Message Boards

Topic : 05/31 Falsely Accused

Number of Replies: 526
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 28, 2005, 02:16:37 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 11/2/2005) False accusations have ruined lives and divided families. No one knows this better than Terry. She claims she was falsely labeled as a gossip at her son, Steve's, rehearsal dinner and was escorted out of his wedding by security! Now, she confronts her son and daughter-in-law for the first time in almost five months. Can this family ever reconcile, or are they better off apart? Then, a former high school principal made headlines when a 16-year-old student accused him of having sex with her. The scandal rocked the town, and now he struggles to regain his reputation and move forward.  Share your thoughts here.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More May 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
November 2, 2005, 6:35 pm PST

you're right

Quote From: veterancop

 News flash...Among reported crimes, rape has the highest percentage of falseness.
http://www.anandaanswers.com/pages/naaFalse.html
In my jurisdiction the percentage of false reports is over 90%. The main reason this number is so high is because the false victims aren't prosecuted and exposed in the media. For those who think that practice would further discourage true rape victims from coming forward, you're wrong.
You are right most cases are false!! I also think it is one of the reasons true victims don't come forward. If the liars were prosecuted they would most likely think twice before telling their story, however the true victims might be more willing to come forward without having to fear what the public has to say. As there should be a punishment for the sex offenders there should also be punishment for the liars. I think the public is more into thinking "guilty until proven innocent" instead of "innocent until proven guilty "
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 6:36 pm PST

Struggles with teaching

I was saddened to hear Dr. Wilson's story.  I do believe him and I know how difficult it is to make changes in struggling innercity schools.  I spent one year teaching chemistry at an inner city high school.  Teaching is my passion and I left a high paying job to pursue my teaching dream.  While there, I spent a lot of time counseling students and I built good relationships with my students.  I was angered and deeply saddened when two of my students came to tell me that another female student was telling students that she and I had a relationship.  I barely even knew that student.  I immediately went to my administrators and they confronted the student.  She denied the allegations.  Later on I found out that many of my students had heard the rumors, some ignored it and others kind of believed it.  I was appalled.  I am married and at the time I was pregnant with my second child.  I am a Christian and I know I am an excellent role model.  That student's lies could have cost me my career and damaged the reputation that I spent my whole life building.  This incident made it easy for me to decide to be a stay-at-home mom.  I changed lives while teaching, but I believe that incidents like that of Dr. Wilson's will cause good teachers to shy away from the teaching field.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 6:41 pm PST

Charlotte-Mecklenburg Really needs You

Quote From: aroberts68

Come to Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools in NC. We can use all the help we can get! 

Dr. Wilson...please come to Charlotte-Mecklenburg.  Ours is a public school system that really needs a good principle like yourself in addition to the publicity since we are going through many issues in our system related to race, disciplina and scores.  Your book looks awesome (got it) and you would inspire many at-risk kids here to succeed!
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 6:47 pm PST

Dear Dr. Wilson

You are in my prayers, that would be an horrible, devastating thing to go through. I hope the visibility today will restore peoples' confidence in you. Thanks for your dedication with the children! God Bless
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
frustrated
November 2, 2005, 6:53 pm PST

I could not agree more

Quote From: rbngage

Mom had every right to be angry. 27 years of marriage down the drain. Sometimes the truth hurts.  Her ex had an affair and got his mistress pregnant. Why would the son even invite this homewrecker is beyond me. For the Aunt to repeat what was said is just as wrong. Why is all the blame on the mom? I for one do not believe what the daughter in law has to say. I think she is trying to put a wedge between her new husband and his mom. Maybe mom is a gossip. So what. To have her escorted out of the wedding was extreme.

I could not agree with your quote more.  I cannot believe no one addressed it from the angle that even if the Mom said EXACTLY what she supposedly said - who cares!  It may have been tacky, but big deal.  The truth isn't always pleasant. 

  

 

 

  

 

The mother has every right to be bitter at her cheating ex-husband and his mistress.  Her son should have asked his mother if it was ok with her if his Dad and his new wife/mistress attended the wedding!  It is because of Dad's lack of commitment to his own wedding vows (ironic since this all took place at a wedding!) that the mother was put in such an uncomfortable situation.

  

 

 

  

 

For a child to take sides with a parent who was clearly in the wrong is morally wrong, but then to kick out his Mother is horrible.  The daughter in law must have it out for her new husband's mother for whatever reason.  I am sure she is not perfect, but I would like to see how the son's new bride would act/feel if her new husband did such a thing to her!  They both need a lesson in compassion and loyalty. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 6:58 pm PST

Principal falsely accused

I was deeply saddened by this story. I unfortunately could relate. I am a teacher. 18 years ago in my first year teaching,  I was falsely accused of physical abuse. This student had no remorse and had done it to each teacher prior to me. Thank God our city police department knew of the prior situations and called each case ridiculousand saw a pattern. The case went to the DA's office and not only my job, but my career was on the line. Even though the charges were dropped, this situation has stayed with me all these years.  This student after all charges were dropped, came running up to me, hugged me (my arms went straight out as I did not want to be accuse of ever touching her)  and told me I was the best teacher she had ever had!  Luckily this incident occured on the playground with many witnesses. When I questioned her of why she had done what she did, she laughed it off and said it was a joke. (this student was in second grade at the time). No consequences were ever imposed on this student, but yet my hesitation to how I react to primary children running up to me and wanting hugs still bothers me. I want to return their hugs, but now I am very careful of how I react while trying to be sensitive to their feelings. Situations like this really affect you for the rest of your life. 

  

I felt so proud as an educator and as a human being when Dr. Phil called you up at the end of the show and stood by you. You are a true inspiration to all. Believe that God will see you through this situation. I am purchasing your book and telling others about it, so they too can purchase it. Thank you so much for sharing your story. I know it could not have been easy. You and your wife will be in my prayers. If possible, could you give Dr. Phil an update in the near future to let us know how you are doing? 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 7:01 pm PST

You missed the point

Quote From: benjyboy

 Idea #1 - Dr. Phil, the holidays are coming.  I have seen a real split in the responses to the Terry/Theresa wedding story.  Many of the respondents are convinced (as am I) that you should NOT have to include toxic relatives in family gatherings.  These charming individuals would certainly include drunks, junkies, child molesters, and outright crazy people, but ought also to include relatives who always have to be "the bride at every wedding and the corpse at every funeral."  Terry is a prime example of this type of family sore spot - she creates chaos so she can be the center of attention, then acts innocent and hurt when she's excluded as a consequence of her own behavior.  So, Dr. Phil - how about doing a show presenting some REAL ideas about how to deal with these walking nightmares during the holidays?  (I'm talking about concrete ideas like - don't let you car get blocked in the driveway, have an "escape code word" with your spouse, enlist sympathetic family members who will help you gather up your kids and turkey leftovers and slide out the door when Uncle Harry starts raving about the good ol' days when he was in the Klan...)  In  some families,  the "why can't we all just get along, because ol' Harry might die soon" plan doesn't work.  If the entire family can't agree to shun the toxic relatives, the rest of us need a plan to maintain sanity and avoid police intervention during the upcoming holiday season.  Cheers!.

Idea #2 - for Dr. Wilson and all other professionals who work with children - yes, it's a fact that kids will sometimes lie, and you really do have my sympathy for the nightmare this has caused you.  It's also a fact that thousands of kids really ARE molested and grownups have to give them the benefit of the doubt while investigating their allegations.  So what can we adults do when working with kids, either professionally or as volunteers in our community?  Well, the Boy Scouts have a great rule - it's called "Two Deep Leadership" - meaning that no one-on-one adult/boy contact is EVER, EVER allowed.  Either a group of boys, or more than one adult, is always required.  This is so simple, but it precludes so many problems.   Now, obviously, Dr. Wilson can't be accompanied at all times when patrolling the hallways - but he and anyone else who deals with kids can certainly think about ways to protect their own reputations.  So how about a show on this topic?  Maybe student conferences should only be held in public, or in rooms with a window opening into another occupied office, or in offices with video monitors.  I know our elementary band director gives private music lessons, but always has the classroom door open to a busy hallway.  Adults who work with kids deserve our thanks and our trust - and they should be entitled to a measure of self-protection.  It would be better for the kids, too, since one-on-one "alone time" with an adult is a prerequisite for molestation.  So, Dr. Phil, what's the current state of thinking on this topic?  Maybe education professors are covering this in college - the rest of us band parents, youth group leaders, and room mothers would benefit from their ideas.
Her gossip, for lack of a better word. Was due to what had happened in her marriage. Why would you even label her toxic. She was cheated on after 27 years of  marriage. Why would the son accept that kind of behavior from his father. But instead condemn his mom for talking about it? She had every right to be angry.
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
hopeful
November 2, 2005, 7:01 pm PST

Yes yes yes!

Quote From: kday01

How in the world did Dr. Phil go though this entire interview and not get the to the fact that this was not gossip!!!!!!!!!  Dad WAS unable to keep his _______ in this pants!  He cheated on his wife, destroyed his family, and shamefully got some hussy pregnant!!!!  I was raised that it should be the cheating, family-crushing dog-of-a-father that should not have been at that wedding!!  Did that son not put two and two together and figure out that he invited his father, the one who just TOTALLY betrayed his OWN vows, to come be a witness to his own vow taking?  What kind of hypocrisy is that?  What is wrong with that son?   

  

Did mom say those things about dad?  Probably.  So when did telling the truth become a bad thing????  She was not speaking of someone else.  This was HER marriage, HER husband.  Dr. Phil, you need to listen to a little more Dr. Laura.  Where is the protection of the innocent? 

  

     

I replied to an earlier comment you made, almost exactly the same points - good call.  I was thinking the SAME thing about Dr. Laura!! 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 7:06 pm PST

Sympathy for Terry

I feel sympathy for Terry. The poor woman is in a lot of pain! Bravo to her other son for standing up for her! 

  

Just shy of our 25th anniversary, my husband decided to "call it quits and go our separate ways" (as if we were only going steady or dating!) I asked if there was someone else and he lied (that came really easy for him) and said no. I found out a little later that he had been seeing another woman his own age for about 13 years. After we separated, he started "dating" her, introducing her to our teenage daughter and his son, from his previous marriage, as his new girlfriend.  

  

I met him while I was working as a waitress to put myself through college. I was a very young 21 year old innocent, who never dated or had a boyfriend, partly because I was shy, but mostly because I only wanted a career. (Not because I didn't look good: petite 5'2", 105 lbs, long blonde hair, green eyes, nice teeth....more than just my mom told me I was beautiful). I was a talented artist. He was 5 years older, a divorced cop and father to a 5 year old son. He relentlessly pursued me for months (didn't realize at the time but it is called "stalking" nowadays) until I finally dated him. He was very generous and loving to me, saying the nicest things about how he would love me forever and ever, and all that. I told him I didn't want to get married, but somehow we ended up getting married. 

  

After our marriage, he changed jobs and made a great salary,  I couldn't find a job in my chosen field (art/graphic design),  which he didn't seem to mind that much since he was afraid some guy would steal me away. He was very controlling and posessive. He made Scrooge look like a spendthrift. But only I was witness to his miserly ways. He kept telling me he had to save money for our old age. I would get upset when we would go out to dinner with people and he would try to pick up the check, but at home he wouldn't give me 5 bucks.  

After marriage, I noticed he didn't seem to like his mom. Found out later she was a tramp (to put it nicely) who was a rotten mom. His parents divorced when he was 8. He didn't seem to know what her birthdate was. So I asked her, and every year I would remind him to wish his mom happy birthday. (Funny, years later, she bragged how he always remembered her birthday.)  

When his dad was dying of cancer, I took his dad into our home and took care of him. His dad left him a lot of money. He was still miserly to me. 

  

After I had our daughter, our marriage really took a nose dive. He started to bug me to get a job. I did some freelance art work. When my daughter started school, I took a menial job which was all I could get because I hadn't worked outside the home since college. I was paying for my own car, expenses, clothes etc. 

  

 When his mom had a heart attack, she asked my husband to take care of her finances. He found out how much money she had and then he played the dutiful son. He would visit her a lot, got power of attorney....She used to annoy my mom and friends with her comments about how I had it so good and her son was such a 'good provider'. She would point out how I had all these things. (Well, I bought them with my money.) When she got cancer, I helped take care of her for a short while before she had to go to a nursing home. She died and he got a lot of money. About 10 months later, he left to be with his longtime girlfriend.  

After he left, he started to call our daughter every day and buy her things and take her out to eat. I thought it was about time. It looks like he didn't know how to be a father, but knows how to be a divorced father. 

  

The divorce took 2 years and it was costly, horrible and stressful. He had all the money he stashed over the 25 years (money he saved because of me), plus his inheritances, but made it look to the Court like he was poor....He filed petitions about trivial nonsense, had his lawyer keep sending my lawyer letters....anything he could think of to cost me money (lawyers charge for every single phone call, reading and sending letters etc.) We only had communication through the lawyers. I don't ever want to see him again. My daughter is a Sophomore in college and is on the Dean's List. She is beautiful and an extremely brilliant, talented writer. So far, she has never had a boyfriend....she is focused on having a career. 

She now has a good relationship with her father. She thinks I should just forget all about the past and gets upset when I even mention her father. It is difficult to erase more than half your life. I'm trying. It takes time. If my daughter gets married, I would not disrupt her wedding, but if someone asks me why her dad and I don't talk to each other, I may tell them. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 2, 2005, 7:12 pm PST

11/02 Falsely Accused

Dear Dr. and Mrs. Wilson: 

I am a huge fan of Dr. Phil and have never been compelled to respond to any show. Your story is not the first one Dr. Phil has aired regarding injustices. I am truly sorry for your family's humiliation.  

The reason I decided to respond is actually selfish.  

I would love to have you, and your wife, become educators in the Duval County Public School system. I could write for hours, but would much rather speak to either of you on the phone, or in person. I am the mother of three boys and I just believed in you and your abilities immediately. I think that Jacksonville is capable; we just don't have the fortitude I saw in you and Mrs. Wilson on the show.  

Even if you don't contact me, I will pray for God's blessings for you both. Please don't stop being educators.  

Sincerely, 

Barbara McM.

 
First | Prev | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | Next | Last