Viewers go head-to-head with Dr. Phil, arguing that his advice was off the mark!

Adoption Debate
Melissa and Nichole, who have opposing views, challenge the advice Dr. Phil gave Alexandra, the 15-year-old new mother on the “Dr. Phil Family” series.

View this debate and Dr. Phil’s defense. 

Vocabulary Lesson
Laurie, an adoptive mother, makes Dr. Phil do his homework when it comes to the words he uses about adoption.

“Dr. Phil Is a Bully.”
D.L., who is happy at 325 pounds, thinks Dr. Phil hates fat people, and takes offense to a conversation he had with one of his competitors in the Weight Loss Challenge.

See what Dr. Phil has to say. 

“You Owe Me an Apology”
On a Weight Loss Challenge show, Dr. Phil made a comment that Genger says was way off base. Dr. Phil clarifies his position by referring to a previous show, and speaking to a former guest. 

View this debate and update.  

See this debate. 

Pet Death Disagreement
Noreen has a bone to pick with Dr. Phil regarding advice he gave a family on “Kids’ First…” Dr. Phil follows up with that family to see how his advice worked.


View this debate.