Message Boards

Topic : 01/18 "Fighting Over the Will"

Number of Replies: 374
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Tuesday, November 22, 2005, 03:25:43 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Airdate: 11/29/05) When you imagine receiving an inheritance, you might dream that all your financial problems would be solved. But sometimes, the money is more trouble than it's worth. Eighty-four-year-old Aileen inherited a 2,000-acre farm after her husband died. But is her granddaughter, Amber, jumping the gun by wanting her mother's name on the title now? Then, Tracy says her 19-year-old son, Mark, changed when he came into a large inheritance this year after his dad passed away. She says the money wasn't what changed her son, but his long-lost friend, Brandon. Talk about the show here.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More January 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
January 19, 2006, 6:29 pm PST

Responce to uraura

Quote From: uraura

HI 

Your idea sound good in theory, but the reality is that many people don't do this.  Your assessment of Dr Phil's response is one the money.  

  

My parents included and they have a  small estate of about 500,000.  My parents didn't deal with any of these issues until both of them were not competent and my well meaning sister  and kids(adult kids) helped themselves and  to all of their assets. 

  

Believe me if there is any money involved then the  one that is the most greediest and selfish will find away to get it.   

  

My parents created a will, when I would say they both were still "with it", but well meaning sis change it to a trust and my parents home, which was suppose to be divided by the five of us, is locked up for 20 years after they pass.  

  

So believe me even if parents try to do the right thing, there will be someone that will try to get it all.  I know for a fact.  I am living it now.  My sister does not want to use the estate money for my dad with dementia, she leaves him home alone and sees no problem.  Also, has taken it upon her self to be the beneficiary of all the annuities, insurance policies and trustee of the trust.  Sometimes a small about of knowledge can be dangerous.   

Sorry you had these problems with your family which goes to show that wills, etc. need to be done 

so they are air tight and filed with the state so there is a record. You are right that most people do not have the proper documents and don't think about doing so until something happens, which, by that time, it's too late.  

  

Have you thought about taking your sister to court so at least what is left of your parents money is 

under a courts supervision. That might stop her from spending it all. Also, you might be able to recover some of what is due to the 5 of you. 

  

I find it amazing what people, who are supposed to love one another, do to each other when there is money involved. 

  

This kind of thing happened to to cousins of mine and caused damage that will never be set right. 

  

All one can do it try to get it right, I guess. 

 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
hopeful
January 19, 2006, 7:02 pm PST

The daughter's situation is similiar to my own

I too have lived with my mother for over 20 years and know the feeling of control the daughter, Davene talks about.  However, I am from an alcoholic family (the adult child of an alcoholic - my mother) and am in Alanon.  I use to feel the way Davene feels and had the resentment the granddaughter, Amber has, but by working the 12 steps of AA applied to the non-drinking adult children of alcoholics (Ala-non) I have been able to surmount much of those old feelings of resentment and being controlled by my mother.  Alcoholism is a disease which my mother suffers from and I suspect that this family might also suffer from alcoholism itself, as the symptoms of their family is almost exactly like mine.  When ala-non says adult children, it means exactly that;  often adult children are almost invoked into living with their parents AS CHILDREN EVEN THOUGH THEY'RE ADULTS.  It is one of the uncontrollable EFFECTS OF ALCOHOLISM.  I agree with Dr. Phil that the inheritance has very little to do with this family's problems. 

  

Since recovering enough in Alanon to be able to see this, it has really helped me to detach with love from my alcoholic situation, forgive my mother and am starting to see that she is just as much a victim of this disease as I am.  She didn't choose to be an alcoholic with that particular controlling type of behavior.  And the result is that I no longer feel such resentment and helplessness and have actually started to form a good relationship with my mother.  We both are much happier now and starting to actually enjoy each others company, something I thought would never happen! 

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 20, 2006, 4:49 am PST

Fighting to be fair

I don't understand how these people can claim to love each other, when obviously for them it's all about the "stuff". Having gone through a lot of deaths in the past 3 years, the "stuff" is unimportant. I would give up all of my inheritances to have the people back, in an instant. When my aunt died in June, her will split her estate into 6 parts - my mother, my uncle (her brother), myself and my 3 siblings. Because my mother had predeceased her, we 4 siblings inherited my mother's portion, so we each got another 1/4 of 1/6 of her estate, meaning my uncle got less than the rest of us. My sister felt badly for him, since he had done so much for his sister while she was alive (not that we hadn't also, but it seemed the bulk of it fell onto him because he is retired and was available during the day), so at Christmas time she gave him an evelope with $1500. However, there had been quite a saga with my Aunt's diamond earrings being lost, almost burned up with the garbage, then found, so at Christmas we also each got an envelope from my Uncle with "The Saga Of Aunt Flo's Earrings" and the whole story retold and for each of us a cheque for $500.00, that to compensate for the appraised value of the earrings which they had had re-set. There was really no need for them to do that, we all expected them to keep the earrings anyway, so there is an example of the opposite of what a lot of families seem to go through. It's called caring about your family, not the "stuff".
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
January 20, 2006, 7:53 am PST

I agree

Quote From: ckobza

That wonderful grandmother owns her farm. She's cared for it all her life. My advice to her? Give the farm to someone other than her daughter. Her daughter and granddaughter are rude and insensitive. There are worthy organizations and people who would take wonderful care of her farm AND respect her wishes. Those women are not entitled to the farm simply because they were born in that family. If grandmother wants a wonderful way to give her farm to a worthy cause, have her contact me.
 I totally agree with you, they are not entitled to anything just because they were born, if I had a child that  was that disrespectful I certainly would not reward her with that inheritance. I would give it to charity, I think they would appreciate alot more. The granddaughter only sides with her mother because she is looking out for interest as well when her mother becomes elderly. Even if I had issues with my mother i would not of said what her daughter said if front of the world, she could of gotten the same help from Dr Phil with putting her mother down. Shame on those girls!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 20, 2006, 9:21 pm PST

01/18 "Fighting Over the Will"

Quote From: judyblue22

Would that POA be legal in Canada without the signature of the daughter who supposedly would be named in the document?  

In Canada, the person who is granting a power of attorney has to sign the document in front of a lawyer.  The appointed attorney doesn't have to sign anything.   

  

In my office, if a client has granted someone a power of attorney and has lost capacity, the appointed attorney would come to my office and show me their identification and prove that the granter had lost capacity (usually with a letter from their doctor) and then I would give the attorney the document. 

  

How would they know it was the correct person if they did not have the signature with which to compare it?  

Banks and the Land registry office all require proper identification from an attorney. 

Judyblue22, I think you misunderstood what I was asking. I was not asking whether the attorney had to sign the document. In the US the person to whom the POA is being granted has to sign. I guess I assumed that she had granted the POA to her daughter but I couldn't figure how she had done that without her daughter's signature, since her daughter denied having seen any such document. However, she may have granted the POA to someone else--perhaps her lawyer. That would explain my confusion. Thanks for your response.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
January 20, 2006, 11:59 pm PST

Fighting Over The Will

This show proved to me how materialistic some people can be.  I couldn't believe how this daughter and grand-daugther were treating this poor lady.  Come on, why would someone constantly want to hear about what their family wants when they die! 

  

Six years ago, my family had to make the hard decision of placing my grandmother in a nursing home due to her illnesses.  I lived with my grandmother the majority of my life.  Basically, she was my mother.  My grandmother was not a wealthy person, therefore, her home had to be sold.  My aunt called me and asked me what I wanted of my grandmother's things...I told her nothing.  I couldn't bear taking my grandmother's things when she was still alive.  They were her things. 

  

So to see this show, it broke my heart.  I can't believe that they won't just leave the mother alone and let her do what she wants.  So what if they have to pay an inheritance tax.  It's not theirs until she's gone anyway.   

  

Honestly, I don't see how some people sleep at night. 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2006, 9:02 am PST

Message for judyblue22

Judy,

Please check your email account that you registered this username with.

Thanks,
DrPhilboard1
Lead Moderator
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2006, 4:30 pm PST

01/18 "Fighting Over the Will"

Quote From: babygirl74

 Why can't the 19 year-old just grow up? Just because you inherited some money, doesn't mean your ego has to be so high that you have no idea as to what you're doing. My mom tried to protect me for so long that when I moved out, I had to learn about the world the hard way. I don't wish that on anyone. I think that the mom needs to leave the son alone, and when he comes to his senses, sooner or later, he'll realized that life is not about money, and the way the he's spending it is showing how responsible he really is.
I am wavering between naming my son, now 22, as beneficiary on my life insurance because he is a drug addict, and I'm afraid he will just blow the money on drugs., and my husband, who swears he would give my son money to live on, but not all of it to kill himself with.  By the time I croak, he may be clean and sober, in which case I would want him to have the money, or he might be in prison or a drug rehab place. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 21, 2006, 8:57 pm PST

Bewildered over the will

I recently lost the last blood relative from my father's side of the family.  My son and myself were his only living blood relatives, as well.  We were fairly close.  His deceased wife's relatives took care of the funeral arrangements.  I found out that they were appointed executors.  Though many non-blood relatives from his deceased wife's side were mentioned in the obituary, and eulogy, my son and I were not acknowledged at all.  Since I did not hear about a will, when I found out one was recorded, I went to the county office to view it.  I was shocked to find that he left his entire estate to his deceased wife's relatives, and didn't leave anything to us (his only blood relatives).  The will was written 2 years ago, 9 years after his wife passed.  It is a handwritten will, but as far as I can tell, the signature looks like his.  The people that he left it to are pretty well off.  My son and I have had many hardships over the past years, and my cousin (first cousin - who died) knew this.  His estate was nearly 3/4 of a million.  I am having a hard time with this.  I love him very much.  And it's not so much about the money (even though a small portion would have turned our lives around), it's that it makes me feel like he didn't care about us anywhere near what I thought - nor anywhere near as much as I did him.  From hearsay, I heard that when his wife was dying, she asked him to leave everything to her side of the family.  Another thing I can't get over.  There was only 2 of us on his side, and so much money.  Oh, and by the way...the form that they had to fill out for Probate that accompanies the will stated that he had no next of kin.  Again, no acknowledgement.
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
angry
January 21, 2006, 11:12 pm PST

I was so mad!!!

Quote From: primchick

This show proved to me how materialistic some people can be.  I couldn't believe how this daughter and grand-daugther were treating this poor lady.  Come on, why would someone constantly want to hear about what their family wants when they die! 

  

Six years ago, my family had to make the hard decision of placing my grandmother in a nursing home due to her illnesses.  I lived with my grandmother the majority of my life.  Basically, she was my mother.  My grandmother was not a wealthy person, therefore, her home had to be sold.  My aunt called me and asked me what I wanted of my grandmother's things...I told her nothing.  I couldn't bear taking my grandmother's things when she was still alive.  They were her things. 

  

So to see this show, it broke my heart.  I can't believe that they won't just leave the mother alone and let her do what she wants.  So what if they have to pay an inheritance tax.  It's not theirs until she's gone anyway.   

  

Honestly, I don't see how some people sleep at night. 

When I watched this show I was amazed on how the mother and daughter were treating that elderly lady (grandma)  You selfish little snags!!!  It is not thier estate, it is not thier money, its non of thier buisness what grandma does with her money!!!  Be happy that you two were even thought of when it was time to make up the will.  If I was Grandma I would take those two off the will and give it all to charity or something.   I was very proud of Grandma for keeping to her decisions and not letting the girls pressure get to her.  YOU GO GRANDMA!! 

As for the next story of the mom being WAY to nosey with her son's inheritance.  Look Lady!! The money is not there for you, It was not intended for you, and you have no right to it!  Yes your son is a little young to be handling all that cash, but  it was left to him.  NOT YOU!!  My feeling on the whole issue is Mom thinks she deserves part of that money.  NOT!!!  keep your grubby hands off it and act like the mature person you are and pay your own way threw life!   Hell we all have had financial difficulties in life,  we all get threw them, and a majority of the people dont steal thier kids money to do it.   

 
First | Prev | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | Next | Last