Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:28 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: mommyjenna

 I'm sorry you took it that way.  I didn't mean it that way at all.

I said I was using the most extreme example of how the devil works on our minds (Mine too!!) 

It was an extreme example but the devil plants thoughts in our heads.  If we dwell on them long enough, the lies become truth.

Same would go for a KKK member.  It starts with a lie that festers over and over until that person believes something totally untrue is truth.

I was just stating that homosexuals start off with thoughts, allow the thoughts to continue until the person is convinced that the thoughts are the truth.   By the time they are adults, they fully believe that they have no choice in being gay.  The compulsions are so strong after so long that they believe they were born with these compulsions.   I talked on another board with a man who had turned from homosexuality and he told me that a lot of what they do, is help them to control the thoughts, or stop the thoughts and turn them. 

Again, I'm sorry I offended you.




I'm missing something in this logic...teenager feels lost, teenager doesn't fit in, teenager is not happy in relationships, teenager becomes suicidal thinking there is something wrong with him. the devil steps in, plants lies in the teenager's head. the teenager believes the lies, meets a mice boy, settles down into a consensual, loving relationship, feels peaceful for the first time in his life. teenager lives happily, having decided not to kill himself after all. teenager grows old with his lover, dies then burns in hell for eternity for not deciding to live miserably for god?  

  

I'm not tryna be a jerk, that seriously seems so messed up to me. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:36 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: mtnlady1

The problem Jenna is that you believe homosexuality to be a sin and we do not. Have you ever studied the Scriptures closely that some condemn gays with? I would be more than happy to discuss these Scriptures one by one with you or anyone. I have no problem quoting the Bible - it's when it's misquoted that I have a problem with it. More than misquoted - misquoted to the harm of others. You, and others like you, have no idea how much harm you are doing the Body of Christ by falsly accusing gay people of being sinners and going to hell. Your very actions and hateful words drive away most gay folks from seeking the very Christ they need. You are the Pharisees of our age.
 Yes, I've studied the scriptures and they've been posted here a few times by people but no responses on them.  We just keep hearing the same thing about 'hate' 'close-minded' etc.

I also have a problem with the Bible being taken out of context.  One verse in particular posted by a pro-gay advocate was from Romans which basically says "every man must decide for himself."  Now, this verse was grossly taken out of context because what Paul was referring to was whether or not to eat meat. 

I really don't think I am doing any harm to gay people by pointing out scriptures that do pertain to them.  I do not want to see them believing lies and manipulations.  There are no hateful words whatsoever and I am resenting the name calling.

If I were Muslim and here stating that I loved people and wanted them to know that I believed their actions were wrong according to the Koran, you people would not be jumping down my throat the way you are.  The fact of the matter is, it is perfectly 'socially acceptable' to out and out bash Christians who quote scripture.  As long as you're a Christian and not quoting any scripture, you're fine on this board, but quote scripture and you're looked at as some sort of venomous hater, which is definitely not the case at all.
 

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:39 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: rapunzel

kay...this wasn't posted to me, but I couldn't resist. the logic seems so flawed. 'gay people choose to be gay, but mentally retarded (your awful word, not mine) people don't choose the wya they were born'..? what is that assumption based on? and what about people with developmental disabilities who are gay?? and as far as your point about sinning goes, according to the bible's definition of sin, people with developmemtal delays can sin as well as anyone. my client masturbates (that can be pretty sinful, depending on how fundamentalist ya wanna get), she's definitely a big fan of gluttony, she doesn't honour her parents a whole bunch...you get the idea. she doesn't repent those sins though. in fact, she doesn't even have enough language to know what christianity is, let alone memorize all the rules and regulations around it.

First of all, the words "mentally retarded" are not mine either--they're the person's to whom I responded to (I forget who--I don't keep track of who I respond to....maybe "mommyjenna"? not sure). Anyway, those were her words--just to make that clear. 

  

Also, then your client obviously has the brain power to do what she does. She knows what she wants. If she doesn't honor her parents "a whole bunch" than she knows how they're supposed to be treated, but chooses to treat them a different way. The fact that she "doesn't know what christianity is let alone memorize the rules and regulations around it", also implys that she doesn't know what repentance is. Therefore, she couldn't repent if she wanted to. I don't see how she's applicable to the argument. 

  

Also, your question, "what is that assumptions based on?", referring to my statement of mentally challenged people not choosing to be born that way, has me confused. Are you saying that mentally challenged people choose to be born that way? I'm not sure what you meant. Please explain. 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:46 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: maria_44

I've already answered these questions to you in my comment. 

  

No, I do not believe that other people have a different experience "than me". Boys don't NATURALLY want other little boys--their body wants balance or girls. Vice-versa.  

  

When exactly did I mention hair color??????? Please! People are born black, white, hispanic, asian, etc--not homosexual. 

  

If you say that people are born homo, than you also say that people are born serial killers, child molestors, thiefs, rapists, terrorists, etc. Is that what you're saying? 

  

As far as America on homosexuality, I know all that. That's exactly why I said that homosexuals don't come out and say that they made their choice--because they don't want to be subject to that persecution. They'd rather try to convince people that they were born that way to try to get some kind or pity and acceptance. 

  

If people were born homo, then half of our population would be gay. Right? 

  

Also, it's true, some people like experimenting with the same sex--others don't. Umm....usually people who like it are the ones who become gay....and people who don't....well, they don't. 

  

ok....I don't think this is gonna go anywhere. all of your claims are based on completely unsupported, subjective beliefs. I can't argue with that. that's like me coming up with a random opinion "it's natural to be purple, all people should be purple because i am", then tryna have a discussion based on that. it's not logical, you can'y base a discussion on it. 

  

your underlying beliefs seem to be:  the definition of 'natural' is your personal experience. I can't really argue with you if you don't believe in diversity of experience. how do you know boys aren't naturally attracted to other little boys? because you said so? I'm sorry, but that just isn't enough evidence for me.  

we don't have a definition of 'natural' to work with here. 

  

you say you were born hetero, and that makes it natural. I'm gonna assume by the way you're talking that you're white, so please excuse me if my assumtion is wrong. but, if you being straight makes that natural, then is it only natural to be white because you are? if it's unnatural to be gay, because you weren't born gay, is it unnatural to be asian, because you weren't born asian? 

  

as far as america being homophobic, my point was, wouldn't it be easier for all the people born straight, to just stay straight, rather than choosing to be gay and then 'pretending' they were born  

gay? why go to the trouble? 

  

you said this: 

"If people were born homo, then half of our population would be gay. Right? " 

  

where did that come from? again, you're making up random thoughts and using them as thought they are logic, or supported fact. people are born asian, doesn't mean half the population is asian. people are born deaf, doesn't mean half the population is deaf. why would you say half the population should be homo if people are born homo? 

  

I am soooo lost.   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:49 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: kelly029xx

I, too, have been waiting for Dr. Phil to breach this subject, since finding about about my daughter's (18) orientation last year.   I don't even know where to start in this post.  I knew this show would tongues a-wagging.  I am also amazed at how "concerned" people are over who someone is attracted too, when there are so many more important concerns in the US. 

  

A brief introduction of myself:  I am a 36 year old mother of five, married for 12 years.  I grew up as a pastor's daughter.  My parents did a great job raising me to love and accept all people.  I don't have racial or gay issues, people are people who need to be loved and not criticized.  I became sexually active at 16 (we didn't discuss "sex"), got pregnant at 17, and had my oldest daugther at 18.  Last year, I found a letter in Lauren's (oldest daugther) room from her girlfriend, suffice to say, I was shocked!  When I married and had more children, my husband and I discussed many of the issues we, as parents, might possibly face but homosexuality never entered out thoughts or conversations.  So when I found out about Lauren, I was furious, she had been hanging with new friends who dressed like I had perceived lesbians to dress, so my assumption was that they "turned" her gay, that it was a fad, boy was I wrong.  I had banned her from seeing these girls and her girlfriend.  Lauren became very angry and depressed, she came to be about a month later and asked how I would feel if she moved out when she turned 18, I asked her why and she said she wanted her life back, that she can't live the life her father and I wanted her to live.  Well, that was a wake up call for me.  The next day I was at work, and our software was down (feel God played a part in this) and the only thing I could use for 6 hours was the computer.  I spent those next hours just reading everything I could on God and homosexuality.  By the end of that day, I was in tears for Lauren and all the other people who were made this way and how they have been treated by society.  I decided I was no longer gonna be a part of the problem anymore.  That night I talked with my daughter at lengths, telling her I love her and will support her in who she is.  Since then, Lauren has done remarkable.  She will be graduating this year from high school, the depression has lifted, and our communication has opened again.  My parents have been wonderful with her as well.  It took some time with my dad on this issue, because he never really had to think about it and no one ever does until it hits home.  I would still be ignorant and sound like a lot of people on this board if I didn't have to confront it head on.  My dad said, as a pastor, this was always a gray issue with him.  My parents were missionaries in Africa when I was younger, they worked with drug addicts, prostitutes, gang members, drug dealers, etc.  But until last year, they had their own closed thoughts on gay people.  My dad, after hearing about Lauren, prayed and read the Word, and spoke with respected, Christian friends and after many months of searching, he has a passion and drive to reach the churches of America that are pushing the gays out of the Church (don't think God wanted that!).  He has preached at many great Christian, spirit-filled gay-inclusive churches and he cannot deny that God's presense is in those places of Worship!  Lauren and I went with him to one in Long Beach, CA and I met some tremendous, wonderful, stable, loving, married for years gay couples that would put some of us heterosexual couples to shame.  But the bottom line, is God loves the gay community!!  God's presense is with them, they can serve, love, and worship Him right alongside with the rest of us.  So, bottom line, instead of "Bible thumping", do more research than just quoting things you've heard, or ignorant beliefs.  Love goes a long way and I live by "Love is Never Wrong"  I would love to talk to any parent who has or is going through what I have!  God's journey is never-ending and there is so much that no one knows or never will know until we meet our Creator!!  Whew- that was long, tried to make it short  =)  But I am so passionate for the gay community, I want them to be loved and accepted just like anyone else, that day is coming! 

  

TulseyJoeCan I have your email?  I forwarded to my dad some of what you had posted and he is very interested in emailing (speaking) with you!  Thanks!  Kelly 

  

Keep up the great work, Dr. Phil, God is using you greatly to educate and change the family dynamics in America today!!  Is is a continued work in progress! 

  

An appreciative fan in PA, 

  

Kelly 

  

 As a Christian, I find it strange that you use the term "bible thumping" when we quote scripture.  Isn't scripture truth?  I don't understand.   Instead of looking to the Internet for answers, I would have guessd a Christian would go to the scriptures.

And by the way, I am not close minded nor ignorant.  I am open to people telling me differently but so far no one has.  I've also asked someone to tell me their best peice of evidence for being 'born gay'  so I can look it up.  I'd be willing to change my mind. 

But as a Christian, how do you reconcile this verse, for example?

Romans 1: 24 -

For this reason, God gave them over to degrading passions;  for their women exchanged the natural function for that which is natural and in the same way also the men abandoned the natural function of the women and burned in their desire for one another, men with men committing indecent actsand receiving in their own the due penalty for their error.

As well, as a Christian parent, don't you think 16 is too young to be having sexual relations anyway?







 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:51 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: april_lk

I believe in a loving God. If the God I worship condemns people for being exactly how he created them, then I need to find a new God to worship.
 Do you worship the God of the Bible?  If yes, how do you reconcile Romans 1:24-32?

And if you believe in the Bible, where does it ever say that he created some people gay?


 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:52 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: april_lk

why do so many heterosexuals beat eachother and beat their children? all the children in care are from heterosexual families. why are heterosexuals so violent?
 Again, because people don't care about God's laws.

Are you making some blanket statement here that there are no violent homosexuals?




 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:53 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: april_lk

No he didn't. God gave muslims the Koran because he is the author of the Koran, therefore Muslims can safely say they know what God wants. Who's the author of the Bible? 

 I'm not sure why we're talking about Muslims or the Koran, but for the record, the Koran also states that homosexuality is a sin. 
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:55 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: maria_44

First of all, the words "mentally retarded" are not mine either--they're the person's to whom I responded to (I forget who--I don't keep track of who I respond to....maybe "mommyjenna"? not sure). Anyway, those were her words--just to make that clear. 

  

Also, then your client obviously has the brain power to do what she does. She knows what she wants. If she doesn't honor her parents "a whole bunch" than she knows how they're supposed to be treated, but chooses to treat them a different way. The fact that she "doesn't know what christianity is let alone memorize the rules and regulations around it", also implys that she doesn't know what repentance is. Therefore, she couldn't repent if she wanted to. I don't see how she's applicable to the argument. 

  

Also, your question, "what is that assumptions based on?", referring to my statement of mentally challenged people not choosing to be born that way, has me confused. Are you saying that mentally challenged people choose to be born that way? I'm not sure what you meant. Please explain. 

ah, I re-read and saw that term was in the original quote from someone else. sorry!. 

  

my client does know how her parents are supposed to be treated etc. she masturbates cuz it feels good, cuz it's natural to keep doing something that feels good. she doesn't know other people think it's wrong. she doesn't 'honour' her parents because she has no reason to. she doesn't understand abstract moral concepts. and it's applicable to the argument because you said 'what sins do they have to repent for?'. there's some right there. also, you didn't reply to those with develomental disabilities who are gay. to they have to burn for eternity too? and what about kids who grow up in families who are very accepting and loving and not worried about the gender of their children's lovers, as long as they are happy? what if those children grow up not knowing that some christians think it's wrong? do they get out of eternal damnation because they didn't know better? same as those with developmental disabilities? 

  

and I'm not saying menatlly challenged people chose to be born that way - no more than gay people chose to be born that way. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 1:57 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: kelly029xx

Hey, an FYI, the boy who is featured on the cover of Time Magazine is my daughter's (lauren) best friend in high school  He is a great gay male who I've really enjoyed getting know over the last year.  His parents are Christians who felt that sending him to an Exodus International Camp would change his attraction to the same-sex.  Guess what?  It didn't work and will never work
 I guess you think that God can't change people.  Oh ye of little faith.


 
First | Prev | 95 | 96 | 97 | 98 | 99 | 100 | 101 | 102 | 103 | 104 | Next | Last