The State of Oklahoma arrested Amber Hilberling and charged the pregnant 19-year-old with second-degree murder, despite her insistence that she only pushed her husband in self-defense and never meant for him to fall out of the window to his death.  

In episode 3 of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife?, prosecutors offered Amber the option to plead guilty and serve five years. But in a shocking twist and in a move that would later come to haunt her, Amber refused the deal. She decided to take her chances and go to trial. It was a choice that would lead to a fate no one could have predicted. 

This episode of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil drops Thursday. Listen and subscribe here.