Message Boards

Messages By: mtnlady1

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 6:28 pm PDT

About 5-10% in both

Quote From: maria_44

How often do you see animals engaging in homosexual behavior? How often do you see humans engaging in it? Do the math. 

  

  

About 5-10% in all species show homosexual tendancies... and your point is? 

  

Sources:  

  • Biological Exuberance : Animal Homosexuality and Natural Diversity (by Bagemihl)
  • A Natural History of Homosexuality (by Mondimore)
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 6:36 pm PDT

Excellent! Now we're talking Scriptures and not opinions!

Quote From: maria_44

Even though this comment was not directed to me, I'd like to add my input. 

  

If you want to talk about what the Bible and what it says on the subject, then please do so. However, don't disregard what is says against it. First off, look in the Bible dictionary (I'm reading from the King James Version) under "Homosexuality". What does it compare it to in parentheses? I'll tell you; "Sexual immorality". Why doesn't it say "see also Love, companionship, marriage"?  

  

Next, in Leviticus 18:22, it says "Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind: it is an abomination." If you look at the footnotes under that verse, you'll see that it is referring to homosexuality. 

  

I don't have time to quote all of these scriptures to you, gotta go, but read them before responding to this post. Please. 

  

Leviticus 18:22 

Isaiah 3:9 

Romans 1:27 

Jude 1:7 

Genises 13:13, 18:20 

Ezekiel 16:50 

2 Timothy 3:3 

  

If you're really interested in this discussion, please read all of these. Some of them, you may not see that they are talking about homosexuality, but like I said previously, look at the FOOTNOTES, and you'll see exactly what their talking about. 

  

I might not respond until tomorrow, but I'll try to get back tonight. 

  

Unfortanetly Maria we've already talked about several of these. Did you read the past posts? To save the effort of retyping everything I have a better idea. Why don't you log onto the web site www.gaychurch.org and to the section titled "Gay and Christian?" Scroll down and you will see a whole series of articles on the "clobber" passages (see below). 

  

The Clobber Passages 

           Why do many in the Church believe homosexuality a sin? What does the 

           Bible have to say about this issue? 

                  -   Sodom and Gomorrah (Genesis 19) 

                  -   The Levitical Law (Leviticus 18:22, 20:13) 

                  -   Shrine Prostitutes (Deuteronomy 23:17) 

                  -   Arsenokoitais (1 Timothy 1:9-10 and 1 Corinthians 6:9-10) 

                  -   What is "Natural"? (Romans 1:21-31) 

                  -   Strange Flesh (Jude 1:6-7) 

                  -   Jesus' Teaching on Homosexuality 

 

If that isn't enough I suggest you go to the next article series titled The Bible, Christianity, and Homosexuality by Justin Cannon     (The Truth Sets Free) 

 

Need more? How about the next series of articles by Bruce Lowe, a retired Baptist minister titled "A Letter to Louise". 

 

It would save me a lot of typing if you read these first. Plus I could type everything out and I'm not sure you would read it as you hadn't read any of my previous posts in which we had already discussed several of these issues. 

 

Good luck, and let me know if you want to know more. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 21, 2005, 6:52 pm PDT

Excuse me I am not...

Quote From: rlanthier

You're confusing my posts with somebody else's. I don't tolerate contradiction. Either homosexuality is unnatural and vile or it is not. The hard evidence gleaned from Nature and from scholarship argues for the latter. You are wrong about homosexuality.  You pontificate from the culture , not from any spiritual insight. It takes no spirituality to be prejudiced. 

  

Excuse me I am not confusing your post with anyone elses... Here is your post to me... 

  

"I am saying that I have a responsibility to decide what is right or wrong for ME, and I have made a decision about homosexuality. Obviously, your decision is different than mine, but making that decision is your responsibility. Arguing about what the bible says will not be how either of us reach the truth--for me, it will be studying the bible and communicating with God through prayer because I am a Christian. If you, too, are a Christian you will have to search for yourself as well. If you are not a Christian, it doesn't matter to you what the bible says, so an argument about what the bible says is useless in that case as well. I have found the answer for ME on the issue of homosexuality (though I am still searching for answers about other things)...you must find the answer for YOU. And as we search for our own answers for the issues of our own lives, we must do our utmost understand that each of us has our own searches, struggles, and faults --and because of that understanding allow others to find their own way without casting stones. It isn't my business what you and God (if you include him in your decisions) decide is right for your life. My business is following what I believe the laws for MY life are! No amount of arguing about what the bible says will find the answers for anyone. " 

  

Basically this, and I reiterate my last post: 

  

1. There are two sides to this issue, both of which base their opinions on Scripture.  

  

2. I AGREE with you that each person must find their own way in this matter. 

  

3. I AGREE with you that neither side should "cast stones" at the other.  

  

4. You then proceeded to "cast stones" at a sister because she believed differently than you did. Telling her that she needed to "dig a little deeper" to find the truth. Why? Because she didn't believe as you did.  

  

I don't "tolerate contradiction" either but I will call you on things when you say one thing and then proceed to do another. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 23, 2005, 2:01 pm PDT

Levitical Law

Quote From: mommyjenna

 Where does it say in the Bible you can beat your wife?  It says "love your wives as Christ loved the church".   It does address sex with children and says that anyone who hurts a child will face hell.  

You're right, it doesn't say keeping slaves is a sin.  However, I don't think the definition of slave is the same one we have today  - of people in chains, barely fed because it also mentions that if a slave wants to continue service, allow him to do so. It also addresses when to allow them freedom.  I think it was more of a work for food and shelter kind of thing  It also says to treat them fairly.    The reason why God was so angry with Egypt is because they'd kept his people as slaves for way too long

As far as the shellfish thing goes, these, I think it can be abandoned because Jesus came to fulfill the law and we are no longer bound by some of these old laws, although Jesus said to keep the commandements (as in 10 commandments)  However, that being said, homosexuality is also addressed in the New Testament.   I think God knew the future and knew that the laws of sex with children, siblings, animals etc would not be an issue, but homosexuality would, therefore it would indeed need mention again in the New Testament.


Well I'm glad we've come into agreement that we're not under the Levitical Law!  

  

As for the New Testament it can be broken down into 4 verses. One of which is rarely used anymore (Jude) as that passage is commonly understood now to being spiritual beings having relations with humans and has nothing to do with homosexuality. 

  

As for Romans the issue is the word "natural" which come from the Greek words phusikos and phusis which literally mean that which is a persons "natural disposition" and something that comes "instinctively" to them. In other words, it is who you are naturaly; without reprogramming, counseling, or any other form of behavioral modification that attempts to change your behavior to something others (e.g. right wing Christians) has deemed acceptable. 

  

The real danger of course is when others impose their idea of what "natural" is for them onto others. In Romans Paul is talking about people turning away from what was natural for them (phusis) that that which was unnatural for them. They did this after FIRST turning away from God. They were after chasing ('whoring') after the next sexual high. Because they turned away from God they reaped the full spiritual fruit of the god they were following (which wasn't God of course). 

  

How does this differ from homosexuals? Especially Christian homosexuals? Well first off we haven't turned away from God. If we had, we could care less what the Bible has to say or what God thinks about this issue. We do care. If we didn't we certainly wouldn't be here discussing this issue with you, going to church and devoting our lives to reaching the lost within the gay community etc. So we have not, are not, and have no future plans in turning away from God. Turning away from incorrect and misguided church doctrines yes - but never from God. 

  

Secondly our situation is different because we have not turned from what is natural (phusis) from us but have finally accepted how God has made us to be. Gay and Christian.  

  

 

As for 1 Timothy and 1 Corinthians the debate over these scriptures revolve around the Greek word "arsenokoitais" which has been pointed out numerous times is a word that is found nowhere else. It's a word made up by Paul to try and desribe someone or something. It literally means a person with many sexual partners. If Paul HAD meant to say "homosexual" there were words in the Greek dialect which described males who preferred the sexual bed of other males. Paul did not use these words but made up another word instead. If we literally translate what Paul is saying he is saying that sleeping around with different folks is a bad thing to do. This word of advice is applicable to both the hetrosexual as well as the homosexual community. 

  

So what's left to condemn gays with? Opinions? Biases? Sure, but is that God's will? Would God want Christians to attack other Christians based upon such things? No. 

  

Note: If you want to do more study on this matter I suggest two good books: 

"The Children are Free" by David Miner and "Calling the Rainbow Nation Home" by E T Sundby. A good web site with excellent info is www.gaychurch.org. Study out there resources and I think it will help. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 23, 2005, 2:13 pm PDT

Yes Christians Have Called for the Physical Assault of Gays!

Quote From: mommyjenna

 And besides, she makes the absurd claim that christians physically assault homosexuals, which is a very unfair accusation.

No one has mentioned the millions of Christians who have died over the centuries.  This still happens every day  in the middle east, communist China and other places. 

As an example I used to get a newsletter from Christ for the Nations. Back in 1993 I was horrified when in an editorial Mrs. Lindsey (wife of the college founder) called for the Levitical Law to be carried out and Homosexuals to be stoned to death! I've kept the copy of the newsletters and am still stunned to this day by it. 

  

Was it a 'one time thing'? No, for close to 7 years I pastored a non denominational church "Faith Full Gospel Fellowship" and received material on an almost daily basis from para-religious groups calling for all sorts of terrible things against the gay community. Besides hate mongering they were pandering for money to "stop the gay agenda", "protect marriage", "protect children from the homosexual agenda", and on and on and on it went. Terrible, terrible things to say against gays. And here we were with a church full of gay Christians serving God, loving each other, reaching out to their community for Christ and these people were saying such wicked things about them. I'm sure Christ was weeping at the wickedness and hardness of heart. But it wasn't for the gay people in our church. It was for the misguided Christians who were attempting to attack them in His name. Shameful. Thank God(!) things are starting to change! 

 

First | Prev | 2 | 3 | Next Page | Last Page
Return to Message Board