Message Boards

Topic : 11/22 "Yours, Mine & Ours"

Number of Replies: 174
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 18, 2005, 03:40:19 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

Falling in love is easy. Falling in love with your new spouse's kids is not so easy. Actor Dennis Quaid, co-star of the new movie "Yours, Mine & Ours," joins Dr. Phil. He talks about how being a dad helped him prepare for his role as a man dealing with the difficulties of blending a family. Then, Juli says her stepdaughter, Samantha, makes her feel like the other woman. Her husband, Mark, says that Samantha is his best friend. Will Juli's jealousy tear their new family apart? Then, they have two dogs, two cats, four fish and six kids. Meet two parents blending their chaotic family under one very small roof.  Join the discussion.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More November 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 28, 2005, 3:47 pm PST

i 'hear' you

Quote From: debi14

sorry, I don't remember your name. 

  

I am the woman who raised my ex's kids for the past 18 years, and am now facing divorce because of his daughter. 

  

I completely understand that your daughter needs time with you...time to feel special, to know that she will always be your little girl. BUT.... 

  

YOU created this problem when you turned to your child to fill a void that only an adult woman is supposed to fill, and YOU have to be the one to fix it. Your new wife will never be able to fix anything, because any and everything she does will be suspect to your daughter. Your daughter is too young to do anything but want and take anything and everything she can get, and shouldn't have to fix your mistake. You are the only one who can stop the madness. 

  

Spend time with your daughter on a regular basis, just the two of you. But when you allow her to come in between  you and your wife, she feels as if is she is succeeding in gaining you back as an adult companion, and your wife will never feel as if her place in the home and family is secure and sure. Trade all of those "late night TV" watchings in for a movie or some other outing once a week, and take some time EVERY SINGLE DAY to spend ALONE, with your wife, one on one, during the waking hours of the day when your daughter can observe a healthy male/female adult relationship. 

  

Let me ask you this: 

  

If any other grown man who had divorced his wife had become "best friends" with your daughter, wouldn't you see that as "strange" and "unhealthy"? Just because you are her father doesn't make it any less strange and unhealthy, that is just an excuse, and is tantamount to emotional incest. If you have done everything except have physical sex with your daughter, on an emotional level, it is the same thing, as hard as that may be to swallow. 

  

If you....YOU....don't fix this NOW, you will find yourself in a constant battle that will only grow worse and worse as your daughter learns advanced adult manipulation skills that will eventually force you into an impossible situation. Back your wife up in the house, establish adult/child boundaries and roles, and NEVER argue or take your daughter's side in front of them. Talk....talktalktalktalk to them both, and place them in the age and role-appropriate places in your life, sir. Also, never make any decisions without first discussing them with your wife, leaving her out of the loop of communication. I cannot count the number of time that my husband and step-daughter would just make plans and expect me to fall in with them or change my plans to accommodate their little dates. 

  

My husband couldn't and wouldn't do this, and now, it is over for us. Don't let this happen to you. A  wife is supposed to be for a lifetime partner, and children are for a temporary gift until you hand them off to another adult....their future spouse....who is supposed to fill the appropriate place in their life. And trust me, that man will thank you later for not giving him an emotional basketcase to try and deal with. 

  

My prayers and sympathies for your wife, who is probably suffering more emotionally than you will ever know. You still have time to work on this, so do it. Stop abusing your daughter by spoiling her and giving her an inappropriate amount of time, space and emotion in your life. You will eventually cripple her emotionally and mentally if you don't. 

  

Been there, done it, and FAILED because the man wouldn't have the balls to step up to the plate and do what was necessary to repair the damage done. I'd hate to see that happen to you and your family. 

  

Debi 

this is so huge to me... i have been starting to think something was really wrong with me.  You said stuff that i have said and felt about my husband..   but, wow, you have to have lived it before you know what its about.   i had been calling it emotional incest and then found out it really is 'just  that'..  It is really sick..  some of my friends and even my husband have said i am sick for things i have said and felt about them.   but  when i hear it from others.. its like a huge weight is lifting casue im feeling validated.   They stare at each other all the time.   and she dances and sings around him.. i said she acted like his 'geisha girl' 

.   I told him she was not created for his 'pleasure'. I raised a girl with a step dad since she was 3.  now i am with a new husband and his 5 year old princess.  so i speak from experience.  my first husband knew that i was 'in love' with him.   all i really ;know about my present husband that he 'loves her so much'.   I feel like he is constantily cheating on me with her.  now they live down the road 2 blocks in anoter place and it makes me cringe to think of all the 'private time they have and bonding and how she is 'so' happy now with them... i said to him. that she sleeps with him more thant i do.  i just cant seem to let go.  and i think its becasue it is a literal compettion.  and he is feeling pretty important.. having 2 girls fight over him.. its an ego boost.. its cruel to both child and mother and i feel so small to think that i am in compettion with a 5year old.   its a real sick hook and hard to get out of.   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 28, 2005, 8:01 pm PST

11/22 "Yours, Mine & Ours”

Quote From: smoochy00

     I watched todays show!  The 2nd family look like they will make it and will be happy! 

 

The first family ..has problems.  I'm taking a guess here.. hear me out! 

 

the husband treated his daughter like a wife for 2years.  there needs to be some space.  I could see this daughter having a sexual relationship with her dad.  I'm not saying anything like that would happen or the dad being a perve but, the daughter and the dad have taken the daughter's role so far that its natural to think about the next step.  I also think that this dad likes  having to women fight over him.  How he sat there and smirked and says I spoil the daughter. i feel as if he doesn't want to change it.  Also, I think its going to be hard to change the daughter.  If the daughter does get less attention with dad ..she might act out 2 try and get that attention back.   

 

this is a messy problem.  I hope they have an update show on the first couple.   

i would love to talk to you,, just for support.. it is the most ripping situation ...  like living with his girlfriend and him expecting you to smile and like it.   and then crawl into bed with him and be intimate.   it really , really hurts.   i , again, am so surprised that other woman really have had the same reactions as me.  it just alters the very core of what 'marriage' is. 

very draining and wearing. 

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 28, 2005, 8:03 pm PST

It can work

When I married my husband we discussed prior to the marriage that the marriage comes FIRST, no matter what. My husband's kids had a key to his home and he always wanted them to feel like it was their home too (not just their mother's home where they lived full time).  When I sold my house and moved into his I wanted privacy.  I didn't want his kids to come bouncing in anytime they were in the area. We were married the same month his daughter turned 18.  He asked his kids for their keys to "our" home . Although they weren't happy, I was thrilled. 

  

I have found that everytime my husband takes my part (which is always), I love him even more.  

  

Believe me, his daughter could be a handful if he allowed it but he doesn't. It's interesting how she continues to try but she doesn't get anywhere. 

  

His son lived with us for a few months and it worked out fine. I tried to be as accommodating and caring as I could. I wasn't happy about how messy his room was but other than that, everything worked out fine. In fact, when he decided to move out, we were both sad. (he moved out due to our putting the house on the market and his uncertainty about how long we would be in the area where he goes to college. 

  

I think what Dr. Phil said about boundaries is the answer. There are so many men out there who are spineless. That seems to be the issue more than anything. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2005, 6:22 am PST

11/22 "Yours, Mine & Ours”

Quote From: bonniesue

this is so huge to me... i have been starting to think something was really wrong with me.  You said stuff that i have said and felt about my husband..   but, wow, you have to have lived it before you know what its about.   i had been calling it emotional incest and then found out it really is 'just  that'..  It is really sick..  some of my friends and even my husband have said i am sick for things i have said and felt about them.   but  when i hear it from others.. its like a huge weight is lifting casue im feeling validated.   They stare at each other all the time.   and she dances and sings around him.. i said she acted like his 'geisha girl' 

.   I told him she was not created for his 'pleasure'. I raised a girl with a step dad since she was 3.  now i am with a new husband and his 5 year old princess.  so i speak from experience.  my first husband knew that i was 'in love' with him.   all i really ;know about my present husband that he 'loves her so much'.   I feel like he is constantily cheating on me with her.  now they live down the road 2 blocks in anoter place and it makes me cringe to think of all the 'private time they have and bonding and how she is 'so' happy now with them... i said to him. that she sleeps with him more thant i do.  i just cant seem to let go.  and i think its becasue it is a literal compettion.  and he is feeling pretty important.. having 2 girls fight over him.. its an ego boost.. its cruel to both child and mother and i feel so small to think that i am in compettion with a 5year old.   its a real sick hook and hard to get out of.   

For a lot of years I thought that my "issues" were clouding this one, as I didn't have a close relationship with my father. They both knew it and kept telling me that it was "normal" for a father to love his daughter so much. But even our friends saw and commented on things, and when she was still 13 14 15 years old and piling up in his lap to "snuggle" I knew for sure that she was just trying to goad me and prove that he loved her "more". 

  

Make no mistake...kids are not "innocent" as people would like to thing they are, and they haven't developed the conscience to see past the selfishness of what they want, at the expense of others. This girl told me she would eventually get rid of me, and now, after she is grown, married and pregnant, her dream of having me gone is finally being realized. 

  

Don't for one instant think it will get better when they grow up and start having lives of their own. It probably won't. I thought if I could stick it out until they were out of the house that I would have it made. WRONG. 

  

My advice is that if he cannot or will not see a problem here, and take any pro-active steps to change things, you are better off getting out while you can, instead of investing years in a doomed relationship. 

  

I feel for you, sweetie. it's hard, isnt it? You are NOT the "sick" one, here. As Dr. P says, it is better to be well alone than sick with someone else. Think about it, and make a wise choice. 

  

Debi 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
November 29, 2005, 6:34 am PST

the same situation

Quote From: puptent

I have from day one tried to get along with her for the sake of the kids....I know we'll never be friends but we should be able to get along for their sake.  She tells me that my job as stepmom is hard and she wouldn't want to be one.  She says she agrees with what hubby has decided to do to discipline the kdis etc and then she does the opposite (who are we to rule what she does?).  She creates problems that don't need to be there at all.  The kids are 13 (boy) and 15 (girl).  She has three other children -- 10 year old boy by second husband who lives with his dad but she never sees him and then she has two boys ages 2 and 4 months old that live with her and her third husband.  We have two other children -- a 4 year old boy and a 2 year old girl (our daughter is three months younger than her son).   Everytime the kids go there for a weekend they come back with major attitude and sharp tongues...but we try and give them a break as we know it isn't easy on them...Her 13 year old son wants to live with her and we did everything we could to help this to happen but the next step was his mom's and she hasn't done anything to help it to happen since September (although she tells him that he could come and live with her...she won't notarize and file papers with the court).  I agree about the classes idea but I know she wouldn't go!  

  

  

so the same as it was for us when the kids were small.  You can live past this stage.  It seemed like forever at the time.  My  h has 5 they were ages 10 and down to 3 when we stared dating.  Now they are 30 to 21.  We had all the them with us at one time or another.  Also when his daughter was 16 and her newborn baby.   We all get along, except the 21 year old.  we take family vacations have and great holiday's together.  Camping, sking, ice skating days,  Mafia day. It's a game we play.The most important thing (hind sight for us) that we wished we would of done is not to protect the bio so much from the kids.  We took alot of the blame and made up for her failures.  I am not saying be hateful towards her or hurt the kids in any way. I need to back trac some, his children blamed me and my h for alot of things because of the what the bio told the kids.  Children will forgive their parents but they don't forgive the step as easily.  It took us years to become this way.  With alot of hurt feelings and angry words.  You have to get real tough skin and take more than you deserve to be a step parent.  For me I tried to focus on the good and put the bad in the back of my mind.  They are just kids.  Hope this helps
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2005, 10:54 am PST

COULD HAVE BEEN ME...

Quote From: mari3kids

 Oh my God, you are living my life!!  I am at my wits end as well, it is causing major strain in the relationship.  My stepdtr is a slut and dresses trashy, acts, speaks you name it, she does it.  Their behaviours are almost identical.  I'm sorry I don't have any answers for you, I'm struggling too.  However I do console myself with this: This is not my daughter, not my problem, if the two parents cannot see the damage that they are doing to their daughter, long term then there is not much I can do about it.  I too get extremely anxious when I know she is coming over, for there is ALWAYS some sort of drama that we have to deal with.  Currently, she is staying at a hotel through the week, mon-fri - the mom works nights there and she stays the night to go to the school that SHE wants to go to.  She doesn't want to go to the one that the bus picks her up at the door. and thinks we should all drive her 40 minutes out of everyones way so she can do what she wants. She tells us  she has made up her mind and isn't budging.  And what do the parents do?  Whatever she tells them to.  It makes me sick to watch her manipulate my hb and then I get so angry with him.  He is the reason she is the way she is and he will have no one to blame when she cannot function as an adult.  I feel sorry for us. and yes I could go on and on and on,  

  

Well, my fiance and I had a long discussion about this show the other night and the way I see it as the way things are with us.  He doesn't like the fact that she would be considered his surrogate wife.  I have been telling him this since we got together at the end of May.  He said he hasn't been having her come over here to our house until some things get worked out.  I told him it isn't going to do her any good to stay away and not be involved.  He said he doesn't want to put it all on her so fast all at one time...I told him he needs to stop babying her and she needs to deal with life sometime - it isn't going to go away.  So since she hasn't been over for 2-3 weeks he had made plans - without my knowing - to take her out.  Well, since I didn't know anything about it his plans backfired and it didn't happen because of his obligations here.  So, his rude, disrespectful daughter hung up on him.  

 

The only time she even comes around or wants anything to do with her dad is when he is buying her something.  He doesn't agree.  I have told him all she cares about are material things and not about the relationship.  I told him that when she does come over here she doesn't pay much attention to him - it is all with my daughter - and when my daughter isn't here or doesn't pay all her attention to her she leaves.   

 

He said if he had the money right now like he did before he would be buying my kids everything they wanted to and I said no you wouldn't - I won't let you.  I don't want my kids to end up being spoiled brats and I want them to know what it is like to have to work for what they want and feel the accomplishment of it.  They aren't going to learn to expect everything and that they deserve everything - to be handed over to them.  He just doesn't get it. 

 

My daughter said that my fiances daughter doesn't even talk to her anymore at school, which doesn't surprise me.  She gets what she wants when she comes over here and that is for my daughter to treat me like s**t and all the attention on her and what she wants so it doesn't matter when she isn't here. 

 

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2005, 11:09 am PST

FIANCES DAUGHTER DOES THE SAME

Quote From: bonniesue

this is so huge to me... i have been starting to think something was really wrong with me.  You said stuff that i have said and felt about my husband..   but, wow, you have to have lived it before you know what its about.   i had been calling it emotional incest and then found out it really is 'just  that'..  It is really sick..  some of my friends and even my husband have said i am sick for things i have said and felt about them.   but  when i hear it from others.. its like a huge weight is lifting casue im feeling validated.   They stare at each other all the time.   and she dances and sings around him.. i said she acted like his 'geisha girl' 

.   I told him she was not created for his 'pleasure'. I raised a girl with a step dad since she was 3.  now i am with a new husband and his 5 year old princess.  so i speak from experience.  my first husband knew that i was 'in love' with him.   all i really ;know about my present husband that he 'loves her so much'.   I feel like he is constantily cheating on me with her.  now they live down the road 2 blocks in anoter place and it makes me cringe to think of all the 'private time they have and bonding and how she is 'so' happy now with them... i said to him. that she sleeps with him more thant i do.  i just cant seem to let go.  and i think its becasue it is a literal compettion.  and he is feeling pretty important.. having 2 girls fight over him.. its an ego boost.. its cruel to both child and mother and i feel so small to think that i am in compettion with a 5year old.   its a real sick hook and hard to get out of.   

My finaces daughter does the same things - she is almost 13 - and we used to have "dance" parties with the kids.   I have 1 son (16)  and 4 daughters (ages almost 14, 11, almost 9 and 4).  We used to have a lot of fun but it would get uncomfortable for me when his daughter would come over and grab him and pull him away from me and start grinding him - from the front and back.  It makes my stomach turn to see the way she interacts with him and nothing is done - at least until I say something.  We talk about her future and how these things will affect her later on in life in so many areas but then he gets to blaming himself and then he says things like she is my daughter and I don't like to think of her as being cruel, manipulative, disrespectful....He has always said since we met that he wants to keep her as young and innocent as long as he can but I told him she needs to grow up and stop being treated like a 2 year old.  She is constantly sitting on his lap with her arms wrapped around his neck, she is always flashing herself at him - anything to get attention. 

 

I have done a separate post which goes into more detail on some things so I won't do it here.  But there is just so many things that are so inappropriate. 

 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
November 30, 2005, 9:04 am PST

11/22 "Yours, Mine & Ours”

I saw this episode for the first time last night.  And then of course, I came on the message boards to see what was said about it.... 

  

I am the mother of an 8 year old little boy.  My husband and I started dating when he was 5.  We knew pretty much from the start that this was it - we were in love and wanted to get married.  But - it was VERY important to me that my son be as in love with him as I am.  I told my now husband that when he asked me to marry him - he needed to ask my son too.  Hey - ya know what?  I'm a package deal... I am now and forever a mom.  When we were married, my son and husband took vows to one another - they exchanged ring... we signed a family contract.  I wanted my son to know that this decision was not made FOR him - he was included in this relationship.  We got married when my son was 7.  I'm glad that we did it this way... my husband is established as a father figure, an authority, my son is comfortable in his spot as "OUR SON". 

  

I'm not saying we did everything right.... but here's where I see the problems coming in from the stories I've read and seen... 

These kids parents divorced, I'm sure that the kids were never consulted on this decision (nor should they be...) - the kids feel like their lives were tossed in the air and they are completely out of control of it.   Many Dad's (not all) are used to being the "fun parent"... they support the kids in sports, they do fun things together - it's Mom who has yelled about cleaning the room, doing the chores, getting homework done... Dad's a generally unprepared to be the SOLE PARENT - so they continue being the fun guy...  

Then Dad starts dating... and maybe get's married.  OF COURSE the child is going to rebel. 

Now - let me go on record and state that there is nothing wrong with a girl child of any age crawling into Daddy's lap for comfort.  I was 22 years old and pregnant when my ex left me - I remember crawling into my Daddy's lap and letting him comfort me - HE'S MY DADDY!!!!   Daddy's don't stop being Daddy's when their little girls start growing up... Daddy is always Daddy. 

Dad's - you HAVE to be the Parent.  You can't be the buddy.  You can be your kids BEST FRIENDS - but you can't be their buddy.  Be the adult - make good decisions, do not burden your kids with grown up issues.   

Step Mom's - Be the adult.  Do not be jealous, be firm.  One of the most powerful things that my parents EVER said to me was this.... "I don't care if your LIKE me - it's not my job to have kids that LIKE me - it IS my job to raise kids who will be productive, law abiding, adults.  I can do it the easy way or the hard way - THAT much is in your control".   

  

But I beg of you all single parents out their dating - considering getting married... talk to your kids.  Let them know that their happiness matters - that your new spouse will never take their place.  Have date nights with your kids.  My son and I go out several times a month - just the 2 of us - to dinner or for a walk... just so that I can keep a grasp on how he's feeling...  

  

BE PARENTS!!!  

Good luck! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
worried
November 30, 2005, 11:21 am PST

Do we have the same kid here or what?

Quote From: darlene14

Well, my fiance and I had a long discussion about this show the other night and the way I see it as the way things are with us.  He doesn't like the fact that she would be considered his surrogate wife.  I have been telling him this since we got together at the end of May.  He said he hasn't been having her come over here to our house until some things get worked out.  I told him it isn't going to do her any good to stay away and not be involved.  He said he doesn't want to put it all on her so fast all at one time...I told him he needs to stop babying her and she needs to deal with life sometime - it isn't going to go away.  So since she hasn't been over for 2-3 weeks he had made plans - without my knowing - to take her out.  Well, since I didn't know anything about it his plans backfired and it didn't happen because of his obligations here.  So, his rude, disrespectful daughter hung up on him.  

 

The only time she even comes around or wants anything to do with her dad is when he is buying her something.  He doesn't agree.  I have told him all she cares about are material things and not about the relationship.  I told him that when she does come over here she doesn't pay much attention to him - it is all with my daughter - and when my daughter isn't here or doesn't pay all her attention to her she leaves.   

 

He said if he had the money right now like he did before he would be buying my kids everything they wanted to and I said no you wouldn't - I won't let you.  I don't want my kids to end up being spoiled brats and I want them to know what it is like to have to work for what they want and feel the accomplishment of it.  They aren't going to learn to expect everything and that they deserve everything - to be handed over to them.  He just doesn't get it. 

 

My daughter said that my fiances daughter doesn't even talk to her anymore at school, which doesn't surprise me.  She gets what she wants when she comes over here and that is for my daughter to treat me like s**t and all the attention on her and what she wants so it doesn't matter when she isn't here. 

 

 I feel soooo much better knowing there are others who are experiencing the same thing I am.  I was beginning to wonder if I was looking for trouble.  My Stpdtr too, only comes around when she wants something and then leaves when she gets it.  For the most part, if she calls and requests something and Dad won't do it, he gets called a bunch of names, emotional warfare results and then she very nicely hangs up on him. I have said that they have the most warped relationship I've ever seen between father and daughter, he deals with her "outbursts" as a husband would deal with a wife, not a Father dealing with daughter. Once she hangs up on him, she does not come around, call - nothing - could be days, weeks (as long as someone else is catering to her in this time frame)Then....she calls and hb just about trips over himself he is soooo happy, she can hear it in his voice and at this point he will go to the ends of the earth just to see her and guess what?  She has won once again. It is a vicious cycle and is quite pathetic to watch from where I stand.  The outcome of this for me is that I am slowly losing respect for his as a person and as a man.  And that I know is the kiss of death for a relationship.  I feel like my future is in the hands of a hormone riddled, psychotic teenage girl and it scares me.  I have even looked up NPD (Narcissitic Personality Disorder) because I think most of the symptoms apply to the step, I fluctuate between thinking she has a real mental disorder or is she just the most spoiled, indulged child I've ever met and what the @##$% kind of adult is she going to be?  Jeez, are we going to be bailing this kid out of everything for the rest of our lives? She also has not much of relationship with my kids(my son is the same age, same grade) and he finds it very difficult, because he feels he gets branded with the same reputation as her as she is VERY PROMISCUOUS - no detail, you'd be shocked. Dad knows about ALL of it, the drugs, the sex everything and is SCARED to talk to her, because he is scared she won't come around at all then.  Vicious circle.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
November 30, 2005, 9:25 pm PST

Step kids older than me!

At our home we have yours, mine ours and the neighborhoods it seems.  I have to step-daughters who are older than I. That was not good at first.  My husband is many years older than I am and my youngest step-daughter is 9 days older than I am.  My step kids and I now get a long and I in no way try to mother them but I am able to give advice that their Mother can't give. My husband and I have 2 kids together that all the children love and we are on big happy family most of the time and look forward to the holidays together.
 
First | Prev | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | Next | Last