Message Boards

Topic : 06/19 Pressured Into Marriage

Number of Replies: 234
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, January 06, 2006, 01:42:38 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 01/10/06) Whether from personal guilt or family pressure, many couples rush to the altar – and regret it later. Heather and Jeff were virgins when they started dating. After their relationship started heating up and the two became intimate, Heather feared judgment from her minister father and ran down the aisle. Now their house is filled with resentment. Why is she disappointed with Jeff, and is there hope for their future? Next, Michelle said she had doubts about marrying Steve during her walk down the aisle. Now, nine years later, what is behind the overwhelming conflict in their marriage? Plus, meet two best friends who are plotting to make sure their kids get married. What do the teens think? Whether you're planning a black-tie affair or eloping to Sin City, don't miss what Dr. Phil says you need to know, consider and plan for when making a lifetime commitment. Join the discussion.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 19, 2006, 2:30 pm PDT

06/19 Pressured Into Marriage

Quote From: beaners

 this is my first time writing into dr. phil discussion.  I've been reading over everyones messages and I am currently one of those nieve stupid young people looking into marriage.  I am 21 have a 14 month old son and am scheduled for marriage for june of next year.  Recently I have been debating whether or not this is the right thing to do.  Unfortunetly I don't ever have anyone to talk to that isn't going to have a bias opinion.  I know i love my fiance but i think that there are things that he needs to work on before.  I want to provide a stable and loving home for my child because he is my #1 priority.  my fiance and I just had this conversation the other night when i told him for the first time that i needed more time.  Needless to say it turned into a 2 hour long fight, and he pretty much told me that i shouldn't be questioning anything if i really loved him and that i was threatening him.  Im not exactly sure what to do.  we've tried counseling and then we got engagted and it all seemed to get better for a while after that and then we stopped going.  None of our previous problems have changed even though i have been promised many times that they will.  He said that i should love him for who he is and that i shouldn't be trying to change him.. i am so confused and don't really know where else to turn to.
DO NOT GET MARRIED UNTIL OR UNLESS YOU ARE READY!  If you have doubts, call it off.  If your fiance gets angry, oh well, he gets angry.  Just because you have a child together is absolutely no reason to get married.  Go back to counseling...even if you have to go alone.  If you have problems now and you aren't married, you will still have those same problems later.  The only difference is you will be married.  You're not stupid...you're smart enough to realize that you aren't ready to get married.  Don't let anybody pressure you into a lifetime commitment.  Small problems before a marriage can turn into big problems after a marriage.  It seems to me that you fiance is trying to be controlling...telling you that you wouldn't be questioning anything if you really loved him....You being honest with him about your doubts is not THREATENING him....it's being honest.  If you do not have honesty in a relationship, you will never have a TRUE relationship.  Please go back to counseling.  It's like you know the right thing to do....you just need some support.  Good luck to you.
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
upset
June 19, 2006, 2:32 pm PDT

Pressured into Marriage

Neither one of these marriages stand a chance--I was happy to see you attempt to save them, but when someone expresses the sentiment that they would not have this person in their life if they could turn the clock back--welllllll,  There is no more to be said.  Leave-- the children will be better off.  I knew when I got married the first time I made a hugh mistake, (18)  and I wished everyday I could leave unfortunately by the time I did leave I had two small children.  Luckly that was many years ago.  Life is too short to be miserable. 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
June 19, 2006, 2:39 pm PDT

06/19 Pressured Into Marriage

Quote From: beaners

 this is my first time writing into dr. phil discussion.  I've been reading over everyones messages and I am currently one of those nieve stupid young people looking into marriage.  I am 21 have a 14 month old son and am scheduled for marriage for june of next year.  Recently I have been debating whether or not this is the right thing to do.  Unfortunetly I don't ever have anyone to talk to that isn't going to have a bias opinion.  I know i love my fiance but i think that there are things that he needs to work on before.  I want to provide a stable and loving home for my child because he is my #1 priority.  my fiance and I just had this conversation the other night when i told him for the first time that i needed more time.  Needless to say it turned into a 2 hour long fight, and he pretty much told me that i shouldn't be questioning anything if i really loved him and that i was threatening him.  Im not exactly sure what to do.  we've tried counseling and then we got engagted and it all seemed to get better for a while after that and then we stopped going.  None of our previous problems have changed even though i have been promised many times that they will.  He said that i should love him for who he is and that i shouldn't be trying to change him.. i am so confused and don't really know where else to turn to.
WOW!!! I have never given advice before in this type of forum--but I will say this.  If you are having doubts please and I mean this please don't get married.  Nothing will change if anything it will get worse.  I am not say don't marry him--just right now.  When someone uses emotional blackmails such as you don't love me --run in the opposite direction.  This is a way to force you into doing something you already know is not right.  If he loves you he can wait until you are sure.  Remember it not just about you--its about your child also.  Think about the fact that you want to bring your baby up in a healthy safe environment and not one rocked with instabiity.  People do not magically change because the say "I do".  I hope this helps.
 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
June 19, 2006, 2:48 pm PDT

tough to make it work

I was pressured into marrying a man who I knew down deep I shouldn't marry. We cancelled the wedding 2 times. But in the end he convinced me that he loved me, would be faithful and we would have a great life. He set up a wedding with my two children (6 and 10) and no one else knew. Later I found out he was afraid someone would convince me not to go through it.  I was married 18 years. All 18 years it was so hard. He was unfaithful, he was rude, he was distant. He did not participate in parenting unless forced. We are now divorced. I would have tried and did try to work it out. But he never stepped up to the plate to try to make it right.  I now having gone through a horrible divorce realize how hard each day was. I should have forced the issue to try to fix it or gotten out much earlier.   

If you get that gut instinct to not get married.       DON'T DO IT!  

However, if both people are willing to go to bat and try to make it right, do try! If you don't you will always wonder "what if".  

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 19, 2006, 3:00 pm PDT

06/19 Pressured Into Marriage

Quote From: jim1970

Look, I've been on the other side of this marriage debate.  I'm 36 and have wanted to be married since my teens because I knew I was unable to control my urges. 

  

My untreated A.D.D. made it impossible to have a relationship until my late twenties when I was finally put on Ritalin. 

  

Marriage is a great idea, just don't have children for a very long time.  I think that a married couple should get all of the spontaneity out of their system at first, because once kids come into the picture, life is over.  No more trips to Motel 6 in the middle of the night, or trips to Vegas. 

  

Any woman I end up with must understand that the mere discussion of having children is out of the question for AT LEAST FIVE YEARS.  I want to enjoy her without interruption. 

  

If one doesn't get married in their youth, one tends to become embittered toward the opposite sex due to too many flings and disappointments.  People have bought into the "have fun now, get married later mentality," and look what it gotten us. 

  

Men and women don't trust each other and feel cheated. 

I was 29 when I married. why older? Because before my hubby came along, no one else was good enough! He won my heart in ways that no other ever could and 13 years later, he still wins my heart.................I kept my self honest and pure and accepted myself for who I was and appreciated the fact that I was/am my own individual and when one does this, their self image is a good one and believe me, waiting til the right one comes and knowing without a doubt that they are the one and understanding the real truth that marriage is a life time committement and takes two loving and supportive people to make it happy and successful, no regrets here on waiting and becasue of the fact that I waited, I am happily married and fullfilled with two beautiful little girls............I would encourage every one to follow your hearts and do what is right, know that you are in love with each other and are willing to work together and honest and true, marriage is awesome for those who are in it for the right reasons, the wait can be well worth it.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
June 19, 2006, 3:11 pm PDT

On committment

I am glad Dr. Phil talks about such hard issues. To stay or not to stay really depends on one's view of committment. Heather and Jeff decided to get married out of guilt. I am assuming they are Christian or Jewish. If this is the case, I would encourage them to seek the guidance of a Christian or Jewish counselor who can help them according to their religeous values. I came from a broken home and was my father's pawn and I have found, with the help of my minister, that I am able to reinforce my Christian beliefs and strengthen my marriage on a daily basis. When people say marriage is work, it is. Committment and dedication take time and effort. A pop-psych saying is: you become what you think. If you think you can't maintain a committment, then you won't. So it is a decision based from the thoughts in your head. My prayer for everyone on the show and those reading my message is that they consider their personal values and have the courage to act upon them, even if it means a hard road. Repairing a relationship is a hard road, but if you believe in committment, it is well worth the trouble. Good luck to everyone and God's blessings!
 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
June 19, 2006, 3:16 pm PDT

Go to another country

I just watched your show on pressured into marriage.  I too felt I had to marry.  I was 19 he was 28.  My parents said he was the best one to come around.  Or the only one.  So I married him not wanting to walk down the aisle.  I did.  Then I married him a second time after a divorce.  What was wrong with me.  I was told he will make sure your secure for life.   

   

I just found Mr Right in a different country where man treat woman the way they should.  It doesn't matter what is on the outside but what you share on the inside. Because they don't have what others have had their entire life they appreciate everything they have.  They love like love should be and they have respect and they teach respect and appreciation to their children at a very young age.  I certainly was not pressured into this marriage but it's the one that I would walk down the aisle over and over again.   

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
June 19, 2006, 3:27 pm PDT

ya right

ummmmm im thinking the first two couples are done
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
hopeful
June 19, 2006, 4:08 pm PDT

The real deal

After watching this show I got the impression that Heather had already made up her mind about this marriage. On one hand she said that she was willing to give it a try wheras on the other hand she said she hated her husband.  According to her own words, "she felt guilty after having sex and they decided they needed to get married."  She also said, "that she wanted children".  She also said that she "tended to be impulsive and make impulsive decisions."  This seems to me where the problem lies.  People grow up with this fairy tale belief that the man will sweep them off their feet and take care of them forever.  No where in this fairy tale does it say that a wife is to honor, encourage and respect her husband.  I'm not sticking up for Jeff who had not lived up to his committments either, but the way that they have described their home life and Heather has agreed, is that she has emotionally checked out of the marriage.  Therefore, Jeff see no hope in a future for his family.  No wonder he is not motivated to finish the house? Why bother when there will be no one to live in it! Duh!!  I think Heather needs to "grow up" and stop having a temper tantrum.  She doesn't say if she works or if she is a homemaker.  Is she helping Jeff finish the house.  There are plenty of shows on TV to show women and men how to do home repairs.  I think that if Heather would "check bak in" to the marriage, it would give Jeff renewed hope in a future and he would recognize this as a second chance to do better.  It's all about seeing where each person can be a better person to the other person.  Heather needs to find something to do to feel good about herself.  Jeff needs to grow up and seek a male mentor to help him learn how to lead a family.  Hopefully this male mentor will be someone of good character, integrity and spirituality.  May God bless them both.   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 19, 2006, 4:18 pm PDT

If only life were a guarantee Jim1970

My father died in 1970 when I was 1 month from 5 yrs of age.  My mother was 25 & a widown with 3 children 5 and under.  She graduated high school and she struggled and we did without plenty.  that is why education is important.  No man is guaranteed to be around for life and my mother went plenty of times without eating so we could have something to eat.  So don't tell me how unnecessary education is, a woman should be prepared for life if death should happen to a spouse.
 
First | Prev | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | Next | Last