Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:03 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: maria_44

so you agree that your homosexuality was due to an incedent that you experienced, which caused you to become curious, which caused you to experiment, which caused you to like it and become addicted? 

  

bottom line: you agree that you were not born this way? 

 I think it's rather strange that a toddler feels a sense of frustration and sexual pleasure while someone destroys his favourite toy.  Does anyone else find that odd?

 I also find it even more strange that the toddler would then pee on his favorite toy as an act of 'masturbation".

I've been a foster parent for three years and I've never seen any child act out sexually except the ones who'd been sexually abused.

Children just don't think that way unless they've been exposed to it. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:04 pm PDT

The Image of God

Quote From: anothervio

I don't think anyone here is really qualified to say what Gods will or Sexual preference is.
My point is that we are all made in the image of God. Black, white, male, female, hetro, gay - all are made in God's image. We are all God's children. Even more than that - when we become a Christian we are ONE in Christ. These things that society uses to seperate and divide ourselves into neat little categories are pure silliness in the eyes of God. God sees us as one family, one people. When you attack me - a fellow Christian - you are attacking Christ Himself.
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:08 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: mommyjenna

 Again, because people don't care about God's laws.

Are you making some blanket statement here that there are no violent homosexuals?




statistically, there is a higher rate of domestic violence in heterosexual households than in same-sex households.  

  

wouldn't that make same-sex households a healthier environment for children to grow up in? statistically speaking, I mean. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:11 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: minnie04

I just dont understand who has the right to judge others...listen people we only have ONE life and what ever way you choose to live, it  SHOULD only be up to that person and NO ONE else  I think  people put to much into this subject and not enough into there own problems..such as what the heck is happening in there own back yards we are all human and thats it ..there is no one better then the next we are all born and we will all die one day and I just hope there are enough GOD's up there to except us all ... 

  

  

stop judging and let people LIVE LIFE TO THE FULLEST!!!!!! theres no second chances  

It sounds like you are saying that people should mind their own business.  Is that true?  Well if I follow your logic and apply it to another situation it may look like this:  I'm walking down the street and I see a teenage girl who is standing directly in front of me.  She has a razor in one hand and her other wrist is exposed.  As I walk toward her, I see her take the razor and drag it repeatedly across her wrist.  Should I watch her do it and mind my own business?  Should I disregard her dying condition and instead nurse my own cuts that I may have gathered that day?  Your logic says that I should NOT call 9-1-1, bandage her wounds, stay with her till the paramedics are there to treat her and contact her family.  According to your logic, I should just mind my own business. 

  

  Does that sound like a good thing to do to you?  Does that sound loving?  

  

    In the situation above, if I were to decide whether I would help or not help I needed to make a JUDGEMENT.  I would have to decide whether the wounds were bad enough to warrant the help of paramedics, I would need to judge the girl's mental condition to decide whether or not she would need mental help after the dilemma was over and I would need to make judgements on the people around us to see if they would help and in what ways they could.    Judgements get a bad rap but to judge is basically a critical analysis, appraisal or assessment of something.  While it is not anyone's place except God's to judge a person,  we all are able and rightfully so, to judge a behavior.   When you truly love people you are concerned about them all the time, especially, when they are doing something (behavior) that will hurt themselves or others.  A real Christian is a person who is being transformed by Christ to become like Christ.  When this happens, a person develops a heart like Christ and they begin to feel about humanity the way that God does.  God is concerned about all of us.  He does not want us doing things that are harmful to us or others.  That's what all His rules are about:  protecting us from doing things that hurt us or others because He loves us so much!!!!    God is our Heavenly Father and He wants to protect us from danger.  Any good parents sets up rules for their kids so that they won't get hurt, right?   That is the same thing that God does because of His love.  Now that same good parent must enforce those rules or they won't protect the kids right?  And if the kid does not follow the rules, the kid has to be disciplined right?  That is the same thing God does for us because He loves us.  His discipline proves He loves us and that He is good.    

  

   God is equally loving and Just!!!  He both loves us and judges our behavior.  That is everything we do right and everything we do wrong.  He sets the rules for right and wrong because He is perfect and loving so His rules are right.  He tells us what is right and wrong in His Holy Word, The Bible.    Some people are trying to show how this behavior is wrong because they care about people and don't want to see them hurt and as  I stated earlier, if you truly love someone, you want them to do what is right so bad things won't happen as a result of their behavior.  If you really love someone, you tell them the TRUTH.  Just like if you are dating someone or are married to them you expect them to be honest with you--even when it hurts.  That's what Christians are trying to do.  Some can and must do it in a more loving fashion.  But the truth still remains--they must do it.   Kind of like the slogan "Friends don't let Friends drink and drive" because you know the consequences, Christians don't let fellow Christians or non-Christians continue to live in sin because we know the consequences.   You say to let people live life to the fullest.  Well the only way for people to do that is to accept Jesus Christ as lord and Savior.  You say there are no second chances and that is so true so people must do what is right while there is still time!!!!  The first way to love and help them is to tell them the truth about sin and then to tell them how much God loved them that he would make himself flesh, be born of a virgin, and live a perfect life among us to show us how to do it.  After that much love, he loves us even more by allowing himself to be ridiculed, hurt, persecuted, embarrassed, harassed, beaten, bruised and even killed so that people can come out of sin which includes homosexuality and receive His full love and acceptance of them through their acceptance of Christ Jesus.  I would love to talk with you some more about how this freedom is possible for all if you'd like.  Just respond to this message.  I appreciate your opinion and hope you have the same appreciation for mine.    Have a great day!!!! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:12 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: tulseyjoe

Can you prove that? After the Bible was officially complied as a collection of books in 397 AD, by the Eastern Orthodox people, there is no evidence that the churches even taught their parishoners to read from a Bible. 

  

I know for a fact here in Oklahoma that as a general rule members of Roman Catholic Churches were told NOT to own a Bible, let alone read one. It was not until the 1970s before they approved of church members owning a Bible and reading it on their own. 

  

Why were they told not to read the Bible? Because the RCC leaders were supposedly afraid that they would misinterpret what they read. And only an ordained minister in the RCC was allowed to interpret what they read in the Scriptures. Well, that meant that the Holy Spirit must not be involved with the church member's walk with the Lord or the fact that the RCC people were afraid that some church doctrines and traditions were NOT supported by what was written in the Bible. 

  

And, also, Jesus, Himself, did not approve of spiritual leaders being called "Father" or by any other title.  

  

One thing has been proven in this message board discussion about Wednesday's show, lots of people don't know when things are meant to be taken as literal and when some things are meant to be taken as figures of speech or metaphors by the Bibles authors. Jesus used parables, made up stories, a whole lot of times to teach a particular doctrine. They had truth in them; but, they were not actual literal events.  

 I would point you in the driction of Simon Greenleaf, who was the Royale Professor of evidence at Harvard. His students posed a question to him "Was Jesus the son of God".   He open-mindedly searched and became a Christian, based on evidence.  Remember, this guy was an expert in evidence. 
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:12 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: pilar5810

Dr. Phil is awesome.  Today, however, I think he's sidestepping the issue of having a gay child.  To advise the family to just not talk about the gay child's sex life is NOT the issue.  It's not simply about her SEX life.  It's about she's dating, who she's, how her heart is being broken, what activities she's filling her life with.  If she's volunteering at a gay youth center, should she not talk about that, too?  She can't talk about herself with very much depth, without hitting something gay-related.    

  

For right now, that girl seems very immersed in being gay.  She wants to share her life with her family.  This daughter is looking for love from her mother, and doesn't find it in the rings and money that her mom is giving her.  Couldn't you have helped the family see what they might lose if they try to apply the "don't ask, don't tell" policy to this sweet girl?  

I know it's not what any counselor would advise, but I know what I'd have done if I was in the gay daughter's position with her family.  I'd have left them behind.  There's just too much pain and they're not willing to budge at all and are just conspiring against her and outright withholding their love on any subject they disapprove of, like discussing her well-being, which is all tied up with her relationships.  I had no sympathy for the mom or the sister.  They only want to love her on their terms.  And honestly, I don't think there's any love on the sister's part.  I've seen a lot of gays struggle with their families and I've come to believe that you give it your best shot at being honest and trying to help them understand and give them some time to adjust, because it is hard.  But if they are too rigid to do anything but hurt you, your only remaining chance at getting them to come around is by staying away.  If that doesn't make them re-examine their ethics, nothing will, and there's no point in nurturing an abusive relationship with them for the rest of your lives.  When I was young, I finally felt I had to cut off my mom over some issues, and it wasn't until I did that she finally made a decision to accept me for who I was.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:15 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: kelly029xx

I, too, have been waiting for Dr. Phil to breach this subject, since finding about about my daughter's (18) orientation last year.   I don't even know where to start in this post.  I knew this show would tongues a-wagging.  I am also amazed at how "concerned" people are over who someone is attracted too, when there are so many more important concerns in the US. 

  

A brief introduction of myself:  I am a 36 year old mother of five, married for 12 years.  I grew up as a pastor's daughter.  My parents did a great job raising me to love and accept all people.  I don't have racial or gay issues, people are people who need to be loved and not criticized.  I became sexually active at 16 (we didn't discuss "sex"), got pregnant at 17, and had my oldest daugther at 18.  Last year, I found a letter in Lauren's (oldest daugther) room from her girlfriend, suffice to say, I was shocked!  When I married and had more children, my husband and I discussed many of the issues we, as parents, might possibly face but homosexuality never entered out thoughts or conversations.  So when I found out about Lauren, I was furious, she had been hanging with new friends who dressed like I had perceived lesbians to dress, so my assumption was that they "turned" her gay, that it was a fad, boy was I wrong.  I had banned her from seeing these girls and her girlfriend.  Lauren became very angry and depressed, she came to be about a month later and asked how I would feel if she moved out when she turned 18, I asked her why and she said she wanted her life back, that she can't live the life her father and I wanted her to live.  Well, that was a wake up call for me.  The next day I was at work, and our software was down (feel God played a part in this) and the only thing I could use for 6 hours was the computer.  I spent those next hours just reading everything I could on God and homosexuality.  By the end of that day, I was in tears for Lauren and all the other people who were made this way and how they have been treated by society.  I decided I was no longer gonna be a part of the problem anymore.  That night I talked with my daughter at lengths, telling her I love her and will support her in who she is.  Since then, Lauren has done remarkable.  She will be graduating this year from high school, the depression has lifted, and our communication has opened again.  My parents have been wonderful with her as well.  It took some time with my dad on this issue, because he never really had to think about it and no one ever does until it hits home.  I would still be ignorant and sound like a lot of people on this board if I didn't have to confront it head on.  My dad said, as a pastor, this was always a gray issue with him.  My parents were missionaries in Africa when I was younger, they worked with drug addicts, prostitutes, gang members, drug dealers, etc.  But until last year, they had their own closed thoughts on gay people.  My dad, after hearing about Lauren, prayed and read the Word, and spoke with respected, Christian friends and after many months of searching, he has a passion and drive to reach the churches of America that are pushing the gays out of the Church (don't think God wanted that!).  He has preached at many great Christian, spirit-filled gay-inclusive churches and he cannot deny that God's presense is in those places of Worship!  Lauren and I went with him to one in Long Beach, CA and I met some tremendous, wonderful, stable, loving, married for years gay couples that would put some of us heterosexual couples to shame.  But the bottom line, is God loves the gay community!!  God's presense is with them, they can serve, love, and worship Him right alongside with the rest of us.  So, bottom line, instead of "Bible thumping", do more research than just quoting things you've heard, or ignorant beliefs.  Love goes a long way and I live by "Love is Never Wrong"  I would love to talk to any parent who has or is going through what I have!  God's journey is never-ending and there is so much that no one knows or never will know until we meet our Creator!!  Whew- that was long, tried to make it short  =)  But I am so passionate for the gay community, I want them to be loved and accepted just like anyone else, that day is coming! 

  

TulseyJoeCan I have your email?  I forwarded to my dad some of what you had posted and he is very interested in emailing (speaking) with you!  Thanks!  Kelly 

  

Keep up the great work, Dr. Phil, God is using you greatly to educate and change the family dynamics in America today!!  Is is a continued work in progress! 

  

An appreciative fan in PA, 

  

Kelly 

  

 I forgot to mention something earlier.  It sounds like in the course of one day doing research on the Internet you changed your mind on this issue,  Is that right?


 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:16 pm PDT

Romans - is what is Natural to you Natural to everyone else?

Quote From: mommyjenna

 Do you worship the God of the Bible?  If yes, how do you reconcile Romans 1:24-32?

And if you believe in the Bible, where does it ever say that he created some people gay?


Romans 1:21-31 

  

  

The key to these passages is the word "natural". But first the story for those who are not familier with it.  In these versus we see that there is a group of people who turn away from God. From this point on their lives begin to spiral downward and they commit all sorts of sins. One of which is turning from what is “natural” for them to that which is “unnatural”.

   

 

The issue here revolves around the word “natural” which is derived from two Greek words phusikos (Strong's #5446) and phusis (Strong's #5449). These words literally mean that which is a persons "natural disposition" and something that comes "instinctively" to them. In other words, it is who you are naturally; without reprogramming, counseling, or any other form of behavioral modification that attempts to change your behavior to that which society has deemed acceptable.

   

 

You ask any gay person what their natural sexual orientation is and they won’t even hesitate to tell you that being gay is. The problem is of course when you discuss the issue with a heterosexual person. Unfortunately many times people who belong to the majority tend to think of themselves as the ‘norm’ and therefore what is ‘natural’. Everyone else falls into another category altogether and in some cases is considered even slightly abnormal. 

 

  

This point was illustrated best to me by a story my Grandmother used to tell me. In her day all the children were expected to be right handed. Anything else was considered slightly abnormal and therefore undesirable. Because of this if children showed a natural propensity to use their left hand they were repeatedly encouraged and then required to use their right hand. It wasn’t until years later when they realized that roughly ten percent of all children were naturally left handed that there were calls for this practice to stop. In spite of this, some time passed before the more forward thinking schools allowed left handed children to be who they were naturally without attempting to change their writing habits. Now day’s left-handed children are seen as just another everyday variation.

  

Our sexual orientation is no different. The vast majority of our population is predominately heterosexual in nature  (approx. 90-95%) with the remaining minority being homosexual (approx. 5-10%). Researchers have found that these percentages remain pretty much the same across all racial and cultural lines. Varying only by the amount of tolerance or intolerance a particular society has for such differences.  

 

Another key point in Paul’s story is that the people turned away from God FIRST and THEN began living a sinful ‘lifestyle’. If homosexuality is a sin. By this description we should see that every homosexual person first turned away from God and THEN became a homosexual. Yet I’ve seen everything but. I’ve met numerous Christians who were gay. Some were saved before they came to grips with their sexuality. Some were saved after they “came out”. There is no common denominator. I can only conclude that ones sexual orientation has nothing to do with ones relationship with God. 

  

Another important point to keep in mind is what Jesus taught us concerning those who have ‘fallen away’ from God. That being that those who are separated from God will envariably exhibit the full gambit of bad spiritual “fruit” in keeping with who they serve. Jesus said that “a good tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a bad tree bear good fruit.” (Matthew 7:18) Therefore “by their fruits you will know them.” (Matthew 7:20)  

  

  

When I met my first Christian gay woman I knew something was a miss with the Church’s doctrine concerning homosexuals. Here standing before me was a person who professed Jesus Christ as their lord and savior and exhibited in their life the full plethoria of “good fruit” that Paul described in Galatians 5:22-23. How could this be? According to Jesus good fruit could not be produced on such a “bad tree”. If homosexuality was a terrible sin that separated us from God it was physically and spiritually impossible for this woman to be standing before me and yet she was. 

  

 

Only one conclusion remained. That being that ones sexual orientation was not, in and of itself, a sin. It was instead just another variation in God’s grand scheme of diversity and as such we should not reject it merely because it was different. 

 

Note: There is a much more thorough discussion of Romans and the other 'anti-gay' passages on the web site www.gaychurch.org which is a sister site of Justin's. Check out the section "Gay and Christian?" there you will find 3 excellent series of articles on the matter. One from E T Sundby the author of "Calling the Rainbow Nation Home" another from Justin the author of the web site truthsetfree.com and another from Bruce Lowe a retired (straight) Baptist minister and a theological school teacher. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:21 pm PDT

Scriptures

Quote From: mommyjenna

 Yes, I've studied the scriptures and they've been posted here a few times by people but no responses on them.  We just keep hearing the same thing about 'hate' 'close-minded' etc.

I also have a problem with the Bible being taken out of context.  One verse in particular posted by a pro-gay advocate was from Romans which basically says "every man must decide for himself."  Now, this verse was grossly taken out of context because what Paul was referring to was whether or not to eat meat. 

I really don't think I am doing any harm to gay people by pointing out scriptures that do pertain to them.  I do not want to see them believing lies and manipulations.  There are no hateful words whatsoever and I am resenting the name calling.

If I were Muslim and here stating that I loved people and wanted them to know that I believed their actions were wrong according to the Koran, you people would not be jumping down my throat the way you are.  The fact of the matter is, it is perfectly 'socially acceptable' to out and out bash Christians who quote scripture.  As long as you're a Christian and not quoting any scripture, you're fine on this board, but quote scripture and you're looked at as some sort of venomous hater, which is definitely not the case at all.

"I also have a problem with the Bible being taken out of context. "  

  

-- So do I. 

  

" We just keep hearing the same thing about 'hate' 'close-minded' etc." 

  

-- How else do you describe folks who believe their intrepretation of Scripture is the only intrepreation out there? Worse yet, if you or someone else believes Scripture is saying something else then you are labeled as "believing lies and manipulations" or taking Scriptures "out of context" 

  

" Yes, I've studied the scriptures and they've been posted here a few times by people but no responses on them." 

  

-- Perhaps there are no responses because people have things to do and it takes awhile for their comments to be posted. Or worse yet - they believe you are close minded and only label others with differing opinions as believing in "lies and manipulations". Learning new things requires honest dialog and an open mind. 

  

Jenna if you want to discuss the Scriptures I have no problem with that. Where do you want to begin? The story of Sodom or in the New Testament? Your choice. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 2:22 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: rapunzel

I'm missing something in this logic...teenager feels lost, teenager doesn't fit in, teenager is not happy in relationships, teenager becomes suicidal thinking there is something wrong with him. the devil steps in, plants lies in the teenager's head. the teenager believes the lies, meets a mice boy, settles down into a consensual, loving relationship, feels peaceful for the first time in his life. teenager lives happily, having decided not to kill himself after all. teenager grows old with his lover, dies then burns in hell for eternity for not deciding to live miserably for god?  

  

I'm not tryna be a jerk, that seriously seems so messed up to me. 

 Teenager probably already feels lost, doesn't fit in, isn't happy, etc because he is already believing lies that he is gay and he feels ashamed.  Would you agree?


 
First | Prev | 96 | 97 | 98 | 99 | 100 | 101 | 102 | 103 | 104 | 105 | Next | Last