Dr. Phil,
What happened to you? Have Oprah and her “nomenklatura” comrades hijacked your show? You did not show how the homeless are treated; instead, you stuck an able-bodied, healthy man out to panhandle. Before I had kids, I had a real job in a major downtown business district. The homeless there never begged (most were mentally ill and not even coherent enough to panhandle). Some of the secretaries in our building would send untouched left-overs from lunch meetings down to the folks who lived in our parking garage and on the benches in front of the building.
In the summertime, when the tourists arrived, we would see quite a few young, healthy adults show up during beautiful weather to scam for money. I never saw any of these folks after dark, or sleeping on a bench, or eating out of a trash can. After concerns of aggressive panhandlers accosting tourists surfaced, our local news media caught one of the fair-weather panhandlers getting into his nice car and driving back to his lovely house in the suburbs.
Your staffer collected $20.00 in one hour. Some of your viewers, like me, have to work a few hours to clear that much after taxes. I have compassion for those down on their luck, but please do not pour on the guilt trip for those who do not like being accosted on the street. It is not a safe world we live in, and to try to guilt people into opening their wallets in public or engaging strangers is just not a bright idea. My area has encouraged residents to give to shelters and not to panhandlers.
Americans give generously of their time and resources (just look at the response to Katrina and the Tsunami). Your self-righteous segment was uncalled for and completely out of character for you. With so many people in need, couldn’t you have inspired viewers to help by showing the positive work of a local shelter?