|
September 3, 2005, 5:12 pm PDT
Rosemary
Quote From: rosemaryThank you so very much for your reply, and thanks to all the others who have written back to me. There have been so many wonderful people responding to my email thoughts, that I am just overwhelmed by your kindness. I know in my heart his suicide wasn't my fault, and I find a peace in that -- but there is always something I feel I could have done. He had been under psychiatric care for 20 years. I was never told exactly what his illness was, but I am beginning to suspect bi-polar from what I have read. His psychiatrist was certainly not helpful to me in any way. He never told me the actual diagnosis he had made about my husband, or the possible side affects of all the medicine he prescribed -- he never gave me any encouragement about anything at all. He simply said he was "depressed." He never told me my husband would just fall off a chair after taking some of the medication he was prescribed! The most help I ever received was from a social worker. My opinion of psychiatrists at this point is very low. If anyone has had a good experience with one, it would be very good to hear. Again, thanks to all of you who have responded to my message. I love the Dr. Phil show, and I think this is a wonderful forum for so many people to get together who may never have had the chance without the internet and Dr. Phil. Thank God for progress! My love to all -- Rosemary I am so sorry for all that you have been through as the result of your husband's illness and subsequent suicide. And I can certainly understand your low opinion of the psychiatric profession as well. You asked if anyone could share a more positive side of psychiatry and I would love a chance to do so, not to diminish or demean your feelings from your experience, but to show you that there could have been more going on than you were aware of.
First of all, my experience stems from the fact that not only do I suffer from depression, I am married to a psychiatrist and have been for 25 years. I have been with him from the beginning of his medical training, through all the internships and residencies and further through the fellowships and if I may say so, the practice of psychiatry is far from a perfect science but it is one that is constantly evolving and improving. You have to understand that in the process of treating mental illness, you don't have as many specific things to guide you as you do in traditional medicine. And unfortunately, a lot of what helps a psychiatric diagnosis must be information that comes from the patient themselves. As you well know, that information may or may not be totally truthful and it is often difficult to ascertain whether these patients are even following the prescribed course of treatment. This I have experienced first hand with my brother. He lies to his therapist, goes for the meds only and doesn't take them correctly. But that's a whole other story LOL. Anyway, as to your frustration surrounding your husband's diagnosis and the information about his medications, I"m afraid that the psychiatrist is only allowed to share with you whatever the patient has allowed, and if he hasn't recieved that permission, he can't even acknowledge that the person is even a patient. Patient's rights are set in place for a reason, but they very often leave the family uninformed and very frustrated.
But aside from the daily ins and outs of psychiatry, I hope you realize that if your husband was truly determined to take his own life, there was nothing you or anyone else could have possibly done. And the frightening thing is, his decision to take his life was probably the highest point of his life at the time because he knew that by doing so, he would permanently escape his pain. Sadly, it leaves the lives of his survivors in shatters and full of doubts as to what could have been done differently.
I hope that you can begin to rebuild your life knowing in your heart that there was probably very little you could have done. I hope you will continue to post with us and let us know how you are doing. And if there is ever anything you need, I hope you know that we will try our best to offer it.
Debbie
|