Message Boards

Messages By: arizonamom2

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 27, 2008, 8:48 am PST

18-Year Old Daughter Does Not Give Family Holiday Gifts

My 18-year old daughter was the most giving, thoughtful and sweet child growing up.  This changed after she started high school.  This year, she did not give anyone in the family (her dad, brother, myself) a gift, not even a card.  She is employed at a good job and lives at home, so her personal expenses are not an issue.  Before Christmas she talked about the gifts she wanted to get everyone, but then there was nothing.  This needs to be discussed with her - any tips on how to begin? 

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 27, 2008, 3:23 pm PST

Thank You...

Quote From: jaimie1974

I urge you to speak with her ASAP. Approach her in a gentle manner; don't be angry or on the 'attack,' because that will only create a defensive response in her. Just ask her, "why didn't you buy for your family?" and wait for her answer. Then let her know you 'understand' her reason, but that she still should have done something...

I did speak with her, beginning with asking why she didn't get her brother the gift she had said she was going to purchase for him (he has given up a lot of his own time to help her with her car).  Her response was to tell me that she just "didn't have time" to shop for gifts, or even pick up cards, which is really just an excuse; she did manage to pick up a gift for her best friend, along with some new clothes for herself.  I can't help but think there's something beneath the surface here.  This episode is the last straw - she lives at home and as long as she attends college and gets good grades I don't ask her to pay rent.  Yet, she does nothing to contribute.  Getting her to take care of her room/bathroom, and other responsibilities is like pulling teeth.  Her attitude is typical teenage rudeness, although by now I would have thought maturity was on the horizon and the sweet girl she used to be would come back to us. 

 

There is an entitlement attitude at work here, I think.  We scaled back spending this holiday season and both kids understood why this was necessary.  However, both received the one or two gifts they wanted the most, yet my daughter seemed totally unconcerned that she had nothing in return for her family. 

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 29, 2008, 3:23 pm PST

The Meaning of "Family"

Quote From: jaimie1974

I can understand where you are coming from. Your daughters entitlement hurts your feelings; you know that you raised her better then this yet she is displaying these unattractive characteristics anyway.
When you spoke to your daughter & she gave you her excuse - that she just didnt have time to get gifts - what was your response to that? You know that its a lame excuse.
I also have an 18 year old daughter, and we have the same rules in our home- you work & go to college, you get good grades, and you dont have to pay any rent. But we also have other rules, such as doing your own laundry, if you take something out you put it back, emptying the dishwasher/filling the dishwasher, etc. It sounds like you want to implement those rules, but you get a lot of resistance from your daughter. You said it is like pulling teeth to get her to do anything. The best thing you can do is to sit down with her and tell her that you are revising the house rules; that from this day forward, she is responsible for A, B and C.  (Doing her own laundry is a BIG one! At least start with that!) When she gives you her excuses as to why that wont work, just remain calm and let her know that all you ask is that she complete A, B and C. Also let her know that you are willing to be flexible - for example, she was hurrying to get to class & left dirty clothes on floor or whatever - the point is that she needs to start pitching in. The next day when she doesnt do A, B or C, you MUST approach her about it! Dont put it off or make excuses for her- although this is annoying to have to baby sit her like a small child, you need to do this for your sake as well as for her. If she goes out into the world with this entitlement attitude, she wont have success. She will end up back home on your doorstep. You dont want that. Youve got to have the strength & endurance to create reasonable rules and stick with them because it will make her a better citizen of the world. I wish you the best!!

Thank you for your advice and input.  I appreciate hearing from another perspective.  Hopefully things will begin to improve and home life won't be so unpleasant for either of us.

 

 

 

First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page
Return to Message Board