Zip Code:
  
Provider Type:
Provider:
        Listings:
          Parenting

          Three Questions to Ask Before Spanking

          July 20, 2003


          Brent and Nickie have a 3-year-old son whom they describe as a “holy terror.” He doesn’t listen, chases other children around, and has even run through the house with a barbecue fork! In addition to spanking, they’ve tried talking to him, yelling at him, and giving him a warning countdown before spanking, but nothing seems to work.

          Is spanking the only punishment your child seems to understand? Many parents feel like they’ve tried everything, and spank as a last resort.


          Dr. Phil’s advice: Ask yourself these three questions before the next time you go to spank your child.

          Is Spanking a Calming Interaction?
          If your goal is to get your child to calm down, chances are, hitting them doesn’t bring he or she any closer to that. Your child will most likely understand hitting as a chaotic behavior, and instead of relaxing, your child will become more anxious — and he or she will be more likely to return to his unruly behavior.

          What Does Your Child Learn by Being Hit?

          When you spank, you introduce chaos into your child’s world. This tells him or her that violence is acceptable, and it’s an OK way to react when you’re mad. If your child is subdued, but continues to think of hitting as an acceptable behavior, is the trade-off worth it?

          Is It Working for the Long-Term?
          As Phil told Nickie and Brent, "If it's working so well, why does your child continue to push you to the edge?" Spanking your kids may work to suppress his or her bad behavior temporarily, but it isn't a learning type of discipline. The message they get from being spanked is "I'm a bad kid," which doesn't help your child figure out what he or she did wrong — or how to keep from doing it again!


          TELL DR. PHIL YOUR STORY: At your final breaking point?
          Be on the Show

          Need Dr. Phil’s Help?

          Share your story for a chance to be on the show!

          Tell Us Your Story

          Be on the Show! Text “PHIL” to 88500
          Be on the Show

          Toxic Relative?

          Do you have a relative who you are completely at odds with because of their toxic behavior? Desperate for Dr. Phil’s help?

          Be on the Show

          I’m Living a Nightmare!

          Is your story so extreme that it’s unbelievable? Do you feel your problems have no end?

          Be on the Show

          Explosive Family Drama?

          Does everyone in your family have strong personalities and refuse to back down?

          Help & Resources

          Find Treatment Centers and Therapists!

          Check out the mental health treatment programs that have assisted Dr. Phil guests.

          Feeding America

          Learn how you can help feed a child this summer.

          Be on the Show

          Have a Story Dr. Phil Won’t Believe?

          Want to appear on Dr. Phil? Text PHIL to 88500

          Simple Share Buttons
          Simple Share Buttons