Message Boards

Topic : 01/16 Honeymoon's Over Follow-up

Number of Replies: 191
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, January 13, 2006, 02:16:30 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

They’re newlyweds, married only a short time, and already they're headed for divorce court. First, Michelle says she's not the only woman in her marriage. Her husband, Matthew, has many female friends whom she has never met. Should he give them up or did she make a promise she can't keep? Then, when Marlon and Shamika first appeared on the show, they were eight months newly wed and were on the verge of becoming newly divorced because of their constant fighting. Did they put Dr. Phil's advice to work and have things changed? Share your thoughts.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More January 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Good

Message Emote
upset
January 16, 2006, 4:46 pm PST

Matthew & Michelle

Michelle made a mistake when she said it was okay for him to keep his female friends after marriage.  These women don't want to be her friend because if they did they would have come to the wedding and made every effort to meet Michelle.  Matthew, What are you thinking????!!!!  How would he feel if Michelle had male friends that she visited during the day and he did not know them?  Michelle should get some self esteem and quit thinking that because Matthew is so good looking that she has to take a back seat to his friendships.  Michelle is the wife.  Not those woment and those women don't and won't like her.  They all probably have feelings for him and would love to see her be insecure and leave the marriage.  Matthew should listen to his momma and put his wife's feelings first.  I did not like the way he defended that other woman who went to school and worked and could not meet Michelle. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 16, 2006, 4:50 pm PST

nights

Shamika get off of the night shift.  You need to be home with your man.  Getting a night job does not make the situation any better. 
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
January 16, 2006, 4:50 pm PST

Happy, Unhappy, Confused

Shanika really cannot be happy for too long until she catches on to the fact that appreciating her husband takes nothing away from her and her abilities. As a matter of fact, as she understands about appreciating him, it equally says a lot about her choices.  

Submission is hard for her because she constantly has to affirm to herself that she can do things without the help of a man. She doesn't understand that submission is not a nasty word but is one of the most freeing things in a marriage. Submission does not equal weak.  Just in case Shamika might happen to read this message, a super book written by a woman (Bunny Wilson) in California on submission is called Liberated through Submission. It definitely keeps us secure as wives and adds to our strength.  

Marlon also has to know that he cannot be all that makes Shamika happy. Yes, by all means be the best husband and continue to give the 100% but Shamika's happiness is not rolled into one ball called Marlon. That's why the rules keep changing on what makes her happy about him. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
hopeful
January 16, 2006, 5:03 pm PST

There maybe hope for us yet

I originally had no intentions of getting on this message board, but like some other people, I couldn't stay silent.  This was an insightful show.  It reminds us that we need to take others feelings into consideration.  We cannot just expect people to make us happy.   

The one thing I did not see in any of the postings is the possiblity that Shamika my not actually love Marlon.  This may be because she difficulty loving herself.  Does this excuse her from her actions?  Definitely not, but it does give us all a chance to look carefully at ourselves.  This way if we have a little bit of Shamika's mentality, we need to correct it in ourselves.   

Michelle does have cause to be concerned, if Matthew doesn't.  It is easy to get pulled into something you had not counted on because you "resolve" has been worn away by kindness.  Anyone, male or female, has to be careful how his/her needs (primarily emotional) are being met.  If it is by someone other than your spouse, or the person you are currently dating, you are setting yourself up for trouble. 

  

Thanks for today's show and this forum Dr. McGraw 

  

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
confused
January 16, 2006, 5:11 pm PST

Shamika Does Not Love Marlon

Quote From: shimosan

I originally had no intentions of getting on this message board, but like some other people, I couldn't stay silent.  This was an insightful show.  It reminds us that we need to take others feelings into consideration.  We cannot just expect people to make us happy.   

The one thing I did not see in any of the postings is the possiblity that Shamika my not actually love Marlon.  This may be because she difficulty loving herself.  Does this excuse her from her actions?  Definitely not, but it does give us all a chance to look carefully at ourselves.  This way if we have a little bit of Shamika's mentality, we need to correct it in ourselves.   

Michelle does have cause to be concerned, if Matthew doesn't.  It is easy to get pulled into something you had not counted on because you "resolve" has been worn away by kindness.  Anyone, male or female, has to be careful how his/her needs (primarily emotional) are being met.  If it is by someone other than your spouse, or the person you are currently dating, you are setting yourself up for trouble. 

  

Thanks for today's show and this forum Dr. McGraw 

  

 I agree with the statment that Shamika probably does not love Marlon.  They did not have a chance to find out if they loved each other before jumping into a life together.  Shamika never once said she loved him, only that he was a good provider.  I think that is why Marlon looked so sad.  He said he loved her.  I wish I had a "Marlon" in my life. 
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
January 16, 2006, 5:28 pm PST

Very sad for Marlon

Well I agree with the majority of the board about Shameeka. 
 

When Marlon said something about feeling like crying and people in the audience laughed, I wanted to cry myself.   

  

Everyone has already said it all.  I am a 47 year old woman, married for 27 years with three daughters and believe me I would let my daughters know if they were/are treating a mad badly, just ask my daughters.... ha ha.  Equally I would let them know if I thought they needed to stand up for themselves a little more (actually I would probably say something to the guy too!) 

  

I understand wanting to be equal and liberated and strong and all that, but c'mon Shameeka, you don't want to give at all.  I didn't quite understand the thing about the car, but from reading other posts, Shameeka didn't want to go get something he asked her for out of the car?  Okay, then do NOT expect him to do the same for you.  She doesn't want a KING, she wants a slave. 

  

Marriage is give and take and sometimes you give more than you take.   

  

I hope Marlon and Shameeka are reading these boards.  Shameeka WAKE UP!  Marlon, hang in there, hopefully she will get it.  Be careful not to take advantage when she does, but be grateful and stay the changed loving man you appear to be.    Only then can you two truly have a great marriage.  Be grateful and respect each other. 

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 16, 2006, 5:29 pm PST

Shamika is a golddigger

 When Marlon said that "she was thugged out" he hit the nail on the wall.  You can take the girl out of the ghetto, but you can't take the ghetto out of the girl.  Shamika is all about herself. Eventually Marlon will have nothing else to give because she will have sucked him dry emotionally and physically! I am no expert on marriage counseling, but these two should have never gotten married. It's obvious. Well Marlon should not have married Shamika. He deserves so much better.  Marlon!! when you get tired of Shamika!! and I'm sure you will, give me a call (contact Dr. Phil to get my info)! I'm serious, Marlon is a handsome man. I will treat you like you are supposed to be treated :-) Never let anyone strip you of who you are and make you feel like you are less than.  I'm referring to when Marlon said he felt like the woman in the relationship.  He is a man and should stand up to Ms. Thang.  She couldn't say one thing when Dr. Phil asked her "what does Marlon do right"  I was so angry at her. Shamika get to steppin and let a real woman take of that man!  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 16, 2006, 5:43 pm PST

This Woman Is Confused

Shaneka does not get it. I was watching this and I was so upset with her. She does not seem to like anything that he does. Nothing seems to be good enough for her. What is she exactly looking for in a man. After the first show it looks like he has tried to make a change to make his marriage work but she is not satisfied. I don't mean to make her look like the bad person but she doesn't realize what she has. A man like him does not happen all the time. I also liked what Dr. Phil said that they were lucky being that they only knew each other for a week They seem to make a very good couple she just need to get off the negative and look at the positive. I would believe that they would get along even better. I also don't believe that she loves him. If this was a man that she truly loved she would not she all the negative and make adjustments in herself to make this thing work.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 16, 2006, 6:16 pm PST

Another way to look at Shamika

I have lurked long enough and need to join this fray because I beleive we need to be careful about jumping on the "Shamika doesn't know what she gots and doesn't love him anyway" bandwagon. 

  

Dr. Phil is correct.  They married, their are children involved, and they can make it work.  Besides the normal miscommunication and misunderstanding of married life, these two do not understand the way each is expressing themselves or to each other. 

  

Shamika is a truly dominant person in all aspects of her life, except maybe the way she desires to be with her husband.  Her husband is naturally submissive in his approach to her.  He is dominant in his business and in providing for his family; but that is where the buck stops, literally and figuratively.  His love is expressed strickly in submissive and in a self sacrificing way.  Shamika either does not recognize this submissive form of expression, or doesn't understand her own dominance.   This is typical role reversal in which both parties have not understand their natural's selves.   If they discuss and analize who they truly are and what they want from each other, they can build from the original attraction and make it work.  Besides they got Dr. Phil helping them! 

 
User Mood
Nervous

Message Emote
blank
January 16, 2006, 6:34 pm PST

Reality Check

Ok, seems like almost everyone agrees that Shemika needs a reality check, and I'm surprised Dr. Phil didn't open her eyes a bit more. Talk about high maintenance! phew! I want to know what Dr. Phil has them doing for the next 2 weeks. What is the exercise?

  

 

 
First | Prev | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | Next | Last