Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 9:18 am PDT

Finally someone who can read!

Quote From: mommyjenna

 If  I can step in, the only comparison he (or she?) is making here is that both groups claim their orientation is something they were born with.   That's it. 
Thank you.  At least now I know I am speaking english. Just like some people chose to be gay, they also chose to see only what they want to see and ignore the truth.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 9:32 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: rapunzel

"It is not Christians that are doing this and please stop making that truly absurd claim unless you can prove it somehow. 

I'm sure at some point a gay person has beat up a straight person but who cares?  I'm not going to find that information and start claiming that gays are beating up on straights because that would be equally as absurd and unfair." 

  

I'm only going on historical record. many-gaybashings are perpetrated by people who claim to be christian. christians are responsible for the colonization of many many peoples. KKK members claim to be christian. If they claim to be christian, and use the bible to defend their actions, who am I to say they aren't christian? you say you're christian. many people on this board say hateful things about gay people and claim to be christian. who am I to say you guys aren't christian? (and I don't mean to lump you with the some of the others here - you've pretty well expressed your views without the hate and name-calling some of the others have employed). but you get my gist. if people say they're christian, I believe it. it's not my absurd claims at all. I think it's crazy that people say they are christian, follow a loving god etc, then say he/they hate/s all the gayness. but definitely not *my* absurd claim.  

  

re: your hypothetical situation...sure, if you were muslim, jewish, whatever, saying the same things, i would have a similar reaction (though I think 'hateful' a 'spewing venom' is a bit harsh). I may not be *as* upset because I don't have to deal the harm that muslim/jewish beliefs about homosexuality cause, the way I do christian beliefs, but yeah, if you were muslim, or atheist for that matter, and you were perpetuating a belief system that directly harmed children (and others), I'd have a pretty strong reaction. I'm not tryna be an ass cuz you're christian, I want equal rights, and children who have the opportunity to be accepted for who they are. currently, christianity is doing the most damage to gay/trans/whatever kids, and to the movement for equality, so I take particular issue with christianity - but only as long as it remains so dedicated to the oppression of gays. I'm prepared to lay of my negativity toward christianity, when it lays off the gays. 

  

if you're referring to me re: hateful outrageous claims, I have to disagree. sorry if I've been a little snappy - it's hard to keep you separate from some other posters here - but I definitely don't think my claims have been outrageous, and most definitely not hateful. sorry if they came across that way, but they are all very real issues to me. 

  

 as far as your comments re: me being an egocentric american, I'm neither egocentric, nor american. however, america is a right-wing christian country. it's also the only super power on the planet. it's the richest and most pwerful country on the planet. because of that, is has a great deal of control over the rest of the planet (ie, can defy the united nations, blow up other countries, take their resources, generally coerce a good portion of the world into doing as it's told etc etc) -- so, christian country with more power and control than any other country...not mention christians outnumbering everyone else. you do the math as far as christians being in control goes. some are being martyred, for sure, but it kind of goes with the territory. I am in no way suggesting it's ever justified to harm anyone, but people of peaceful religions, content to let others have their own beliefs, don't tend to become martyrs, or be the target of violence. if people are opressed long enough, they're gonna revolt, and christians are doing a lot of oppressing (or certain presidents are oppressing in the name of christianity - same difference to the people being oppressed).  

  

I saw your other post where someone posted stats about violence in marriage - they are higher than the stats I learned in school, but seeing as though I've been so flaky as far as finding and posting them goes, those are as good as any. I was surprised they were so high from that source.  

  

  

 What historical record?  

Gay bashings happen by bullies.  

No one here has said homosexuals don't deserve equal civil rights.  They do have equal civil rights and they certainly deserve equal civil and human rights, just like anyone else.  We just don't want them having the right to marry.  We also want to make it clear that if they follow the Bible, the Bible is also pretty clear that homosexuality is a sin, at least the way I am reading and am open to changing my mind, if someone can present some really good arguments.   These two subjects can lead to an enlightening debate but it's too difficult in this forum.  There are too many people who just have no idea what they are talking about (not meaning you) and we have to waste too much time answering them and the real discussions get lost in the mess.

I don't know if I would consider America a right wing Christian country.  I do think that there are more Christians in America than probably any other country, per capita.  I also don't think that America is the only superpower on the planet. I would include China and Japan  for sure as well as possibly others. 

The Christians who are living in some Muslim countries or China have to be very secretive.  They cannot openly meet or profess Jesus or they will be jailed or killed.  This kind of thing happens daily. 

You have probably seen the fish symbol for Christians.  That began because it was illegal to talk about Jesus.  So, if you just met someone and didn't know if they were Christian, you would draw one half of the fish.  If the other person drew the other half, you would then know it was safe to talk about Jesus.  Christians were martyred since the beginning of Christianity.  The early Romans used to throw them to the lions in the beginning.  Paul, one of the new testament writers, was actually one who used to kill Christians, until he converted himself.  Every one of the 12 apostles died because they would not renounce Christianity.  As well, during the Inquistion, true Christians who stood out against the astrocities being committed under direction of the Roman Church were also martyred.  And it's continued right into modern times.  




 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 9:44 am PDT

he does not think he is transgender

Quote From: rlanthier

Your son's gender issue, is not necessarily a sign that he is gay. Transgenders are not gay. They identify with the opposite sex. Gay men identify with being male and under no circumstance would want to have their penis removed. But I still think it's too early to tell if your son is even a transgender. This is a question for Dr. Phil.
I would agree with you except that he no longer wishes  to have his penis removed and does not wish to be a woman.   He is now 17 and is quite insistent that he is gay.  I wish I thought it was a phase that could pass, but have given up on that hope.  Even the psychiatrist says he presents as a gay male.   I feel for the parents of the little boy on that show, because that is exactly what my son was like when he was that age.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 9:47 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: tammyo1973

I am a stay at home mom. My husband works 80-110 hours a week and I hate to say it but I am the head of the household. I pay the bills. I say when we can do things. I spend the money. I make all the big money choices in our house.  I would have to say just because he is the money maker doesn't mean he is the "head" of the household. Am I a sinner because I run our home? Just wondering. 

 No you are not a sinner in any way.  If that arrangement works well for your family then that is great. 

Jesus commands husbands to love their wives as Christ loved the church.  He then tells wives to submit to their husbands - certainly not to all men - only those who are following the Biblical model.  If a man is loving a woman the way he should, then submssion will come naturally to the woman.  This is if both parties are following Christ.  And this doesn't mean that he can boss her around or that she has to submit to his every whim.  The man is to seek God's will on important matters concerning the family and God will give him the answers, then the wife should submit.  For instance, if a husband were to to be offered a job in another country, the wife may not be willing to go at first.  Both seek God's guidance and then the husband will eventually come up with the right answer for the whole family, because he has sought out God's guidance, it will be the right answer.  The woman has to trust her husband and God that this is the right move.    How many divorces happen because there comes a big issue where no one wants to give.  Families are upheaved, children go through trauma etc. 

In any organization at all - a company for example, there has to be one person at the top who has the final say.  Otherwise, companies would also fold and be unproductive.

Now, that doesn't mean that the man cannot consider all of the wife's arguments and make his decision based on her needs more than his own.  It's about love.  Love for God and for your spouse.  It's not about selfishness or bossing someone around at all. 

Also, that being said, because men have more authority in this manner, they will also be judged more harshly.  Personally, as a women, I like that the major decisions fall on my husband.  That may be a cop out but I trust him.  I also trust him more than myself when it comes to finances and things of that nature because he is better in that regard than I am.    I will also certainly put in my input if I disagree with him and often he'll change his mind based on that, but often if a decision is up in the air and we both have good points of view, I really don't mind letting him have the final say if I believe he's seeking God's help when making the decision.  And as well, if he's loving me the way he is commanded to do. 
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
confused
October 25, 2005, 9:48 am PDT

childlove movement?

Quote From: sboyd55

  

  

The word pedosexual was coined by childlove activists somewhere between the 80's and 90's of the 20th century 

  

 

Because of this shift from "romance" to "illness", certain activists in the modern childlove movement decided to adopt a new term which they feel more fairly and accurately represents their attractions as how it relates to modern atonement of the sentiment and practice of pederasty. This term is pedosexual. The word reflects the gay rights movement's decision to shift from "homophile" to "homosexual". 

 

 

  

 

I live in a small town and dont get out much.  LOL  What exactly is this childlove movement?  I have never heard of that before either!  Is that pretty much like people wanting to have sex with children and claiming that its fine in the name of love?  Hence: Childlove movement? 

  

You know... im actually a bit scared to read your response!  *biting nails*    I do appreciate you explaining though!  THANK YOU! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 9:49 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: dbrrtt1

If he even thought he was a Christian (which he didn't) he wouldn't have killed himself.  

  

So anyone who, under any circumstances, commits suicide, wasnt really a Christian? 

  

How do we make that distinction? 

  

So, anyone who, under any circumstances, tells a lie, steals food, etc, aren't really Christians? 

  

Cause Im pretty sure the Bible says that Gods is the only one who knows everybodys hearts, and what will come on the day of judgment.  And there is no sort of list stating which sins Christ's blood can and cannot wash clean. 

 Do you believe Hitler was a true follower of Christ?  Yes or no.

Do you believe he was a liar? 
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
confused
October 25, 2005, 9:53 am PDT

Ummmmm

Quote From: mommyjenna

 Mohammed wrote the Koran.  

Mohammed had a four year old wife.  He started sleeping  with her when she was nine.  He also had more wives than he said should be allowed in the Koran. 

The koran also condemns homosexuality.  As well, it's okay, according to the Koran to beat your wife with a stick (after other 'disciplinary' measures are taken, of course)

You claimed you were Anglican. Well, Anglicans certainly do not follow the Koran.  They follow the Bible. 

I'm not even going to ask you again about this subject because you'll come up with some other wacky answers.

Im confused.  Is there some reason you say Anglicans dont follow the Koran?    Surely you must know there are in fact Anglicans who follow the Koran?   Also you must know that not all Anglicans follow the Bible?   

  

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 10:00 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: rlanthier

you said: By your logic then are all people insane?  

  

It's not my logic. It's the logic of those who would excuse all Christian corruption with the disclaimer that it isn't Christian by the very fact that it's corrupt. Nice.. 

  

The definition of insanity is not so general. A sane person can be considered sane by their 'normal' patterns of behavior, regardless of the exceptions 

  

Christians, on the other hand, have historically violated the stricture of their own morality for centuries. They obsess over homosexuality and sexual sins that have only a passing mention and yet commit the grossest atrocities against humanity.  

It isn't the exceptional behavior, it is more frequent than that otherwise Paul would not have to had to write Romans. That letter was addressed to a CHRISTIAN community. He didn't say, well you've engaged mostly in corrupt behavior, so you're not christians. 

  

  

  

  

  

I just want to butt in here for a minute. Everyone who claims to be a Christian, is not a Christian. I know this because I have gone to church all my life and have seen deacons of my church saved after thinking they were saved a long time ago. I point this out because I am sure there are people on this board who think they are Christians but in God's book they are not. I am not going to judge them though that is up to God. So a lot of people have formed an opinion about Christianity when in reality they are looking at people who don't even follow the word themselves. The people you are talking about pick and choose what they want to follow. I choose to follow the whole Bible. I don't claim to be perfect and I know that sin on a daily bases. This is the nature of the human flesh. It is not perfect nor could it ever be. A Christian is suppose to be Christ like. Will anyone ever be just like Jesus, NO but we are suppose to try. Accepting Christ as your person savior is the only way to be a Christian, and then you try to model your life after what the Bible says in order to live your life the way God wants you too. 

Another thing, a true Christian will tell you that all sins are equal. God doesn't see one sin bigger than another. I think that Christians speak out against the sins we as humans have the most control over. The ones we feel you have a choice to commit or not. But either way it doesn't matter what sin we speak out against because we are going to be put down for it no matter what it is. Christian are constantly belittled for their beliefs, and although our country was founded on it, our children are not allow to learn about it in school. They can learn about other cultures and their religions and they can learn about Darwinism but they can't even speak the name God because it might offend someone. I see something wrong with that! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 10:02 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: dbrrtt1

Homosexuals I have talked with who demonstrate true conversion tell me the hardest thing for them was admitting it was a sin and the second hardest was denying themselves any homosexual sexual contact.  

  

Funny, cause when I went through the phase of my life where I thought I could change, I thought homosexuality was a sin, and I was still a virgin... neither were hard to accept.  What was still impossible...  "true conversion."  

A former homosexual friend of mine still struggles with porn but that's it for him now.  He wants to eventually marry a woman but only when he knows he's fully capable.

He also said that his admission was very difficult and for a long time, he was able to reconcile the Bible verses in his mind.




 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 10:06 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: april_lk

I am not Muslim (by the way, you can be Muslim and not wear the hijab) 

  

I merely stated that if anyone can speak about the word of God, it's the Muslims, because God is the author of the Koran, the Bible only worked on heresay after 40 years of playing telephone. 

  

Either way I contend to people thinking for themselves. 

 There was no 'playing telephone" with the Bible.  The words were written down.

Proof is in the Dead Sea scrolls which contain some of the books.  For instance, the book of Isaiah, the words are identical, right to the usage of punctation.  As well, there have been other ancient copies found and none of the archeaology proves anything but that when the scribes copied the words, they were nothing but meticious.  God chose the right people (the Jews) to preseve his word.   Most recent archaological proof only about 3 weeks ago, was a 2000 year old copy of the book of Leviticus. 


 
First | Prev | 128 | 129 | 130 | 131 | 132 | 133 | 134 | 135 | 136 | 137 | Next | Last