Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 7:12 am PDT

need an answer

So far I still have not received a coherent non-circular answer to the question- what is wrong with consensual sex?  

  

What do not qualify as answers are: 

1. It's a sin: That is just restating that it's wrong without explaining why. 

2. It's a sin cause God doesn't like it: That' just another way of saying 'its a sin' (see 1) 

  

Do we check with God everytime we have a moral issue? Don't we know that child rape is wrong without looking it up in the Bible.? Surely that action is wrong in and of itself, because children have a right to live unmolested. That's why God doesn't like it- not the other way round. Would God's saying so change those reasons? Even atheists know that much. Thomas Aquinas discounted the view that an action is evil because God does not will it. 

That fallacy is called volitionism. 

He said rather, God does not will it because it is evil. 

  

 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 7:16 am PDT

sex for procreation

Quote From: tselb2

If God truly made someone homosexual, why on Earth would He consider it so important to procreate?  Considering this is impossible without BOTH men and women.  I don't know, why didn't He just create us all men or all women if this is what He divinely appoints.  Go figure.

If sex is only licit for the purposes of procreation then the Catholic view is the correct one. No masturbation, no condoms, no birth control pills and definitely no abortions. Even most Catholics don't abide by that. 

Also if a couple is infertile , then they should be celibate. Sounds crazy doesn't it. That probably cause it is. 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 7:38 am PDT

seek and ye shall find

Quote From: rlanthier

You have dedicated a lot of space and careful biblical references to just tell me that homosexuality is a sin because God doesn't like it. I didn't ask why it's a sin. I asked what harm does it do? 

It is arguing in circles to tell me that it's harmful because its' a sin (God doesn't like it) and that the reason it's harmful is that it's a sin. You have tried to strengthen  this non-response with sweeping claims about homosexuals = "Feministic lesbians bash men and are disrespectful and mean towards them in the same way that homosexual men of the past were mean and hurtful to women.  So homosexuality causes devision between the sexes, uses lust, masturbation, and pornography, and has broken up marriages after one spouse has found out another has had homosexual or lesbian sex. " 

  

First of all being a lesbian doesn't necessarily depend on hating men. I have lesbian friends who are not in the least hateful. Conversely being gay doesn't depend on hating women. 

In fact, many gay men are very good friends with women. If gays, lesbians 'disrespect' heterosexuals it's probably because the heterosexuals like yourself condemn them. - Another vicious circle. 

 You are simply imposing your rigid view that sexual relations have to be with the opposite sex when you say that homosexuals 'divide' the sexes.  If the sexes are heterosexual, homosexuals can hardly divide them. The next circular argument you offer is that homosexuality is wrong because it makes heterosexual relationships impossible. Well if that is supposed to be the purpose of homosexuals , they have failed miserably, since heterosexual marriages are being made everyday. Neverthelsss,the divorce rates are almost 50%, and not because the partners have turned gay. That's a ridiculous statistic. 

  

The gist of the 'harm' done is that homosexuality is not heterosexuality which is just saying that homosexuality is harmful because it's homosexuality. That's not an answer. 

  

  

If you wanted to see the truth you could find the answer in that post.  If you don't want to see the truth then why did you even ask the question?  Something doesn't have to be harmful to be sin.  All sex outside of marriage is sin.
 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 7:41 am PDT

Putting it to bed

Quote From: jeremiah

The Bible says that man shall not lay with man.  Men should not wear woman's clothes and woman shall not wear men's clothes.  We are to love the sinner, but hate the sin.  We can do all things through Christ who strengthens us.  Being gay is a choice and God never makes us do anything we do not want to do.  But we have to what he wants to get into heaven, we are accountable to God for everything we do. 

The Biblical references to homosexuality have been addressed so many times - I wish they could be settled once and for all. 

  

One can easily count on the fingers of one hand (and have some left over) the number of references to same-sex unions found in Scripture.  

  

Only one is in the New Testatment Romans I and it has to do with HETEROSEXUALS behaving as homosexuals. 

  

Cor 6-9 uses 'porniea' which simply means fornication which simply means unmarried sex but the culture has seen fit to add the word homosexual to the list. (It used to add masturbation) 

Realize of course there was no Jewish, Greek or Aramaic word for homosexual which was coined in the nineteenth century. 

  

If your thing is to quote Tamuldic Law then go Jewish, then we can talk. 

  

Interestingly, we don't hear a lot of Jews ranting about homosexuality. 

Oy enough already. 

 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 7:44 am PDT

cracking me up

Quote From: cijaym

Yes, I'm acountable to God. Not to you, not to Jesus. It's between He and I.  

  

Being as we're doing the crusty book literally... I'm a woman who doesn't lie with a man...according to the crusty book, I'm okay then right?  

  

Women are REALLY screwed when it comes to clothing then. I wear blue jeans, t-shirts and occasionally a baseball hat (but I don't wear it backwards, there should be some redemption in that, shouldn't there?). Is that men's clothing? Because back when the crusty book was being written (by mortals), men wore floor length open garments that one might call a dress now...so, if I wear a dress...is that men's clothing or women's? How about in countries where men still wear "dresses" I'm from Scotland and we'll remember monks, too. Oooh, nuns wear loose open floor length garments...are they sinning? Or are we just talking about men who shop at Victoria's Secret?   

  

Right now I'm in pyjamas. They're flannel pants and an RVD t-shirts, is that women's clothing or men's? 

  

I'm soooo confused! Please, do tell.  

  

  

You should do stand up. ROFLMAO
 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 7:48 am PDT

assumptions assumptions assumptions

Quote From: krcarmi

The Christian life is all about yielding our will to the will of Jesus.  When we are saved Jesus wants all of us.  We are no longer our own.  First Corinthians 6:19-20 states, "What?  Know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Sirit who is in you, whom ye have of God, and ye are not your own?  For ye are bought with a price; therefore, glorify God in your body and in your spirit, which are God's."  God wants us to be holy like He is holy.  See, He is not interested so much in our HAPPINESS as He is in our HOLINESS.  As a person who has been saved there should be a desire to do right.  If there isn't that desire then I would seriously wonder if I have truly been saved.  Just because we say words to a prayer doesn't mean we are saved.  There has to be a change in our heart.  Our desires should be different from what they were before.  I'm not saying that there won't be temptations or that we won't even give into those temptations but when we do we feel a godly sorrow.  Godly sorrow is the type of sorrow that brings about change not just guilt.  God's word has all the answers that we will ever need for our sin problem.  First Corinthians 10:13 tells us, "There hath no temptation taken you but such as is common to man; but God is faithful, who will not permit you to be tempted above that ye are able, but will, with the temptation, also make the way to escape, that ye may be able to bear it."  God does call homosexuality a sin.  This is good news because there is an answer for our sin problem.  The world says homosexuality cannot be overcome.  The world says you were born that way.  God calls it a sin and He has provided us with all we need to overcome sin.  This should be encouraging to all who have truly accepted Christ as Saviour and are looking to overcome this particular sin.  Again in First Corinthians 6:9-10 the apostle Paul tells us, "Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God?  Be not deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate, nor abusers of themselves with mankind, nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, shall inherit the kingdom of God"  That would be really bad news if it didn't continue into verse 11 which says, "And such were some of you; but ye are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God."  You see, in Christ there is hope for change.  Without Christ there is no hope for change.  If a person is truly seeking after Christ and is really interested in changing sinful patterns of behavior in his/her life one must be willing to forsake everything.  Be willing to "die to yourself" DAILY in order to be holy as Christ is holy.  This reminds of a song.   

  

For whatever it takes to  

draw closer to you, Lord 

That's what I'll be willing to do 

For whatever it takes for my will to break 

That's what I'll be willing to do 

I'll trade sunshine for rain 

Comfort for pain  

That's what I'd be willing to do 

  

And this is what anyone must be willing to do to get victory over any sin in life, including homosexuality. 

You preach ad nausea based on the assumption that homosexuality is a sin. 

That remains to be proved and since Jesus never spoke on the subject, you're on shaky ground. 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 7:54 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: jscarroll

Jesus Christ died on the cross for our sins. He paid the price for us so we don't have to.Homosexuality is a sin (not disputed at all), but so is acting like you are God. You have no right to say that anyone will be punished for sins that God has already forgiven. If you ask for forgiveness and believe in Him for the forgiveness, you will never hear about it from God, just narrow-minded, stiff-necked hippocrites. I have a few friends that are gay and I know them to be true Christians. When we stand before God on Judgement Day I truly believe we will be hearing about things we didn't do and not mistakes we made that are already forgiven.
Are your friends still engaging in sexual activity?  God doesn't condemn them for 'being gay', He does however disapprove of sex out of marriage and between same sex partners.  You are right God will forgive if we ask Him, but He also said "repent", which means turn from your sin and don't do it anymore. 
 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 8:02 am PDT

facts??

Quote From: rapunzel

 I don't know if that has been replied to or not, but it upset me (this whole thread is starting to get really upsetting) so I just wanted to jump in. saying that AIDS is spread through multiple sex partners is simple ignorance. the fastest growing population of AIDS victims is heterosexual women, firstly, and a good percentage are married. then there's the babies who are born HIV positive. and those who are raped. and those who have done nothing at all except need a blood transfusion. oh, and better not forget the babies (and I mean infant babies) who are raped throut countries all over africa in particular, because of the myth that you can cure AIDS by having sex with a virgin child. maybe with a little education and birth control, babies wouldn't be raped and infected and killed. except that would be unchristian, so we're just gonna go on letting it happen. 

  

and while all upset, I might as well point out the obvious fact that the planet is so overpopulated that it can't sustain us. that we are physically running out of resources on earth. and you say you're pretty sure god would just want us to have more sex for reproduction, and not bother with useless stuff like birth control?  

  

good. you guys can run the planet, and we'll have no water, no fuel and a whole lot of dead babies. are you serious??! 

Surely you must realize by now that facts have nothing to do with the homophobic beliefs stated in these trheads.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 8:10 am PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: rapunzel

 I don't know if that has been replied to or not, but it upset me (this whole thread is starting to get really upsetting) so I just wanted to jump in. saying that AIDS is spread through multiple sex partners is simple ignorance. the fastest growing population of AIDS victims is heterosexual women, firstly, and a good percentage are married. then there's the babies who are born HIV positive. and those who are raped. and those who have done nothing at all except need a blood transfusion. oh, and better not forget the babies (and I mean infant babies) who are raped throut countries all over africa in particular, because of the myth that you can cure AIDS by having sex with a virgin child. maybe with a little education and birth control, babies wouldn't be raped and infected and killed. except that would be unchristian, so we're just gonna go on letting it happen. 

  

and while all upset, I might as well point out the obvious fact that the planet is so overpopulated that it can't sustain us. that we are physically running out of resources on earth. and you say you're pretty sure god would just want us to have more sex for reproduction, and not bother with useless stuff like birth control?  

  

good. you guys can run the planet, and we'll have no water, no fuel and a whole lot of dead babies. are you serious??! 

State your source.  Where is proof of your statement?  I don't see how birth control would stop babies from being raped. 
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
October 22, 2005, 8:30 am PDT

key word?

Quote From: mtnlady1

Romans has already been discussed but this is what I had to say... (or something like this :) 

  

Romans 1:21-31 

The key to this scripture is the word "natural". In these versus we see that there is a group of people who turn away from God. From this point on their lives begin to spiral downward and they commit all sorts of sins. One of which is turning from what is “natural” for them to that which is “unnatural”. 

   

The issue here revolves around the word “natural” which is derived from two Greek words phusikos (Strong's #5446) and phusis (Strong's #5449). These words literally mean that which is a persons "natural disposition" and something that comes "instinctively" to them. In other words, it is who you are naturally; without reprogramming, counseling, or any other form of behavioral modification that attempts to change your behavior to that which society has deemed acceptable.

  

 

  

You ask any gay person what their natural sexual orientation is and they won’t even hesitate to tell you that being gay is. The problem is of course when you discuss the issue with a heterosexual person. Unfortunately many times people who belong to the majority tend to think of themselves as the ‘norm’ and therefore what is ‘natural’. Everyone else falls into another category altogether and in some cases is considered even slightly abnormal. 

  

  

This point was illustrated best to me by a story my Grandmother used to tell me. In her day all the children were expected to be right handed. Anything else was considered slightly abnormal and therefore undesirable. Because of this if children showed a natural propensity to use their left hand they were repeatedly encouraged and then required to use their right hand. It wasn’t until years later when they realized that roughly ten percent of all children were naturally left handed that there were calls for this practice to stop. In spite of this, some time passed before the more forward thinking schools allowed left handed children to be who they were naturally without attempting to change their writing habits. Now day’s left-handed children are seen as just another everyday variation. 

 

Our sexual orientation is no different. The vast majority of our population is predominately heterosexual in nature  (approx. 90-95%) with the remaining minority being homosexual (approx. 5-10%). Researchers have found that these percentages remain pretty much the same across all racial and cultural lines. Varying only by the amount of tolerance or intolerance a particular society has for such differences. 

  

  

Another key point in Paul’s story is that the people turned away from God FIRST and THEN began living a sinful ‘lifestyle’. If homosexuality is a sin. By this description we should see that every homosexual person first turned away from God and THEN became a homosexual. Yet I’ve seen everything but. I’ve met numerous Christians who were gay. Some were saved before they came to grips with their sexuality. Some were saved after they “came out”. There is no common denominator. I can only conclude that ones sexual orientation has nothing to do with ones relationship with God. 

  

Another important point to keep in mind is what Jesus taught us concerning those who have ‘fallen away’ from God. That being that those who are separated from God will envariably exhibit the full gambit of bad spiritual “fruit” in keeping with who they serve. Jesus said that “a good tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a bad tree bear good fruit.” (Matthew 7:18) Therefore “by their fruits you will know them.” (Matthew 7:20) 

  

  

When I met my first Christian gay woman I knew something was a miss with the Church’s doctrine concerning homosexuals. Here standing before me was a person who professed Jesus Christ as their lord and savior and exhibited in their life the full plethoria of “good fruit” that Paul described in Galatians 5:22-23. How could this be? According to Jesus good fruit could not be produced on such a “bad tree”. If homosexuality was a terrible sin that separated us from God it was physically and spiritually impossible for this woman to be standing before me and yet she was.

  

 

  

Only one conclusion remained. That being that ones sexual orientation was not, in and of itself, a sin. It was instead just another variation in God’s grand scheme of diversity and as such we should not reject it merely because it was different. 

 

 

 

 

There is a much better discussion of Romans on the web site www.gaychurch.org. Check out the section titled "Gay and Christian?" I think it will help you. :) 

 

 

 

What do you want to discuss next? Since we're in the New Testament how about 1 Corinthians 6:9-10 & 1 Timothy 1:9-10? 

Just because YOU say it's the key word?  what about vile passions being the key word? Or men with men committing what is shameful, receiving in themsleves the penalty of their error?  Your argument is lame. 
 
First | Prev | 107 | 108 | 109 | 110 | 111 | 112 | 113 | 114 | 115 | 116 | Next | Last