Quote From: pwmommyThis is the first time I find myself inclined to write to a talk show, but, given that I have a very personal connnection with the issue, I suppose it is not surprising. Watching Michelle's pain come through was horrific - I don't condone the coping techniques - but she clearly stated that she wanted help. I found out my daughter had PW when she was three and my reaction was to take a garbage bag and empty the entire contents of my kitchen into it! I have not always coped well, but I did get help from some amazing professionals. My daughter is now 23 and is 125 pounds. She is awesome. Although I realize that Dr. Phil was probably trying to shock treat Michelle by showing her Mirabelle's story, I was pretty angry that he could did not take the trouble to find a different scenario to show her, to give her hope. I was just as distressed seeing Mirabelle's tape as I was seeing Michelle's. Although I have no doubt that the family love Mirabelle, I did not see alot of evidence that she had been given many coping strategies or that her environment was very encouraging for other's to see. Believe me, that is NOT the way it has to be. 
 
Michelle, please know that your daughter does NOT have to be obese, she can be taught to react appropriately and she can find her place in society. But, it does require compassion, patience and love on your part. It does require that you realize that she may hear what you say, may seem to even understand your rules, but that does not stop the impulses. You have to teach her ways to cope that are realistic and you have to give her an environment that lends itself to helping her use her coping strategies. She will require constant supervision, a group home environment when she is older - but she can have a great life and so can you. 
 
In all of this, please don't forget about your other child - of which little was said. They too, deserve compassion, love and patience and they too, need to learn to cope with and love their sibling. 
 
Take heart, this is the beginning. It was indeed brave of you to come forward, but the world is now watching to see where you will go from here. I would love to find a way to help you. I certainly would never presume to judge you - especially since we only knew you for 30 minutes. 
 
Diane