Message Boards

Topic : 01/12 Racism Experiment

Number of Replies: 226
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, January 06, 2006, 01:48:12 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

Charlie, a self-described racist, struggled with the fact that his daughter was going to have a biracial baby. His insensitive, hate-based thinking tore apart his family. After speaking with Dr. Phil, he agreed to spend some time learning about African-American culture. How did he do when Dr. Phil set him up to live with a black family for two days? And, Dave grew up believing he was white, but found out the family secret when he was 26 - that he was actually biracial. In an effort to heal the pain of being deceived his whole childhood, Dave went public with his story, with disastrous consequences. How can he heal and move on? Plus, Cene is biracial and says her mother accuses her of acting "too white." Should Cene have to choose a race? Share your thoughts.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More January 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 8:04 pm PST

Dr Phil Show.

Charlie Doctor Phil. Charlie I think Doctor Phil is correct and as for black peoples aswell it is ok aswel. Doctor Phil I think you convince Charlie to except black peoples aswell and maybe I kn-- 

ew it all along aswell. Charlie Doctor Phil you did a great job aswell. See you tomorrow Aftern--- 

oon. Well I had better close now. Sincerley Your. Russell 

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
January 12, 2006, 8:20 pm PST

BiRacial Children

      I could have been Charlie's sister and raised in the same household. I was a teenager in the 70's in the south and was taught racial hate in my home growing up. My daughter born in 1977 had a biracial daughter in 1999. I had to come to terms with this fact while being put between my Dad whom I love and my daughter that I love also. The minute Alexis was born she stole my heart and from that moment on I have loved her more than life itself. She is a beautiful sweet 6 year old and all I want to do is be the BEST grandma ever to her. I learned a lot the hard way and could have benefited from a show like today.  I say to anyone out there that is in the same situation and having trouble accepting a biracial baby, please consider that this is an innocent child coming into the world that deserves nothing less than the best family and love.  It does not matter what color the mere skin of the parents happen to be.  Maybe when a couple generations of biracial people are born, just maybe, people will realize that racism is such a waste of time and brain cells. It sounds strange to me  to speak of my granddaughter as biracial because I only see her as my sweet Alexis!!!!! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 8:44 pm PST

Thoughts on Racism

As a 29-year-old African-American female I have had a problem with racism.  Unfortunately most of it has come from my own race. I don't speak Ebonics, do not listen to rap music, or dress "ghetto fabulous" yet I'm discriminated by my own race because they feel I act too "white". First let me say that I was not brought up in a suburban or ethnically diverse neighborhood. I grew up in "the hood" all of my neighbors are African-American as well.  I feel very fortunate and lucky to have parents that taught me that there is more to life then my neighborhood. Music was my first taste of that. My father was a guitar player and while we listened to R&B favorites like Earth, Wind and Fire, James Brown and Parliament I was also exposed to Rock like Aerosmith, Led Zeppelin, Queen, and Pink Floyd. My parents believed that you need to know how to communicate and interact with EVERYONE regardless of color or race and to be proud of my heritage. 

  

One of the most important things that my parents especially my mother has taught me is that people DO see color and ethnicity and some people believe that some ethnic groups are inferior to others. That is unfortunate. I don't believe that people should be color blind because that creates a sense of a "we are all the same" ideology that don't believe is correct. Everyone no mater what ethnicity or color should be proud of your heritage. I don't believe that dating outside your race or having friends of another race makes you hate your own race. Some people I think believe that about me. I for one I'm very proud to be African-American and believe that everyone else should be proud of who they are too. But, being proud of one's race shouldn't go to the point of thinking that someone else's race is inferior and not worthy of respect  which I believe is the true problem of racism. Once you believe that someone is inferior it leads the way to stereotypes and abuses. I think that you should be proud of who you are and RESPECT other races for who they are too. I like to think of the world more like a beautiful array of colors than just colorblind. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 8:46 pm PST

Experiment is bogus!

Dr. Phil,  I'm sorry but your experiment is outside the real world.  The black comedian and his family was not representative of most of the black culture in America.  First off, the man is still married to his wife.  Second he is rich.  He may be black, but he probably doesn't live like very many intercity blacks.  How many newborn black children have a father living at home in 2006? Case in point: Where is the father of Charlie's granddaughter?   What if you had sent Charlie to New Orleans to live with some of those people we saw looting during hurricane Katrina?  What if you had sent him to Harlem in New York City to just "hang" in the hood".  He may be dead or at least a victim of crime. The problem is not those blacks who have jobs and families and live normal American lives.  It's the huge part of that culture that is unemployed, into crime, generationally on welfare and has no moral values in the sexual realm.  I'm not racist because of the color of their skin, but I may qualify because I don't like or feel that I should appreciate their poverty mentalities, lawlessness and immorality.

Granted Caucasians are not perfect either.  Many of them have the same problems.  But why are prisons full of predominantly black men?  Why are more illegitimate black children born than white?  The point is your show did not represent reality.
 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 9:37 pm PST

people are people

 I am a Hispanic woman. I don't consider myself bi-racial even though I am. My mom is white and my dad is mexican. I was born in ElPaso, Texas. We moved to missouri when I was 3 years old. When I was about 22 years old I moved back to live with my dad who had moved back there when he and my mom seperated. When I started working I was confronted with alot of questions and I had never experienced that. It  wasn't the fact that I look white it was more along the lines that I have a spanish last name, but can't speak spanish. They didn't understand it, and when I explained that when we moved my dad didn't teach it to me and my brother and sister because he thought that we didn't need to know since we lived in missouri. I think they were mad and thought that I didn't think that part of my life wasn't very important. I was angry at my dad for putting me in that position. Even one of my uncles scolded my dad for keeping part of our heretiage away from us. And yes he regretted it. I wish I could learn but it is so hard. I lived in Elpaso for about 6 years. There I met my daughter's dad who is 100% mexican. I don't know how to teach her, her heritage since I don't know spanish. I don't want to make the same mistakes that my dad did. I am angry that the elementary schools here don't teach foreign languages. It is so much easier to learn when you're a kid than when you're an adult.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 9:54 pm PST

01/12 Racism Experiment

It is an interesting coincidence that this show should air on the same day a fight broke out at my school between two students. The two students were part of the growing population of Hispanic-Americans on my island. It was a pretty bad fight from what I heard, one of them ended up with what looked like a broken nose. A few months early I had to step in between two girls, both Hispanic-Americans, when one of them positivley charged the other and started attacking her (it was a girl fight, they were slapping and pulling hair, no one was in danger of getting hurt, I just couldn't stand the utter immaturity of it). That same girl that started a fight seem to have a reputation of getting up in peoples faces and getting aggressive. I tell my dad about these incidences and his response is always the same, "Latinos tend to be hot tempered". I live in a small community with a small yet wonderfull school system where fights in which fights like the one between the two boys are extremley rare. It would be easy for me to be upset at this newly arrived group of people for disturbing the peace of my small school. But I have to remind myself that the older brother of the girl who gets into fights had told her to cool it and tried to herd her away before she started the fight that I had to break up. I have to look away from the troublemakers and focus on the Latino kids in my school who have never caused any of the commotion the others have. I remember that, throughout my life, every time I have gotten to know someone, no matter how unpleasent they seemed at first, I am always able to find at least a little good in even the most unfriendly seeming of characters. I know these kids are no different than me, they are mindful of their classes and schoolwork, they have boyfriends and girlfriends, they hang out with their buddies, they have interests and, they are about as "hot-tempered" as anyone else. And, just like me, they have time left to grow, mature, and develop into happy, productive people. No matter what, we are all Americans, and America stands for tolerance and freedom and individuality. It is who you are as an individual that counts, nothing else ought to matter.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 10:18 pm PST

01/12 Racism Experiment

No matter how hard we try, no matter what we do, racism will always exist. However, each individual can make a significant difference in society by acceptng others for who they are. I am mixed with Korean and Irish and find that being mixed gives me the best of both worlds. As a teacher, I've seen unnecessary fights between Latinos and Blacks, Whites and Asians, whatever. The point is, no matter our skin color, we still bleed red.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 10:36 pm PST

wrong thinking

Quote From: illneptune

It still amazes me when I see and hear so many people who don't realize the sort of world we are living in today.

We are still bleating on and whining about supposed "racism"? The father on the show has every right to be angry and furious with his daughter and it has nothing to do with hating other people. Maybe he's angry that his daughter just threw away her heritage and culture thereby effectively discontinuing one "branch" of his family. Perhaps he's also upset over the fact that his daughter's selfish behaviour just robbed a child of its identity. It is neither Black or White and one can't be both.  Listen to the story of the man who just found out he's "biracial." Children such as this are often forced to choose a "side" and they still aren't fully accepted. Why bring a child into such suffering?

So here is a man who is branded a racist, because he wants to preserve his culture and heritage. He wants his family to look like he does! God forbid he desire a perfectly natural thing like that! How hateful of him to be angry with his daughter, who just threw away how many thousands of years of evolution? Even though the father and the daughter are ordinary people, they still have the blood of the people who built the modern world. White people should remember that. We have a fantastic heritage and we shouldn't throw it away on the sick fad of multiculturalism.

I fully expect to be called a "racist" here. It doesn't matter because it's nothing more than an attack word for people who have no argument? Why? Because the word can't be defined. It's too general. What may be a "racist" thought, word or action to one person...may not be "racist" at all to another person. So have at it.


 I have never heard the term marxist. The truth is i don't think that it is right to call people with different heritages bi-racial. People are people that's all there is to it. My mom is Polish and my dad is Mexican. I also have a sister who is half black and half white. You are entitled to your opinion however you're way of thinking is wrong. I am not just saying that because it is my opinion, but also because of what it says in the bible. In god's eyes predjustice is sinful. I am not going to call you a racist, you just don't know. You can't help who you fall in love with. You talk about the world we live but  the truth is that not very many people today are concerned about bi-racial issues and as time go on less and less people will consider it an issue. Then people like you will have to deal with it. God does'nt judge us on the color of our skin so why should we. If I were you I would be more concerned that the condition of your heart is acceptable to God. People are people and that is that.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 10:43 pm PST

To Charlie

I want to say that Charlie has been a great inspiration. I used to believe that someone who has grown up around racism and been racist all their life would be incapable of understanding tolerance. Charlie certainley proved me wrong! He not only learned to tolerate African Americans, he learned to love them. What really moved me is when he became so overwhelmed by all the love and happieness he was feeling and being surrounded with that he was brought to tears. Charlie, your joy brings me joy.  

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 12, 2006, 11:29 pm PST

peace and harmony

Quote From: mdaniels79

No matter how hard we try, no matter what we do, racism will always exist. However, each individual can make a significant difference in society by acceptng others for who they are. I am mixed with Korean and Irish and find that being mixed gives me the best of both worlds. As a teacher, I've seen unnecessary fights between Latinos and Blacks, Whites and Asians, whatever. The point is, no matter our skin color, we still bleed red.
 Racism will not always exist. There will be a time when we live in complete peace and harmony. I am mixed with Mexican and Polish and I have a sister who is mixed with Polish and African-American. Although I have not seen or been a part of what you have seen and experienced being a teacher. My highschool didn't have those problems. There were blacks there, but most of them were Popular with both blacks and whites. Read Revelation 21:4 and Isiah 11:7 and then pray about it. It might help you to know that even though these things exist today that they won't always exist. And that we do have a hope for the future!
 
First | Prev | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | Next | Last