Maybe she was looking for maturity and chose not to judge or exclude someone because of their age.
I dated several men in their late 20's and early 30's when I was 19. I also considered dating a man that I met on the university campus where I was earning my Master - that man was about to retire. Looking back on it, I know that probably would have been an excellent match though it was frowned on due to our age by others. We had lots in common with hobbies, interests, religion, etc. He was never married because he devoted himself to a government career and was great with children. I doubt he would have been dishonest or unfaithful.
Why did I date men in their thirties when I was 19?
I was getting my Masters degree and I was considering either finishing an at risk youth Masters at Harvard or my Phd.
I had a house that I owed about half of what it was worth from appreciation, paying extra each month, and remodeling that I did myself with family (wood floors, gutted & new kitchen, gutted & new guest bath, paint, porch, etc).
I had paid my car off completely.
I had contributed to and set my retirement in effect.
I had already been working for 6 years or so by that time.
I had already created a family business and ran it.
I had already worked for the government, nonprofit sector, financial industry, and public schools by this time.
I had already taken the adoption & foster care classes in case I wanted to adopt or married so late I would not be able to have children.
I had already started saving for "if" I had children so that I could stay home while they were young.
Here is a good reason: All the men in my courses in college were in their late 20s or early 30s. I was in graduate school not undergraduate school.
Here is another good reason: Most of the men who circulated in my circles at work were between 30 and 60. Why? I was not just a teacher but chair of the dept. I was not just a teacher for public schools when I transfered at 20, I was a TIMs and instructing other teachers and traveling the US participating in conferences.
Men my own age - 19 and 20 - a lot of them where not at my level.
They did not have stable jobs. I was almost tenured.
They did not have money in the back. I had accumulated assets - house, car, stocks, saving, money markets, etc.
They had not even started college or graduated yet. I had already earned my AA, my BBA in Finance, and was working on a Master & completed some towards the Certified Financial Planner's Designation.
They had just bought their first car. Mine was paid off.
They lived at home and did not have houses. I had one.
They were looking forward to turning 21 or partying or dating. I was looking to settle down, get married, and plan to have kids after getting my PhD.
I did not want to mommy some one. I wanted some one who was motivated, had a sense of self, was driven at work, had solid faith, and did not want my help with his college homework or resumes or getting a job, etc.
When I met my husband, I thought he had a house.
I thought he was mature, he told me that he thought men who cheated and went to strip bars were jerks. He said he was way over partying and wanted to settle down.
He had been at his job for 2 years and it seemed stable.
And I thought he had good boundaries with his parents.
It turned out:
He did not have a house but was looking to buy one. He did not party on the weekend like the younger men, he was with me. But he was partying Wed - Fri at the strip bars while I was attending college at night after working full time by day.
And he usually lost his job every 3 years for losing his temper on his boss, including getting dishonorably discharged in the military.
And it turned out AFTER we married, that we went from seeing his parents a few times a year at least once a week. So much that I was not able to manage finishing my degree. In fact, I was finishing my college courses and he DID NOT EVEN KNOW I was still attending after we got married.
We got pregnant almost immediately, he wanted too, I wanted to wait. And then he decided that it was "too much for him."
We bought a house together because I did not want him to just move in mine, I wanted to move up and put our assets together, and he did not mow the lawn or take care of anything. However, he WANTED to mow his mother's lawn for $15 but not ours.
And he started partying and drinking every week and handing out with his parents every Sunday from noon till night.
Our relationship got even worse - he found nasty things to do, his parents were weird and perverted, and he became abusive & jealous. And at the time, the residing judge said that he would get partial custody because "just because a man hits his wife does not mean he will hit his child" so I stayed through it.
You do not always know all these things or see them coming. Had I known that he would be verbally abusive, physically abuse, unfaithful, deny his own daughter, go from seeing his mother twice a year with me to every week and wanted her to run our lives & holidays... would I have married him? No.
And before that I was married for 3 years to a nice man with a nice family. He was not always highly motivated with work but he was a great with pets & children. What happened? He freaked out and thought I cheated, we divorced, and it turned out I had not cheated when he accused me. But it ruined our relationship. He ended up marrying an old friend from elementary school a few years after our split and I actually gave him the birthday gift for her that sealed the deal.
So I did not always pick them wrong.
Before the man that I married and had problems with, I dated another guy I met getting our Masters and in a few months he became moody and possessive and I broke it off.
You live and learn. One thing that I plan on doing to help my daughter is to move to a MUCH bigger town and a MUCH BIGGER church that way she has a better selection then what is available here in these little 7 mile wide towns with churchs of 25 to 100 people. In a church this small, there are NO unmarried men in a 25 person church and there might be a handful in the 100 person church.
I wish that I would have been able to find a guy like myself at that time but that would have been looking for a needle in a haystack - this would have been his qualifications:
Believe in Jesus and walk the walk, not just talk the talk
Faithful & Honest
No addictions - cigarettes, alcohol, porn, etc
19 years old
Masters degree
Almost tenured at work
Owned house
Paid off car
Already funded retirement
Ready to have children in 3 or 4 years
Oh.. and a model (yes, I am that too)
Athletic
Involved in the community
Has savings, checkings, money market, & investment
Loves children
Comes from a good family - solid in character, morals, financially, and involved in the govt and community work
Well, there was not a chance of me finding that in the small town I lived in. Maybe I should have moved to improve my prospects. LOL
Okay so that explains why some people date MUCH older. And sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't.
We cannot affect someone's free will. You can do everything right and someone still choose to cheat, leave you, do drugs, etc.