Message Boards

Topic : 12/29 "Is This Normal?"

Number of Replies: 493
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, October 20, 2005, 02:47:02 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Airdate 10/24/05) Do you have a really strange habit? Are you in a bizarre situation and think you’re the only one experiencing it? Monica and Joe call each other names like "fat ass" and "ugly." They love their bad banter, but wonder if it's influencing their young children in a negative way. Then, Mary's husband had a liver transplant, and his medical bills are putting a strain on their marriage. Is it normal for her to resent the financial burden, or is she just being selfish? Plus, a new mom wonders how to raise her 4-month-old with her nudist fiance. Talk about the show here.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More December 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.


Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2005, 10:32 pm PDT

Sympathizing/Overwhleming healthcare costs

Quote From: susielewes

     I hear what you say about how selfish this wife is/was, and I have to speak up for her! I honestly did not think she didn't want her husband because of the medical bills, but she loves him, and couldn't express it differently at the time. My husband and I are in the same situation! My husband first had prostate cancer, then two brain tumors, and now the doctor thinks he had a silent heart attack, which will require further testing tomorrow. Our medical bills that are not covered by insurance are overwhelming, and we pay our health insurance premium of almost $1500.oo a MONTH out of our income, because we are self-employed. No, we are not wealthy, have no employees, do no splurging on ANYTHING. ... and live in a trailer. We cannot get any other health insurance because we are a risk. Some of our prescriptions we pay $45 a month, some $10, some $20 and others, the whole thing! I feel this wife's frustration! Where is the help when we need it? I never have begrudged anyone, anything, and think it is wonderful that the people who have suffered through these natural disasters have had needed help, and I know it could not be easy at all for them! My problem is, how do WE get the needed help when we are having a crisis because of health concerns and health insurance premiums? It is heartbreaking and depressing when you work so very hard and have very little "play" time, just to pay those bills. I would never leave my husband because of it, and he has been truly amazing through all of this! Even while he went through the treatments, and the surgery, he knew we would be without income, so he tried to work 3 hours off and on, over almost a two year period, then would come home and sleep. It sounds funny to say now, but I couldn't really get a "job" because when he was home, I was caring for him, and when he was able to work, I did the paperwork, and went out on the construction site to help, and I still do. There really isn't much more I can do to better our situation, but all of you who are degrading this wife that was on the show, don't do it unless you walk in her shoes. I can sympathize with her 100%!!

Sympathizing and condoning her behavior is two different things. While I can sympathize how Mary or my husband may feel, I can't condone how they chose to express their anger, resentment or any other mixed bags of emotions they are feeling. In Mary's case, there may be some hope. Her and her husband are only a few months into their ordeal. Maybe Mary will chose to get therapy to address her feelings so she can express them in a more appropriate fashion. Hopefully, if the therapist is good, he or she can help Mary separate her feelings about her husband's illness and her feelings about her husband as a person. In my case, my husband isn't interested in getting help and we have been going through this for 10 years now. He is unwilling to acknowledge that his behavior isn't making the situation better nor is it conducive to helping me heal. I feel really bad for my husband (43) because he is stuck and wallowing in his immaturity. Both Mary and my husband are adults. There comes a time when one has to grow-up and realize that as John Lennon once said: Life happens when you have other plans. In regards to the overwhelming costs of health-care, it is truly a sad state of dis-repair. Yet, no one is truly interested in fixing the problem. As with anything, our government officials whether Democratic or Republican, would rather filibuster something to death or pick each other's plans a part and never get down to actually addressing the problem. And, who should they go after first? The doctors, clinics, hospitals, insurance companies, HMO's or the pharmaceuticals??? My feelings are pharmaceutical companies are worse than the local drug dealer on the street. The system is set-up so they can rip us off legally. They spend more money on advertising to the public and wining & dining the doctors in order to peddle their pills. They have to turn a profit in order to make their investors happy. The insurance companies are, also, out to make a buck, otherwise they wouldn't be in business. They deliberately make their policies so complicated that the individual who is sick can't make heads or tails out of what to do. You call in to get a pre-authorization or pre-certification and the first and last thing they say is they still don't guarantee payment. I understand there are people out there that try to take advantage of the system, but when you are faced with brain surgery or a transplant, what are you supposed to do? In my situation, I was told it was imperative I have the operation as soon as possible. I didn't have time to shop a around for a neuro-surgeon. The rich can afford the no-hassle policies. We can barely afford our premiums. Our deductible is ridiculously high and goes up, sometimes has doubled from one year to the next. Then we have the co-pays, the co-insurance and out-of pocket expenses. My first surgery was done out of network, so we paid more. I had one doctor refer to me as 'insurance poor'. That made me feel well. Then, I get real anger every time I go in for my after care because both hospitals closest to me are constantly remodeling or adding on. Ten years ago, my first MRI cost $1000. My latest one cost $2500. And, they used the same machine as the first one. It makes no sense. Right now I am of the mind set that if (& I am still young enough) if I get breast cancer or something equally bad, I am going to refuse treatment because not only do I not want to see my husband in the poor house, but I am tired of lining someone else's pocket. My thought is after I die and I get reincarnated, I am coming back to reform our health-care system. I guess I will get off my soap box now. Take care and stay healthy. J 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
upset
October 25, 2005, 11:31 pm PDT

TRANSPLANTS: THE OTHER SIDE

I truly hope that Mary never gets sick or loses a loved one.  She just may regret her disgusting attitude.  My 18-year old son was killed in an automobile accident a year ago and I made the very difficult decision to donate his organs.  I will never regret the decision I made because he saved several lives.  All I could think of when I was listening to Mary was that I would like to reach inside the TV and shake her back to reality.  Did she ever once stop to think about her sick husband who had no choice or think about where his new organ came from?  She should be eternally grateful that her husband is alive and realize that another person had to die in order for him to get better!!  How dare her or anyone else demean my son's memory by choosing to be selfish and uncaring!!!  She needs to learn how to sacrifice a little of her own happiness and realize just how unselfish us donor families are when faced with very emotional situations.  If we can be unselfish, so can she?    

 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2005, 1:43 am PDT

10/24 "Is This Normal?"

 What upset people is not the situation she was in, but her attitude towards the problem and her husband.
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2005, 3:23 am PDT

This is not right.

Quote From: martin1975

My  heart goes out to you. I really don't know why our spouses behave the way they do. Maybe they are worried to invest time and emotion into someone that might not be there for them in the future. Which i think is a crap excuse.  

  

I took our vowes seriously , for better or worse, for richer or poorer, in sickiness and in health to death do us part. 

  

I wish you the best of luck and try to be strong i know it is tough. I myself am loosing faith and strength and klingin on by a thread, can not take this  

How could anyone think that calling your wife a dirty whore is ok. These relationships do not last. People build up resentment and end up leaving. People will try to top each put down with one that is harsher than the last. Would you talk to your mother this way or God. I know Crist would not have called Mary a dirty whore. You shouldn't even talk to your worst enemy this way let alone your family and friends. Dr. Phil, you are right about alot of things but this time you are just plain wrong. There is no getting out of this other than admitting you are wrong. Dont even think about explaining this one away. There is something wrong with this husband and wife to like calling and like to be called these crazy names. Its called low self esteem. I would never let anyone talk to me that way no matter who they are. On this one Dr. Phil you are plain wrong!
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2005, 5:50 am PDT

Medical Bills

Quote From: topstitch

Sympathizing and condoning her behavior is two different things. While I can sympathize how Mary or my husband may feel, I can't condone how they chose to express their anger, resentment or any other mixed bags of emotions they are feeling. In Mary's case, there may be some hope. Her and her husband are only a few months into their ordeal. Maybe Mary will chose to get therapy to address her feelings so she can express them in a more appropriate fashion. Hopefully, if the therapist is good, he or she can help Mary separate her feelings about her husband's illness and her feelings about her husband as a person. In my case, my husband isn't interested in getting help and we have been going through this for 10 years now. He is unwilling to acknowledge that his behavior isn't making the situation better nor is it conducive to helping me heal. I feel really bad for my husband (43) because he is stuck and wallowing in his immaturity. Both Mary and my husband are adults. There comes a time when one has to grow-up and realize that as John Lennon once said: Life happens when you have other plans. In regards to the overwhelming costs of health-care, it is truly a sad state of dis-repair. Yet, no one is truly interested in fixing the problem. As with anything, our government officials whether Democratic or Republican, would rather filibuster something to death or pick each other's plans a part and never get down to actually addressing the problem. And, who should they go after first? The doctors, clinics, hospitals, insurance companies, HMO's or the pharmaceuticals??? My feelings are pharmaceutical companies are worse than the local drug dealer on the street. The system is set-up so they can rip us off legally. They spend more money on advertising to the public and wining & dining the doctors in order to peddle their pills. They have to turn a profit in order to make their investors happy. The insurance companies are, also, out to make a buck, otherwise they wouldn't be in business. They deliberately make their policies so complicated that the individual who is sick can't make heads or tails out of what to do. You call in to get a pre-authorization or pre-certification and the first and last thing they say is they still don't guarantee payment. I understand there are people out there that try to take advantage of the system, but when you are faced with brain surgery or a transplant, what are you supposed to do? In my situation, I was told it was imperative I have the operation as soon as possible. I didn't have time to shop a around for a neuro-surgeon. The rich can afford the no-hassle policies. We can barely afford our premiums. Our deductible is ridiculously high and goes up, sometimes has doubled from one year to the next. Then we have the co-pays, the co-insurance and out-of pocket expenses. My first surgery was done out of network, so we paid more. I had one doctor refer to me as 'insurance poor'. That made me feel well. Then, I get real anger every time I go in for my after care because both hospitals closest to me are constantly remodeling or adding on. Ten years ago, my first MRI cost $1000. My latest one cost $2500. And, they used the same machine as the first one. It makes no sense. Right now I am of the mind set that if (& I am still young enough) if I get breast cancer or something equally bad, I am going to refuse treatment because not only do I not want to see my husband in the poor house, but I am tired of lining someone else's pocket. My thought is after I die and I get reincarnated, I am coming back to reform our health-care system. I guess I will get off my soap box now. Take care and stay healthy. J 

I understand how a wife can get "selfish" about her husband's medical bills.  We have been married 30 years and my husband has been on medical disability  (Social Security) for 21 of those years.  He had one heart attack before we were married and eight heart attacks, carotoid artery surgery, and two heart bypass surgeries, not to mention a hernia operation and gall bladder surgery since we've been married.  There has been no insurance for him since 1985 (one year from the date the disability started) and since he was so young, we could not get a medicare supplement policy.  When he became of age to get  a supplemental policy, his health was such that the premiums would have been unbelievable. 

  

After racing to meet ambulances from downtown, I quit my job and started a secretarial service out of our home so that I could be here for him.   The reason I am so frustrated and furious with this situation is that he will not follow doctor's orders, so his health keeps declining.  Right now is a very good example, the wind chill here is 28 degrees.  He has to wear a mask (along with his oxygen) from 32 to 45 degrees and is not supposed to be outside at all under freezing.  He is at this moment taking his mother to the grocery store, the drugstore, the bank, and any other place she wants to go.  She is another major bone of contention in our marriage.  He makes all my deliveries and pick-ups when it is above 45 degrees (he is paid) and I have to hire someone else to do it in the cold weather.   He just doesn't seem to get it! 

  

I know that I have made the mistake of feelng sorry for him because of his illness and when he really HAD TO HAVE a Lincoln, a boat, a truck, I signed the papers.  Those things are all paid for now, but that added to the $16,000 out of pocket for the first open heart and $60,000 out of pocket for the second one has just about done me in.  Our credit is pretty much now shot because I can no longer work 18 hours a day, seven days a week.  His prescriptions are $900 a month and his doctor bills are approximately $300 per month, all out of pocket.  

  

I have been to the doctor three times in the last twenty years.  I have high blood pressure (imagine that), but can't afford the medication or the doctor's visits to keep it monitored. 

  

I guess maybe I am selfish also, but what I feel are anger and resentment.  Not because of his health condition, but because he only follows doctor's orders when it is convenient for him (and his mother).  

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2005, 10:27 am PDT

What about the organ donors, how disrespectful!

I am still in shock and can't stop thinking about your guest who was upset about the finances over her husband's liver transplant. This woman should be so thankful that her husband is surviving his transplant-she should feel blessed. 

  

I guess I'm so frustrated with your guest because I know someone had to die for her husband to live and they received one of the greatest gifts you can receive, a donated organ. 

  

I want you to know I'm talking from experience-only on the other side. My beautiful 20 year old daughter, Missy, was killed 10 years ago and she was an organ donor. When Missy was killed I truly became aware of what was important in life. 

  

I have been in contact with one of Missy's recipients for the last 8 years and I will never forget that first time I talked to her, she told me she realized the best night of her life was the worst night of my life. Cheryl, the recipient, is a blessing to me. 

  

There are not too many seconds in my day that I don't think about and miss my daughter Missy, but I also feel so blessed that I got to have her for 20 years. If God was to give me Missy for 20 short years or no years at all- I'll take 20 and live the rest of my life with a broken heart. So I'm thinking how sad this woman has no idea how blessed she is and I hope she realizes it before its too late. 

  

Now back to my original feeling of anger-and I am NOT and angry person! To all people who have given the gift of donating organs and we the families of those loved ones I felt we were all disrespected by one selfish woman. I would give anything to live in a 'trailer' and have medical bills that I'd never be able to pay off just to have my daughter Missy back. 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2005, 10:55 am PDT

10/24 "Is This Normal?"

Quote From: spachic23

I think some of you are missing the point that Joe and Monica say they like to call each other names.  This obviously works for their relationship. I am going to guess when they call each other fat ass, neither of them are probably fat.  Also, it doesn't sound like it is one-sided, like some of the relationships you all are describing. If Joe was constantly telling Monica she was fat, stupid, lazy, etc. or vice versa ( and meaning it), it might be considered verbal abuse. But it doesn't sound like this is the case. We don't know these people, so "we" probably should be telling them the SERIOUSLY need to do anything. 

I totally agree with you.....this couple is only joking with each other and they both know it and enjoy it...... 

The only thing they have to watch is bantering back and forth in front of their son...... he obviously doesn't know *most* people don't like it...... :)  I think Dr. Phil was right on with this couple. ;) 

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2005, 12:24 pm PDT

I've been there too

Quote From: etcjeanie

I understand how a wife can get "selfish" about her husband's medical bills.  We have been married 30 years and my husband has been on medical disability  (Social Security) for 21 of those years.  He had one heart attack before we were married and eight heart attacks, carotoid artery surgery, and two heart bypass surgeries, not to mention a hernia operation and gall bladder surgery since we've been married.  There has been no insurance for him since 1985 (one year from the date the disability started) and since he was so young, we could not get a medicare supplement policy.  When he became of age to get  a supplemental policy, his health was such that the premiums would have been unbelievable. 

  

After racing to meet ambulances from downtown, I quit my job and started a secretarial service out of our home so that I could be here for him.   The reason I am so frustrated and furious with this situation is that he will not follow doctor's orders, so his health keeps declining.  Right now is a very good example, the wind chill here is 28 degrees.  He has to wear a mask (along with his oxygen) from 32 to 45 degrees and is not supposed to be outside at all under freezing.  He is at this moment taking his mother to the grocery store, the drugstore, the bank, and any other place she wants to go.  She is another major bone of contention in our marriage.  He makes all my deliveries and pick-ups when it is above 45 degrees (he is paid) and I have to hire someone else to do it in the cold weather.   He just doesn't seem to get it! 

  

I know that I have made the mistake of feelng sorry for him because of his illness and when he really HAD TO HAVE a Lincoln, a boat, a truck, I signed the papers.  Those things are all paid for now, but that added to the $16,000 out of pocket for the first open heart and $60,000 out of pocket for the second one has just about done me in.  Our credit is pretty much now shot because I can no longer work 18 hours a day, seven days a week.  His prescriptions are $900 a month and his doctor bills are approximately $300 per month, all out of pocket.  

  

I have been to the doctor three times in the last twenty years.  I have high blood pressure (imagine that), but can't afford the medication or the doctor's visits to keep it monitored. 

  

I guess maybe I am selfish also, but what I feel are anger and resentment.  Not because of his health condition, but because he only follows doctor's orders when it is convenient for him (and his mother).  

I too have a husband who is sick. My husband had his last major surgery on March 12, 2004 Nad my rollercoaster ride from hell began. The surgery went fine until the next morning he went into Renal failure....that was the first trip to intensive care. He stayed there for three days and got better (or so we thought). They moved him back to a regular room and said he would be in the hospital for a few more days.So I decided to go home and sleep in a real bed for the first time in over a week. I got up and took my children to school then proceeded to go to the hospital to visit him.When I got there they were rushing him back to ICU because his lungs had filled up with fluid and he had to be put on a ventilator.I was told that they couldn't explain why it happened because he was fine when I left the night before.So I  had the task of calling his family to let them know... but I couldn't really tell them anything because I didn't know anymore than they did. He was in ICU that time for over two weeks and we weren't sure if he was going to live or not.... then the doctor came out and told me if there was anyone else that needed to be there that I had better call them now. Not a great feeling. I didn't know what I was going to do, how was I going to tell my children that the man they consider their father was dying and probably wouldn't be here much longer,plus the fact that we had no money (because of his illness)so how was I going to pay for the expenses. Thankfully he survived we lost everything our trailer our car but at least he is alive. We struggle everyday and with the holidays fast approaching I'm at my witt's end trying to figure out how I can afford Christmas presents for my children.But I thank God every day that my husband lived. I don't resent him for getting sick.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
sad
October 26, 2005, 1:32 pm PDT

Hi Steve

Quote From: shamus55

Dr. Phil, 

     My name is Steve and I am just blown away by the comments made by the lady who was upset about the bills she and her husband had have to pay due to his transplant. I believe that if you aren't willing to do whatever it takes to keep the person you love with you, healthy and happy, you just don't know what the word "love" means. 

     This last March I lost my soul mate. His name was Tony and I would have died for him. Six months after we met he was diagnosed with A.I.D.S. and at that time I begged him to do whatever it took to give it to me so we would die together. Well, he loved me too much to do that, so I am still here...healthy. 

     We owned and antique store together and within a year we had to close it and liquidate the assets to pay bills. Within another year he was so sick that he couldn't take care of himself so I worked 40 hours a week at my job and and was with him every night, all night, and every weekend, all weekend, to care for him. This went on for nearly 10 years with no break of any sort...no vacations...no days off. 

     I came home one day to find Tony being taken away by a group from a nursing home. I was horrified to think that I wasn't doing a good enough job and became quite hysterical. Tony called my into the van and told me that he was doing this for me...he wanted me to be able to have a day off and some time to myself. It took me 3 hours to stop blubbering like and idiot and realize that he would get better care there by the professionals though I had to teach them allot about his care. He have 2 catheters,  a feeding tube and a lidacane drip for the pain, plus he was very atrophied in his left hand and foot due to Toxoplasmosis Encephalitis which hit him somewhat like a stroke. 

     I guess I have gone on way too long, but just wanted to let you know that we lost our business, our home (moved into an old mobile home where I still live) our S.U.V. was repossessed and I never once thought of complaining about taking care of him...NEVER CROSSED MY MIND! 

     You know what I do feel bad about?  I lost my soul mate! And now I am alone with no regrets of what I did when he got sick. 

Steve 

I read your passage-and I don't think you went on 'too long'. I have seen a documentary on a man dying of AIDS and it was horrific.I can't imagine what it must have been like for you.I'm sure your love would not want you to hurt like this.I hope in time you are able to able to celebrate his life with you. I hope you find condolence in the fact that he is no longer in agony.He really IS in a better place. You have my sympathy.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2005, 8:47 pm PDT

who am I?

If this is the way their relationship is, and it works for them who am I to judge them? My relationship isnt perfect and we may say things we dont mean or that may be harsh to some people but we love each other just like anyone else. You can't tell me that nobody says anything mean about their spouse at anytime and sometimes didnt mean it. As long as you know you love him/her and vise versa then what does it matter how disfunctional your marriage is. Look at the Osbornes. They are picture of disfunction (from what you see on tv). And they are just as much in love as you or I. I don't agree with the fact that the children are around when the comments are being said. It does influence their behavior and opinions of their parents and or future relationships and it shouldn't be done. And another thing, If my husband was sick I dont care how much money it would cost to save his life, without him and my children I am nothing. I wouldnt be whole. I would do anything I could, work any job and any hours to save his life. To put that blame on him when it wasnt his fault is harsh and maybe she shouldn't be married!!
 
First | Prev | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | Next | Last