Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:04 pm PDT

Actually...no

Quote From: tulseyjoe

Actually there are two different versions of creation in the Bible.  

  

In Genesis chapter 1, male and female human beings, plural of each gender, were made at the very same time. And, there is says that God said "be fruitful and multiply." Humans are made after the land animals are created. In that chapter, God (plural) states, "Let us make humans in our images (literally)."  

  

But, in Genesis chapter 2, a human being (the proper translation of "adam" in context) is created and then God creates plants and also creates the garden/park known as "Eden." Then, God (the Hebrew word is actually plural, not singular) puts the human, aka the adam (the Hebrew word for "the" is used there), in the garden. 

  

When they (God) realized that the human is lonely, they said literally, "It is not good for the human to be alone; let US (plural) make a helper suitable for him."  

  

The KJV has "help meet" (note TWO words) for "helper suitable." "Helper" in the Hebrew text is "ezer" which is masculine (that's male in sex/gender). Some people think that "meet" means "mate" when "ezer" is another word for "mate." A helper who is a woman would be an "ezerah," which is the female form of "ezer." "Neged" is the word translated as "meet" or "suitable." A "neged" can be an identical copy of an original. Or it can be a copy of something with everything reversed as far as viewing is concerned.  

  

So the first adam had an identical copy of himself made (by God) which would have been a mirror image of himself if he were to look into a mirror.  

  

If you properly read the text, it was not God who said that the 2nd human being was an "eshah" (meaning taken from an "eesh") or was a "woman" because the 2nd person was taken from a "man," it was the 1st human who said that.  

  

Not even one time in Genesis chapter 2 does God tell those two humans they created to "be fruitful and multiply." Nothing is related to sexual reproduction until Genesis chapter 2 after the two humans eat of the fruit of the "Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil." That was the only thing the humans were told not to do. 

  

In chapter 3, when God (plural) asks, "Adam, where are you?" The verb in that question is plural and "adam," being a colletive noun, has the same spelling in Hebrew in both the singular and plural. "Adam" is like our words, "sheep" or "deer," which are spelled the same in singular or plural usage.  

  

Also, God NEVER calls/names the 2nd person "Eve." It is the first human who gives "her" that name. In Genesis 5, it is stated that God called both male and female human beings "adam."  

I don't remember ever reading that in the bible.Only the Mormon bibles have that.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:06 pm PDT

Wrong

Quote From: ddsmommy

Anjela, 

      I think that you are just trying to cry predjudice because people won't except your life style but I sure don't see you accepting anybody elses life style!  All homosexuals have an agenda.  They are all out there crying "poor poor me!" and want everyone to feel sorry for THEIR CHOICE in life!  And yes, it is a CHOICE.  Read your Bible and what God has to say about it and it is VERY clear!  Your sister is wrong that if you accepted Jesus that you can live any way you feel like living and you will just go to heaven.  You obviously never truly wanted to surrender your ENTIRE life to Christ because if you did you could have changed a long time ago and be heterosexual today in your actions.  You have always been heterosexual inside.  God did not make you that way.  Does He love you, Of course!  He loves me too even while I was a sinner and not saved.  I chose to trust in Christ and fully surrender my entire life to him and HE changed me once I repented of my sin and asked Him to save me and change my life.  You can turn over a new leaf  by yourself over and over but ultimately you will fail every time because you can't do it on your own.  So until you are willing to admit to God that homosexuality is a sin and nothing less just like alcoholism and stealing are sins, you will never be saved and you will never be free from this sin in your life.  Don't get me wrong, your homosexuality is no worse of a sin than any other sin that anyone has ever committed.  I would be happy to give you the numerous scriptures that I know are blatently against homosexuality.  God is a God of love but He is also a just God!  I think your father dying might have had something to do with your choices.  Maybe not.  There is usually some trauma that happened in the homosexuals life.  I do not hate homosexuals, just the sin.  I love every person that God has ever created.  But God gives us all a choice whether to choose Him and His way or to go our own way.  The Bible even says that after a certain time that He will give homosexuals over to a debased mind.  Meaning He will leave you to be in the life style you choose and He will not bother you further.  Yes, you will die in your sin and spend the rest of eternity in Hell burning for eternity.  Jesus doesn't want you there so please choose Him before it is too late!  He loves you and is waiting patiently.  

"until you are willing to admit to God that homosexuality is a sin and nothing less just like alcoholism and stealing are sins, you will never be saved and you will never be free from this sin in your life." 

  

I don't agree at all. Never be saved? So are you saying that those that drink and steal can't be saved either? When did the Blood of Jesus become so selective or impotent? 

  

Also Scripture does not say that "He will give homosexuals over to a debased mind". It says in Romans that certain people had (first) turned away from God and THEN they turned away from what was NATURAL (Greek word "phusikos") to that which was UNNATURAL to them. For an excellent write up on this passage in Romans I highly suggest your read the article found on the www.gaychurch.org web site titled "What is Natural?" It's located in the section of the site titled "Gay and Christian?" This web site is a sister site with Justin's web site (Justin was on the show). The link to the Gay and Christian section is below along with a link to the "What is Natural?" article. 

  

Gay and Christian?  

http://www.gaychurch.org/Gay_and_Christian_YES/gay_and_christian_yes.htm  

  

"What is Natural?" http://www.gaychurch.org/Gay_and_Christian_YES/calling_the_rainbow_nation_home/7d_gac_clobber_passages_what_is_natural.htm  

  

And more great articles on salvation and being gay... 

http://www.gaychurch.org/The_Word/Salvation/whosoever.htm  

http://www.gaychurch.org/Gay_and_Christian_YES/calling_the_rainbow_nation_home/3_gac_are_homesexuals_condemned_to_hell.htm  

  

In the "Gay and Christian?" section you will find every scripture used by some against homosexuals discussed. I suggest you read through these articles. You will find that your opinion (doctrine) is only one and that Christians interpret these passages differently. 

  

And yes there are other Christians out there who believe that gays are part of God's creation too. At last count there were over 3,550 Gay "Welcoming" congregations out there. Again I cite the church directory on the www.gaychurch.org web site as proof of this. 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:07 pm PDT

What?

Quote From: rlanthier

you said: many times in the Bible  

Really? I can barely count more than three. All the quotes but one are from the Old Testament. 

  

Are you justifying these un-Godly actions?
 

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:12 pm PDT

Further Thoughts

Quote From: jandrus

Homosexual folks are pretty consistent in populations world-wide. No matter what country you look at, which belief system people belong to, population size, and whatever other factors you can think of... it's always around 10% of the population that is homosexual. It is normal. Whether you like it or not, it's a natural thing to happen. It's not only a strictly human phenomenon either. Did you know that at certain temperatures you can make groups of male flies form long mating chains? Did you know that there are species of fish and other organisms that can alter their sex to accomodate their community? Ever seen a hermaphroditic banana slug mate with another of its kind, then watch them each chew off the other's penile projection so the other can't mate again? Nature is full of fun quirks, and homosexuality is one of them. 

  

So what if we don't know what causes it. We'll figure it out someday. Most scientists are split between whether it's caused by environmental pressures or genetic changes. Nature vs. nurture. Homosexuality is a fact of life, and for anyone to deny that is just completely silly.  

  

Even more silly is for someone to think that their beliefs should come before personal freedom, equality, and respect for our fellows. Marriage should be something that anyone can participate in. It's a union between two people who love each other. I know that's beside the point, but it is very important.  

After studying human sexuality for about 40 years I believe that it is far more complex than most people think.  There are so many factors that can affect sexuality.  I've also come to believe that basically, all humans are potentially bi-sexual at birth.  The polarizing "us and them" type mentality that prevails as a result of the labels, Gay - Straight, is very disturbing and serves to perpetuate further ignorance of human sexuality. 

  

If you consider the pressures that children and teens growing up have to deal with as a result of the pervasive force of Heterosexism, a force that demands almost constant proof of heterosexuality especially on the part of boys and young men, it's no wonder that the statistics only show 10% of the population being homosexual.  In modern society, I believe there's a whole gray area between the two sexuality extremes.  In this gray area, many people live so called heterosexual lifestyles in terms of behaviour, but are to varying degrees, homosexual in desire. 

  

I agree with you about the many variations of sexuality on this planet.  And a majority of reproduction in nature even occurs without sex.  And think about the possibilities of life forms in other galaxies!  There are probably far more complex forms of intelligent life that reproduce in a manner that we can't even imagine.  Sex, as we think of it is probably unknown. 

  

The Bible thumpers love to call homosexual relations a sin, and equate homosexuality with promiscuity and prostitution, yet they refuse to recognize same sex marriage that would endorse monogamy and commitment.. 

  

One last thing, our modern society could take a lesson from a tribe of native peoples of the Amazon Rain Forrest.  I believe they're called the Zoa.  They are untouched by the modern world and technology.  They've survived peacefully for many centuries in this Rain Forrest.  They wear no clothes at all.  They hunt only for the food they need and have the greatest respect for the earth, nature, and for life, including each other.  They have no wars.  They have polygamous marriages - with men having more than one wife AND women having more than one husband!  No homophobia here.  Children are free to explore their sexuality, there is no abuse.  Families can have sex freely, but with the greatest respect for each other.  There's no rape.  And they seem to have mastered a knowledge of NFP - Natural Family Planning.  They do not kill their pre-born as is so common in our society, which BTW is a heterosexual atrocity - another result mostly of forced heterosexism.  These people are probably the most psychologically healthy people in the world.  Bible thumpers, take heed!  

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:14 pm PDT

Um,hello?

Quote From: tulseyjoe

And in those two places, it is in the very same context of in the Book of Leviticus, chapters 18, 19, and 20. If you don't read all three of those same chapters together, you are missing the actual context of them.  

  

I see that people are posting messages here without even reading what other members of Dr. Phil's internet community are writing.  

  

Real homosexual men don't lie with another male pretending that the male is a woman. In the context of Leviticus' chapters, a heterosexual man goes to a pagan temple to make a sexual sacrifice to the Canaanite fertility goddess, Asherah (also known as Astarte or Asteroth).  

  

The purpose of the sacrifice of semen (called "seed" in the KJV) to the goddess is to "plant a 'seed' in the male holy person doing a stand-in for Asherah and that "holy" person dressed up like a woman, too. The holy person knows that he is not the goddess; but, in the spiritual/psychological mind of the heterosexual man who is a Canaanite to begin with in that context, HE IS HAVING SEX WITH A WOMAN  . . .  NOT WITH ANOTHER MAN!  

  

In those 3 chapters, the Israelites are being told not to follow certain religious practices related to the CANAANITE culture. In modern times, we refer to the CANAANITES as PHOENICIANS, but, they were actually the very same people!  

  

Oh, the residents of Sodom were not Canaanites; because Sodom was NOT in Canaan at all and any well-read student of the Bible would know that when Abram (later called Abraham) and his nephew, Lot, decided that the country of Canaan was not big enough for both of them and all of their sheep and cattle, etc., Lot moved to the east across the Jordan River out of the country of Canaan into the "Plain of Jordan" (just called Jordan in modern times). 

  

In Romans 1, where it mentions men having sex with each other, the sexual activity actually takes place in a pagan place of worship where fertility gods are honored. Roman holy men in service to pagan gods also dressed up like females as in the Canaan. And, in the Roman pagan places of worship of fertility deities, where male gods were also revered, women strapped on male sexual devices and pretended to represent the god. It was not considered a natural sex act for a woman to pretend to be a man and have anal sexual intercourse with a heterosexual man.  

Try Romans 1:26-27 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:15 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: tulseyjoe

"godin44" posted: All translations of the Holy Bible state that homosexuality is a sin. The KJV, NIV and NAS translations are word for word translations. This means they were translated from the original Hebrew and Greek texts. You are looking for an "out" for your sin., which is human nature. No one is sinless, except Jesus. But we are told to confess our sins and give them to God. When your sin becomes a lifestyle, your are not living in the way God has asked us to: Galations chapter 5 says... 

  

No, you are quite wrong about word for word English translations of the Bible! If you have copies of the original texts (the very same ones those translators used), and you can read Hebrew and Greek, you will see that none of them are literal "word-for-word" translations. In fact, word-for-word translations are and would be very confusing. When the KJV translated "kodesh" as "sodomite," when the word "kodesh" literally meant "holy," it was not a word-for-word translation; it was a mis-interpretation. "Kodesh" as a verb means to "be or make holy." As a noun, it means a "holy" person, place, or thing. In every place the KJV coined word "sodomite" appears, the context has absolutely no connection with Sodom nor the residents of Sodom; in each instance the religion is always that of the people who lived in the Country of Canaan which was to the west of the Jordan River. Sodom was not in Canaan, it was one of the cities in the Jordan Plain, to the east of the River. We call the Jordan Plain country just Jordan in modern times. 

  

Oh, a person's sin can be come a lifestyle; but, homosexuality, aka homosexual orientation, is NOT a lifestyle. One can choose a lifestyle; but, one cannot choose one's sexual orienation.  

  

Attempting to confess one's sexual orientation as sin is equal to me attempting to confess that I have green eyes because neither my parents nor my siblings have/had green eyes. One is born with one's sexual orientation already determined by God just as one's eye color is determined before birth, too. 

  

Or more dramatically, attempting to confess, as sin, one's sexual orientation is like confessing one's sin of being left-handed instead of right-handed. Our word "sinister" comes from the Latin word for "left" and people who were left-handed used to be told that they were that way because either the devil made them left handed or they were in rebellion against God because they were using their left hands instead of their right hands.  

You can go to any Christian bookstore and they will give a description of each of the translations. Word for Word and thought for thought versions are the most reliable. They were translated from the original text, not other english versions.  

  

1. The King James Version (KJV) — Translated in 1611 by 47 scholars using the Byzantine family of manuscripts, Textus Receptus. This remains as a good version of the Bible. It has been the most reliable translation for over three centuries, but its Elizabethan style Old English is difficult for modern readers, especially youth. This is still a good translation for those who can deal with the language. 

 

2. The New American Standard Bible (NASB) — Translated in 1971 by 58 scholars of the Lockman Foundation, from Kittle’s Biblia Hebraica and Nestle’s Greek New Testament 23rd ed., which include the Alexandrian Family codices. Though academic in tone, it is said to be the most exact English translation available. A very good version. 

 

 

The bible dictionary says this: Sodomites - those who imitated the licentious wickedness of Sodom (Deut. 23:17; 1 Kings 14:24; Rom. 1:26, 27). Asa destroyed them "out of the land" (1 Kings 15:12), as did also his son Jehoshaphat (22:46). 

 

If you know so much about what the original bible said, you should know that it stated that men having unnatural relations with men and women with women is a disgrace before God. I work for and go to church with a Professor that has studied the original Greek, Hebrew and Aramic text and he can confirm this. 

 

 

Being left-handed is not in the bible. "They" are men that said these silly thing, not God. God would not make someone a homosexual if He declares it a sin. He loves us too much for that. He gave us free will to make choices- Him or the world. I see you left off the scripture I had to back up my statement. 

 

especially Galations 5:19-21.. 

 

 19The acts of the sinful nature are obvious: sexual immorality, impurity and debauchery; 20idolatry and witchcraft; hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions 21and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. I warn you, as I did before, that those who live like this will not inherit the kingdom of God. 

 

 

 

We as christians do not hate the homosexuals, only their sin. We love everyone and we want people to understand how God wants us live. I personally hate the idea of anyone going to hell. It hurts my heart to think of it. I want everyone to see the light of Jesus and the freedom you can have in Him. Yes, it is freedom! Because I do not have to worry about where I will go after this life on earth is done.- Amen 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:16 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: anne1776

Not everyone is like you! My son loved Strawberry Shortcake when he was 3 and put on lipstick today (he's 5), but he's as boy as you get, playing with cars, trains, and his tractor outside.
We'll see, only time can tell.  And I understand not everyone is like me, nobody is like me.  I'm the only me.  But If your boy was like the 4 year old on the show yesterday - only liked girl stuff and severly disliked boy stuff then that's a different situation.  Your son obviously likes the boy stuff, so that's completely different than the situation I was discussing.  I only liked girl stuff, just like the 4 year old on the show yesterday.  Those are the kinds of people I'm talking about. Again, only time can tell.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:19 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: oet_gaol

The hiding behind religion is that when you give you're opinion on gay-related issues you say "The bible says" you don't say I think and if you do you say right after that "but the bible says" so you take away the power of your words so you don't have to say what you think instead of what the bible thinks that is why it's hiding behind religion. 

  

Yes maby the sories went beyond the babylonian and egyptian era even more reason to doubt how true they are because the first writing isn't much older then those eras. 

  

About the stories of jesus is just not how I heard it I'm sorry 

  

I didn't say you where following the koran I gave it as an example on how the same thing came be interpreted in sow many ways so can you inteprete the bible in different ways why else would there be so many different churches? 

  

But man wrote down the scriptures is it not possible that god might have made it understandable for man in that period and that we can interprete it for this period? Because if god is a greater being he should've cut down to our level of understanding and that ment that in that era man might not have been ready for a gay community. 

  

And that bible was kept by the vatican for many centuries 

 I've stated before, if there was no God I wouldn't care less about this subject.  Fact is, I do believe there is a God and I also believe that he does not condone this lifestyle, in fact He despises it. 

I base my truth upon the Bible.  Most Christians do.   It's the only absolute truth I know of. I'm not 'hiding' behind' anything. 

I don't know why you doubt the books of the Bible by the statement you've made. 

The Koran is not the same thing at all as the Bible.  They are two completely separate peices of literature.   Both Christians and Muslims would agree.

The Bible is written to our understanding. It's pretty clear.

While the vatican may have made it illegal at one point in history to own a Bible in Italy, this was during a time long after it had already been written and widely dispersed.   As soon as the books were written they were recopied and distributed all over.  The early Christians were very eager to go forth and preach the gospel.

There have been many attempts to destroy the Bible or to make it illegal but it's still the all time best seller.  
 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:27 pm PDT

justification

Quote From: neko_yasha

Are you justifying these un-Godly actions?

Funny you should use that word - as in "justification by faith" 

The references in Leviticus must be taken all of a piece with Levitical law. There's no picking and choosing. Unless you're an orthodox Jew, it doesn't apply to you. The Romans I reference concludes with an admonition not to judge. An analysis  of the original text in Greek, suggests that what was unnatural about the men lying with other men was that men in question were heterosexual. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 20, 2005, 1:30 pm PDT

Doctrines and opinions

When it comes right down to it folks interpret Scripture differently. Nothing ever changes. The Pharisees used Scripture to frame their opinion of what the Messiah would be like and they got Jesus. They killed Jesus. 

  

The Jewish Christians used Scripture to substantuate their belief that the Gospel was only for the Jews. And the Holy Spirit took care of that issue. First bringing the "Good News" to the Samaritans, then to the Eunuchs (see the story of Philip) and then to the Gentiles. God has a way of getting us to see things in a new light. 

  

I could go on and on throughout history. We paint God into a box and then the Holy Spirit proves how narrow minded we are. An excellent article on the subject can be found on the web site www.gaychurch.org in the section titled "Gay and Christian?" The article is titled "Prejudice in the Church": 

  

Little do many in the church know that God is doing a mighty work in the gay community today. A great revival has been sweeping through our community and there are over 3,550 churches now. Amazing! Regardles of opinions and misinterpretations of Scripture GOD is on the move and is bringing the gay community in - JUST AS THEY ARE. 

 
First | Prev | 80 | 81 | 82 | 83 | 84 | 85 | 86 | 87 | 88 | 89 | Next | Last