Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 4:10 am PDT

06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: gwmnpsca

Obviously the straight sister has resentment issues as depicted by her combative stance on all issues pertaining to her sisters sexuality. Although, mother and daughters have Christian background, mother and sister have used a minute and archaic scripture from the bible as to attack their loved ones sexuality and justify their hardliner stance as gospel. Their are just as many scriptures to contradict their insistence that she ask for forgiveness for her "sins" and agree not to practice her sexuality. Meaning, she give up her life to "god" and never fall in love emotionally, physically, or spiritually. In other words, they believe she is not entitled to lead her life in a "normal" fashion as they have.  

   The stigma begins with prejudice, hate, and resentment as early as childhood and continues through most of our lives because of a backwards, ultra conservative, oppressive, and third world barbaric government that has legislated legal prejudicial hatred for a segment of society deemed unworthy of equal rights.  Our government and clergy have held Gay and Lesbian people hostage, keeping the nuclear family from growing, healing, and moving on to the many other trials and tribulations in life.  

Why must we continue to be chastised for only wanting what the Bush Administration claims to be fighting for, individual freedom. We are second class citizens who pay more taxes for less rights. The black and women movements have gained equality, when will this bassakward country get their laws out of our bedrooms and give all its citizens liberty and justice for all? We are suppose to be the "leader of the free world" yet we are still practicing third world oppressive laws and philosophies.   

Only when the government leads by example in lieu of ignorance and fear will our people begin the healing process of decades of oppression, legalized prejudice, and hatred justified by those who call themselves Christians. No loving god would approve of the vehement hatred spewed by those who call themselves Christians.
 

PRECISELY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 5:07 am PDT

And somewhere there we disagree:) but where?

Quote From: jayde287

Yes, but saying you'll take my word for it is just like saying you don't believe me. It's a condescending way to tell me I'm lying while you're trying to make it look like you're not saying that. 

  

And why do I need "healing"? I am not broken. I am a strong, independant, loving, nurturing woman. And I don't see anything wrong with that! 

  

  

"yes, but saying you'll take my word for it is just like saying you don't believe me.  It's a condescending way to tell me I'm lying while your trying to make it look like you're not saying that,"   

   

Something I learned while being on this message board while reading through what people have writen and taking my own personal experience into concideration is the fact that many people want their feelings and emotions validated.   

   

What I am reading on these message boards are not so much theological discussions.  I see from a different perspective then what the Christians on these boards are seeing from because of my own personal experience.   

   

At one time I used to speak to gay's and lesbian's as a Christian instead of from the perspective of the fact that I still have to deal with same-sex attraction issues every single day of my life while knowing it is my choice of what I do with it.   

   

This one night I got into this very heated conversation while I was sleeping over at a friends house.  He was on this spiritual journey himself while openly gay.     

   

As I was reading through what you had writen I was reminded of this conversation I had with this friend of mine, because of what you had writen....   

   

"How do you know when you yourself are not homosexual???????????????????????"   

   

There was this point in our conversation where this friend of mine lost control in his emotions.  He yelled at me, he screamed and cried and basicaly told me off.  Conflict can be a bridge to intimacy, it all depends on whether or not a person is open or closed off during the conflict.  In this case with my friend I was challenged and the end result became a closer friendship.   

   

He screamed at me, "How do you know what I am going through when you don't know what it means to be gay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"   

   

After my friend yelled at me, with tears running down my face I began to pray for the Lord's guidance and ask how on earth I am to respond to this.  For the next three hours I shared with him my story and that pretty much became an all night discussion on this very issue.   

   

What I learned through my friend and through many people on this board, whether they know it or not, I came to see that Christian's are not doing one thing that perhaps I could because I do understand.   

   

I understand this and yes, it's my opinion but it's what I've come to learn as truth.....   

My feelings are very real but they do not define who it is that I am.   

   

And what I saw were many people who have very real emotions, emotions and feelings that are valid and many Christians on this message board are not seeing your very real emotions.  Emotions that I know you are not making up, and emotions in our human nature is not something we choose but it's something we feel and it affects all of us in many different ways.     

   

A few people have asked straight people in not so many words, "have you chosen to be straight?"   

   

What I have done (and perhaps you are not used to experiencing this, because maybe I just happen to not be like any of the Christians that you have come across.) is actualy acknowledge your emotions and feelings as being very real because they are.   

   

It had nothing to do with being a condenscending way to tell you that you were lieing.  I wrote my last message coming from the perspective that what you were telling me was true about you.  Does that make sense?     

   

And to answer your question.......first of all, you say that you are a strong, independant, loving, nurturing woman.  And that you see nothing wrong with that.  Is there any reason for me to believe different?   

   

You ask, why you need healing?  I guess when I speak of God's healing work in my life you would think that I am saying that gay's and lesbian's need healing in their lives, because if I thought that gay relationships were healthy and moraly acceptable as a Christian then I would be involved in a gay relationship.  That is true.  If I thought that it were healthy and moraly acceptable I would be in a gay relationship...why would I work towards reaching "the potential of my true heterosexual self,"   

   

And the term...."the potential heterosexual self,"  I am using because I do believe that healing is possable.  I also believe that healing and deliverance is a much needed work in everyone's life when coming to faith in Christ.     

   

You say you are not broken but in reference to my view of homosexuality, it is a form of brokenness but I don't look at brokenness as a bad thing.     

   

I know many functional gay people, more functional that I am.  For what I have been through in my own journey I can't claim to be functional.  I can only claim to be weak and powerless over my addictions and tendency to do the wrong thing.   

   

I can only go to my Lord and savior with this in mind......and this is what I tell myself everyday....   

   

"lean not on your own understanding but in all your ways acknowledge Him and He shall direct your paths,"   

   

"humble yourself therefore, under the mighty hand of God and in due time He will exhault you.  For God resists the proud but gives grace to the humble,"   

   

"My grace is sufficient for my power is made perfect in weakness,"   

   

God's grace is not only tailor made and precision cut to fit all my needs in whatever circumstance I find myself in, which includes failure.  God's grace also means to be for me what I cannot be for myself.  God's grace which is His divine power at work in me, and who through His grace comes under me to lift me up enabling and empowering me to walk out His will for my life.   

   

"For it is by grace through faith in Christ Jesus that we are saved not by works lest any man should boast,"   

   

Salvation has nothing to do with our works and sometimes people kind of miss the mark on that because salvation has everything to do with the work of Christ on the cross.  Jesus Christ of which scripture says not only learned obedience through the things he suffered but God's word also says, "For the joy set before Him He endured the cross....yet while we were still sinners Christ died,"   

   

Again, salvation has nothing to do with works but faith without works is futile because with faith comes the fruit of the Spirit.  And it's not my place to judge the fruit in your life.  My place is not to judge of whether or not you personaly know the Lord, where God has sent me is to simply proclaim His good news.  That yes, our sin seperates us from God but He has made a way for us to come back into relationship with God our father.     

   

And even Christian's can miss this point right here.  The Father sent His son not to save us from hell but so that we could have a relationship with Him.   

   

The working out of ones salvation is between the person and God.  We are not the judges and we do not choose who comes in and who does not.  I do know the word of God and I know what it teaches and God's word stand alone.   

   

Not only does God's word stand alone but it also says that we are without excuse.  Something else that scripture also teaches, is that He will hand us over to our sinful ways if that is what we choose and he will allow our hearts to harden.  I am not saying this to judge you in any way or form but simply to share from scripture what I have come to believe.   

   

Scripture says this, "If today you hear the voice of God, do not harden your heart."   

   

Scripture also says, that He has a future and plan for your life, not to harm you but to give you hope and a future....you will find me delcares the Lord when you search for me with all your heart.  I will be found by you declares the Lord and lead you up from captivity,"  Jer 29:11-14a   

   

This scripture continues to be one that gives me the hope that I so desperatly need.  I mean, we all do.   

   

You see, at the time when my friend yelled at me, I had a choice.   I could either choose to come to him with honesty or continue to hide behind this falsified image of this straight and very strong Christian.  Up until that point, I WAS THE RELIGIOUS POSTER.     

   

And this is the gospal that I have come to see as true...and the whole reason why I can stand with confidence with who I am in Christ and say, although my emotions are very real, my emotions do not define who it is that I am.  And who defines me is God and in His word I stand on who He says I am in His word.   

   

I am a woman created in the image of God and the daughter of the most high God.   

   

You know 1Cor 6:9,10, it often is used to condemn gay people....but there was a reason that was placed in scripture, and it wasn't to condemn people with it but to remind the church that they too can be placed within that list..."And such were some of you"  Paul said.  And it was writen so that the power of God can be revealed.  Not only the power of God but His love, grace and mercy.....in 1Cor 6:11 the verse that follows after..... (but sometimes there does exist people within the church who forget where they came from and I for one do not want to forget where I came from.  I don't believe I ever will forget where I came from.  Because, I do have people in my life who will remind me where I came from.     

   

I look at that as a blessing in my life.   

   

And so with all of this, although through a very long message I say, this is the reason why when you tell me how you feel, how  can I go against how you feel. How you feel is what's inside of you.  How you feel is not inside of me and so I have to take your word on it.     

   

As I have said, people do not believe that God exists and are very happy. Being happy and secure does not reveal one's relationship with God or lack thereof.   

   

And so this is God's good news for me just as it is for anyone who chooses to surrender their lives to Christ.  And when I say everyone, that is exactly what I am saying....everyone.   

    

"And that is what some of you were, but you were washed, you were sanctified and you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God,"   

   

Peace<><  

   

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 5:24 am PDT

who can cast the stone?

Quote From: thinkwwjd

first of all....Jesus never condemed a person...so if a family member told me that they were gay...they definatly know how I feel....but I would not condemn them or treat them with hate...Their decision is between them and God....And only he is the one that should make the judgment against them....not me....You remember when he told the first one without sin to cast the first stone....well...none of us is without sin...no matter how had we try...so....we can not cast that stone now can we?
For sure I can't cast the stone:)
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 5:30 am PDT

being gay?

Quote From: loveboduke

I WOULD TELL THEM  THAT JESUS LOVES THEM AND  THAT  BEING GAY IS A SIN,  BUT GOD WILL FORGIVE THEM IF THEY WILL ASK FOR HIS FORGIVENESS  AND STOP  THE SIN.  TURN THERE LIFE AROUND    AND LIVE FOR JESUS.

Well, here it is....and it's with that comment people are lost......  

   

You didn't wake one morning to say, "I think I want to be straight," and there you were....  

   

Like wise people didn't wake up to say, "I think I want to be gay,"   

   

The question and debate........how?  It's certainly not a choice because the very long and hard journey is to try and be everything but....some say it is who they are and others like myself who say, my emotions are very real but they don't define who I am.  Being gay does not define who it is that I am but rather God through His word defines who it is that I am.  

   

Peace<><  

   

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 5:43 am PDT

I can't make them believe

Quote From: loveboduke

WELL   I    CARE FOR PEOPLE SOULS  AND DON'T   WANT TO SEE NO ONE GO TO HELL!   THATS WHY I TELL  PEOPLE  THE TRUTH ABOUT GOD AND HIS WORD!    IF  SOME PEOPLE  DON'T LIKE HEARING THE TRUTH AND STILL DON'T BELEVIE IN GOD.  THEN   THERE IS NOTHING ELSE I CAN SAY.  I CAN'T MAKE THEM   BELEVIE IN OUR TRUE GOD.  THATS ALL UP TO THEM.  I DID MY PART BY WITNESS   TO   THEM   AND PRAYING  FOR THEM.    I  AM A SWEET  CAREING, LOVEING CHRISTIAN AND I JUDGE NO ONE. I ONLY  TELL THE TRUTH ABOUT GOD!   I  WISH  PEOPLE THAT ARE LOST  THE BEST  AND MAY GOD BLESS THEM.  PRAYING  FOR THE LOST!! 

"I can't make them believe,"  

  

How about we start there.  Only by the Spirit of God do people come to believe.  People either respond to God's Holy Spirit or they don't.  And we don't truthfuly know the work of God in any person's life.  

   

"I am a sweet caring, loving Christian and I judge no one. I only tell the truth about God,"  

  

You know,  somehow I do actualy believe that, but sometimes people can't read between the lines....sometimes they can't see behind your words and simply see judgment and condemnation from you rather than the love of Christ.  They see you casting a stone when it's not your place to cast a stone.  I am not saying this to judge you but simply sharing with you how the words you've writen are conveying to people.    

   

I might not be the best person to learn from, but as a Christian you and I agree with something and that is, that the homosexual lifestyle is not moraly acceptable as a Christian.  Read more of what I writen and it's from my perspective as a Christian who does her best to live according to Judeo-Christian moral's and values.  

   

It's a suggestion, until then,  Peace<><  

   

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 5:50 am PDT

correction....

Quote From: eden777

Now this is what I like to call some food for thought.  

   

I once wrote a poem and I called it From Out of Darkness.  It was an exhortation to the church just to think about it for one moment, to seriously think about it.  

   

Jesus said, "I am the way, the truth and the life,"  

Jesus said, "I can that they might have life,"  

Jesus said, "the least you do for the least of these you do to me,"  

   

I say, "Do you realy love me,"  

I say, "can I sit at your table,"  

Jesus said, "I am the way, the truth and the life," 

Jesus said, "I came that they might have life," 

Jesus said, "the least you do for the least of these you do to me," 

  

I ask, "Do you realy love me?" 

I ask, "Can I sit at your table?" 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 6:15 am PDT

what is this you say?

To tigercat44,   

   

There are two reason's why I am on this message board....and this in reference to you dear Christian's....... and in reference to the scripture you quoted......  

   

#1....I don't believe that I am casting pearls before swine   

and so I will not be dusting off my sandels any time soon.  

   

#2....this is a discussion on whether or not gay's can be a Christian  

and so I share why I hold to Judeo-Christian moral's and values...and make scriptural references for the reason's why I believe what I do which is all apart of this discussion.  

   

And with all do respect, if you realy are getting just a bit frustrated with this whole thing maybe you need to take a break....:)  

   

   

   

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 6:31 am PDT

I loved this response...

Quote From: purplepain

First of all Powers, your stance IS the popular one. I hate it when Christians try to act like some picked on minority. Hardly. (Want to know what it's really like to be a picked on minority. Try being an atheist!)

Second of all I am glad you follow your religion the way you believe are commanded to. But that doesn't answer her question. Why should YOUR religion be the law?

"(want to know what it's really like to be a picked on minority.  Try being an atheist!)  

   

How about being a gay atheist...are you a gay atheist?  because then that would realy place you in the minority.  

   

What about this one...to be a Christian after leading a gay lifestyle and preach healing.....  

   

I loved this response because this is so true.  I was just at a young adults Christian coffee shop hang out place and we had a pretty good discussion on spirituality in general.  

   

I brought up the point that atheists are truly in the minority.  

   

When one thinks about it, most people believe that God exists, it's just a debate on whose right.  

   

Sincerly,  

Eden  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
June 14, 2006, 6:54 am PDT

hello

well   i   care for all  people   and  i want everyone to go to heaven.   thats  why  i tell   people the truth about  GOD  AND HIS  WORD.   i   don't   make  none of this up.  it all comes from  GOD'S WORD!  i   read  the bible  and go to church.    i   judge no one!   i   only  witness to them. because i care for there souls.   i   can't  make no one belevie  in  GOD.   thats up to them.   i can  only  tell  them the truth about our GOD  and  his word.   pray for them.      also  wish them the best.    

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 14, 2006, 7:04 am PDT

hey

 
First | Prev | 345 | 346 | 347 | 348 | 349 | 350 | 351 | 352 | 353 | 354 | Next | Last