Quote From: nanamgI'm sorry but I think the cause of suicide is a health issue. My daughter lost her best friend to suicide. Her best friend had five beautiful children, that she loved as much as any mother I know. Yes, we were devastated at what happened, but we knew that she had to be ill to do what she did.
Mental illness is an illness, that may have different symptoms, but the person is still ill.
I tried suicide five years back when I suffered a breakdown. I was so ill, I was convinced my loved ones were better off with me gone. I was one of the lucky ones who was unsuccessful and was able to get help for my ILLNESS, and look back now and realize just how sick I was.
I agree there is a fear that my loved ones might try the same thing one day, and it could be strictly because of what I did. I can't change the past, so I am keeping my ears and eyes open for any sign they may need help and if I suspect anything, I will aggressively try to get them to help.
Families that haven't experienced this type of loss, or have never felt the desire to end their life, may be left with the feeling, after losing a loved one, that they should have seen the signs. But really why would they. They either didn't know what to look for, or the loved one did a good job of hiding their feelings, which is not uncommon.
Three years ago, my beautiful, smart, wonderful five year old grandson had a near drowning and is now severely brain damaged. I can't even put into words the level of my grief, because he isn't my David anymore and he isn't at peace with his Lord either. But I pray, and I know that when the Lord calls him home, he won't suffer any more and no matter who gets there first, we will be together again.
NanaMG
But none the less, the grief is very different for those of us left behind. I've miscarried twice, buried both parents, 4 g.parents, 1 b-i-l & 1 s-i-l, and the grief is different. Those that leave us because they have no choice do not leave behind the feeling of betrayal that a suicide leaves, nor the guilt that accompanies it. What I know in my mind about the illness that causes suicide does not always comfort my heart nor negate feelings of guilt. Of course your opinion is your opinion, but until you've been in my shoes you can't possibly know how they fit. While I am not wearing your shoes either, from my point of view your grandson David still has hope...where there is life there is hope for change and/or improvement. I believe God has given peace to your grandson even as He gives peace to the soul of a child. Mentally David will always be a child of sorts & God has a special place in His heart for children. I prayed for my daughter to come home from the hospital in whatever shape I could have her, God said no. He knows best & we have to accept that, for David & for Heather. I also firmly believe that when a person decides to suicide, they will do what it takes. My daughter left a note stating that it had to be fast & irreversible, so she used a gun. I am not saying we should ignore the attempts of others that aren't so determined, just that when a mind is truly made up to leave this world, they will find a way. My sister made an attempt the Sunday following this past Easter, thankfully she wasn't as serious as my daughter. She called a friend who got police & rescue to her in time & is now in therapy & on medication. Thank God she made that phone call...when the police showed up she was still conscious & handed them her handgun so she wouldn't use it if she felt that way again.
I don't mean to sound argumentative, just voicing a different point of view.
I love that you call yourself Nana...that's what my eldest sisters g.son calls her & it's so cute!
I will remember NanaMG, David & your family in my prayers. God bless you.
Denise