Quote From: ashelizbthI don't expect people to believe me or every word I write. This IS, afterall- the Dr. Phil message board and most of you, with the exception of a couple of trolls, are here because you are fans of him and/or his show. Getting defensive is excpected.
I'm asking that those of you who have a brain in your head and know how to use it simply just take my words into consideration instead of immediately attacking me.
I have been Samantha's (the girl featured on today's show) best friend now for close to five years. Five years is a long time, and during those five years- I have seen the many ups and downs that has happened to Sam and her family. Things that were not mentioned on today's show. Things that were edited out of the program in order to attract viewers and get ratings. A lot happened backstage at Dr. Phil's studio both pre and post show. Things that were unprofessional and shady, but those are best reserved for another day.
Let's just say things aren't always as they seem. I'm simply here to give a little insight to the side of Samantha that wasn't shown today.
It was mentioned briefly on today's show that Sam had cancer, a bone cancer that nearly cost her her leg, and when I first met her years ago- she was still recovering, still getting her bearings from learning how to WALK again, and attempting to start college and live a normal life. As anyone who is a cancer survivor, or anyone who is currently fighting cancer can tell you- this is no easy task, made even more difficult by the looming thought of medical bills that need to be paid.
I'm happy to report that Sam is now cancer-free (obviously, but still- it makes me smile to say it) and graduated college last year with the degree she worked so hard for YEARS for. Through blood tests, x-rays, and constant checkups.
I have seen Sam go from job to job, attempting to make a living and put her degree to use, so the very thought that she isn't trying outlandish. Living in a very 'tourist' area of New Hampshire in the middle of winter, surrounded by mom and pop shops that are going out of business because of a failing economy- is anyone truly suprised she's having difficulty maintaining employment? That, and the weakened condition of her knee due to the cancer causes limitations on just how far she can travel for work and how far she can push herself.
Someone earler reccomended she work at a dough shop since Hampton is filled with them. Yes, that's possible for the short-term, but do you really think minimum wage is going to be enough? I doubt it.
I'm not saying Sam is blameless. She's been careless with money before, but haven't we all? I certainly have. I doubt there is a single person here pointing fingers at today's guests who haven't, at some point- purchased something they didn't need, something on impulse, etc. I'm just saying- the show was edited to make Sam look like she spends her money on frivilous things and hangs around her parents' house all the time- which isn't the case. She has been searching HIGH AND LOW for a decent job that will help her pay her own way, AND help pay her bills and loans, non-stop for the past two months.
Also keep in mind that Sam and Jonathan's father lost his job not too long ago. That's never easy for anyone, or anyone's family.
As far as Jonathan- I've known him just as long as Sam, and he too, is good kid who was portrayed in poor light.
As far as Dr. Phil's "move out, lose the phone, lose the car" mantra. How in the hell is someone supposed to get a job, save money, and better themselves without a roof over their head, a vehicle to GET to work, and a phone? Are you kidding me? It's 2009. It's time to get with it.
Ehhh, I'm getting carried away. I just wanted to express that there are two sides to every story. Unfortunately one side has producers, lawyers, and an editing crew to make his seem more legit.
I do agree with some of what you said. I do like DR PHIL and hardly ever miss an episode but am not stupid enough to agree with everything he does or says. I agree with you on the point with Samantha. How is she supposed to find a job with no car. I dont give a crap what town or city you go to there are very few jobs to be had out there these days.
As the mother of 2 grown daughters (one 25 with 3 kids and the other one 28) who are still living at home I also feel for the parents, but they chose to have it this way just as I have chosen to do this. I dont know how I would ever throw either of them out on the streets. They both have a lot of physical and emotional issues.
I would love to see them grow up and get a life of their own but I also know that it is not likely to happen until I am gone from this world. The 28 year old has the emotional maturity of a 12 year old. She has bipolar and Anti-Social personality. She hates being around people, it makes her extremely nervous. She has had several jobs and has moved out a few times but she didnt have the maturity to handle it. I wish I could help her in some way other than just throwing her out onto the streets. I wish there was some place she could go to help her mature and deal with life.
The 25 year old has major depressive disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, fibromylgia and suffers from chronic migranes (2 to 3 a week). She too has had several jobs and has moved out a couple times but now with 3 boys whose dad abandoned them she just cant make it on her own with her health.
So yeah it is hard to just throw them out.
And I agree that Samantha and Jonathon should not have to give up their cars or anything. It is not as easy to make it on your own as DR phil would like everyone to beleive. He may have been born poor as dirt and made it on his own but not everyone can become super rich and have life handed to them on a silver platter.
I have been out of my parents home since I was 17. But not everyone can be. There are those who just dont develop enough mentally to be able to do it. I know because I work with people with Developmental Disabilities.
Would I like to see my grown kids in their own homes, making it on their own? You can bet on it.