Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:04 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: lisamcghee

IF YOUR FAMILY WENT TO CHURCH THEN YOUR DAD SHOUDLD KNOW THE BIBLE SAYS (LEVITICUS 18:22) THOU SHALT NOT LIE WITH MANKIND AS WITH WOMANKIND IT IS ABOMINATION. 

  

(MARK 10:6,7) BUT FROM THE BEGINNING OF THE CREATION GOD MADE THEM MALE AND FEMALE 

                            FOR THIS CAUSE SHALL A MAN LEAVE HIS FATHER AND MOTHER AND CLEAVE TO HIS WIFE. 

  

  

Yep...my dad stuggled with that daily. But he is also HUMAN, we all fall short. One sin isn't greater than another.  A sin is a sin, and we ALL sin. So who are you to judge? I don't understand how we can just judge people without looking at our own lives....
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
frustrated
October 19, 2005, 2:05 pm PDT

What if it isn't a phase?

Quote From: ttrttrttr

I used to baby sit a 4 year old boy who put on my little sisters necklaces, purses and heels. He is Now 17 and not gay. Parents don't need to get so upset over kids just role playing. Children learn by playing and I believe parents who make a big deal out of this could cause a problem where there wouldn't of been one.

 When my son was 2 and put on my nylon knee highs and my high heels and prances around in his blue diaper I took pictures and tought it was cute.  When I would catch him with my lipstick all over his mouth, again, I thought it was cute.  Then when he got a little older I would find girly panties from my sister's house (she has girls his age), stuffed in places in his room.  His brother that is 16 months younger, never did any of this though.  This behavior has continued.  Everyone said it was a phase.  Even today, Dr. Phil said that it is more than likely to be a phase.  My son turns 16 next week.  Last week we caught him dressing up in a g-string.  We are contantly finding lingerie hiden in his room, which he has stolen from other peoples homes and such.  I have tried talking to him about.  I have told him that I want to understand, that I am not upset or mad.  But I did tell him that the stealing needs to stop.  If he is having gender issues we will deal with it, but I won't condon stealing.  

  

My point is this, I don't think it is always a phase.  I am upset and torn about what to do to help my son and me to understand this all.  I don't know if he is gay or not, that wouldn't matter to me.  But I do want him to learn to accept himself and understand his gender and his preferences if that is the case.  I am so lost and confused by it all. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:06 pm PDT

Little boy likes girl things

There is absolutely nothing wrong with alittle boy playing with girl things. My son went through a phase where he loved Strawberry Shortcake. My sister-in-law bought him a Strawberry Shortcake doll, which he adored and carried everywhere. That was 2 years ago. For Halloween this year, he's going to be Darth Vader. Somehow, he wasn't scarred by playing with girl items. I work with children, and it's been my experience that boys LOVE to dress up in girl clothes. It's fun, and doesn't make them gay. In fact, there is evidence to suggest that boys who play with dolls as young children, actually grow up to be more loving companions and fathers. To the parents who are worried, please check out the book William's Doll.
 

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:07 pm PDT

I must have missed something!

Quote From: dukebites

If gays cannot be healed of their behavior, then there's no hope for bulimics, alcoholics, or anyone else suffering with the other afflictions the Bible speaks of as sin.  Of course God can, does and will heal gay people.  To disagree is to limit His power to do just what He promised-to deliver us from all evil.  But there's a caveat-"If we confess our sins, He is faithful to forgive us". When did Gay become OK, and holiness become optional? Sure we all have free will, but there are always consequences -good and bad, to every action.  Has anyone gone to the Bible to see what it really says about homosexuality. It seems that there are three camps in America: Those who believe that the Bible is true AS IS, not to be "interpreted" ; those who completely reject the Bible as truth; and those who feel the two aforementioned sides can be blended by synthesizing personal opinions and relativistic morality (based on something other than absolute truth).  But what does the Bible itself say?  Why hasn't anyone said the real truth about homosexuality? HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SPIRITUAL ISSUE!  IT IS NOT CHOSEN, NOR IS IT GENETIC.  There is no evidence to support the genetic theory, nor do I believe that you can just up and change your sexual attraction anymore than an alcoholic can just stop drinking.  Even if there were scientific evidence to support the genetic link, that stil wouldn't make it right, anymore.  Think about it-there is a proven genetic predispositon to alcoholism, but no one is marching in the streets for the right to be drunk-genetics don't excuse the behavior.  There are a few who turn away from their sin of choice cold turkey because God instantaneously delivers them, but for most everyone else, we have our own personal crosses to bear.  Paul never had his thorn removed-he learned to live with it WITHIN the confines of Gods Word.  For the homosexual, that may be struggle with same-sex desires til the day he or she dies, it may mean celibacy.  For the straight adulterer, it may mean strict accountability everyday, all day.  But there are plenty of ex-gay people who have struggled and won-and they are living the hetero life they never thought they could.  I once heard a preeminent physician who specializes in treating transgendered people say something that can be applied across the board in the 'sexual orientation' arena: "We have patients in their 20's who come to us weighing 78 pounds at 5' 8', who truly believie that they are overweight, obese even.  In their minds and hearts you cannot convince them that they are not overweight-their behavior reflects this in purging and or not eating, etc. Similarly, if a person thinks they are gay or transgendered, they may really believe that, feel it and act on it,  but just like the bulimic or anorexic, that doesn't necessarily make it so, nor does it make it right".     Homosexuality is called a 'familiar' spirit in the Bible, one of those sins that can be passed through generations just like the Old Testament says-a generational curse.  That would explain why very young children exhibit homosexual tendencies without ever having been exposed to abuse, other trauma or neglect.   It is no different from any other sin in God's eyes-no better, no worse.  The good news is that homosexuality CAN BE OVERCOME! I believe that the real thing that bothers most Bible believing Americans isn't so much homosexuality, but the pervasive atttude that 'Gay is OK' which stands in open, arrogant defiance to the Word of God, which the majority here hold true.  For those of us who do respect and revere God's Word whether Old or New Testament (Orthodox Islam and Judaism inluded), the beginning of healing from ANY sinful issue (which we ALL HAVE!) begins when we CONFESS our sins-we all have our crosses to bear-this implies struggle.  Some struggle with weight, others with perverted sexual attractions, others with drugs and alcohol.   The problem with homosexuals is that they have decided that what God says (that homosexuality is sin) is wrong. According to 'gay' people, there is no sin to confess!  Because it is a difficult thing to overcome, because it is painful to admit this particular thing in this country (let's be honest, many of us are not very friendly to homosexuals here in the US!), gay folks have employed the classic defense mechanism  that we all have done when we know deep down that we are wrong-they have become aggressive which they call 'activist', intolerant and defiant of those who disagree with their beliefs-especially people of faith.  But is it really fair to ask someone to be accepting of something that they believe is dangerous and wrong? Would you ask a truly Orthodox Jew to eat pork? Far be it!  In the same vein, it is utterly repugnant for most people to think of homosexuality as OK, regardless of what's happening with the "breeder" crowd.  Marriages may be going down the tubes faster than ever, shacking up may be at an all time high, but it doesn't make these or any other deviant behaviors, including homosexuality or polygamy (for that matter) more credible.  That doesn't mean, however, that we have to lead totally separate lives.  And it doesn't mean homosexuals are doomed to burn! There is healing and deliverance for homosexuals.  It will take honesty, time, discipline, accountability, and a true willingness to get help.  You may fall, everyone does at some time or other.  For those of you with 'gay' family members, if you really love them, tell them TRUTH.  Do not shun them, but set boundaries that honor God while also letting them know in no uncertain terms that you love them just as God does, imperfections and all.  Show them mercy just as God shows each of us every day.  Perversion is NOT LOVE.  God has been gracious enough to give us a detailed guide of how to live safe, happy and healthy lives rather than leaving us to guess what He wants and how to do things. Just look at the story of Cain and Abel--sacrifice animals, not fruit! Homosexuals have taken on the role of Abel, angry with their brothers because God accepts their heterosexuality but not the alternatives.   God loves everyone the same, and applies the same standard to everyone. He loves us all and shows us all the same mercy and grace as we trust Him to perfect us in this life. Can we choose to do it outside of His way? sure.  Is it wise? Absolutely not. 

When did eating disorders become a sin?  

  

Dang, and here I thought it was an illness.  

  

Of course, if it is an illness, then how can it be a sin? Illnesses are not chosen behaviors. Sins are.  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:07 pm PDT

Very Disturbed by Today's Show

  

I found today's show disturbing.  While as a Christian I am to emulate the love of Christ I also have a responsibility to express the truth and to do so lovingly. 

  

I have seen first hand the destructive forces of a homosexual lifestyle having lived with a family member that lived and totally embraced this lifestyle.  His life was dark, unhappy and he often abused drugs and alcohol to deal with the emptiness.  He attended a "gay" church and played the piano and was very involved but he never found peace.  The truth was withheld from him and in an effort to be inclusive his lifestyle was glossed over. 

  

The truth is, homosexuality is a sin, just like promiscuity, adultery, fornication.  It is not an orientation any more than choosing to kill is one.  It is a horrible bondage that appears to be just another lifestyle choice but in reality it is a slippery slope into darkness, emptiness and deception.  My uncle died gripped by this deception and never knew the joy and peace anyone can find in a relationship with Jesus Christ.  To tell someone caught in this sin that they are OK, just different and that God will understand and may have even created them this way is as devastating as telling someone sick with cancer that they are OK, just live with it, there is no need to seek a cure.  You are just as good as everyone that does not have cancer.  You have just condemned that person to death.  When we ignore the truth of God's Word and don't love enough to confront sin and show people that there is a cure, we condemn them to eternal death and separation. 

  

When one comes to Jesus Christ for forgiveness and healing of sin that person is not only forgiven but God tells us in His Word that He makes them a new person that is now no longer a slave to sin.  It is still a struggle but if one goes to God daily, seeking Him through prayer, Bible study and the support of other Christians, there is victory.  I know this to be TRUE because of my own life and testimony.  There is a cure for all sin, deception and bondage and it is found in a relationship with Jesus Christ.  If you are searching for the truth and want help go to www.precept..org.  They are a Bible Teaching ministry and are there to help everyone find peace, love and truth God's way.  Jesus said, "I am the way, the truth and the life." 

  

Thanks for taking the time to read this and please pray for all those caught in this lifestyle. 

Tracee 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:08 pm PDT

For the worried parents

I have an awesome book to recommend to you.  My husband and I read it and feel that it is going to be a valuable resource for raising our boy.  It is called Bringing up Boys, by Dr. James Dobson. 

Here is a blurb about it:  Boys are different! But with pressure to be "gender neutral," many try to mold children into a one-size-fits-all model. Dr. Dobson explains why boys are the way they are, how to understand their emotional and physical development, and the best way to motivate them to become godly men.   Best wishes!  You have such a cute little guy!! 

 

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:10 pm PDT

To you with a true Christian View

Quote From: a31g49

Why is it so hard for so many on this site to understand that not everyone is a christian and not everyone is a born again christian. 

  

I happen to be Native American and am proud of my heritage-- ethnic and spiritual.  My culture doesn't condem people for living how they are made.  We don't believe we own our children-- meaning we can not chose their path for them-- we can only guide them.   

  

 We have nothing in common with fundamentalist christians when it comes to belief systems.  Many in my community have embraced a spirituality (christianity) which DESTROYED our culture and way of life.  It's a very sad thing.  But I suppose when you are confronted with "Convert or die"  many do choose to accept the conquerers way of life. 

  

So, when you all start going on and on about what your god wants from all people of the earth, all I can do is shake my head at your ignorance.  For isn't that what you do when you are confronted with traditions different from your own? 

  

I believe the Earth is the mother of us all, and that we are destroying our mother.  Can't you hear her screams?  But do I tell you SUV driving, 6000 square foot house living, polluting non-bleievers that you our murdering our mother?  Isn't that more important that who someone loves?  No, I don't.  Not generally, anyway. 

  

My tribe has a cultural history of accepting all among us as brothers and sisters.  Including those who do not fit into traditional gender roles.  Including those who are attracted to those of the same sex.  It's all around us on mother earth.  All mammal species show same sex attraction.  While it is not the norm, it is not unnatural. 

  

You do not get the right, because you call yourself a christian to comdemn people who believe other than you do.  And you sure don't get the right to make the laws that affect us all according to your religion. 

  

You surely do not have the right to impose self-hatred and self-loathing on people being true to their born selves. 

  

I'm so thankful I live in a part of the country where I do not have people like the visitors on this board trying to convert me to their religion. 

  

And all of this judgement day stuff is a little confusing.  I remember that less than 20 years ago, that kind of reasoning was only used by doomsday cultists like Jim Jones or David Koresh.  It's frightening to me how many seemingly sane Americans have fallen into the doomsday cult mentality. 

  

I could really get into the jesus rhetoric if more pople who claimed to be christians quoted the Sermon on the Mount insteas of leviticus. 

  

I am not gay, but I have had the pleasure of knowing many gays, lesbians and transgendered people throughout my lifetime.  I am the richer in spirit for it. 

  

And I almost for got.  For those illogical people who claim that god doesn't make mistakes?  What about people born transgendered?  In  the US, the birth rate of people with ambigous genitalia (intersex) is about 2% of live births.  So those people are not mistakes?  I don't believe they are and according to your logic, you shouldn't, either.  But then that doesn't fit your worldview of two genders and strict gender based societal roles. 

  

I long for the day we all get past out superstitious knee jerk reactions to those who are different.  I am hopeful though.  It was only a little over a hundred years ago that the official US government position on my people was 'the only good indian is a dead indian.' 

  

Maybe someday the attitudes I'm seeing here toward those who are gay/lebian/bisexual/intersex/transgendered are just as abhored by mainstream society. 

  

I might have to do some prostelytizing of my own, if I had to face this type of self-righteousness on a daily basis. 

I am so sad for you that you have been treated in a wrong manner by those who call themselves Christians. Before you decide I am a fundamentalist nut, let me just say I am the sister of an openly homosexual male who I love with all of my heart. My best friend has also been living an openly lesbian lifestyle for the past 18 years and I still love her like a sister without judging her. I am also 1/16 Choctaw and finally I am a true Christian. Basically what the world calls Christians are religious people who don't exemplify Jesus. If they or you read the Bible you would see that Jesus did not hang out with the religious people of His day and was often accused by those same religious people for hanging out with sinners. I am not religious. Unfortunately in our country all sides, whether they are Christian or not, Gay or not, believe their point of view is the right one. While reading your post, I felt great sorrow for you because while you were condemning the religious people who'd posted, you couldn't see in your anger that you were being just as bad as they were. We all need to quit waging our own little wars for our viewpoint and leave each other alone. For our country to be called the United States of America, we have never been more separated. We are divided by race, gender and sexual orientation. Finally I would say this to you and would just ask that you really think about it...is it any more right for homosexuals to shove their sexual orientation down the throats of heterosexuals than for heterosexuals to shove their sexual orientation down the throats of homosexuals? Neither way is right. What two people do in the privacy of their own bedroom is their own business, however if you put it out there into a public forum, you make it the business of other people, so you can't get mad if they don't agree with you. Dr. Phil was right, the first lady wasn't really having an issue with her sister about her sexual orientation, but they had other issues going on. I hope that in your life instead of running into and dealing with religious people you have many more come into your life who are true Christians. Take a look in a mirror and you might find your behavior is just like those you are having a problem with, because you are really angry and feeling that your way is the right way just like them. That's what really showed in your post.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:10 pm PDT

Be gay

Quote From: starscars

As a faithful Catholic I belive firmly in "hate the sin love the sinner" that said, the Catholic church does not have a problem with a person being "gay" "lesbian" but when that person acts on it sexually it is considered a mortal sin. I know gay and lesbian people who are choosing to live a celibate life without ever engaging in any form of sexual act, is it a difficult life? Yes, but we are talking about your mortal soul and in the long run this life is nothing compared to our life in Heaven, do you want to be in Heaven or Hell? God has made it very clear that it is not ok to have sex with the same sex, if God wanted it that way there would be no aids, what type of God would allow that? A man and a woman were made just right to come together in marriage and have children, that is from God, if God wanted same sexes together they would be able to have children together and they would not be able to give aids to eachother. 

I think that we need to pray for gays and lesbians that God will give them the strength to live celibate lives and not act on their sexual needs, there is way more to life than sex. 

Im straight and very christian But.. 

IF your Gay and happy Be gay and happy."It saves more men for the woman if your lesbian,and more women for the men if your gay".I dont think theres anything wrong with that.If your gay theres absolutly nothing wrong with that.For me though.Every gay person i've ever met are awesome. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:11 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

I'm 16 going on 17 and i'm a bisexual i believe god made me this way for a reason. Just because u like the same sex does not mean that god hates them. if u judge some1 before u know them u should b punished not them for the wat they choose to live they're life
 

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 2:12 pm PDT

Another point

Quote From: lr90angel

Um....the woman didnt just TURN gay after 15 years, she always was gay. Gay people want so badly just to live a "normal" lifestyle and she thought that getting married and having "well adjusted" (why wouldnt they be?) kids would help her. But in the end, she still wasnt fullfilled and she perhaps was sick of living a lie. Understand? You would be suprised of how many millions of people out there are married to the opposite sex and are still secretly gay. Society is so unaccepting of gays and thats probably why it took this particular woman so long to "come out". Hope this answers your question.
Society is so intolerant of alternative sexuality of all sorts that many people are unable even to admit it to themselves.  She may honestly have not known that she was gay when she married her husband.
 
First | Prev | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | Next | Last