Message Boards

Topic : 06/05 Conception Deception

Number of Replies: 708
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Tuesday, November 22, 2005, 03:23:42 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 11/28/05) What if your husband tricked you into getting pregnant? What if your wife lied to you and got pregnant? First, Stacy didn't tell Derek she went off birth control until after she got pregnant. He thought he was doing the right thing by marrying her but now feels trapped. When Stacy reveals the real reason she went off birth control, will Derek decide to stay in the marriage, or is it over? Next, Steve got Mary pregnant so that she would marry him. Since they've had more than one unplanned child, how does he keep getting her pregnant, and is he trying to trap her? Share your thoughts.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 2, 2005, 3:03 pm PST

The Hamster story is partially true....

 I am really surprized no one liked my hamster story...  but it is a partially true story and not made up.  See this cute little gal belongs now to my youngest son who talked me into getting her.  AND SINCE HE HAS HAD HER, HE HAS LOST HER 5 TIMES.  Including underneath the 6 level, 300 book shelf that needed to be removed to get her out.  And the 5th time he lost her I told him if you lose this hamster one more time... You are going to lose custody of it!  And he hasn't lost her since. AW  isn't she cute! She's a teddy bear hamster.   AND THAT'S THE REASON I LOVE AND WANT KIDS.... **laugh**
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 2, 2005, 3:07 pm PST

hope for you

Quote From: dawnwan20

Hi all, 

I just wanted to write my thoughts down....I have a six month old , and a husband who calls me dirty names almost on a daily basis.The other day he was burping her, and he was doing it rather hard, and one of the burps made her cry......I dont believe it. He hugged her and said sorry, but how could this happen in the first place? I was always known as a STRONG woman. and now............. 

I wanted to know how the fighting and name calling will affect my little baby. I know it cant be good. And I cant leave. I am not american, and if i cross the border to canada, my husband WILL claim kidnapping. I told him that we need counselling, but he refuses. I am scared, and I dont want my child to grow up thinking this is ok. Nor do I want her to feel scared in her own home. He takes everything away from me if he suspects that I want to leave, and says he will take her away too. So, my loving husband turned monster has me hostage.(so I feel) I want to get out. I cant see her cry. I need to bring her to my family where it is safe and healthy for the both of us.. He wants me pregnant again.... I cant get a professional opinion without him knowing, I need to know if there is a way for me to get away....I know there has to be. Please let me know.......thank u 

Please contact a shelter for battered women regardless of your status in the United States.  Abusers often go from verbal to physical abuse, as demonstrated by his rough treatment of your baby.  He will now feel that he has a real hold over you with the child.  I was a direct service advocate in a homeless shelter and we had many women come through with their children, looking for something better.  Some of these women had limited or no English  and no job skills - the case manager can put you in touch with the appropriate resources to a better situation.  Please don't tip him off about what you might be considering.  His game is all about manipulation and circumstances could become very dangerous for you and the baby. There should be a list of shelters in the front of the phone book - even if you call the wrong one, they will probably be able to give you some numbers to get in touch with appropriate people.  You already know what all of that bad talk is doing to your baby - get out of there and don't turn back!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 3, 2005, 1:42 am PST

11/28 Conception Deception

Quote From: blouic

Thank you for your words of appreciation and support.  I'm glad someone gets it--and hope many will benefit.  I'm so glad to hear that yours is a survivor story!  Keep striving!!!  May Healing and peace stay with you.  Let's keep this string of support going...more people will have to get it...it'll have to click with them sometime!
Thank you, I have clicked "Search Boards" and I have great admiration for your sharing, your eloquence AND your patience. Bless you. I can tell you have been deep inside yourself, and see others clearer because of that. There is great courage in healing. Deciding to take the unknown pathway away from abuse is frightening and exciting, like dying and being born in one single step. After walking 20 years, I say that step is worth more than anything that came before. Not easy, but worth it.
 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
December 4, 2005, 12:27 pm PST

actually.. they are pretty foolproof

Quote From: rabrog

It's very ignorant to say that all peopel who become pregnant allow it to happen.  Birth control pills and condoms are not 100% foolproof.  It goes back to unless you're ready for a kid, don't have sex.  That's the only way to be sure you don't get pregnant or get someone else pregnant. 

  

Jenn 

Female trial lawyers, female accountants, and female CEO's seem to have a much better time with "accidental" pregnancy. 

It seems that a bit of depression, a touch of underemployment and a modicum of lack of direction can wipe out much of the effacacy of birth control. 

"trouble in the relationship" or " he is breaking up with me" seems to render birth control completely ineffective. 

  

 

Message Emote
blank
December 4, 2005, 12:43 pm PST

print these out to bring to your counselor

Quote From: suepattyn

Thank you for your wise words. I can't say as though I blame myself so much as I am just in a state of confusion and uncertainty as to how a healthy relationship should look and feel. I will read the books but I don't think I can figure it out by myself. Mary is fortunate that Dr Phil and his staff will find an effective counselor for her. I don't even know where to start. The rape hotline worker I called this morning was distracted and bored but gave me the name of the only counselor in town who would be able to help me and she is the counselor that told me several years ago that no one could take me seriously. I'm not very anxious to go back to her for help. Does Dr Phil have a list of 'approved' counselors? I have searched through the website but didn't see anything. Anyone? Ideas?

If there is only one counselor available, work with that one--but don't limit yourself to her as a resource for support and education.  Be prepared to have to educate HER about how to counsel you.  A good counselor will be humble enough to recognize you as a partner in your own healing--as any medical doctor should.   

  

I've had to work long and hard with many physical doctors because, besides dealing w/ the crap from my ex-, I have multiple medical conditions, a couple of which are rare/ unknown--and having them in combination makes makes my situation all the more unique.  I've had to educate myself first (diagnosed myself on the Internet two summers ago) then go to the doctors, including the specialist, and educate them!  It's exhausting, but you eventually do win over listening ears and get the help you need.  But you need to do the work and be prepared yourself! 

  

The first time I went to see a marriage counselor, I told him what I had done to help myself so far (the titles of the self-help books I had already read).  He stared at me a moment and then said, "By reading those five books, you just saved yourself the first five sessions."  Read up yourself on abuse/ rape/ relationships issues--and re-read, and re-read again!!  It took two years and twice reading through both of Patricia Evans' books before the reality of it sank in crystal clear--and that was AFTER several years and several books preceding.  It takes a long time to get thoroughly educated on an intellectual level--and much longer for the psyche to be able to catch up, especially while you're still living in the thick of it.   

  

Take printed copies of the correspondences on this website that detail others people's claims/ experiences.  I'm sure she will sit up and take notice.  Heck, do it anyway, even if you decide not to use her as a resource partner.  Wouldn't hurt her to be educated on this--and may even help some of her clients.           

  

For anyone who hasn't: Do a msg. board search for blouic.  The list of correspondences is growing! 

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
December 4, 2005, 12:51 pm PST

Desperate woman

My opinion of women who intentionally trap men with a pregnancy is pathetic and desperate. My husband lived with this person and she trapped him with a pregnancy after promising him repeatedly that she was continuing birth control. This was a decision that SHE made without giving him the benefit of a choice. Their relationship wasn't healthy and she knew he didn't love her. They argued all the time. He had no intention of having a life connected to her, but faced with a threat of not seeing his child or being involved in her life, agreed to marry her.   You say how could she have gotten away with that?  Her mother is Clerk of Court in a small town, and believe me, grandma has connections and plenty of money. The powers that be can twist the laws  to fit, especially in a small town.   Anyway, the pregnant one bought her own engagement/wedding ring, set the date, and told him when to show up. A friend of grandma and grandpa showed up at the ceremony packing his pistol inside his jacket and made sure the groom knew it. The marriage lasted less than 12 months. The child lives in a broken home because her mother was pathetic and desperate.  Several years later, she becomes desperate again and traps another victim.  I believe their child is 2.  My husband and I have the child support burden month after month after month. We rent a condo and do without because of it. We can't fufil our dreams until the child care and child  support demands are over.  My children are grown. We have no children together.  Yes, I knew this when I married him, but it doesn't change the fact that I  resent it. This child is not the product of a loving healthy relationship, but a desperate woman with a trap between her legs.        

 

Message Emote
blank
December 5, 2005, 7:15 am PST

11/28 Conception Deception

Quote From: jewelerboy

Female trial lawyers, female accountants, and female CEO's seem to have a much better time with "accidental" pregnancy. 

It seems that a bit of depression, a touch of underemployment and a modicum of lack of direction can wipe out much of the effacacy of birth control. 

"trouble in the relationship" or " he is breaking up with me" seems to render birth control completely ineffective. 

  

 Please stop saying that only women who want to get pregnant get pregnant while on the pill.  I was on the pill before I had an abortion.  I assure you, I was NOT trying to trap anyone.  In fact, I felt at least as trapped as the father did, since I had not completed my education and had no way of realistically supporting myself and a child.  I did NOT miss taking the pill.  I was NOT taking antibiotics.  IT HAPPENS.  Yes, I did make him go with me to the clinic and hold my hand during the procedure.  But I assure you, I would MUCH rather NOT have had that particular life experience, especially with the pro-lifers protesting out front and calling me a murderer.  (I note that not one of them offered to adopt my 'oopsie'!)

Yes, there ARE pitiful, misogynistic women who 'trap' men by deliberately misleading them about birth control.  (I call them misogynists because I believe that such behaviour undermines the strides made by women  towards equality.)  But please stop assuming that only women who want to get pregnant do so!
 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
December 5, 2005, 8:12 am PST

again.. not a trial lawyer.. or accountant

Quote From: sumgrrl

 Please stop saying that only women who want to get pregnant get pregnant while on the pill.  I was on the pill before I had an abortion.  I assure you, I was NOT trying to trap anyone.  In fact, I felt at least as trapped as the father did, since I had not completed my education and had no way of realistically supporting myself and a child.  I did NOT miss taking the pill.  I was NOT taking antibiotics.  IT HAPPENS.  Yes, I did make him go with me to the clinic and hold my hand during the procedure.  But I assure you, I would MUCH rather NOT have had that particular life experience, especially with the pro-lifers protesting out front and calling me a murderer.  (I note that not one of them offered to adopt my 'oopsie'!)

Yes, there ARE pitiful, misogynistic women who 'trap' men by deliberately misleading them about birth control.  (I call them misogynists because I believe that such behaviour undermines the strides made by women  towards equality.)  But please stop assuming that only women who want to get pregnant do so!

You have to take it properly. 

Again i go back to the trial lawyer/accountant/ CEO issue 

do a message search for Jewelerboy and find " double pregnant" 

you may have started the pill that month 

you may have had some stomach issue/diarhea etc through the month. 

Good for you however for finding the strength to resolve your issue. 

 

Message Emote
blank
December 5, 2005, 10:27 am PST

U of MN, Mankato--stats. & stats. for psych.

Quote From: jewelerboy

You asked. 

  

Yes... one third of the world is muslim.. so yes.. in any given 50/50 situation they too will be right as individuals, both female and male.. 50% of the time.. not 1/3 as you asked. 

which of course leads to the question... what stats course did YOU take?? 

LOL     You're cute--I know you're just playing!  The diversionary tactics can only hold out for so long:  

  

Fifty-fifty chance of being right applies to situations of pure chance only--i.e., if all the people are on equal ground in making uneducated guesses only.  Obviously, people retaining previous knowledge/ exposure/ experience  related to the question will have a greater than fifty percent chance of answering correctly--while those without are stuck at the disadvantaged level of answering correctly purely by chance (fifty-fifty). 

  

Seriously--are you ready to concede on the real point, now?  

 

Message Emote
blank
December 5, 2005, 12:06 pm PST

using your parachute analogy

Quote From: jewelerboy

There are so many confusing issues involved here, Again let me help you get it. 

  

For decades women have wanted equal rights, women have wanted pay equity, the right to own property, the right to vote etc and have all all times and in all issues been seen as equal to men. If Women want to be equal.. then they should " walk the walk".  What you see as " hostility" is actually frustration.  

When a message poster says " he should have worn a condom" to the man who was tricked into pregnancy..what are they (THEY NOT ME)...  are really  saying is no matter what your relationship.. you should not  trust a woman. Let help you more. If SHE says she is on the pill ( and she isnt) some people blame HIM for not being smart enough to protect HIMSELF. Turn the tables for a minute.. when a MAN is sneaky and gets her pregnant you people want to form a lynch mob. 

In that instance you are saying... if SHE lies.. she should be supported.. if HE lies.. the expectation is different. Hence the sarcasm from my dads imaginary speech. The sarcasm was designed to point out the stupid idea of a womans integrity requirement being lower than a mans. Women fought for decades to achieve equality.. but equality is not served "buffet style" you dont get to take it and leave it on a whim. 

My point is if you want to live up to the example set by women who cleared the path for equality, you have to hold women accoutable for their actions.. the same as you do men. 

Everytime I hear somone bleating out " I feel your pain" to either of the women in this show i cant help but wonder why we are not outraged for one woman hijacking a mans life by LYING to him and another woman who seems to be shooting for a record number of " not at all my fault" children. 

It is not mysogonystic.. it is the disparity of consequence that each sex is held to.. despite the assumed want of women to be "equal" to men. 

If you hold men responsible for YOUR uterus how much other responsibility should you give up? 

Again I go back to the parachute.. if you are skydiving will you "just trust someone else" to make sure you have a parachute.. or will you handle that detail yourself? 

Nobody " exerts power" over Mary..Mary allows it.. and for kid two.. three and four.. Mary has trusted someone else to make sure she has a parachute.. she should stop skydiving. Clearly hers is an unfortunate situation, but she needs to either leave him.. or find a way of preventing pregnancy. 

BTW I do not remember ANYONE controlling Mary's use of Birth control as you alluded to . 

I am not stubbornly refusing to "see or consider any other aspect" I would hope that all people in this world find a way of being treated equally, those that hope to advance womens rights in this world should stop trying to make it okay for a woman to abdicate her responsibility for her fertility and should certainly stop the double standard of letting them off the hook for lying to men, while trying to lynch men who lie to women. 

Ya wanna be equal.. start acting equal 

and start holding your "sisters" responsible when they do something you would want to lynch a man for doing. 

It happened to me.  

I was a stockbroker in a firm in Toronto we a hired a brokerage assistant and she was " like all of us"..  what I mean about this is we are all degreed, backgrounds in economics etc, we hire a staff member who like us handles millions of dollars a week in client funds.. all of us trustable with our word as our bond. The assistants term with us is finished and we decide to "go out". Remenber again, this woman has held herself out as trustworthy.. and claims to have the same goals and carreer hopes as the rest of this office. I ask about birthcontrol proir to ANY horizontal position and I am assured of her use of the pill. Remember.. she is a professional 25 plus year old in a professional business peer group.. so I trust her.  Why?? because it never occoured to me that a woman was somehow less trustworthy than a man. She calls my secretary and says " If we let men make these kind of decisions there would be no children" and "once he sees the baby he will be fine" The only time she could find the time to tell me she lied was after it was too late. So now I get to pay her for her lies.. which meant i could not afford to have children of my own.  Further something about her uterus functioning led her to believe that it was okay to try to force herself into my life, she called my parents, would hang around my house when i was not home .. told her story to my neighbours etc and treats me like I owe her something.  I had to have the police remove her from my front steps twice. 

The woman who says " it takes two" needs to understand.. it only takes one who is lying. 

the women who condone this type of action do very little to advance the cause of women as trustworthy responsible people who should be treated equally in all aspects of life. 

Hope I did not sound too "dense" or stubborn..what happend to me was totally unfair and derailed my life to the point of suicide.. and it happens every day.. and women are not too outraged by it apparently. 

  

  

Jewelerboy, 

  

You held onto HER, relying on her parachute during the jump--while not wearing a parachute of your own.  Halfway down the fall, she says, "Oh, this is just a knapsack."  Had you been wearing your own parachute (condom!), her knapsack would not have been a failure to you. 

  

Every talk about birth control that I have ever heard (by professional health care providers and safe sex proponents) says USE TWO FORMS OF BIRTH CONTROL.  Anything less is still risky--even with the best of intentions. 

  

Now, mind you, I am not pointing fingers about your stupidity--or carelessness.  I made the same mistake (i.e., When my partner insisted on no birth control, I did not initially hold my ground to protect myself).  I do, however, take responsibility for the choice I made that contributed to the outcome (unplanned pregnancy). 

  

If my ex- entered into another relationship with a woman, he would repeat all his same old behaviors that destroyed our union no matter how hard he tried to hold on.  He won't accept responsibility for more than just the smallest of his behaviors being a problem.  I do accept the mistakes I made (big and small) and, therefore, am in a better position to change them for future.  I hope you are able to take the same open, honest look at your own mistakes/ contributions and legitimately learn from them. 

  

This woman's lying to you (manipulation & control) was despicable, no question about it.... My ex-husband's manipulation, control, and other abuse of me (including sleep-sex rape) was/ is also despicable.  These things are outrageous, all, and should not be perpetrated or tolerated by anyone--regardless of gender.   

  

Realize that your situation should not be generalized to defame all women and/ or the women's rights issues.  WOMEN'S RIGHTS ISSUES ARE REALLY HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUES.  [Or, to quote my coffee mug, "Feminism is the radical notion that women are people."]   

  

Despite the crap my ex-husband has put me through (in some cases, still puts me through), I do not believe that all--or even most--men would be like this.  On the contrary, I believe most men would have a better grasp on how to treat another human being with respect and be willing to at least consider the consequence of their own actions to the other person (male or female).   

  

I do not allow myself to generalize my negative feelings toward him to men as a whole.  I do, however, let this previous life lesson lead me to be more cautious--on multiple levels--in how I deal with men  (including holding my ground--about birth control, among other things).  TWO FORMS.  Anything less is still being risky. 

  

  

 
First | Prev | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | Next | Last