Message Boards

Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 27, 2006, 12:04 pm PDT

Your response?

Quote From: julie1418

I posted a reply to you, but I guess it was deemed off topic :( 

  

I posted another on the Debating Different Religious Beliefs Board....you can find it under Beyond the News and Headlines on the Message Board main page. 

  

Julie 

Sorry that I was unable to respond to you.  I must not have had the chance to read what you had written.  I do, with the best of my ability read every response that is written to me.  I just need a little time to read through them. 

  

I never deem any person's words as unimportant and invalid.  Everybody has a valid response and every person's feelings are valid.   

  

I haven't realy checked out other message boards because I have realy enjoyed what I have been learning through this message board.   

  

I will do my best to find what you had written and then respond the best way I know how. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 27, 2006, 12:12 pm PDT

06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: eden777

Sorry that I was unable to respond to you.  I must not have had the chance to read what you had written.  I do, with the best of my ability read every response that is written to me.  I just need a little time to read through them. 

  

I never deem any person's words as unimportant and invalid.  Everybody has a valid response and every person's feelings are valid.   

  

I haven't realy checked out other message boards because I have realy enjoyed what I have been learning through this message board.   

  

I will do my best to find what you had written and then respond the best way I know how. 

No... No... No...The moderators didn't post it, you didn't 'dis' me, my post never hit the boards. No apology necessary.
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
June 27, 2006, 1:17 pm PDT

06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: irishmom

The Bible CLEARLY states that homosexuality is a sin.  However, the Bible also clearly states that we should love EVERYONE, as does Jesus.  There were many people in Biblical times that sinned, but Jesus himself said, "He who is without sin, let him cast the first stone".  I do not agree with homosexuality, but I have my own sins to worry about.  Who am I to judge another when I walk imperfectly?  If one of my children were to come to me and tell me they were gay, I would be very sad for them (for many reasons, not just because of the fact that they are gay, but because it is such a hard lifestyle to live, in part because of all the hatred toward them), but I would LOVE them NO differently.   So-called Christians who HATE gays and treat them unkindly are not Christians at all in my opinion. 

I agree with about 90% of what you said  

  

  

Ps  

  

  

At least they are not acting like christians. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 28, 2006, 2:57 am PDT

I am running out of titles!

Quote From: jayde287

Eden777,  

  

I didn't repost your whole message because is was just too long. I just wanted to ask you something. I know you believe you came out of your homosexuality, but why would anyone who is truly happy want to do that? What is the point? I know for me it would make me miserable. I couldn't stand to go through this life without my wife. She is my world, my life! She means more to me than anyone else, and I wouldn't give that up for a second!  

  

It makes me sad to hear your family supports you being gay, and you rebuke it. That's terrible. So many young gays and lesbians don't have that support.  

  

And one more thing, I know I asked this before, but I haven't gotten a solid answer. If it is so possible to "become straight", then how come the FOUNDERS of Exodus International left the company and went back into being homosexuals? I know people say, "oh, they're married...blah, blah, blah...." He was caught at a GAY BAR.....hmmmmmmm......how do we explain that??? 

  

It is one thing to completely change your sexuality....it's quite another to just be celibate. 

I wasn't saying thank you to you for being so kind for re-posting my message on the right message board.  I thought I answered your question just fine.  

   

I know of John and Anne Paulk the founders of Love Won Out...today they are still married...they never renounced their affiliation with Focus On The Family.  

   

John was caught in a gay bar...and the gay community watch Focus On The Family like a hawlk to find out how John would be treated.    

   

Most of the studies that have been done over long period of time having to do with a person's healing journey if you will....most of the studies do show that most people do reach a certain level of heterosexual relating while still struggling with homosexuality.  However, their same-sex attractions no longer have the power if you will over their lives and have decreased in it's intensity while there has been an increase in oppisate-sex attraction.  

   

Do I expect full healing to come into my life..i.e a complete change in sexual orientation?    

   

I actualy don't expect a complete change in my sexual orientation but I don't limit the power of God to make that possable.  I do expect more healing to come into my life.  I never used to me attracted to me, I was the predominatly homosexual.  I am nearly 30 years old I am just now coming to sense an attraction towards men but am I still very attracted to women?  The answer would be yes.  

   

I can remember John and Anne Paulk being interviewed on the Oprah Winfrey show and Oprah asked Anne a question...are you still find yourself attracted to women?  Anne Paulk's response was...yes.  

   

It seems to me that most people coming out of homosexuality will always have homosexual tendencies but the person through Christ can be given the power to live above and beyond all that and experience a level of healing.  While, it is true, some do experience complete change.  I actualy know a couple of people who can proclaim complete healing in their lives and say that it's now become a foreign concept to them.  Given certain situations, I believe it might be possable for them to regress, much like an alcoholic will always have a possability to regress back into their addictions.    

   

At least, all of the studies that have been made watching a number of people through their healing process do show that for most cases there will always be a certain level of homosexual temptation but this by no means negates what healing has occured in their lives.  

   

As far as Exodus Global Alliance...there has been some false accusation...I mean, many people have their oppinions about me and it's not based upon truth.  Many people have judged me and have been wrong with what they have said about me.  And so I am not quick to take your word on it.  

   

However, even if the founder of Exodus went back into the gay community, that wouldn't affect my decision to keep following Christ and using the Bible as my moral guide through life.    

   

I will do some research though, and will get back to you with what I find out.  

   

   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 28, 2006, 7:24 am PDT

What you call "healing" I call repression!

Quote From: eden777

I wasn't saying thank you to you for being so kind for re-posting my message on the right message board.  I thought I answered your question just fine.  

   

I know of John and Anne Paulk the founders of Love Won Out...today they are still married...they never renounced their affiliation with Focus On The Family.  

   

John was caught in a gay bar...and the gay community watch Focus On The Family like a hawlk to find out how John would be treated.    

   

Most of the studies that have been done over long period of time having to do with a person's healing journey if you will....most of the studies do show that most people do reach a certain level of heterosexual relating while still struggling with homosexuality.  However, their same-sex attractions no longer have the power if you will over their lives and have decreased in it's intensity while there has been an increase in oppisate-sex attraction.  

   

Do I expect full healing to come into my life..i.e a complete change in sexual orientation?    

   

I actualy don't expect a complete change in my sexual orientation but I don't limit the power of God to make that possable.  I do expect more healing to come into my life.  I never used to me attracted to me, I was the predominatly homosexual.  I am nearly 30 years old I am just now coming to sense an attraction towards men but am I still very attracted to women?  The answer would be yes.  

   

I can remember John and Anne Paulk being interviewed on the Oprah Winfrey show and Oprah asked Anne a question...are you still find yourself attracted to women?  Anne Paulk's response was...yes.  

   

It seems to me that most people coming out of homosexuality will always have homosexual tendencies but the person through Christ can be given the power to live above and beyond all that and experience a level of healing.  While, it is true, some do experience complete change.  I actualy know a couple of people who can proclaim complete healing in their lives and say that it's now become a foreign concept to them.  Given certain situations, I believe it might be possable for them to regress, much like an alcoholic will always have a possability to regress back into their addictions.    

   

At least, all of the studies that have been made watching a number of people through their healing process do show that for most cases there will always be a certain level of homosexual temptation but this by no means negates what healing has occured in their lives.  

   

As far as Exodus Global Alliance...there has been some false accusation...I mean, many people have their oppinions about me and it's not based upon truth.  Many people have judged me and have been wrong with what they have said about me.  And so I am not quick to take your word on it.  

   

However, even if the founder of Exodus went back into the gay community, that wouldn't affect my decision to keep following Christ and using the Bible as my moral guide through life.    

   

I will do some research though, and will get back to you with what I find out.  

   

   

Well, you've just said it yourself. You said that even the most "healed" people still have homosexual tendencies. Therefore they are pushing and pushing very hard to hide deep inside themselves who they really are. This can only lead to two things: UNHAPPINESS AND SELF LOATHING. These are not good things to have in your life. Yes, there may be people out there who "claim" to be "healed" of their homosexual selves, but I can say, with 100% truth that they are just lying to themselves and everyone around them. Of course they have to say that! If you go around yelling about how you can change, you have to at least try to come across as having done so. Otherwise you will feel like a complete fool! 

  

For example, let's say I ran around all day shouting that the sky was purple. No one believed me, but I as so ADAMANT about it and I truly believed the sky was purple. And then I looked up and saw that the sky is actually blue, I would damn sure probably still insist it was purple as to not embarass myself!  

  

All these "ex-gay" groups do is add to the already extremely high suicide rate amoung gay youth! Not a very positive thing to do now, is it? 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 28, 2006, 7:56 am PDT

One more thing...

Quote From: eden777

I wasn't saying thank you to you for being so kind for re-posting my message on the right message board.  I thought I answered your question just fine.  

   

I know of John and Anne Paulk the founders of Love Won Out...today they are still married...they never renounced their affiliation with Focus On The Family.  

   

John was caught in a gay bar...and the gay community watch Focus On The Family like a hawlk to find out how John would be treated.    

   

Most of the studies that have been done over long period of time having to do with a person's healing journey if you will....most of the studies do show that most people do reach a certain level of heterosexual relating while still struggling with homosexuality.  However, their same-sex attractions no longer have the power if you will over their lives and have decreased in it's intensity while there has been an increase in oppisate-sex attraction.  

   

Do I expect full healing to come into my life..i.e a complete change in sexual orientation?    

   

I actualy don't expect a complete change in my sexual orientation but I don't limit the power of God to make that possable.  I do expect more healing to come into my life.  I never used to me attracted to me, I was the predominatly homosexual.  I am nearly 30 years old I am just now coming to sense an attraction towards men but am I still very attracted to women?  The answer would be yes.  

   

I can remember John and Anne Paulk being interviewed on the Oprah Winfrey show and Oprah asked Anne a question...are you still find yourself attracted to women?  Anne Paulk's response was...yes.  

   

It seems to me that most people coming out of homosexuality will always have homosexual tendencies but the person through Christ can be given the power to live above and beyond all that and experience a level of healing.  While, it is true, some do experience complete change.  I actualy know a couple of people who can proclaim complete healing in their lives and say that it's now become a foreign concept to them.  Given certain situations, I believe it might be possable for them to regress, much like an alcoholic will always have a possability to regress back into their addictions.    

   

At least, all of the studies that have been made watching a number of people through their healing process do show that for most cases there will always be a certain level of homosexual temptation but this by no means negates what healing has occured in their lives.  

   

As far as Exodus Global Alliance...there has been some false accusation...I mean, many people have their oppinions about me and it's not based upon truth.  Many people have judged me and have been wrong with what they have said about me.  And so I am not quick to take your word on it.  

   

However, even if the founder of Exodus went back into the gay community, that wouldn't affect my decision to keep following Christ and using the Bible as my moral guide through life.    

   

I will do some research though, and will get back to you with what I find out.  

   

   

Being homosexual is NOT AN ADDICTION. That's a ludicrous statement. Do you think straight people are addicted to their spouses or partners??? 

  

Why is the natural way we are born looked on as such a dirty thing? It's not dirty, it's beautiful! 

 

Message Emote
blank
June 28, 2006, 9:27 am PDT

06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: jayde287

Well, you've just said it yourself. You said that even the most "healed" people still have homosexual tendencies. Therefore they are pushing and pushing very hard to hide deep inside themselves who they really are. This can only lead to two things: UNHAPPINESS AND SELF LOATHING. These are not good things to have in your life. Yes, there may be people out there who "claim" to be "healed" of their homosexual selves, but I can say, with 100% truth that they are just lying to themselves and everyone around them. Of course they have to say that! If you go around yelling about how you can change, you have to at least try to come across as having done so. Otherwise you will feel like a complete fool! 

  

For example, let's say I ran around all day shouting that the sky was purple. No one believed me, but I as so ADAMANT about it and I truly believed the sky was purple. And then I looked up and saw that the sky is actually blue, I would damn sure probably still insist it was purple as to not embarass myself!  

  

All these "ex-gay" groups do is add to the already extremely high suicide rate amoung gay youth! Not a very positive thing to do now, is it? 

Well, you've just said it yourself. You said that even the most "healed" people still have homosexual tendencies. Therefore they are pushing and pushing very hard to hide deep inside themselves who they really are. This can only lead to two things: UNHAPPINESS AND SELF LOATHING. These are not good things to have in your life.  

  

I think the biggest sin that arises from gay people pretending to be straight is that they marry straight people and screw up their lives.  I know of several instances of this and I can never accept that it is ok.   

  

One of my sisters was married to a great man-we all loved him dearly.  He always talked and gestured like a gay guy but it wasn't something we talked about much although we all noticed it.   He killed himself 8 years into their relationship. My sister has never really recovered from that. That was the outcome of all of this religious oppression and IMO THAT was a sin that the people who join in the oppression have to take responsibility for. 

  

  

 

Message Emote
blank
June 28, 2006, 9:48 am PDT

06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: jayde287

Well, you've just said it yourself. You said that even the most "healed" people still have homosexual tendencies. Therefore they are pushing and pushing very hard to hide deep inside themselves who they really are. This can only lead to two things: UNHAPPINESS AND SELF LOATHING. These are not good things to have in your life. Yes, there may be people out there who "claim" to be "healed" of their homosexual selves, but I can say, with 100% truth that they are just lying to themselves and everyone around them. Of course they have to say that! If you go around yelling about how you can change, you have to at least try to come across as having done so. Otherwise you will feel like a complete fool! 

  

For example, let's say I ran around all day shouting that the sky was purple. No one believed me, but I as so ADAMANT about it and I truly believed the sky was purple. And then I looked up and saw that the sky is actually blue, I would damn sure probably still insist it was purple as to not embarass myself!  

  

All these "ex-gay" groups do is add to the already extremely high suicide rate amoung gay youth! Not a very positive thing to do now, is it? 

Since I have no belief in the bible or a god or anything and since I believe we are just animals in nature and science is simply a study of that nature I have to agree.  There is no evidence that sexuality is a choice, that it can be changed, and that it's healthy to try to change it. The bits of evidence we do have now show the opposite. And since homosexuality doesn't hurt anyone I simply can't understand or accept a religious rationale to call it a sin.  Almost all other sins I can appreciate.  This how ever is two consenting adults who LOVE each other. I can't see any reason why god would make that a sin.

And I do also agree that there is a lot of ego and pride in these ex-gay groups and admitting failure would be devastating to that pride.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
June 28, 2006, 10:09 am PDT

Thank you!

Quote From: judyblue22

Well, you've just said it yourself. You said that even the most "healed" people still have homosexual tendencies. Therefore they are pushing and pushing very hard to hide deep inside themselves who they really are. This can only lead to two things: UNHAPPINESS AND SELF LOATHING. These are not good things to have in your life.  

  

I think the biggest sin that arises from gay people pretending to be straight is that they marry straight people and screw up their lives.  I know of several instances of this and I can never accept that it is ok.   

  

One of my sisters was married to a great man-we all loved him dearly.  He always talked and gestured like a gay guy but it wasn't something we talked about much although we all noticed it.   He killed himself 8 years into their relationship. My sister has never really recovered from that. That was the outcome of all of this religious oppression and IMO THAT was a sin that the people who join in the oppression have to take responsibility for. 

  

  

Thank you so much for sharing this tragic story with us all. My heart goes out to your sister and all of you. It must have been so difficult. 

  

And thank you also for the last sentence in your post. I wholeheartedly agree!  

  

Take care, 

Jayde 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 28, 2006, 11:17 am PDT

I did my homework:)

Quote From: jayde287

Eden777,  

  

I didn't repost your whole message because is was just too long. I just wanted to ask you something. I know you believe you came out of your homosexuality, but why would anyone who is truly happy want to do that? What is the point? I know for me it would make me miserable. I couldn't stand to go through this life without my wife. She is my world, my life! She means more to me than anyone else, and I wouldn't give that up for a second!  

  

It makes me sad to hear your family supports you being gay, and you rebuke it. That's terrible. So many young gays and lesbians don't have that support.  

  

And one more thing, I know I asked this before, but I haven't gotten a solid answer. If it is so possible to "become straight", then how come the FOUNDERS of Exodus International left the company and went back into being homosexuals? I know people say, "oh, they're married...blah, blah, blah...." He was caught at a GAY BAR.....hmmmmmmm......how do we explain that??? 

  

It is one thing to completely change your sexuality....it's quite another to just be celibate. 

First things first...to add to a comment that you made...   

   

"It makes me sad to hear your family supports you being gay, and you rebuke it.  That's terrible.  So many young gays and lesbians don't have that support."   

   

First of all, I didn't have parental guidence growing up and with my sisters and my brother, for many years all we had were each other and we survived by working together.  It's not about my family supporting me being gay.  In respect to them, they do find it a little uncomfortable.  Who they support, the best way they know how is me placing my sexuality aside because my sexuality does not define who I am.  People in my family do not use the Bible as a moral guide if you will.  The Bible for them is not a source of guidance for their lives.  I am the one who stands out in my family coming to believe in Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior resulting in me turning from my sinful lifestyle.  My family has not been in support of my faith in Christ.  I actualy would like them to support me in that but they don't.     

   

Now more onto more important things.  I did my homework and searched into the history of Exodus Global Alliance as well as I contacted them and received a response from them.  I couldn't say it any better and so I will quote the e-mail I received from Exodus--Canada's office in Toronto.     

   

Historical timeline of Exodus on their web site:   

http://www.exodusglobalalliance.org/ourhistoryc87.php.   

   

We don't claim that the founders and leaders of Exodus are perfect.  We don't try to hide the struggles that Exodus has had.   

   

Pro-gay organizations present a false story about the founders of Exodus North America in an attempt to discredit organizations that seek to provide Christian help to people seeking freedom from homosexuality.  A common misleading story that they distribute is about Gary Cooper and Michael Busee.  These men claim they were founders of Exodus and that they returned to homosexuality once they discovered that change was not possible.  The truth is that these 2 men came to Frank Worthen's ministry seeking help.  (I will share with you who Frank Worthen is in just a bit)   

   

One man stands out as the founder of Exodus.  His name is Frank Worthen.  He was not the only person who was involved in founding Exodus but he was the person who was called by God and took the initiative to bring people together and get Exodus started.     

   

You can read Frank Worthen's testimony on the Exodus Global Alliance web-site at   

http://www.exodusglobalalliance.org/lookingforafatherp3.php.   

   

Frank is still the director of the ministry he started in 1973.  It is now called New Hope.  His ministry continues to be a member ministry of Exodus.    

   

Gary Cooper and Michael Busee--these 2 men came to Frank Worthen's ministry seeking help.  They did attend at least one information meeting when Frank Worthen was working on the start of Exodus North America.  But coming to information meetings, indicating an interest in receiving Christian help, joining support groups and counseling but later dropping out  and choosing to stay in their homosexual lifestyles does not make them founders.  Their names do not show up on any records from the founding or development of Exodus North America as leaders.     

   

One other response we give to the idea that the failure of a person, even a founder, invalidates a ministry is to ask if the same illogical conclusions are applied to other ministries.  Alcoholics Anonymous has had many more than 2 failures (people who tried to stop drinking using the help of A.A but failed) yet A.A is still concidered a creditable organization.  So, even if the story was true, how does the failure of 2 people some 25-30 years ago discredit the help that is being provided to people?  Further, the kinds of help that Exodus and it's member ministries provide today is not the same as it was 30 years ago.  We have learned many things over 30 years just like any other feild of medicine and social work.  You learn while you work and you apply what you have learned to make your work more effective.    

   

Lastly, the Bible is full of people who fail.  Our hope comes not from people who were perfect but people who failed, sometimes failed big, spectacular, tragic ways, and found that God is a God of truth and grace, who brings hope and healing, redemption and transformation to people who fail.  The issue for God is not failure but repentance.  We all have failed.  But not all of us are willing to repent and let Jesus become Saviour and Lord of our lives.  Those who do find God is merciful, patient, a gentle shepherd, a loving Father, a wonderful counselor, who commits Himself to a process of transformation in our lives so that Jesus will be able to present  us faultless before God's throne.    

   

Failure does not invalidate a ministry any more than it invalidates a person.  Lack of repentance is what invalidates a ministry.     

   

 
First | Prev | 389 | 390 | 391 | 392 | 393 | 394 | 395 | 396 | 397 | 398 | Next | Last