Message Boards

Topic : 11/22 "Yours, Mine & Ours"

Number of Replies: 174
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 18, 2005, 03:40:19 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

Falling in love is easy. Falling in love with your new spouse's kids is not so easy. Actor Dennis Quaid, co-star of the new movie "Yours, Mine & Ours," joins Dr. Phil. He talks about how being a dad helped him prepare for his role as a man dealing with the difficulties of blending a family. Then, Juli says her stepdaughter, Samantha, makes her feel like the other woman. Her husband, Mark, says that Samantha is his best friend. Will Juli's jealousy tear their new family apart? Then, they have two dogs, two cats, four fish and six kids. Meet two parents blending their chaotic family under one very small roof.  Join the discussion.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More November 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
surprised
November 25, 2005, 8:31 am PST

Not true

Quote From: md81264

it seems somw of you have very sick imaginations, or maybe you just fill in the blanks when you see fit.  get a grip.......and pull your heads out of the gutter.
I think you jumped to judging me and missed my point.  There are lines that are crossed and lines that are almost crossed in a innocent manner.   It is a inappropriate behavior.  
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
quiet
November 25, 2005, 2:16 pm PST

11/22 "Yours, Mine & Ours”

Quote From: md81264

I hope this message will set the record strait.  It is true that i am very close to my daughter and my son.  My children are every thing to me......but so is the marriage i have with my wife.  I would do anything for them.  What you do not know is that i was close to my children before my divorce from my first wife.  What you also do not know is that i lost two children from my first marriage, one child at 4 months and then another at 1 month of age.  Could this be a reason for my close relationship with my children or why i try to protect them,.......it might have some thing to do with it.   So for all the messages posted that carried a perverted slant to them.....i suggest you get the facts before assumptions are made. My interaction with my children has not changed from the first marriage to the next.  It seems that my wife sees my relationship with my kids as me favoring them over her own......and that is not true.  It is true that her children have not bonded with me as of yet so it may look to my wife that i am favoring my own.  But i must be honest, i some times feel the same way towards my wife and the way she babies her son........she would probably say that it does not happen, but it does.  I believe that it is only human nature to try and protect your children, and try to make each day a happy one for them. I have a great wife and some great kids, but I do agree that my family needs some work........but don't we all.  Good luck to those who stick with it. 

  

Mark 

 Beware, beware father of the first family.  My situation is scarily similar to yours.  My hb had his daughter from his first marriage become his "pal,sidekick" whatever you want to call it.  Indulged, spoiled, not materially but behaviourly as your daughter seems to be. He made his daughter the centre of his life to the exclusion of his own life. Let's fast forward to now.  Daddy's girl is now 14, lets see her behaviour is as follows: since 12 has been drinking, smoking, doing drugs, sleeping with older boys 18 ++. Has no respect for her father, her mother, me or her step father.  The mother is NO help whatsoever.  Since no boundaries were ever set up between her father and herself, she fancies herself my equal/competition.  Daddy has a hard time disciplining her, because when she does not get her own way it results in emotional warfare. She distances herself, makes him feel guilty for "neglecting" her. Neglect = not getting what she wants. The games have begun.  Beware, he has created a monster that he has very little or no control over her actions, her attitudes, since nothing has ever been addressed in the past, it makes it very hard to step up now and start laying down the law.  My advice to you - start now, start fast and pull in the reins or trust me you will besorry. You will end up with a sullen, spoiled, little girl who uses whatever weapons she may have at her disposal to get her own way and will have a hard time functioning in the real world.  My step dtr has a very difficult time maintaining friends, because she insists things be her way. Most girls do not like her because of her promiscuity.  It has caused tremendous strain on the relationship because I refuse to be disrespected in my own home. My own children do not behave this way.  We do not do our children any favours by making excuses for their behaviour however poor, they must learn to be accountable and responsible for what they do and what they say.  It is never too early to start instilling that in your daughter. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 25, 2005, 5:42 pm PST

11/22 "Yours, Mine & Ours”

Quote From: mspeaches

yeah, i am actually on this show. i'm part of the second family, the oldest daughter. the other family that was on the show, i felt so bad for the step-mother. if i ever did that to my step-mom, i'd hope she'd outright slap me.
I saw that show and my husband and I  were really happy for your family.  We had four kids (two girls, two boys, one of which was a foster child) in a dinky 800 sq ft two bedroom house (ONE bathroom!).  Boy do I know what crowded is all about!  Congratulations on your good fortune!!  You seem like a really nice deserving family.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 26, 2005, 5:19 am PST

11/22 "Yours, Mine & Ours”

Quote From: darlene14

I am in the same situation as the woman who feels like the "other woman".  I am going thru my 2nd divorce and had had it with men when I had run into an old "friend" from 20 years ago and he pursued me and we hit it off and are now engaged.   I have 5 children (son age 16 and 4 girls - 13, 11, 8 and 4) from 2 previous marriages and he has one daughter who is 12.  She has done everything she can to come between us.  She was living with her dad when we first got together and moved back with her mom after she found out her mom was having a baby - who is not married and not even with the guy....anyway, their marriage wasn't much of one to begin with and they were just divorced a year ago.  Instead of fiance doing the things with his wife like he should have he did them with his daughter instead. 

 

Now that we are together she gets jealous and comes around to hug her dad or kiss him to make me jealous.  If we are hugging or something she will come around to get her share - one incident she came in and we were hugging b/c one of us had just gotten home and she got pissed and said "I LOVE YOU TOO DAD!"  She calls her mom in the middle of the night when she is here on the weekends she is here and even on Wednesday nights for her to come and get her.  I think it is because she is used to sleeping with them and doesn't like to sleep by herself or without her mom or dad.  I keep telling fiance not to allow her to call or leave and he does everytime.  I have had panic attacks when she is here and have to leave because of the stress and he ends up leaving taking her to his moms and has her stay there or whatever. 

 

She likes to dress trashy and is proud to look like a "slut" and talks about wanting to be one.  She was always undressing in front of him and lifts her shirt up to show him her bra - she hasn't yet started to develop but still inappropriate.  She talks about her "boobs" to him all the time.  She walks in on him in the bathroom and shower - glass shower doors, and walks in on us all the time when we are in the bedroom. 

 

When she is here she talks bad about me and gets my oldest daughter against me and do the things she knows I don't like or aprrove of.  As soon as she leaves to go back home my daughter is her old self.  My other kids don't like her because of her attitude but especially the way she has treated me.  She has really hurt my 11 year old by the way she has treated me and talked to me and about me. 

 

She was supposed to walk home with my daughter from school and would never show up and go somewhere else and no one would know where she was.  But there was no discipline and she just kept doing it.  She now doesn't come here - she has everyone running all over the place to pick her up whereever she is.  She hasn't been here for a few weeks - mostly b/c her mom had her baby and now she is really treating her dad bad.  She was talking bad behind his back too and being rude to him to his face.  She can't keep friends.  She lies constantly and has been stealing (stole cash and checks from my daughter- which she gave her back the checks but not the cash) and finace doesn't even confront her about any of it.  When he does confront her about anything she lies to him and he lets it go.  They had taken one of my credit cards and used it for a dating site on the internet and they were both confronted about it and I still don't know what happened for sure but he ended up taking his daugher for "a ride" and talked to her about it and got the "facts" from her and then it was dropped.  My daughter was saying one thing and his daughter said she didn't even know anything about it and didn't want to talk about it - she just kept doing her homework. 

 

My finace has told me he wants me to help and he wants his daughter to be able to come to me for anything.  I can talk to my kids about anything and his ex has never been able to talk about "delicate" issues with their daughter.  She had no idea what puberty even was.  He wants the help but he just doesn't seem to get it.  He knows about this show and I told him about it and that that is exactly like our situation and he didn't see it as that way.  I told him it is and that I have told him that since we first got together. 

 

My kids love him to death and don't give him problems - sure they are kids and they act up but not to this extent.  My kids have not had much of a dad - even with their step-dad, and they like the way he wants to be with them and do for them.  But he does "discipline" them and makes them go by rules.  But it doesn't ever apply to his daugher.  He tells me he doesn't want to because she isn't here that much....One of my daughters (11 year old) doesn't live with me right now either and I see her a lot less than he does his daughter but she still has rules... 

 

He also sneaks off almost every night to go call her and talk to her.  I don't like the sneaking around and I have brought it up.  He hasn't talked to her much the past week or two since the baby was born - she gets pissed at him for something and hangs up on him all the time. 

 

I wish I knew what to do.  We are wanting to move out of town and he thinks it would help with some of the problems but to me he is just running from them and not wanting to deal with her and have to treat her like the daughter/child that she is.  She is very childish too and acts like a 2 year old--when she doesn't get her way or get what she wants she cries and blames me and then she will call her mom crying to her.  Which she sneaks off to do that too.  Especially at night when she goes home in the middle of the night - shw will sneak the phone and call her mom then come in all ready to go and just tell her dad she is leaving and make some stupid excuse.  I think a lot of it is for attention.  And she is getting it thats for sure.  She is very conniving and manipulative and fiance says he just can't believe she would do things.... 

 

HELP!!  I could go on and on and on... 

 Oh my God, you are living my life!!  I am at my wits end as well, it is causing major strain in the relationship.  My stepdtr is a slut and dresses trashy, acts, speaks you name it, she does it.  Their behaviours are almost identical.  I'm sorry I don't have any answers for you, I'm struggling too.  However I do console myself with this: This is not my daughter, not my problem, if the two parents cannot see the damage that they are doing to their daughter, long term then there is not much I can do about it.  I too get extremely anxious when I know she is coming over, for there is ALWAYS some sort of drama that we have to deal with.  Currently, she is staying at a hotel through the week, mon-fri - the mom works nights there and she stays the night to go to the school that SHE wants to go to.  She doesn't want to go to the one that the bus picks her up at the door. and thinks we should all drive her 40 minutes out of everyones way so she can do what she wants. She tells us  she has made up her mind and isn't budging.  And what do the parents do?  Whatever she tells them to.  It makes me sick to watch her manipulate my hb and then I get so angry with him.  He is the reason she is the way she is and he will have no one to blame when she cannot function as an adult.  I feel sorry for us. and yes I could go on and on and on,  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
surprised
November 26, 2005, 7:46 am PST

Reading the comments...

I was reading through alot of the posts and am floored that this many families have this kind of a problem to this much of an extreme! 

  

My two daughters are good friends four kids from the same family.  Dad has five kids from the first marriage, four of which live full time with him and his second wife (he's 36, she's 26).  They have one child together.  Fact is, I don't know what their secret is (they should write a book!), but these kids ADORE their stepmom.  All of the kids are well adjusted, happy, respectful, and well behaved.  Stepmom (they don't even consider her to be anything other than their secondary mom, and the kids still see their bio mom all the time) has been in their lives since they were very young.  Both parents are strict but balance that with alot of love and understanding.  I think these people should have been on the show to demonstrate the right way to make this work.   I think partly why this works so well for them is that bio and step moms are friends.  Bio mom has said many times that as far as she's concerned stepmom is mom to them because she does an excellent job.  She says this in front of the kids, showing support for stepmom.   

  

I think it's great that these people have made this situation work so well.  It's not easy to get along with your ex.  But it's best for the kids when the parents put their differences aside and show a united front in raising the children.  It's a shame that more people aren't able to do this! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
November 27, 2005, 1:40 pm PST

very rare

Quote From: dpech66

I was reading through alot of the posts and am floored that this many families have this kind of a problem to this much of an extreme! 

  

My two daughters are good friends four kids from the same family.  Dad has five kids from the first marriage, four of which live full time with him and his second wife (he's 36, she's 26).  They have one child together.  Fact is, I don't know what their secret is (they should write a book!), but these kids ADORE their stepmom.  All of the kids are well adjusted, happy, respectful, and well behaved.  Stepmom (they don't even consider her to be anything other than their secondary mom, and the kids still see their bio mom all the time) has been in their lives since they were very young.  Both parents are strict but balance that with alot of love and understanding.  I think these people should have been on the show to demonstrate the right way to make this work.   I think partly why this works so well for them is that bio and step moms are friends.  Bio mom has said many times that as far as she's concerned stepmom is mom to them because she does an excellent job.  She says this in front of the kids, showing support for stepmom.   

  

I think it's great that these people have made this situation work so well.  It's not easy to get along with your ex.  But it's best for the kids when the parents put their differences aside and show a united front in raising the children.  It's a shame that more people aren't able to do this! 

If only every mother could be supportive towards the stepmother.  Really all the adults should be united.  Most of the problems that kids have is because the bio mother speaks poorly of the stepmom.  the kids think they have to take sides and feel they are betraying their mother, if they are nice to the stepmom.  I tried to be friends with the bio.  It could not happen she was just getting ammo or turned things around.  She was just flatout a miserable woman.  My husband and I lived through it.  The kids are grown and haven't had to deal with her for quite so time.  There really should be some manditory classes that divorced parents and children of divorce should take before a divorce  is granted. 
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
November 27, 2005, 9:03 pm PST

thank you

Quote From: carilou

 I couldn't of said it better myself.  You hit the nail on the head in All the areas. What is is with girls and their dad's?  What is it with dad's and their daughters.  It would creep me out when my husband would let his daughter put and leave her hand in his front pocket of his jeans.  Of course I was the one with my mind in the gutter.  He definitely does have a ego problem.  How sick is that to ruin your daughter and marriage because it.  He is not teaching her about male female married adult relationships.  I hope they have a updated too.   

   I know the dad probably wanted to have another person around to tallk to and act like a wife.  I can see that...Did anyone see the oprah show on the same day?  the girls mom had cancer and made her 100 tapes.  In there she said to her daughter that she wanted her dad to remarry. 

The dad did find someone else and  asked talked to the daughter about the woman.  The daughter said that she needed more time to get to know the new g-f.   And she did.  I think she said about 6mo later she told her dad she was ready to invite the lady into there life. 

 

I think also...the girl had sleep-overs to get to know the future wife.  And just hang-out.    

that seems so great 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
frustrated
November 27, 2005, 9:55 pm PST

blame self

Quote From: md81264

it seems somw of you have very sick imaginations, or maybe you just fill in the blanks when you see fit.  get a grip.......and pull your heads out of the gutter.

I hope dr phil can help you.  Cuz in your messages you are still defending yourself and blaming others. 

your daughter will not change quickly and maybe only 10% because she was acting like your wife for 2 yrs.  The flag went up for me when I heard " i could make my dad his favorite food..he would have to teach me..but, then we wouldnt need her."  that is not exact but, it was something like that .  you can love your kids but, dont LOVE your kids.   

 

Most people dont have that talk untill they are in a very deep relationship. Which your daughter is acting like she is at that step with you. question-->DID you let you daughter and wife have one on one time together.  sleep-overs,shopping, talking?  I also think you were being selfish.  Your daughter wants her mother back..that tells me you never cared if your daughter was ready for another person to come into your household. You just needed a female person around and when you got that your daughter went on the back-burner..but, she will push until you cave and put her in front.  

 

I hope you see what has happend and I'm glad your trying to get help.   

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
November 28, 2005, 9:54 am PST

Yours, Ours - revelation

This past week, since Dr. Phil was on has been a little better...  no blow ups or hurt feelings anyways.  I've been trying to see the situation through my step-daughter's eyes...  rather than how I feel about the whole situation.  I get frustrated sometimes bc I miss out on my relationship time with my husband, what we shared before the kids moved in - but I have reminded myself that she had her own special relationship with her dad before I moved in.  I was thinking about suggesting a "daddy & me" night for the kids and dad only once/week or every other week.... bc there are times when my H and I go out for dinner/date, just the two of us.  The step-daughter has asked for this from her dad before, and he told her that we're all a family now.  But I think I might suggest this idea so they can still experience their dad without their step-mom around. 

A few days ago, the XW asked H if I would sit down with her sometime to discuss the step-daughter situation - he said I'm sure she would.  It may never happen bc she doesn't follow through with anything..  I would like to hear what she has to say in one way - but the frustrating part is she acts like she just won the "mother of the year award"... however she could go weeks without contacting the kids, and it's only after they have called to talk to her that she calls back. 

 
User Mood
Hyper

Message Emote
blank
November 28, 2005, 10:09 am PST

I too am a stepmom who has trouble with the bio mom

Quote From: carilou

If only every mother could be supportive towards the stepmother.  Really all the adults should be united.  Most of the problems that kids have is because the bio mother speaks poorly of the stepmom.  the kids think they have to take sides and feel they are betraying their mother, if they are nice to the stepmom.  I tried to be friends with the bio.  It could not happen she was just getting ammo or turned things around.  She was just flatout a miserable woman.  My husband and I lived through it.  The kids are grown and haven't had to deal with her for quite so time.  There really should be some manditory classes that divorced parents and children of divorce should take before a divorce  is granted. 

I have from day one tried to get along with her for the sake of the kids....I know we'll never be friends but we should be able to get along for their sake.  She tells me that my job as stepmom is hard and she wouldn't want to be one.  She says she agrees with what hubby has decided to do to discipline the kdis etc and then she does the opposite (who are we to rule what she does?).  She creates problems that don't need to be there at all.  The kids are 13 (boy) and 15 (girl).  She has three other children -- 10 year old boy by second husband who lives with his dad but she never sees him and then she has two boys ages 2 and 4 months old that live with her and her third husband.  We have two other children -- a 4 year old boy and a 2 year old girl (our daughter is three months younger than her son).   Everytime the kids go there for a weekend they come back with major attitude and sharp tongues...but we try and give them a break as we know it isn't easy on them...Her 13 year old son wants to live with her and we did everything we could to help this to happen but the next step was his mom's and she hasn't done anything to help it to happen since September (although she tells him that he could come and live with her...she won't notarize and file papers with the court).  I agree about the classes idea but I know she wouldn't go!  

  

  

 
First | Prev | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | Next | Last