Topic : 08/25 Extreme Food Obsessions

Number of Replies: 372
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 28, 2005, 02:17:57 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 11/03/05) What if you were so obsessed with eating that it almost killed you, or craving food so badly that you yelled, kicked and screamed when you couldn't get enough. Nichelle's 6-year-old daughter has Prader-Willi Syndrome and constantly wants to eat. She once threw a fit so loud, the neighbors called the police. Can Nichelle learn to control her own temper when her daughter has a tantrum? Then, Dr. Phil follows up with Kathy, an anorexic whose condition was so severe, she weighed only 68 pounds. She spent three months in treatment, but her struggle is not over yet. Can her family learn the difference between supporting her and enabling her? Talk about the show here.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More August 2006 Show Boards.



User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
November 3, 2005, 6:24 pm PST

Nichelle.

Quote From: kellebelle

Nichelle,

I admire your bravery to publicly open your home life and the struggles that you have dealt with. You were open to change, asking for a new way to deal with the issues that I know you understand are not Savannah's fault.

I think what most people want for you is support for you to learn how to create a structure for your family. That structure gives Savannah comfort and help to learn that there is an order to the day as well as other priorities that have to be incorporated into the day. This structuregives your other child the chance to see that family life has a routine that is normal and creates safe boundaries, and gives you relief in knowing that Savannah is learning the routine, your other child is comfortable in the family stability, and that you can take any challenge in the day and refer back to the routine.

Having worked with street youth dealing with recovery from addiction, and no structure in how to live on a daily basis, I acknowledge that developing the routine and introducing it to an individual - regardless of age, mental developmental level, or other barriers to learning - is the most difficult challenge in starting to gain control and stability in a family. However, the routine is crucial for assisting people who are dealing with behaviour-control issues because the structure is safety. Another key point to making the routine work is posting it in a main area of the house, usually in the kitchen. Use picture magnets, coloured markers, and symbols if that's easier for everyoneto recognize and understand.

This isn't something specific for PWS kids or kids in addiction recovery, this is something thatis often recommended for every family.My friends use it with their kids showing the daily schedule for going to school, after-school activities, family chores, mealtimes, learning self-care (e.g. brushing teeth and bathing), and bedtime. They see the routine, they recognize it, and it becomes part of everyday life, which is the ultimate goal.

It will be difficult, but I think you have lived through the worst part of it, and are ready to find better tools to help your children become amazing people. There have been some great supportive messages from other people who have worked with or who have children with PWS, and I hope that you're able to find the resources that are available to you.You have beautiful kids, I know you love them, and I believe that when we have better tools, we do great things.

I think you can do great things.

Kelle

Nichelle. I heard about your eating disorder like I said to Doctor Phil and Kathy that there is lots of peoples out there who have ezating disorder aswell. Good luck and do what Doctor Phil said.----- 

Friend Your. Russell

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 6:27 pm PST

11/03 Extreme Food Obsessions

Quote From: yarles

perhaps all you people who critizised nichelle should be put in her shoes for a while.nichelle is suffering from burnout.atleast she asked for help and admitted that she was not managing to deal properly with her child.as for dr.phil yelling at her on stage about her conduct,maybe he should try being in her shoes as well.it's not easy.i feel for her.she needs help with the child and some time out from for both their sakes.
 While I agree with you commending Nichelle for reaching out for help, and I agree that she is burnt out, she is still abusing Savannah.  Dr. Phil raised his voice to Nichelle to get her to realize that she is abusing a child who cannot control her own actions.  She needed a wake-up call, and that is exactly what he gave her.  I agree this woman needs serious help, and I know that Dr. Phil will get her that help.  But I don't think for one second that he was overreacting to a woman who beats her child and calls her names.  Nichelle needs a new support system, and perhaps a week away to get her mind around the situation, so that she can approach her daughter with love and understanding, rather than frustration and anger.  I feel for her, too, but she deserved the talking to.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 6:29 pm PST

Could your daughter have it?

Quote From: wiseant

 Today, after watching the Dr. Phil show, was the first time I had ever heard of PWS.   I started to wonder if it was possible that my 13 year old daughter could have this disease because she seems to have an obsession with food and would eat constantly if I did not limit her.  She is overweight and nothing seems to deter her desire to eat.  I have had her tested to see if she had a thyroid problem, something I have, and was told that she was fine.  The difference in her behavior compared to the children on the show is that she doesn't become quite so angry  and upset when she is denied food so I'm wondering is there a degree of severity?  In other words, could someone, say, have a trace and is this something that developes over time or do the symptoms present themselves early in a child's life?  I hope this isn't a silly question but I'm  so worried about my daughter.   She is close to 200 lbs.  We have a membership at a gym, she plays sports but is not very active otherwise.  Also, she doesn't have any of the developmental issues the children on the show have.  That's why I'm asking if it's possible there could be a trace of the disorder without it being full blown.   Any comments will be appreciated.
 It's possible, but doubtful.  I say this because if your daughter had PWS, she would exhibit some of the other 'symptoms' that were not even mentioned or were glossed over in this show.  For example, at birth she would have been 'floppy' and gotten 0 apgars for muscle tone. It would have been difficult to impossible to get her to eat as a baby.  She would not have been able to walk most likely til the age of at least 2.  ANd that's just the muscle tone issue.  There's lots more.  But there are degrees of severity to anything, including PWS.  And I do know a woman who was not diagnosed until she was 16.   So if you still think it's possible, ask your doctor to give your daughter a blood test and make sure he/she gives the "methylation" type test for PWS.  If they give the "FiSH" test, the chance to miss the diagnosis is 30%.  I speak from experience.
Good luck.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
worried
November 3, 2005, 6:31 pm PST

Eating 12 times a day.

Quote From: jalyn4wilh

Also,  

I agree with the people who say stop buying junk food.  Sometimes genetic disease are made worse by the environment. You should be reading up on what food research has shown alleviate PW Syndrome.  I thought I heard something from another parent about not eating any dairy products or maybe it was only dairy products.  Reward your daughter by feeding her.  My professional advice is that she always have a cold bottle of water (so she feels full) or milk and a box of a dozen popsicles a day is not going to hurt her.  Tell her she can have unsalted homemade potatoe cubes but  ask her if she first will drink a full cup of kool-aid and then ask her if she wants another, before she can have the potatoes.  Something where you used healthy foods to reward her.  Plan ahead that you will have to feed her veggies and sandwich halves 12 times a day.  

  

I'll go to the university library and research you conditions myself..It may take a week, but I will post my finding. 

  

Please feel free to add me to you mailing list, and contact me some time.  Your path is right up my alley. 

  

Jaclyn

 

Jaclyn, 

 

You are so misinformed. You need to do your research before you give professional advice.   Your alley sounds like it might be the back alley. 

 

My son Jeremy had Prader Willi. He passed away just after his 17th birthday.  He was a medically very well managed child with PWS. We did this by limiting his food intake, 1100 calories a day, as well as treating him with Growth Hormone, as prescribed by his doctor.  He was 5ft 6in and 135 when he died.  If we had not properly managed his eating and behavior I am sure he would have been well over two hundred pounds and had many more medical problems than just PWS.  He died when his stomach ruptured after sneaking food and the complications that followed.    

 

There any many good doctors that specialize in Prader Willi, Dr. Dan Driscoll at the Univeristy of Florida Shands Hospital is probally the foremost Genetic expert in the US.   

 

I suggest that people go to the National Prader WIlli Syndrome web site www.pwsusa.org  to get the facts rather than rely on the postings of some on this message board that my or may not be as qualified as they suggest. 

 

Pete 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 6:33 pm PST

Walk A Mile In My Shoes

My son does not  have PWS, but he has epilepsy.  I was appalled at Nichelle's treatment of her child. I would never  physically hurt or emotionally hurt my son, but they sure make you feel like 

it sometimes. My son is 19,  has seizures 2-3 times a month. It hurts me to the core to think he 

may never be able to drive or get married. At the same time, he will not do what he is told, does 

not want to do much work, and argues with me in public. He has not done well in school, but 

you ought to see him with a Gameboy. They will play you. It is hard to tell where his illness ends 

and his manipulation begins.  I love him to death and would give my life for him, but sometimes 

they can make you soooooo mad.  

  

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 6:39 pm PST

11/03 Extreme Food Obsessions

Quote From: tsateresa

i grew up an over wieght child.. my father called me fat he told me i was ugly for being fat. i was also picked on by my brother and cousins. they didnt really bother me, but my fahter saying those things to me did. The line " i only say it to help her" is WRONG!!!! it dont help u out it pushes ur self esteem down lower. because of being treated that way by my family i have problems with my mairrage now. i also had lost alot of weight in my teen years and as soon as i felt guys wanted me i went on a binge of sleeping with anyone i could, just to make my self feel better. but i am alos a mother now of a 2yr old, and she is very bad.. she hits me she screams in public if i dont let he have her way.. the list goes on. so i know its hard to have a child that acts up, but if ur saying things of the nature this mother is.. u need to have ur daughter stay with a friend or family member for the weekend and enroll urself in anger managment calles... seriously..or ur gonna loose ur daughter, not only phycically but emionialy too. she will grow up and not forgive u for being so abusive. 

Teresa 

just because my child is not disabled does not mean i dont understand her pain.. but her child being special does NOT excuse her behavior. as far as the disorder tell her she is fat isnt gonna change her disorder.. its along the same lines as telling a smoker they stink or the addiction is making them look unhealthy..addiction is considered a form of disorder and telling them those things wont help. they only thing that will help is to talk with a professional about what can be done to help ease the problem. and im very glad that she is getting help with her outrages. and just because some 1 dont know how to control an emotion does not make them a bad mother. i have issues with my emotions also.. i wish the best of luck with them.. 

  

Teresa 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
hopeful
November 3, 2005, 6:44 pm PST

PWS sibling...

I felt it necessary to educate a little more on PWS.  My older brother Jon has Prader-Willi Syndrome.  He is 37 years old and living in his own apartment, almost independently.  I say almost because I am paid by the state to do all of his meal preparation and unlock his food at mealtimes.  He is very  much a rarity in the Prader-Willi community because of his ability to live "independently".  He goes to a work program 4 times a week that caters to other people with  Prader-Willi.  We are very proud of Jon's accomplishments and it hasn't always been easy.   Adolescence is very difficult and the rages I witnessed as a small child were horrible.  Watching Dr. Phil today was a very emotional experience and sometimes hit waaaay to close to home for me.  As a sibling I think my perspective is different than that of a parent but I did want people to know that Prader-Willi people can be successful at certain things.  There is hope and happiness for families of Prader-Willi people.  I was so glad to see this syndrome being given some attention...jesland 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
angry
November 3, 2005, 6:45 pm PST

PWS Show

I do not have a child with PWS and I have no idea how it is to live with someone with PWS 24/7. 

  

I do though have experience with PWS in the educational setting.  I have taught several children with PWS and they are the most loving children.  The mother of the first child I taught with PWS was a lot like the mother on the Dr. Phil show.  The mother yelled and was verbally abusive.  The mother refused help from the public school system and she manipulated social services and CPS in such a way that that family members and the parent never got help. 

  

This little boy came to me angry, frustrated and just not a happy boy.   With structure, reasonable expectations and shown love he was able to be successful in the classroom setting.  He was mentally retarded and had a severe speech and behavioral delay, but he was able to make friends and participated in all of the classroom activities with appropriate modifications made.   

  

I was alarmed by the mother on the show.  Everything she said was negative and she was extremely verbally and physically abusive.   I fear for this little girls safety and well being.  Like I said earlier this mother on the Dr. Phil show reminded me of the mother of the first child I taught with PWS.  This child that I had taught has since passed away.  There were indicators of foul play, but we cannot bring this sweet boy back! 

  

Please give this mother the assistance she needs and make her realize that although her daughter is mentally challenged that does not make her daughter bad or purposely mean.  This little girl needs a special school with specialists that can help the family and specifically the mother.  The mother needs to stop the abuse and accept here daughter. 

  

The outside world is  hard place.  If your mother isn't going to be in your corner and protect you then who is?  This mother needs to learn to love her child! 

  

Thank you for letting me vent! 

  

  

 
User Mood
Scared

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 6:47 pm PST

hello!?

Quote From: mbsmmt

I am sitting here watching the story about the woman with anorexia getting more and more annoyed. I know the woman on TV today acknowledged that she needed help and kudos to her for admitting it and trying to get better. I just wonder how putting her story on TV hurts others with the problem...they may think "she lived that was for 16 years so what is the problem?".   

  

My Aunt is 50 years old and has been somehow living with anorexia for over 30 years...she has so many physical problems yet she thinks that the rest of the world is at fault not her. She eats nothing with any nutritional value...she is the most selfish person I have ever met. My mother and my grandmother (before she died) tried to get her into treatment. Her Doctor is an enabler...he has helped her stay this way. He has not even diagnosed her because she doesn't want to hear it...she won't go to any other doctor because they all call her on her eating disorder.  I think her doctor should be sued for malpractice or maybe arrested for assisted suicide after she dies. My other Aunt bends over backwards to try to help her and she just uses her...it is pathetic. The anorexic one will allow the other to do so much for her that she becomes physically ill and does not take care of herself because she is so focused on the anorexic one.  I have suggested that they commit her...have talked to my therapist about whether or not that could be done...but my grandfather (the only one who could do it) doesn't think she has a problem. He even brags that she is eating better then ever and gaining weight...complete denial! She acts like she is some super great Christian but as far as I am concerned she is a horrible Christian...last time I checked suicide was not among the Christian teachings. She manipulates our family and has contributed to the demise of the family unit that I used to love being a part of.  She has ruined everything...God forbid anyone upset her!  I can't even stand the thought of family gatherings with that side of the family and I used to love them.  

  

I am glad that Kathy got help...but she has been every bit as selfish as my aunt. I hope she realizes the hurt she has caused her family and now will work extra hard to show them appreciation and love. It is so hard to be a family member of someone with this problem...it poisons every part of the relationship and the family! 

Anorexia is a disorder...a disease, not something that someone just decides to have.  Sure, it can start with a person wanting to lose weight, but it doesn't progress to someone being that thin without other issues.  I do not think Kathy is selfish- what a terrible thing to say.  If I were you, I would start focusing on how to help your aunt or other relatives instead of focusing on the aggravation she is causing you; to me, that is selfish.  I mean, just how is Kathy or your aunt selfish? Do you think your aunt is selfish because she wants attention? SHE NEEDS ATTENTION! When I weighed 70 pounds it was because I was so upset with myself.  And, do you know what keeps/kept me going, instead of killing myself flat out? God. My faith in God, that He had a plan for me, and Jesus, that His dying really did atone for my sins.  What I tend to doubt, though, is that I really am sorry for being human and sinning.  Everyone has trials, no one is perfect, and anorexia is a mental disorder. Think about what your flaws are, then think about having a mental disorder that made these flaws harder to overcome....would you be selfish for having a harder time dealing with your problems and having them show physically than someone else whose problems were masked?  Honestly, I feel that you may need to stop harboring such ill wishes toward you aunt.  Furthermore, why do you call her a horrible Christian? Making presumptions towards others' relationship with God certainly is not the best thing to do. Please, I am not trying to be rude, but you seem to very angry, and it is not helping you or her. 

 
User Mood
Scared

Message Emote
blank
November 3, 2005, 6:53 pm PST

agreed

Quote From: recovery99

I was so relieved to read your post. I love watching the Dr. phil show, but....I just left my second treatment center that I have been in this year. Anorexia is so glorified on TV...seeing the bones is a huge trigger for me. It seems like TV shows flash pictures of the worst cases on TV and quote weights up and down. here is my thought.....if you wouldn't ask or post the weights of "normal" people (because it is considered RUDE), why in the world would anyone post and talk about the weight of a person who is obviously more sensitive about it than the average population? I feel pulled to watch the show, but am scared to death of being triggered into relapse. I am already holding on for my life as it is....I wish that someone would do a show about anorexia and bulemia without focusing on pictures of people at their sickest.  The public already seems to think that eating disorders are about food. Dr. Phil says that you can't fix money problems with money. I say you can't fix anorexia with food. If only he could say that.... 

  

On a better note, the author of Life Without Ed will be on the show, and that is the best book I've ever read about eating disorders. It's as if the author has climbed into my head and written all of my thoughts on paper.  

Yes, people that do not have anorexia really a lot of times do not understand how we become triggered hearing about or seeing someone at a really low weight.  I've never read Life Without ED, but I will try to do so.  I am trying to lose weight now. I know it's not for the 'best,' but I feel so lost without it.  Plus, my pants are tight and no sense having to buy new ones when I'd be happier skinnier, right? 

  

I hope that all of us wouldn't feel the need for this in our lives. It's just something to focus on and be in control over. I am so scared of growing up. I am 20, and I just cannot imagine growing old, alone, and........I'm going to cry. I love God, but I hate myself- what an ironic situation. 

 

First | Prev | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | Next | Last