Zip Code:
Provider Type:

          Will Lack of Juror Diversity Impact the O.J. Simpson Trial?

          October 28, 2008

           By Areva Martin, Esq.

          The issue of the jury selection in O.J. Simpson’s current trial is going to be enormous. We can definitely expect an appeal on the basis of the jury selection process if there is a guilty verdict. O.J.’s attorneys fought to have two African-American women included in order to prevent an all-white jury.

          Under a 1986 Supreme Court case, Batson v. Kentucky, the Court overturned a 1965 case which held that a challenge to juror selection on the basis of race could only be sustained if the defendant could establish systematic exclusion in multiple cases over a number of years. The Batson case overturned this decision and held that the exclusion of one juror on the basis of race is a violation of a defendant’s constitutional rights under the Sixth and 14th Amendments.

          In O.J.’s Las Vegas trial, the judge allowed the district attorney to offer what she termed as “race neutral” reasons for his exclusion of the two African-American women. The district attorney argued that the women were deeply religious, and that he believed one would be inclined to forgive O.J. and the other one stated that she would have a hard time sending someone to prison.

          The lack of diversity on the jury definitely reinforces century-old issues of race and diversity and the essence of the Sixth Amendment. Without doubt, we should expect an appeal on the Batson decision in the event of a guilty verdict.

          Finally, it’s doubtful that O.J. could ever get a fair trial. After his 1995 acquittal, the country was split along racial lines over whether the decision was fair. For many, this current trial is an opportunity to right the wrong of the L.A. jury, which found O.J. not guilty. Despite what people think about the former football star and the decision in the murder trial, he deserves a fair trial by a jury of his peers.

          Areva Martin, Esq. is the owner of the law firm Martin & Martin, LLP, and also manages the non-profit organization Special Needs Network. For more information, visit her Web site at


          Be on the Show

          Need Dr. Phil’s Help?

          Share your story for a chance to be on the show!

          Tell Us Your Story

          Be on the Show! Text “PHIL” to 88500
          Be on the Show

          Know a “Bad Bride”?

          Are you a bridesmaid under pressure to look “perfect?” Is the bride demanding that all her bridesmaids lose weight and get into shape before the big day?

          Be on the Show

          Know Someone Refusing to Act Their Age?

          Is your son or daughter a moocher and refusing to grow up? Is your loved one having a midlife crisis or wearing inappropriate clothing?

          Be on the Show

          At War with Mom?

          Do you feel she is your worst enemy? Can you not believe you are related to someone you dislike so much?

          Be on the Show

          Is a Narcissist Ruining Your Life?

          Do you suspect your partner/ family member to be a narcissist? Do they behave in a way that leaves you confused, distressed and fearful?

          Be on the Show

          Fighting Over A Family-Run Business?

          Are you part owner in a family business and feel like you don’t get your fair share of profits?

          Help & Resources

          Find Treatment Centers and Therapists!

          Check out the mental health treatment programs that have assisted Dr. Phil guests.

          Feeding America

          Learn how you can help feed a child this summer.

          Be on the Show

          Have a Story Dr. Phil Won’t Believe?

          Want to appear on Dr. Phil? Text PHIL to 88500

          Simple Share Buttons
          Simple Share Buttons