Message Boards

Topic : 08/17 Dr. Phil's Road Show: Newlywed Challenge

Number of Replies: 100
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 04, 2005, 02:39:20 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard3

(Original Air Date: 11/07/05) Dr. Phil takes his show on the road! Newlyweds already on the brink of divorce compete in a series of challenges to see if they have what it takes to work together in less-than-perfect situations. Can the couples find their way around an unfamiliar city with the men driving and the women navigating? How do the men do when they are in charge of their wives' makeovers? They've cheated on each other, have explosive fights and you wouldn't believe the names they call each other. Will their relationships survive the competition? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More August 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
August 17, 2006, 2:41 pm PDT

Make a plan

Quote From: pickle427

I am in my 2nd marriage and only been married for 2 1/2 years.  I am 44 and my husband is 33.  We seem to get along great for a few days and then the s*** hits the fan.  It seems like when we don't agree it's world war 3.  He calls me names (something he learned in his first marriage) and then he tells me "If you don't like it here, get the f*** out!"  I feel disposable!  I do EVERYTHING for him... from taking total care of his children.... taking them to and from school, to taking them to their activities, checkign their homework, doing ALL the cooking, cleaning, laundry, yardwork, grocery shopping, errands, taking care of him, packing his lunch, preparing his plate...etc.  He goes to work, and that's it.  I am not working right now, but I do go to school.  When I tell him how I feel about something, if it's not how he wants me to feel about the subject the fight starts.  He has never actually cheated on me, but has gotten on the internet and put a fake profile on there to look at porn.  I caught him and he lied about it, then confessed.  He says he has not done it sense then, but who knows.  Everything we do is about him, his children, his family, his wants... heck we have sex when he wants to!  I almost have to beg when I want it...   He thinks I am being overly dramiatic and blowing things out of proportion.  Lat night for instance, he won a trophy and wanted to put it front and center on our fireplace mantle.  We already had something there, so I said we could put it on the left side of the mantle.  He got mad and threw a fit and put the trophy on his son's dresser and said obviously his trophy doesn't mean as much as my stupid pictures (which by the way, are family pictures).  He also wanted to put his plaque (a winning plaque) on the wall above the mantle, which has a family picture of our wedding, so I took the family picture down, put it where the plaque was hanging, on another wall, put the plaque up, put his trophy on the mantle and moved the family picture off the mantle.  He told me I was a selfish a**-hole and if he gets more trophies he is putting them there and if I don't like it, I can get the fu** out!  It seems like he makes all the rules and I have to like them, live with them, not say anything or get out!  Any suggestions????? Is this a doomed marriage too??????? HELP DR. PHIL AND VIEWERS......       Pickle427

Pickle Honey,  People don't change unless they want to and he doesn't want to.  Make a plan.  Stay in school. Take courses that will teach you to make a good living. Study hard and set a deadline and stick to it.  Don't get pregnant.  Stash away money in a safe place.  Don't sweat the small stuff.  Don't lower yourself to his level arguing over pictures and trophies.  Just look the other  way and remember when he throws his fits that it won't be forever and that you have a plan.  When you have your degree or certificate start looking for a job and as soon as you have a good job pack up and leave. You will be surprised how much you can achieve when you can see a light at the end of the tunnel.  You will be surprised how good you will feel when you do well in school and know it is leading to freedom from the degrading names and treatment.  He is a looser and he knows it, and the only way he can deal with it is to make you a looser too.  Don't let him. Don't loose hope.  Make a plan!

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
August 17, 2006, 3:13 pm PDT

Doctor Phil Show.

Challenge Doctor Newly Phil Road Show Wed. I didnot know all about this. Tell me some more about it. See you tomorrow Afternoon. Well I had better close now. Sincerley Your. Russell Vlaa-

nderen.-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
August 17, 2006, 3:42 pm PDT

Great Show and Topic

Dr. Phil and Show Producers and Etc:

 

This is a GREAT show and topic. I can relate to the show and have many friends who can too, although not necessarily newlyweds. I appreciate shows like this that have wide appeal and  discuss real world situations, addresses tough issues, and appreciate Dr. Phil's genuine concern in making life better for those with this type of need. Wonderful, helpful, relevant!!

 

Thank you,

'liketheshow'

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
August 17, 2006, 3:48 pm PDT

i missed this show the first time it aired

from what i saw on part 1 today it looks like matt and lindy missed a chance to create some relly good memories of a trip that could have relly been fun for them,wow they got a chance to go to calf and do things other people could only dream of doing, and all they could do was call each other ugly names, and i do not know what that was on the plate they were cooking  lol i relly dont think a hog would have eaten it, wow guys you relly missed a good chance to have fun, what a life of heart ache it looks like you two are headed for,glad im not walking in your shoues.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
quiet
August 17, 2006, 4:10 pm PDT

Been there, Done that

I can relate to the couple that couldn't get anything right.  I  went through that kind of relationship

for 23 years before I called it quits.  Back then they didn't have the help they do now like  Dr. Phil

and the help you can get now for relationships that are almost destroyed.  I would say that the couple that won the games,  do stand a chance at recovering their marriage.  I will say that I tried to keep mine together to the very end, but it was all one-sided , and thats no way to have a realtionship.  I do hope that all three couples will recieve the help they need, and not break up. It is

better to be single then to be in those kinds of realtionships.  I just wanted to comment on the show, because it hit home with me.  .

 

 
User Mood
Touched

Message Emote
blank
August 17, 2006, 4:21 pm PDT

How are they married?

As I sat watching todays show I found myself repeatedly asking how these couples are married.  The more I watched the more I was amazed at the names they call one another and the overall way that they treated eachother.  If my husband and myself were to be put into certain high-stress situations as the couples on the show I can see us arguing, but we always turn it around and it never lasts more than a few moments.  If we were to ever call eachother by the awful names the couples did today we wouldboth be so hurt.  My husband  is an awful driver and I tell him when I feel he gets too close to a curb or is fiddling with the radio, and he sometimes will sigh but he changes his driving and or apologizes.  He hates the way I cook, and I try so hard; but hate the way it turns out every time.....and when I would just never cook again, he`always tells me to practice and it will improve, and it does.  I have never felt so lucky to have the relationship I have with my husband until after todays show.  We have been married 6 years and had an awesome relationship up until this time last year. I had a job at a brewery and I worked late nights, escaping my full-time mothering job of our 5 year old and I felt free. He never asked where i was when I came home later than my scheduled shift and I started  not asking how his day was, or even how our daughter had behaved the night before. We had shut down and become numb to eachother.  I became to feel as if I had lost my connection with our daughter who now always wantedher dad; I resented him because I was working. We went to counuciling one time and it opened the door for communication even up to now. We have promised to always speak freely but sweetly.  My idea for all of you at the Dr. Phil show is to add couples who love eachother and get along, in situations like those of todays episode......chances are it is all going to fall apart for them as well.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
August 17, 2006, 4:30 pm PDT

Newlyweds

This show certainly gives us married couples alot to think about.  I also am a newly wed, but of only 10 months now.  I am in my second marriage, and my husband and I compliment each other perfectly.  Watching this show I imagined us in the same circumstances, and we actually work in all the mentioned areas quite well.  He openly admits that he doesn't know his way to new places, so he easily allows me to navigate; and I must say that I know how to read a map and do quite well at it.  We usually do not grocery shop together but when we do, he makes suggestions that I may not have thought about and they are usually good ones.  In the kitchen we are a great team - as he was a confirmed bachelor before we got married he knows his way around our kitchen and we each take a task that will complete our goal and it works well for us.  We do not argue over money or anything else, we sometimes disagree on things, but somehow we have a wonderful communication skills and we are always open to hear each other and work out a solution.  We don't always agree on everything but we can at least come to a mutually acceptable decision.  I'm not real sure how well he would do shopping for me, but I would definetly trust his makeover decisions and wouldn't worry about them. 

The show was quite entertaining and I believe that these couples will watch it later and laugh at some of the things they did while attempting the challenges you put them through, and I certainly hope that they can learn to work better with each other and to communicate in a respectful and meaningful way to stregthen their marriages.  We all come into our relationships with some sort of "baggage" but the important part is that we made the committment and are willing to abide by the vows that we took, and I wish them all the best of luck!!

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
August 17, 2006, 5:16 pm PDT

I though I was on Dr Phil

Boy todays show, showed me that they really are people out there like my husband and me.What I really wanted to find out was how do you be a hero? To stop the battle ,not the marriage?
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
August 17, 2006, 5:58 pm PDT

57% divorce rate. Very sad.

Too many people marry these days because they think they'll be happy (or happier) if married. That's exactly why there's a 57% divorce rate in this country.

 

Many couples wouldn't know the word love, honor, commitment and respect if the words bit them in the butt!

 

The first two years of marriage for us weren't fun (I didn't have the word "Compromise" in my independent vocabulary and my husband had always lived with his folks). The third year was tolerable. During that year I wasn't happy and hubby was clueless. I almost had an affair with a police officer friend; at most, I did have an emotional affair with him. I told hubby how close I came to leaving him for this supposed friend and we decided there and then to sit for hours and decide what WE needed to do to make our marriage work. We both didn't believe in divorce and we knew marriage wasn't supposed to be easy....anytime something involves two humans, it's not going to be easy much of the time.

 

That night of talking and crying and asking what eachother needed to be happy changed everything. Hubby gave up the remote and the recliner and the computer (for the most part). We spent time together on the couch watching t.v. together, we played sports together, we made "date nights" and we BOTH compromised on the big stuff. We COMMUNICATED!

 

That was many years ago (we've been married almost 17 years) and each year our marriage gets better (it's been SUPER for over a decade!). We treat eachother with respect and would NEVER EVER call the other person mean names. We don't insult eachother and we don't let things fester; we communicate and spend time together...quality time.

 

Marriage is a lifelong committment and a promise made before God. It has its ups and downs and when two mature, responsible people put the other person's needs first, marriage can and will be WONDERFUL.. We are now a family of 4 and life is GREAT. I know that I have someone to support me thru the tough times and someone to cheer for me (and beside me) during the good times.

 

People need to stay single IF and UNTIL they can be unselfish, giving, humble and willing to compromise for the good of the marital union. God is not very happy these days with us Americans when it comes to committment!!!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
August 17, 2006, 6:10 pm PDT

SIT DOWN AND TALK!!!

Quote From: tonyroberts

Lisa and I were married on New Year's eve day, we've been friends for 23 years.  We love eachother very much, and you couldn't ask for anything better, when it's good.  We have overcome many issues since we have been married, but the one issue we cannot work out is, she has two children one son who just turned 16 and one daughter who will soon be 13, I have a son who just turned 15.  We both get so really mad when one says anything about the other's child, and we get very defensive.  And when one child is brought up the other's parent always throws up the other's child.  We have been fighting for this is the 3rd day, over something that I shouldn't have done.  We were arguing and I got so mad that I told her that I'll take care of my son and she can take care of her children.  This was said in anger, and I have talk and appologized but she really was hurt by that comment.   Can anyone help with this? 

 

thanks in advance

tony

Geesh, you have TEENAGERS. They're enough to drive any good parent crazy, even if they're not a part of a mixed family!!!

 

You two need a game plan. You need to sit down, hold hands, promise not to raise your voices, promise not to accuse and DO tell the other what YOU need from him/her. Kids will play parents against eachother if allowed to (even the GREAT kids), and these kids probably know what buttons to push. They can make you feel guilty easily and quickly turn each of you against the other.

 

You are now a family unit with teenagers. You've really been a family for 23 years considering you have maintained a friendship that long (that's a very good thing). When you think about all that you've shared over the years, I am quite sure neither of you wants to hurt the other's feelings. APOLOGIZE for what you said and ask your lovely wife to sit down with you to come up with a game plan for dealing with the kids. There has got to be a plan for dealing with all the added stress (and all those TEENAGERS can cause stress:).

 

The kids are now YOUR kids (both of yours). There should not be mine and hers. Unless the two of you work TOGETHER as a team (as one, as the Bible teaches us), you will continue to have problems. Find out what your wife needs from you with regard to dealing with the kids. Then tell her what you need. DON'T tell her what she's been doing wrong (and vice versa). DO come up with a plan on how to make the family unit stronger and healthier and DO make a promise to try your best NEVER EVER to say what was said (that was so hurtful to her).

 

If you've been friends for over 2 decades, you CAN make the marriage work and you CAN make the kids come together as OURS (as opposed to mine and yours). I just know you'll make this work; you sound like a genuine, caring spouse (and one who can admit his mistakes). God bless you both.....ALL (even those dang teenagers...can you tell I am a former high school teacher whose hair has started turning gray due to them?:)

 
First | Prev | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Next | Last