Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:27 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: tselb2

I am a Christian, not a Paulian.  I read the entire Bible, not just parts of it.  Of course, Jesus would say nothing about gays not entering heaven, you said that was not "invented" until the 18th century.  And I believe in "Loving God with your whole heart. . ." you will in turn follow his divine direction.  So, are you saying that repentence is not necessary? 

  

I'm using the NIV, but the King James has it as well when the KJ uses fornication, it is referring to the sexual act between two people who are not married.  Since the Bible refers to a marriage as being between a man and a woman, this act is simply not possible.  Now, I understand there are people who simply live together with others of the same sex and do not perform any sexual act, but that is not the case for the majority. 

  

Why should "catamite" be condemned?  According to your ideas, as long as they "Love God with their whole heart. . ." they will get eternal life.  Gosh, I could do just about anything and get eternal life?  Ya, I don't think so. 

  

I believe, as well (though you may call me a Genisisian) that God created Adam and saw that nothing was fit for his companion other than the creation of a woman has GREAT significance. 

  

Who is bickering?  I'm certainly not.  I just am so sorry that people are deceived by the ways of satan.  It is very easy to fall victim to  his ways.  I, on the other hand, am FAR from being a victim.  Yet more a victor.  Jesus Christ allows this for me.  And to answer your last question, I'm CLEARLY a Christian. 

  

tselb2 

Well I am very happy you see yourself as a followr of Christ and not a follower of Paul and that you read the entire bible. SO DO I. So we have that in common. The only point I was trying to make was that  a TRUE Christian follows Christ as God's Word not the writings of Paul as God's Word.  

  

God only has ONE TRUE WORD and it is Jesus. To say that anything else is God's true word is idolatry.  

  

Furthermore, we do not obey Paul on MANY things he suggested in his letters. He believed slaves should obey their masters in ALL things inTitus 2:9-10 and Ephesians 6:5. Today we Christians know slavery is WRONG and those who are enslaved have EVERY RIGHT to rebel and seek freedom and compensation. Paul believed a man is the head of a woman and women should never seek authority over a man. 1Corinthians 14:34-35 and 1 Timothy 2:11-15. Today we know women can be just as competent leaders, teachers, judges as any man. Peter often disagreed with Paul’s approach and writings, calling them “Difficult to understand” and contain things which the “unlearned and unstable” preoccupy themselves with. See 2 Peter 3:16 

  

This is why it is so important not to fall victom to bible fundamentalism. Just keep focused  JESUS Christ never changes because only HE IS THE WORD.  

  

As for your NIV transaltion. It is not a prefered translation of serious bible scholars and is used mainly by certain sects who like the way it is worded but often it has serious mistranslations. The translation you use is very important because many contain errors. The bible was afterall, copied, translated, compiled and edited by men. Men make mistakes all the time or misunderstand things. So get a version that is as close to the original Hebrew and Greek as possible and also invest in a Hebrew and Greek concordance to get the correct meanings of words when you are not 100% sure.  

  

God bless! 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:28 am PDT

say what!

Quote From: erichrissy

I can't believe that no one else has brought up the concern that an "ex-gay" man is now a priest.  The catholic church is the perfect place for homosexual men to lurk around pretending to be celibate when in fact they are molesting young alter boys behind closed doors. 

Umm, child molesters are heterosexual men, have you not watched Oprah and Dr. Phil shows on this topic.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:34 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: donshort01

Behavior is a choice. I draw this conclusion simply from observation, such as child abusers, serial killers, and gambling addictions, etc.  Behavior is a choice.  Yet there is no movement to approve and accept serial killers or child abusers.  The black and white line has simply become a tad bid grayer.  Yes, some of are driven, though feeling guilty still behave in an inappropriate manner.  How is right and wrong defined.  It is interesting to note that in the bible there is no sin mentioned that is not a choice.  “Though shall not commit adultery”!  These and similar behaviors are all choices, yet we have serial sexual addicts, adulterers and on and on. Unfortunately the gay community of apx 3% of population has managed to politicize there position successfully. 

Behavior is what we do, with defining marriage as between a man and a man, a woman and a woman where does thought process end?  Dog and Man, child and man, dog and woman, child and woman… there is something very WRONG with this thought process. 

The bottom line is it that “anything goes” or is it that some morality does exist?   

Food for thought. 

Don
 

We are not talking about behavior.  We are talking about orientation.  Two different matters.  Heterosexuality and homosexuality are orientations.  Behavior is an act of these persons.  You have no choice as to your orientation, but you can control behavior.  Behavior is a personal choice, you can do good things or bad things.  Bad things land you in jail.  Sexual behavior is no one's business.  What a person does in the privacy of his home belongs there unless it is illegal.  How can you as a heterosexual know anything about a gay person.  You don't my friend, no more than a gay man or woman understands your preferences.  So stop trying to be a judge, jury and expert on homosexual orientation.  10% of the population is more like it, not 3%.  You probably know more gays than you think.  In your family too!  Get your facts right and then you can talk.  My son is gay and my granddaughter is gay.  They are both the most moral individuals you can ask for.  My granddaughter does not dress like some of the young girls (that look like little prostitutes).  She is a virgin at 17.  My son has never fathered illegitimate children or raped or abused women (men).  Look at the heterosexual community - it is the hotbed of immorality and getting worse.  You...can you cast the first stone?  Look at your life, have you been the most moral person you can be.  If so, great, but you are in the minority. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:35 am PDT

When God Doesn't Change Your Sexual Orientation What Next?

I have talked to many Gay Christians and they totally get where Paul was coming from in Romans 7:15 to 25. they identify with Paul’s self loathing, depressing and defeating quest for a standard they can never attain. You could sense Paul’s frustration in these verses. He also grew disheartened when after asking God so many times to remove the “thorn” in his side, God would not do it. This symbolic “thorn” has come to symbolise for gay people, their homosexual orientation. Do you know how many gay people grow disillusioned and frustrated just like Paul, after asking God in tears and total depth of despair to remove their homosexuality and having it not come true?

   

 

  

Now I know when you are Christian you are told just  “Ask and it will be given” and so we think that just because we ask God for something with all our heart, soul and might and really pour out ourselves that God will always say “Yes” to our every prayer. Not true. Remember what we ask for has to be in accordance with what God wills for us at that particular time. Sometimes God says, ‘No.” to our prayers. This is when the REAL test of faith comes in. When a child we pray for dies anyway. When an injustice we pray to be righted is never corrected. We ask ourselves “WHY? Why would God allow this to happen?”  Paul cried out to God to “remove his thorn” and God said, “No.” WHY? According to 2 Corinthians 12:9 “My grace is sufficient for thee: for my strength is made perfect in weakness.”

   

 

  

Imagine that? God actually says that his strength is revealed in OUR WEAKNESS. For a gay person who sees their sexual orientation as a weakness, an imperfect “thorn”, God still manifests his spirit and strength in you. Just as God did not remove the thorn to make Paul a better, stronger and more importantly a HUMBLE person, he does not remove the sexual orientation of many gay people who ask it of Him. Instead he wants you to trust in Christ’s GRACE and find his strength in what you perceive as your weakness. Most gay people find that once they accept God’s answer and just let go of the self hatred they can be better, stronger people. You will find most gay Christians, because of their struggle in the faith are far more  humble, more empathetic, compassionate and a lot less judgemental of other people. Paul’s “thorn” was an inner struggle, a personal flaw. It did not violate Jesus’ commandment.  It was not an anti-social vice or crime against others. It was a secret matter between him and God. So too is a person’s sexual orientation.

   

 

  

Gay Christians are in a unique position to test faith not only theirs but those around them. If God exists and wants everyone to be straight and gay people pray to God to make them straight and it doesn’t happen. Boom! Decision time!  If after deep soul searching and intense commune with their Creator, in addition to therapy and spiritual counselling to address their sexuality, a gay person finds he or she still cannot change what do you want them to do? After inflicting emotional and mental scars upon themselves through these efforts, the time will eventually come when they will simply arrive at an ultimatum. Either

   

 

  

(1)     They get stronger in their faith and learn to depend more on Christ instead of bible dogma and man’s religious fundamentalism and trust God has a plan for them or…

   

 

  

(2)     Reject Christianity and the bible entirely as garbage.

   

 

  

The bible fundamentalists turn hundreds and thousands of gay people away from Christ every day by placing their bible dogma ahead of God’s love. Like Jesus said, ““Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You shut the kingdom of heaven in men’s faces. You yourselves do not enter, nor will you let those enter who are trying to.” (Matthew 23:13) We should therefore admire gay people who choose to remain Christians and have even taken up leadership and positive roles in the church and community. They have been through hell and back, walked the wilderness, suffered isolation and ridicule and still stuck with their faith. How many of us can say we have ever been tested like that?  

 
User Mood
Silly

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:41 am PDT

You can not choose sexual orientation

 Watching David go on TV made me feel very bad for him and the fact that he can't accept his sexulity and will probably never be in a loving relationship. I also feel bad for any homosexuals who are dealing with the pain of coming out, and had to hear him tell them they can change.
 Being  gay, there are two things that set me off. First, when people assume male on male pedophiles are "gay". Second, when people say I chose to be gay.

For anyone who thinks that homosexuality is a  choice,  when did you make the conscious decision to me straight? Did you get up one morning when you were 5, know the real societal differences between being straight/gay, and make an informed choice what to be straight? Please tell me the time in your life you made the decision to be straight and the consequences you weighed to make the decision.

I never said at 7-10 year old "Hmm, the world has two different sexualities, gay and straight. and now I have to make a decision" and chose gay. I did things labled as "gay" since before I was even in pre-school. Also remember  that kids can't think in abstract terms like "gay" so the idea of a kid choosing is ridiculous. In fact, during the toddler to pre-pubescent stages of child development a child thinks in terms of "me, me, me". Their brains have not developed to the point where they can reason with abstract terms or understand homosexuality on a societal level. Since parents pick up all types of signs that children are gay  from when they are young, you can't tell me a kid whose brain hasn't developed made a concious decision to be gay.
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:44 am PDT

(HANDS CLAPPING)

Quote From: openmind1

 

Jesus didn't gay people but he sure did HATE hypocrites! I see quite a few of them here on this message board. They are people who have become so full of pride and self-righteousness because they worship the bible AS GOD's WORD instead of JESUS as GOD'S WORD. They think by doing so they can get free license to predict God’s mind on EVERYTHING and use the bible to judge others.   

 

THIS IS CALLED FUNDAMENTALISM.  It is hypocritical. WHY? 

 

Because NO CHRISTIAN ever obeys the entire bible. It is impossible. Even Paul said he cannot do it. Read Romans 7:15 to 25. Paul says he CANNOT STOP SINNING! HE JUST CANNOT DO IT!  Therefore it amazes me how religious homophobes pick and choose which sins they want to biblically condemn according to their prejudices, personal comforts and popular opinion. These fundamentalist Christian sects are taking old outdated laws in Leviticus and Paul’s letters to the Christians living over 2000 years ago OUT OF CONTEXT and demanding slavish obedience to them. It’s like Jesus never came and set us free of this kind of dogmatic bondage. Bible fundamentalism results in laziness, literalism, hypocrisy, self-righteousness, complacency and rejection of scientific facts and modern discoveries leading to dogmatic stupidity.  

 

I want people to know that not ALL Christians are like these fundamentalist hypocrites. There are those of us out there who are still fair-minded people who do not impose impossible biblical standards on others when we KNOW FOR A FACT we cannot follow it ourselves. As Christians the ONLY person we are supposed to follow is Jesus. Only Christ is absolute. Christ IS the THE word John 1:14.  To worship ANY OTHER THING as the word of God is idolatry.Fundamentalists insist we need to follow Paul's suggestions as if they were GOD'S LAWS. But do they follow Paul in ALL things? They gloss over the fact that Paul also condoned slavery in Titus 2:9-10 and Ephesians 6:5 and believed women should not teach or have authority over a man in 1Corinthians 14:34-35 and 1 Timothy 2:11-15. Do these sects also follow this? Many of them don't.  

 

The truth is, we are not Paulians, we are Christians. Paul was just a human sinner like you and me, expressing his own feelings on spiritual matters. Paul and his writings are no different than any human priest or pastor today writing today. And just like today, even back then not all apostles agreed with Paul. Peter often disagreed with Paul’s approach and writings, calling them “Difficult to understand” and contain things which the “unlearned and unstable” preoccupy themselves with. See 2 Peter 3:16. IF Peter can disagree with Paul on certain matters and not take everything he said literally, so to can ANY CHRISTIAN. Even PAUL HIMSELF said in Romans 14:5 “Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind.” In other words, USE YOUR BRAIN and THINK FOR YOURSELF.   

 

The ONLY figure ANY Christian needs to follow is Christ.  

  • Did Jesus say we need to follow anyone's bible writingis to get eternal life? No. What did he say?  See Luke 10:25-37. 
  • What is the ONE commandment Christ ever demanded we follow the one that is the GREATEST and fullfills the ENTIRE LAW and PROPHETS? See: Matthew 7:12.
  • Which sin did Christ say is 100% UNFORGIVABLE. Is it having gay sex?-- See (Matt. 12: 31)
  • How is it supposed to FEEL when you are a Christian? Burdensome and self-defeating or liberating and joyful? See Mathew 11:28-30.

If your Christian sect is NOT teaching this as THE CORE of its doctrine and they are placing OTHER burdens or rules on you as Jesus warned some would Matthew 23:4, then they are nothing but Pharisees in disguise. If you are gay and in a sect that is causing you to experience self-hatred, suicidal thoughts, rejection, isolation, etc. then you are not in a religious sect that is following Christ but their OWN fundamentalist agenda.  

WOO HOO 

  

thank you thank you 

  

VERY VERY VERY well said, thought, put, whatever.. this is good!!! 

  

Pat yourself on the back for this one!!! 

  

Thanks Tammy :) 

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:45 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: indmiracle

I had a gay friend who died a few years ago.  Before his death, he often took care of his friends who were dying from AIDS, because their families would not have anything to do with them.  He also took care of a co-worker of ours (who, incidentally, was straight) when she had to have a kidney-transplant and her family lived out of town and was not available.  He was also going to take care of myself when I had bariatric surgery, but he died from an apparent heart attack before I had my surgery.  He would take time off from his job to care for people who needed someone with them.    

  

I cannot believe that my God.  My loving and caring God, did not care for him as much as He does for me.  A straight person.  I cannot and will not believe that.  

In no way does this say that God cares for someone more than others. But, God expects us to be obedient to Him as our Father. A parent wants their child to obey them because they love them. If they do not obey their parents, they are punished. Does this mean the parent does not love the child-NO!. If we love them, we will punish them. If you commit a crime, you must be punished. We have to answer for our actions eventually.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:46 am PDT

I agree with you

Quote From: riviera

I think being gay is genetic but not a good thing. I don't think it is normal or should ever be considered normal but a biological defect like mental illness. As so many people say they wouldn't choose it .  

A lot of people have experimented with bi-sexuality in their youth thinking gay sex is ok.  

I think if you are gay "that's nice" but I really don't care what you do in private.  I would like to know why so many married men go to parks to pay for sex with underage boys/ 

If you are gay, that's fine I don't hate you and I'm not scared of you.  However why would anyone gay or striaght want to put their sex life "out there" for the public  to see and hear about.  I am a straight married woman and I don't discuss my private life with anyone, and I don't want to discuss anyone else's private life either
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:47 am PDT

Serial Killer and Gay In The Same Sentence:

Oh please Don!!!!! That is not food for thought. It is rubbish.  

  

I will give you a little insight on what lesbians do on the weekends and I am speaking of myself and the woman I love dearly. 

  

 A few weekends ago we decided to get away for a few days and headed up to Pigeon Forge in the Great Smoky Mountains. Both of us like to travel and we both love to enjoy the view along the way. First stop after getting up mountains was a small roadside shop where they sell apples, jellies, baskets, etc. We bought the best apples and peaches in the world and munched on them till we got to Pigoen Forge and we enjoyed the view of the mountains at every turn in the road. 

  

We checked into our hotel and unpacked. It was dinner time so we explored the city and found a nice place to eat. The Old Mill and ordered a country style meal that was huge. We took most of it home in to go boxes. Then we traveled around the city at night; mostly taking the back roads to see the stars. Boring I know. 

  

Then we drove back to the hotel to change into our swimming suits so we could sit in the outdoor hot tub with our diet cokes, relax from a six hour drive and look at the stars again. Gay people are obsessed with stars. ;) Did I mention that we are both in our 50's and have the normal aches and pains of this age?  

  

We fell into bed exhausted and fell asleep in each others arms. The next morning we got up bright and early and headed to the Great Smoky Mtns National Park where we explored it as much as possible. We saw a water fall that had a trail which was paved. We decided we were going to take a shot at it even though I use a cane from nerve damage in both legs. We almost made it to the top while looking over our shoulders for the Black Bears who call this place home. Then a thunder storm popped up with lighting. Gay people are scared to death of lightening. ;) We huddled into a little cave soaking wet, chilled to wait out the storm so we could head back to the car. We talked about our kids and grandchildren; planning a visit to each of them in the near future. 

  

Then we headed back into our car and explored some more; stopped by a store and looked at the gemstone displays. We both enjoy rockhounding. Yeah gay people are obsessed with rocks too. ;) 

  

We drove back to the hotel to clean up so we could head out to dinner again. We went to Kentucky Fried Chicken. Yeah Gay people adore KFC! ;) After dinner we hit the pool and the hot tub again. Then we hit the sack again cuddled close. Wierd I know. :) 

  

The following morning we got up early and headed back for home taking a different route. We ended up on top of the highest peak Clingman's Dome in the Smokies. I could not manage to hike that steep trail and sent my g/f on ahead because she loves it so. I sat near the car taking photographs of the view. We got a bit lost on the way home because we took a wrong turn. Gay people can't find their way out of a wet paper bag. Didn't you know that? ;) 

  

We got home, checked the mail, checked messages, fed the cats and our dog. Unpacked, put dirty clothing into the washing machine. Had a light supper. Cleaned up the kitchen. Got into bed and talked about how  much fun it was to get up there this past weekend. We also planned on going back up there in a few weeks for a camping trip. If we can find one with good security because there have been several lesbians murdered in their sleeping bags in the past few years. And we didn't want to become another statistic. yeah gay people are freaky about that; we dont want to be murdered having fun with our partners and be slayed in our beds.  

  

It's a really boring life being gay. We own homes, we work in all sorts of jobs, we have kids and grandkids, we go grocery shopping (contrary to what you may think we don't have are own special stores for gays), we pay taxes, we get the flu, we vote, we eat out, we clean our homes and cut the grass, etc. All boring and very unexciting things gay people do on a day to day basis. 

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 6:47 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: jscarroll

Jesus Christ died on the cross for our sins. He paid the price for us so we don't have to.Homosexuality is a sin (not disputed at all), but so is acting like you are God. You have no right to say that anyone will be punished for sins that God has already forgiven. If you ask for forgiveness and believe in Him for the forgiveness, you will never hear about it from God, just narrow-minded, stiff-necked hippocrites. I have a few friends that are gay and I know them to be true Christians. When we stand before God on Judgement Day I truly believe we will be hearing about things we didn't do and not mistakes we made that are already forgiven.
 I'm sorry, but i have to agree with the person whose message you quoted. Yes Jesus died so that our sins can be forgiven, and yes he loves all of us, we imperfect sinners. But God expects us to recognize right from wrong and things that we can control, such as our actions, he expects us to control. So yes, I may have the feelings to have intimate relations with men to whom I am not married and God understands that is how I feel, but he also knows that if I rely on him,  I  can resist the urge, or temptation to give in to the wrong feelings. Same applies for homosexuals. That is why Juses when he taught his disciples to pray included the line "and lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from the wicked one." The Bible also states that God will not let us be tempted beyond wht we can bear in his strength. So yes, if any of us insist on acting on feelings that are wrong, we will be punished...not for having the feelings but for acting on them.
 
First | Prev | 68 | 69 | 70 | 71 | 72 | 73 | 74 | 75 | 76 | 77 | Next | Last