Message Boards

Topic : 12/08 Extreme Follow-up

Number of Replies: 391
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, December 02, 2005, 03:49:46 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

Dr. Phil checks back in with some of his most explosive guests from this season. Michelle's anger was so intense, her family lived in constant fear of her temper. She was screaming obscenities at her husband, Jamey, and yelling at her daughters until they were physically sick. Jamey said her anger was so bad, he frequently considered divorce. Was Michelle able to get her rage under control? Plus, Cathy and Micki were constantly feuding with their half-sister, Hollie, over painful memories of being molested by their stepfather, Hollie's dad. Hollie was stuck in the middle and wanted her sisters to forgive her father. Were they able to end the bitterness and start the healing process? Join the discussion.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More December 2005 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 13, 2005, 12:23 pm PST

You are wrong

Quote From: pnthrfntic

If you think finding another therapist is the answer.......you need to talk to DR PHIL!!!!! You are so judgemental and have so much to say but you are not really watching the show you are posting about. Pathetic is you not me. Let me see if I can put this in STUPID TERMS FOR YOU TO UNDERSTAND......we do not have a vehicle AT ALL!!!!! We use my fathers vehicle to get back and forth to where we need to go. As far as another therapist....hahahhaha this is the one Dr. Phil is having me go to. Its not like I can pick who I want to see each week. Yes you can sit here and say excuses, excuses, excuses but the reality of it all is I do not have a choice in who I see. You dont have to have sympathy for me nor do you have to post messages on this board either. That is your choice. And no Dr Phil did not say "I would sleep there" I DID!!!!!!!! It is obviously painful to read a response from a person who does not know how to keep track of time and has the gull to degrade someone of your nature. HMMMMMM how do I put this in a way you can understand time.....If it takes an hour to drive to the therapist in a car......and I leave at 9am to get there for a 10am appt, and a bus takes 2-3 hours I dont know about you or the clock you go bye but that is not posssible. 

Anyway, thank you so much for posting and showing the world you are just as niave as you appear to be.  

Much appreciated. 

I just  re-watched the show and IT WAS NOT YOU WHO SAID YOU WOULD SLEEP THERE!!! IT WAS DR PHIL.  As far as being naive and whatever else you say, I"m not the one with the completely screwed up life.   Lots of people don't have cars and make their life work.  Just more excuses for not doing the very hard work that is required to change behavior. 
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 13, 2005, 12:36 pm PST

Wrong again

Quote From: musicman

Who are you?  I mean where exactly are you coming from?  How exactly do you know when my kids start school?  Are you a time management expert?  Come on.  For starters,  can you tell me when her therapist has openings?  She must have lied when she told us that was the only openings she had.  (by the way this is the therapist Dr. Phil sent us to)  Which leads to my next comment.  Find another therapist?  Thats right. I forgot it was now socialy acceptable to tell those who are trying to help you how to help you.  I should have stood up and asked if  we have a choice of who we see.  Give me a break.  you said "you would find a way" right?  Don't ya think by writing the show and going through all of this IS FINDING A WAY?  Of course not.  Thats where you would say something along the lines of " seems like you want everyone else to fix things"  My responce to you is, in this case, YES we needed help from someone else because the previous doctors that we saw did nothing for her.  As for things making sence to you..................  I careless if things make sence to you.  Just a few questions for you though.  Do you have children?  What mode of transportation do you take to and from work?  Or do you even work?  Are you even married?  I'm sure the others you blasted on here are dying to know those answers as am I.  I mean please feel free to post your life on here.  I'll be more than happy to point out your flaws and faults.  You seem pretty comfortable doing it to us.  Just in case you are wondering who I am and why I feel the need to post my opinions here,  this is JAMEY.  The husband and father of this family.  So please feel free to start back up with the ranting and raving as much as you would like because the way I see it is if you are here doing it to us then we may just be saving the self esteme of the "McDonalds" worker you would probably bash otherwise.  And if not them, then anyone else im sure you encounter on the path to your perfect existance. 

Yes you did go on the show for help but have excuses for not utilizing the help offered.  You were the one going on tv with your problems so why are you soooo surprised that I am commenting.  Also, seems like you have a little rage problem too -   we may just be saving the self esteme of the "McDonalds" worker you would probably bash otherwise.  And if not them, then anyone else im sure you encounter on the path to your perfect existance.   Making assumptions aren't you?  I have worked hard to change things in my life but as I've said before It's Easier To Do Nothing!   p.s.  Several people called you the hands-off dad - that wasn't me
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
happy
December 13, 2005, 4:35 pm PST

Michelle

I would just like to say that I am impressed with Michelle and her husband...it takes a lot of courage to admit you need help and to open yourself up to the critism and unfortunately, judgement of others.  I applaud you...I know the pain and guilt of looking back at your own mistakes and saying to yourself, "How could I have done that?!?!?!"  You, your husband and your girls should all be proud of  yourselves for making this investment in your family's wellbeing. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 13, 2005, 6:14 pm PST

Valleb

  

Wow!  You may be justified in a lot of what you say but what is the point of kicking someone while they are down??  It is just so mean to do that.  Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.  Especially when someone comes out on TV and makes it very publicized.  But WOW!!  I don't know how else to say it,  but to say that you are unprovoked and never the less down right nasty.  And the way that you peck at this poor family who has enough to deal with without adding to it makes me feel compelled to sheild them from this relentless attack that you have bestowed upon them.  

  

I ask that  you  stop bulling them and let them try and heal.  

  

I am sure that I have now provoked some of your meaness on to myself but I prefer that you lash out at me instead of them. 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 13, 2005, 8:23 pm PST

Nasty?

Quote From: lucabella

  

Wow!  You may be justified in a lot of what you say but what is the point of kicking someone while they are down??  It is just so mean to do that.  Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.  Especially when someone comes out on TV and makes it very publicized.  But WOW!!  I don't know how else to say it,  but to say that you are unprovoked and never the less down right nasty.  And the way that you peck at this poor family who has enough to deal with without adding to it makes me feel compelled to sheild them from this relentless attack that you have bestowed upon them.  

  

I ask that  you  stop bulling them and let them try and heal.  

  

I am sure that I have now provoked some of your meaness on to myself but I prefer that you lash out at me instead of them. 

what exactly is sooo nasty?  The truth is "that poor family" is ruining their children.   It is not a "relentless attack"  just responses to THEIR posts.  They make numerous excuses why she cannot go to therapy no car, appts only 10 to 1 pm, I say get another therapist that is closer/better hours and they go ballistic!  GET REAL    Michelle says she is this way because of HER CHILDHOOD.  What exactly is she doing to her kids?  This "poor family"  has to live with her parents who abused her, I suggested that she get a job to have the $$$ to move, well, can't do that either.  No daycare, car, yada yada yada.  If they wanted to change things they would do anything, I repeat, anything YES EVEN RIDE A BIKE TO WORK to make it happen.  Why can't Michelle work in the evenings while her husband watches the children?   Again, excuses, excuses, excuses. 

  

I have not posted anything nasty (while you and they on the other hand HAVE).  You need to go back and reread ALL POSTS.  Especially from Michelle and Jamey.  I stated the facts that it is easier to do nothing and make excuses.  But nothing is going to change unless the do THE VERY HARD WORK INVOLVED.   Seems to me that they are very defensive for people who asked Dr Phil for help, then can't follow through with the treatment offered and instead give excuse after excuse all the while it is their kids, and any poor stranger that happens to be in the path of Michelle's rage who suffer.  

  

GIVE ME A BREAK and GROW UP.  THESE PEOPLE ARE SUPPOSED TO BE ADULTS.  Who  is protecting their kids.  Seems to me they (and you) need a reality check. 

  

You do not know me nor do you have a clue as to all the hours I volunteer helping others, but they seem to want sympathy and a magic wand waived.  Life is not easy, believe me, I have suffered deaths of children, illness, job loss, etc. but the only people who can fix this mess is THEM and excuses won't do it.  They got themselves into this mess, ONLY they can get themselves out of it. 

  

 Boy, I will sleep better tonight knowing that you are protecting them - "makes me feel compelled to sheild them from this relentless attack that you have bestowed upon them."  I have not relentlessly attack them, but when she posts that she can't go to therapy because of no car, appts not convenient for her schedule (appts SHE DOES NOT EVEN HAVE TO PAY FOR)  I state the obvious - excuses, excuses, excuses.  If she wanted to change, she would find a way to get to those appts.  What about other moms at the school who, while picking up their own children, pick up hers and watch them for a few hours????  Is this SOOOO HARD????   NO  Meanwhile, who is protecting their children?  Not only from Michelle and Jamey BUT what about the so called abusive parents that made Michelle the way she is??????   Why on Earth would they live with abusive people who made Michelle the way she is???   I would live in a shelter before I exposed my children to that.  Explain that please.  

  

It's funny that they (and you) are so defensive when I am asking the hard questions.  SO much easier to get defensive than to stop and think, but that too is part of the rage problem.  It's called DEFLECTO, turn on the person asking the hard questions and attack them so the actual subject is avoided.  THE SUBJECT IS Michelle's rage and need for treatment and THE CHILDREN AND WHO IS PROTECTING THEM?????  Nothing will change unless therapy is involved.  Yes it is not easy to arrange but where there is a will there is a way.  

  

Since I now have absolutely no sympathy for anyone in this situation except their children, I will not post again on this subject.  Put your defensive rage aside, re-read the posts and look at who the real victims here are.  I rest my case.    

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
December 13, 2005, 8:31 pm PST

I Can Relate

  

I have nearly the same anger issues that she does.  I have always been short tempered since I can remember.  I don't have a problem with physical violence but I do have a problem with verbal violence.  It doesn't matter what you think of me because I don't care (at least that is what I keep telling myself.). 

  

I have very little patience for others and it is usually very obvious  I scream at drivers that I feel don't know how to drive.  I can't stand when people in customer service jobs don't have the first idea how to do their job and I don't have a problem letting them know it.  I have asked some of them, on more than one occasion, "How stupid do you have to be to work here?".   

  

I can't stand co-workers who I feel are only there to collect a paycheck.  I know people are fallible but I probably hold people to a higher standard than I really should.  I can't stand it when my co-workers make stupid mistakes and I am not shy telling them, even when it isn't my place to.  I am hard on myself, too.  I don't like it when I make mistakes, even though I know it is normal.  I hold myself to an abnormally high standard when it comes to my job. 

  

I yell at my kids way too much.  I know I don't yell all the time but to them, it seems like it.  I don't yell at my wife too much because I don't really want to fight with her.  I find it almost impossible to carry on a regular conversation because I am not used to it.  Most of the time, I just don't want to be bothered by anyone else and I let them know.  I seem to consider whatever it is I am doing to be more than important than what they want me to do.  If somebody calls me, let me know whay you want now, now a few seconds from now.  I fell like that if you don't need me now, don't call me now. 

  

I am so angry that nobody wants to be around me.  I guess that is OK because I don't really want to be around others either.  I don't have any friends and haven't had any for several years.  I am pulling myself into my cocoon and trying to close it up.  Anger is the only feeling I have right now.  To me, it is like a cancer that keeps growing larger and larger.  I know it needs to be removed but the 'surgery' will hurt and I don't want to go through the pain. 

  

I fully understand the pain and the feelings she is going through right now.  I have been down the road she is travelling right now.  I hope she is able to become rehabilated and that the things she has done won't scar the kids for the rest of their lives. 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
December 14, 2005, 4:41 am PST

Making great strides with that anger problem

Quote From: pnthrfntic

If you think finding another therapist is the answer.......you need to talk to DR PHIL!!!!! You are so judgemental and have so much to say but you are not really watching the show you are posting about. Pathetic is you not me. Let me see if I can put this in STUPID TERMS FOR YOU TO UNDERSTAND......we do not have a vehicle AT ALL!!!!! We use my fathers vehicle to get back and forth to where we need to go. As far as another therapist....hahahhaha this is the one Dr. Phil is having me go to. Its not like I can pick who I want to see each week. Yes you can sit here and say excuses, excuses, excuses but the reality of it all is I do not have a choice in who I see. You dont have to have sympathy for me nor do you have to post messages on this board either. That is your choice. And no Dr Phil did not say "I would sleep there" I DID!!!!!!!! It is obviously painful to read a response from a person who does not know how to keep track of time and has the gull to degrade someone of your nature. HMMMMMM how do I put this in a way you can understand time.....If it takes an hour to drive to the therapist in a car......and I leave at 9am to get there for a 10am appt, and a bus takes 2-3 hours I dont know about you or the clock you go bye but that is not posssible. 

Anyway, thank you so much for posting and showing the world you are just as niave as you appear to be.  

Much appreciated. 

Gee!  You sure can tell how far you have come with that anger problem by your posts.  *raised eyebrow* 

  

You do not have a choice in who you see?  What is that?  Communist therapy sessions?  Of course you have a choice in who you see as well as if you see anybody at all.  Dr. Phil is not God on High and you can tell him you need a different therapist or no therapist at all.  That you and your husband say you have no choice in the matter is quite funny, imo.   It does sound like excuses just as it did sound like you were pushing the doc for a car on the show.   

  

Last time this show aired your husband logged on as an anonymous user posting all kinds of excuses.  Then you logged on bashing people left and right.  I was giggling when I heard you *itch about the posters on this site.  Im surprised the doc didnt pull up some of your previous posts and let everyone see those.  You were no better then anyone else with your messages and still here you are doing the exact same thing, defending and justifying on this new board.  Hows that for progress?   

  

The only reason you are seeing nicer messages this time around is because the doc showed the boards.  Anytime he does that people log on and say all sorts of different things then what you would normally see on these boards.  I have watched enough Dr. Phil and read the boards long enough to know that.  You should give him a big thank you for that one!   It would also be wise if you were able to find a way to read the boards without responding as you make yourself(so does your hubby)look quite foolish and if you havent changed at all.  Obviously, not the message you desire to send. 

  

  

  

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 14, 2005, 5:22 am PST

Loving you Michelle

Michelle- since I saw the first show I have prayed for you. You need love and support- not negative critism being thrown at you. I understand advice but not all these slurs just being thrown at you. I want you to know there is always hope and I believe you can change. I believe you want to and I pray continually for this to happen for you. I know in your heart you desire to be a good mother. Please don't be discouraged by these nasty comments, keep trying, you CAN change-you CAN make it. I believe in you. It is hard for your kids, yes. Your family needs help yes- but people throwing hate at you helps nothing. So I offer you love and support and want to reach out to help you. You can change and I believe you want to. I believe you love your children. You deserve no less love than any person here, you just need guidance and intervention. Please know I care for you and your family. You are worthy of love and there is always hope- please believe that- you CAN turn this around with the right support, friends, guidance- people who won't quit believing in you. I am one of those people. MANY PRAYERS AND MUCH LOVE TO YOU and YOUR FAMILY
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
giddy
December 14, 2005, 7:32 am PST

12/08 Extreme Follow-up

I did not see the first show but I sure did see the follow up show.  I to pray for you and yes a leapard CAN change its spots if it really wants to.  I am a divorced mom that had a really bad year in 2003.  I too have had counseling and psychiatric care for my anger and other problems that has stemmed from my upbringing.  I too did not know how to deal with my anger and then there would be times that I would become so angry that I would withdraw into myself.  One day it hit a breaking point and I tried to take my own life in front of my newly divorced husband and my then 12 year old daughter.  I took some over the counter pain killers along with a jar of Ibuprofen.  Then I took off driving.  My ex husband the called 911 and I was found and involuntarily committed to a mental ward.  I did receive the care that i desperately needed.  I still see a therapist as needed.  It sure does help.  Do not ever give up. on your self.  YOU CAN change.  But first of all it is like Dr. Phil states,  You have to get away from your parents and make a home for yourself and your family and that is when the healing will start.  I too tried to live with my mother and her negativity and that was not a good idea.  But God Bless my mother she is a totally different person now then she was 20 years ago.  Her and my father are divorced as well.  It took many years but she and my dad and my wonderful step mom can talk on the phone without any arguments or negative words.  So change can happen but it does take a long time at times.  Just keep up the wonderful work that you have started.  Good things doe happen in their own time and in Gods time.  But you will  make it.  It is never easy to change but one can if they really want to and I sincerely believe that you want to.  God Bless and take care. 
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
December 14, 2005, 11:34 am PST

12/08 Extreme Follow-up

Quote From: serenity83

I think Michelle is in need of boot camp she needs to go through harsher treatments she has got to some how seeing how what she is doing is affecting the way her kids are living. The girls need a more postive outlook on life. I think the 2 girls need a change of environment. These girls need damage support they need to be shown that they are loved and wanted and cared for. I can't believe that Dr. Phil Sent her back home to abuse the girls some more.

I agree 100 %. They have live in treatment centers for drug and alcohol problem, there should be some thing for anger management. 

 
First | Prev | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | Next | Last