a healthy snack.  It is not just a parent's responsibility to raise your kids to be responsible independent adults, but also to teach them to live healthy lives.  

I think that point to made is not to tell an eight year old that she is on a diet...yes not having the junk food and teaching them to be healthy I agree....but not saying you need to diet you are fat. 

Melissa 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:25 pm PDT

kinda agngry

Quote From: msi_gemini

  

I am a new parent-to-be and have been weighing the pro's and con's of homeschooling.  So far I have found nothing good to public schooling except for the fact that the school would have my child for a few hours so I could work again part-time.   

  

To begin with I don't even trust the school district here in Central Florida.  When I was young some of my friends were molested in elementary school by a man that would frequently visit the school and play with us and his daughter that was in our class.  He was even head of our Brownie Girl Troop until he was arrested.  Then as I went into middle school I was sent to a Catholic school in the area, where the principal was accused of molesting the young boys in the school.  Since I've left high school there has been a whole chain of child molestations in the elementary and middle schools in the area, including one school that was right down the road from me!  I could never be able to leave a child at school now without fearing the worst. 

  

Then once you hit high school here its a complete joke.  At one point the school board tried to enforce a very strict dress code to all public schools in the county.  I witnessed countless friends that were suspended and expelled from school because they refused to wear a polo shirt, tuck in their shirts, or wear a belt!!!!  Then as I asked the Deans when the next school board meetings were, but they would never tell me.  Luckily my mother had a friend in the school system so he would personally take me to the meetings about dresscode but I would geting completely dismissed by one man out of six representatives telling me I was wrong when I just made some simple valid points.  Our school was at the bottom of the grading list and yet they were more concerned about whether we had a belt on that day then if we had done our homework.  They even tried to convince me to take a state test a 2nd time! Not because I had failed the first one, but because I had done so well that they wanted me to take it again to bring up their school score!  Of course I flat out refused. 

  

As far as socializing goes, I already plan on afterschool activities whether it'd be dancing, sports, martial arts, music, anything.  I personally believe that exposing the socializing in hobbies will make the acquantinces more important and the interest more important as well.  Instead of being forced to make friends in a class, doing a hobby would give the child friends that he actually has something in common with.  Plus he/she would be more focused on his studies without the class around to be disruptive or pick on the child which was my problem growing up, so I ended up skipping a lot of school as I got older.  I find with friends that I have that have been homeschooled they come out very level-headed and quite closer to their family as well.     

  

But thats just my opinion... 

I am very upset about the so called research Dr. Phil used to say homeschooling after 8th grade is harmful socially.  This is ridiculous!!!  I homeschool all 5 of my kids, and my oldest is 11.  She is by no means socially retarded.  We are part of a support group here in Wichita Kansas that is full of older kids and teens, they are all very well adjusted.  At least,  none of our kids are mean spirited or or material oriented.  Maybe that's a measure of social acceptibility...being a bully, and material oriented or cliquish. I'd like to know where his research comes from..perhaps we should invite Dr. Phil to one of our playgroups or field trips.  Anyway, I am very upset about this comment.  I hope this doesn't make others who really want to homeschool their kids second guess themselves.  BTW, ivy league colleges are now RECRUITING homeschool kids.  THat in itself should prove the validity of this educational option.  Maybe Dr. Phil should have mentioned some of these facts. 

Stephanie 

 

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:27 pm PDT

10/18 "I Am Right!"

Quote From: tinagold49

Dear Dr. Phil, 

  

  I live in Mississippi which seems to be the home schooling capital of the world.  I have seen many, many home schooled children in my jobs down here.  I have worked in a grocery store and a library . 

  The home schooled children I have seen are shy, more so than other schooled children.  They do not interact with other children or adults and tend to cling to their parents.  When the are placed in a regular school setting they usually do not continue their  "exceptional education status" since they do not function well without individual attention which is what they get in home schooling. 

  A better solution would have been to send the child to a private of  religious school, where the rules are a lot stricter than public school but the child gets the advantage of learning with other children their age. 

  The mother just doesn't want to let go.  You should have seen that!!!! 

  

  

   

   

  

Do you have any scientific evidence to back up these claims?  Anecdotal evidence doesn't count.  Dr. Phil provided empirical evidence cited in accredited scientific psychological and medical journals.  Your personal interactions with home-schooled children are no basis for making an assumption about ALL home-schooled children. 

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
sad
October 18, 2005, 2:28 pm PDT

Twisted society

  

Our society's way of thinking is so screwed up. How can a grandmother say these things about her own grand daughter. Annabelle doesn't need to lose weight, she needs to tone up. Why is society so focused on the "perfect body." This view is what causes eating disorders. Why is our society this way. If we want this problem to be fixed, we need to change our perspective on things.  

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
flirtatious
October 18, 2005, 2:28 pm PDT

Homeschooling beyond 8th grade

Hmm, the research shows, eh Dr Phil?  That wasn't much of an answer!  Anyone have a link to the study he was quoting?  I'm very disappointed. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2005, 2:29 pm PDT

boxing dream

Quote From: julsept

My son is into boxing and I hope is has changed his mind since his last match. In the first round he took a bad fall and injured his knee. It took 2 weeks to heal. This was only a friendly sparing match and there is still a risk of injury. He had had a few matches that I didn't go to and I just happened to go to the one he got injured in. It is hard to stand and just watch someone you love get hurt. I told my son if he does it again not to tell me till it is over as I will never watch him fight again.  

  

I hope your husband listens to you as I do not like boxing and don't understand why they want to inflict damage to others or have it done to them in this way.  

I think that a wife should advise her husband of her feelings and let him know the negatives and positives, but it is his life and he needs to make the decisions for himself. One of the worst things to go through life with is regret. If he gets injured, he will have to live with the decision he made. I know it will affect her too, but I can just see him blaming his regret on her and it becoming an expandinf, irrepairable hole in their bond until eventually it is gone.  I think she needs to support him in his dream. he may decide against it later on.
 
First | Prev | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | Next | Last